SCARLET 2025 Movie Review Mamoru Hosoda

Movie Review
40 followers
Non-Spoiler Movie Review for legendary filmmaker Mamoru Hosoda's new ANIME EPIC "Scarlet". In limited IMAX Theaters December 12th, 2025 and In Wide Release February 6th, 2026.
#movie #anime #review
Legendary filmmaker Mamoru Hosoda, director of beloved works such as Belle and Mirai,
returns to tell a twisted version of Hamlet in the new anime epic Scarlet.
I want to start this off by saying that Mamoru Hosoda is one of my all-time favorite filmmakers.
He stands next to Makoto Shinkai and Hayao Miyazaki as one of the great living anime directors
of our time. His last film, Belle, another adaptation of a famous literary work,
was a spellbinding musical odyssey that literally took my breath away. Unfortunately,
in adapting Shakespeare's Hamlet, he has gone completely awry and created an admirable,
but painfully overwrought film. Scarlet follows a young princess who is sworn to a life of revenge
to kill King Claudius, who murdered her father. She is poisoned and wakes up in an underworld,
where her journey of vengeance continues. Scarlet meets a deceased paramedic from the future,
who also happens to be a pacifist. And he's a pacifist. And the two learn from each other
while venturing to the infinite land. I look at Scarlet as Hosoda's the boy in the heron.
Miyazaki's last film was similarly introspective, and was more concerned about its themes and
messages than telling a compelling story. I didn't vibe with the boy in the heron,
and I found it difficult to get on Scarlet's wavelength as well. The concepts that it deals
with are intriguing, ones that deal with the cycle of violence in society and the power of
forgiveness. Taking the story of Hamlet, arguably one of the defining works about revenge,
and turning it into an anti-violence think piece is a fascinating idea on paper,
but in execution, it is a struggle to get through. The animation is spectacular, as is to be expected
with a Hosoda film. Scarlet uses a mix of photographic landscapes with 2D character
animation to create something that looks unlike anything you've ever seen before.
Hosoda stages a giant battle on horseback near what looks like the gates of Petra,
and in another scene, a diasporic horde of underworldlings hike the summit of an explosive
volcano. There are so many moments in Scarlet that feel unbelievably epic. I have to admit
that there are some scenes where the mix of styles do not blend well, and it looks off,
but mostly this is a visually stunning work that, if seen, should be appreciated on the biggest
screen possible. Unfortunately, visuals aside, Scarlet feels empty because the story is weak
and it lacks an emotional core. It beats us over the head with its messaging,
but doesn't take its time to let us feel anything for its characters. People die,
communities come together, tears are shed, but I was left with no emotion at all. If Hosoda had
come up with a more impactful narrative and allowed his story to convey all of the things
he wanted to say with Scarlet rather than letting them completely drive the film,
the director would have had something special, but what we are left with is something shiny,
but altogether hollow. As nominations for all of the end of the year award shows are being
announced, I was wondering where Scarlet was in Best Animated Feature. If Elio and In Your Dreams
can get nominations, Hosoda's latest surely should be getting one too. Well, now I know why
it isn't showing up. It's because it's just not very good. It's hard to say this because I am such
a fan of Hosoda, but Scarlet is easily his worst film to date. I would still recommend it to hardcore
fans of the director, but pretty much no one else. In a year that has been a huge letdown for
animation buffs, this is the biggest disappointment of all. I will gladly watch Bell, Wolf Children,
or any one of his other films a million times over before I watch Scarlet again.
Thank you so much for watching Lost in the Real. What are your thoughts on Scarlet? What is your
favorite Mamoru Hosoda film? Sound off in the comment section down below and make sure to be
respectful. Until next time my friends, take care and please, please, please support your local cinema.
