Peter Paul Rubens' masterpiece at the Banqueting House was the last thing Charles I saw before he stepped onto the scaffold.
Inside a "great white spaceship" in the heart of London, nine massive canvases by the celebrated Baroque master Peter Paul Rubens dominate the ceiling.
Join Andrew Graham-Dixon as he decodes these breathtaking paintings—a radical assertion of the "Divine Right of Kings" that stood in stark contrast to the King's tragic end.
In this film, we explore iconography the modern viewer might miss: from the "muscle behind the throne" in Hercules clubbing Envy, to the technical blunder that almost saw the canvases fail to fit. This is the story of the brilliance, the ego, and the ultimate tragedy of the Banqueting House. What we’ll explore:
🦶 The "Flemish Feet" Mystery: Why Rubens’s measurements were wrong.
👑 The King as God: Decoding the Solomonic columns and the Apotheosis of James I.
🕊️ The Propaganda of Peace: How the Stuart monarchy used art to hide a nation in chaos.
👁️ The Final Sight: Why these paintings were the last thing Charles I saw before his execution.
Once upon a time this was the first and the only Italian style renaissance classical building
in London. It must have seemed to the Londoners who first witnessed it as if some great white
spaceship had landed in the middle of their town from planet Europe. If you really want to grasp
the artistic genius that went into the making of this place you really have to go inside.
What do we see? Nine great canvases decorated with all the brilliance, the splendor and the
magnificence of the baroque. Where does it come from? This aerial other world,
Rubens' way of painting heaven. Charles I inherited this great space from his father
and it wasn't enough for him to be the possessor of the grandest classical piece of architecture
ever constructed in the British Isles. So he hired an artist Peter Paul Rubens to give him
nine great canvases and after seven years they were installed on the ceiling. The massive pieces
of carpentry that were involved in creating this ceiling. It turns out that when Rubens took his
measurements they were sent from England in English feet but Flemish feet were different
as a result of which Rubens' pictures they were all just a bit too big. So some of them had to
be trimmed down but more often the carpentry had to be expanded. The best way to see them,
the best way to appreciate them is to go up to that balcony at the top of the space.
This is really the best place to get a sense of the structure of the scheme and a sense of its
meaning, how it works, what do we see. Nine great canvases. Canvases so huge that Rubens couldn't
actually paint them in his workshop. He had to move to the Carmelite monastery in Antwerp and do
them there. One of the hardest things when you're looking at art from the distant past, one of the
hardest things to understand and to really feel is how it would have struck people at the time.
You've got to imagine yourself back into their shoes. Now Charles and his court we know they
had no experience whatsoever unless they'd been to Venice or Rome and few of them had.
They had no experience of this type of grand baroque illusionistic art. They'd never seen
anything like it in their lives. You know where does it come from this art? Essentially Rubens is
taking a grand tradition of aerial painting. It starts in its grandest form in Parma with
Correggio's great ceiling for the dome of Parma Cathedral in which we see the Virgin Mary being
whooshed up to heaven. This astonishing vision which astonished the people of Parma when it was
done in the 16th century. Here we are in London nearly a hundred years later. Rubens is taking exactly
that same language, Correggio's misty sense of an aerial other world, his way of painting heaven
and he's putting a real English king into it and having him as it were world round into it
surrounded by this amorphous bunch of putti who are whisking him up. We know for example from
descriptions of Charles's courtiers going to see the plays that Inigo Jones designed, the
theatrical stage designs that he made for them, all of which were calculated in mathematical
perspective. They didn't understand what perspective was. They said oh he's put these flat boards on
either side of people acting. They didn't see that the flat boards were actually arranged into
perspective so whether their eyes could actually understand this is already questionable but my
word they must have been impressed by the overall effect and you have to also remember that
many times this space would have been experienced at night. It's a banqueting hall. It was meant for
evening entertainments so there would have been torch bearers up here, perhaps freestanding torches
which would have been lit. There might have been quite a bit of smoke but there would have been this
you know imagine the atmosphere, imagine the light flickering, imagine you know the smoke playing
around these already quite smoky pictures. The effect would have been beguiling, amazing, totally
different. It would have felt like you were almost under a spell. It would have felt like Rubens was
Prospero and he put you all under a spell, created this amazing mise-en-scene. Now if you were to look
at all these pictures and see them as a prophecy, which I think Charles I is, that's possibly
exactly how you wanted us to see them. If you did that then you would be forgiven for assuming
that all was well in the British Isles. So if one's just going to go through the iconography
of these pictures because I think that's one of the hardest things for a modern viewer to
understand. You know in the past people immediately saw what these figures meant. They were used to
this kind of allegorical language whereas we're not. At the far end we've got James I
depicted as a modern version of King Solomon, the ultimately virtuous and wise monarch. He's
seated within a biblical architectural setting that has two large Solomonic, these barley sugar
columns, again emphasising his wisdom, his status as a new Solomon. He is the King as God
and that I think takes you to the heart of the scheme. It is an incredibly assertive
confirmation of the idea of the divine right of kings, that the Stuart monarchy has been placed
on the throne of England and Scotland to rule the people of these lands by God himself.
It's all reinforced by this heavenly imagery, these winged figures who descend from the heavens
to crown James with the laurels of victory. It's all about victory and peace and wisdom. This is
the Stuart monarchy apotheosized. I suppose the only element of modesty that we find in the whole
thing is the fact that it's not Charles I himself who's being whizzed up to heaven or compared to
Solomon, it's his father. This is a statement of his dynastic legitimacy. He's not quite saying
I am myself a small god to sit on my throne above all of you others. He's saying his father is that
but the implication is pretty clear. The central panel is the one where Rubens really pulls out
all the stops in terms of absolutist monarchy and its symbols and attributes. At the middle
of it all we see James I being whizzed up to heaven. He's exchanging his earthly crown
for the laurel of heavenly immortality. In terms of the platonic philosophy of the time,
this central panel represents what they thought of as the truth. I mean what the monarchy thought
of as the truth, namely that they were indeed appointed by God to rule and once their rule was
over whizzed straight up to heaven. No purgatory, no waiting around, straight up. You take the
elevator straight to the millionth floor. But it's not an elevator of course it is in this case
his taxi ride is Jupiter, the eagle of the gods who is going to carry him to heaven. A nice little
mixing of classical and biblical mythology here but you get the idea. One of the main themes of
the paintings for the ceiling is the way in which the Stuart monarchy has brought, will bring, peace
to this fractured British isles and that's above all expressed in the picture directly above me
here which is the depiction of James I uniting the two crowns. The crown of England and the
crown of Scotland because he is of course James I of England and James VI of Scotland.
Wearing parliamentary robes which is in itself a little bit of an irony given that Charles I
had only just dissolved parliament before these pictures were installed. But wearing
parliamentary robes he brings the two crowns together, unifies Britain and sets off that
sort of theme of peace, unity, harmony, concord which is resoundingly reaffirmed in all these
pictures on all sides. There is Minerva, wisdom slaying ignorance. There is Minerva again
subduing Mars, wisdom subduing war. I can't help but be struck by the huge contrast between
what the paintings are saying about the state of Great Britain and the actual state of the nation
as it was during the years when these paintings were installed and first admired.
My own favourite pieces of painting are not actually the great set piece images of James I.
I love Hercules clubbing envy or rebellion. I mean boy don't show that to a radical or a
revolutionary that's the muscle behind the throne as it were. That's like well don't you dare rise
up against Charles I or James I or this will happen. The most sort of innocent and exuberant
parts of the ceiling are perhaps where Rubens himself is most unchained because it's his own
natural inclination. He was a great celebrator of naked bodies, fecundity, fertility and it's
the scenes of the putti. They sing the virtues of this new reign. Look at the putti bringing
abundant fruit and vegetables to the people of the land. They remind me actually rather a lot of
the wonderful choirs designed by Donatello which are similarly these freezes of exuberant little
babies, classical babies, putti carrying garlands and torches. I'm sure Rubens knew those works by
Donatello and I think that's where he's absolutely at his best in proclaiming the fertility of the
Anything that one thinks about this space is naturally tempered by the fact that we know
none of this was true because we also know what happened next. In the 1630s when Rubens was
painting his great pictures for the ceiling of this space, Britain was in a state of chaos.
Parliament had been dissolved. There was deep public unhappiness at the taxes imposed on his
subject by Charles I. He wasn't listening to anybody. Cromwell was round the corner. The
civil war was round the corner. What was happening in this space? It's a theatre as well as a
banqueting house. What's being performed is a royal mask which is a theatrical entertainment
with music performed by the king, by eight of his lords, his queen Henrietta Maria with only
the court for audience. It lasts for about three hours. It celebrates the union of the two crowns,
his perfect rule, the happiness of the people who of course are not here. The total cost
in modern money four million pounds for three hours of the king's own private entertainment.
Now people often say it's ironic that in 1649 when Charles I finally met his end, was executed
at the end of the civil war, that it happened here. No irony about it. Absolutely deliberate.
Cromwell and his supporters wanted to make an example of Charles I and they wanted to do it
here in the bubble of his autocratic power. They had him executed on a scaffold that took him from
the bubble out into the street where finally he had to face the ordinary people, the people who'd
never been allowed into the great white spaceship. They watched as he had his head cut off and what
was the last thing that he did? The last thing that he did? He refused to pardon his own
executioner for cutting off the head of God's rightful ruler. He still believed as he looked
up at that painting of his father being whisked up to heaven. He still believed that that was his
own destiny and that none of these people understood that the executioner was going
to hell but he was going to heaven. That was probably, probably the last thing he ever saw.