Fencing is a Broken Sport: Here's Why.

Fencing
1 follower
1 Video View·Feb 8, 2026
Fencing is arguably one of the oldest sports in the world.
Its current form can be directly traced
back to historical European dueling practices.
It was one of the first sports
to be included in the Olympics,
which is probably the only time
it really appears in the mainstream consciousness.
I love this sport a lot.
I've dedicated a lot of my life to it.
It's brutal, it's beautifully complex,
but as you may have guessed from the title of this video,
it is fundamentally broken,
built on very unstable foundations,
which could likely endanger its future.
Now, maybe you've seen a bit of fencing before
and have probably been a bit confused by it.
Don't worry, stick around.
I'm gonna do my best to explain for everyone.
In fencing, there are three different weapons.
With each weapon, different equipment is used
and there are different target areas and different rules.
Each weapon is pretty much a different sport.
The most simple to explain is epee.
An epee has a button on the end
that, when compressed, turns on a light,
indicating that a hit has been made.
You can hit any part of the opponent's body
from head to toe.
If a fencer hits, they get a point.
If both fencers hit within 40 milliseconds,
then both fencers get a point.
There are some other rules like stepping off a piece door,
other sorts of infringements,
but that's pretty much all you need to know
to understand what's going on in an epee bout.
The simplicity of epee
is probably what makes it the most popular weapon.
And to be honest, the criticisms I make in this video
don't apply quite so much to epee.
The problems mostly exist in foil and in saber.
These are the weapons of convention.
This means that they are governed
by the rules of right of way or priority.
The basic idea is that if you are under attack,
you should first try and make the opponent's attack fail
before you launch your own attack.
If you attack into an already established attack,
you will lose a point
because the initial attack has priority.
At a service level, that sounds straightforward enough,
but there's a big issue,
and that is what actually is an attack?
Well, let's look at the rule book.
It gives us some pretty clear rules
about how an attack should be properly executed.
Things like beginning the extension of the arm
before the launch,
or even the approximate angle between the blade and the arm.
But if we look at this in practice,
it is actually rare to see an actual attack
performed as prescribed by the rule book.
Look at this example here.
According to the rule book,
the attack is defined as the initial offensive action
made by extending the arm
and continuously threatening the opponent's target
preceding the launching of the lunge.
The fencer on the right
clearly begins extending his arm first,
so by the rule book,
you would assume that he's the one who gets the point.
But no, the referee decides
that it was the fencer on the left
who initiated his attack first,
and so gives him the point.
You see, it turns out that no one actually follows the rules.
Even in cases where they should be pretty clear-cut.
For example, it pretty clearly states
that hits made during or after a fall must be annulled,
and yet top-rated FIE referees
awarded all of these hits without hesitation.
In practice, what we have
is kind of like a common law system.
Instead of referees making decisions
based off of a codified rule book,
instead we just kind of do our best
to copy the kinds of decisions made by top FIE referees,
kind of like your top judges in a court system.
So basically what this means
is that refereeing is kind of vibes-based.
I'm sorry if I've not really given
a particularly detailed explanation
of the right-of-way rules.
It's just something that is so fuzzy
that it's kind of really hard to explain.
Like, for years, I've been trying to make
some kind of video concisely explaining
how this game actually works,
and it's just so frustratingly inconsistent
that it makes it really hard.
And you can imagine,
this is such a huge barrier of entry to the sport
when it becomes really, really hard
to give a concise explanation of the rules,
and it really hurts the sport massively.
Since refereeing is so vibes-based,
it is incredibly inconsistent.
One referee may give an action one way,
and another referee could interpret
a near-identical action very differently.
Matters are further complicated
by the fact that over the years,
refereeing conventions evolve.
So if you want to stay up to date,
you kind of have to watch a lot of high-level fencing.
If you miss a season or two,
things can be kind of different
when you come back to the sport.
But the biggest issue with vibes-based refereeing
is the enormous potential for cheating.
If we just accept that referees
don't need to objectively base their decisions
off of the rule book,
and that refereeing is entirely subjective,
then any given touch,
referees are basically free to give the touch
however they want.
This inconsistency doesn't only apply
to technical decisions,
but to things like disciplinary matters also.
This is what happened when an Uzbek fencer
lost his temper after losing a bout
at a Junior World Cup in Uzbekistan.
And here is what happened
when a Hong Kong fencer did a similar thing.
The Hong Kong fencer received a black card.
The Uzbek didn't even get a telling-off.
But fencing is supposed to be a gentleman's sport.
Surely no fencer, coach, or referee
would attempt to exploit this inconsistency, surely?
Okay, so the problem is with the rule book.
We just need to rewrite it, clear it up, update it,
make it, you know, work.
Surely everything will be fine after that.
Well, not really.
You see, even if you have a super watertight rule system,
you still need someone trustworthy enough to enforce it.
Right now, we have some very clear-cut rules
that are just arbitrarily ignored.
This isn't a problem with rules.
The problem is with the people enforcing them.
International fencing is run by the F.I.E.
Alisher Usmanov has been the president
of the F.I.E. since 2008.
Usmanov has been described by the European Union
as one of Putin's favorite oligarchs.
In 2022, he came under sanctions
that caused him to suspend his presidency.
He was recently re-elected president,
only to immediately suspend himself again.
The interim president, Emmanuel Katsiadakis,
has claimed to be independent of Usmanov,
but that doesn't stop him
from heaping praise on him when he can.
In 2024, allegations of referee corruption
began to bubble over, culminating in this interview
where a former F.I.E. referee recounted being offered a bribe
at an Olympic qualifying event.
How many, by percentage would you say,
referees right now are corrupted in saber fencing?
If you have, let's say you take the top 20 referees?
About half.
That's a lot.
USA Fencing even wrote a letter to the F.I.E.
expressing concerns over certain referees
and commissioned an independent report into the issue.
Katsiadakis dismissed all concerns entirely
and even claimed that fencing truly is the cleanest sport.
Even if you ignore all the people who have voiced concerns
about the integrity of the sport,
there are some pretty concrete signs
that the F.I.E. do not take the integrity
of their competitions very seriously.
This is Vasyl Milenchev of Bulgaria,
one of the F.I.E.'s favorite referees.
Milenchev is supposed to be refereeing the match
on a piece behind between Poland and France.
Instead, he spends the whole time coaching
the Bulgarian team who are fencing on the opposite piece.
This is explicitly not allowed
and clearly unacceptable behavior,
but Milenchev faced zero consequences.
This kind of thing is not unusual.
The rules regarding conflict of interest
between referees and affected parties
are also frequently ignored without consequence
even at the Olympics.
So if the F.I.E. are so clean and transparent,
why won't they enforce their own rules?
The F.I.E. itself isn't exactly built on robust foundations.
It only really has two significant streams of income,
firstly from the International Olympic Committee
and secondly from Usmanov's donations.
Neither of these revenue streams
are guaranteed to exist in the long term.
Usmanov is obviously not going to live forever
and even in the short term,
he currently faces difficulties paying into the F.I.E.
as he used to due to the sanctions he faces.
Fencing's place in the Olympics is not at all guaranteed.
As it stands, fencing is clearly
not the most spectator-friendly sport.
You've got no fence!
And as the IOC turns towards more popular sports
like baseball and cricket,
maybe at some point they'll have to decide
to cull some of these less-viewed events.
The current IOC president
has offered the sport some level of protection
since he himself was a fencer,
but his term runs out very soon
and it's unlikely that the next IOC president
will look on the sport quite so fondly.
Usmanov may have invested a lot of money in fencing,
but he hasn't done a whole lot
to make the sport spectator-friendly.
And if you don't have an audience,
you're gonna have a hard time finding sponsorships
and commercial partners.
The funny thing is,
decent national federations manage to find sponsors,
yet right now it appears that the FIE don't really have any.
You have to wonder why on earth
would big brands like Nike
not want to associate themselves with this guy.
As it stands, the FIE is not self-sustainable in the longterm
and it doesn't look like anyone is gonna change that.
In fact, I'm pretty sure
that there are some people in the sport right now
for whom an increase in attention would not be beneficial.
Currently, fencing doesn't get a whole lot
of media attention,
and I don't think it would take much digging
to uncover some pretty dirty secrets.
The thing is, for all its faults,
most of the time, fencing still kind of works.
Even if the actual rules are ignored
and even without any effective formal systems in place,
a consensus on how things should be refereed
is usually found.
The vast majority of people in the sport
want to compete fairly.
Even the most suspect referees
appear to be fair most of the time.
The FIE is still able to put on
some pretty impressive events,
and I'm sure plenty of other small sports
would love to be able to fill a 5,000-seat arena like this
at this event in France.
There are things to be positive about.
The sport has become very safe
due to robust equipment standards,
and the sport has also spread out
a lot from its traditional European heartland,
with world-class fences being produced on every continent.
Fencing is an inherently interesting sport
and will always have some appeal.
There is also amazing work being done around the world
to promote the sport at a grassroots level.
There is so much potential in fencing,
and it would be a shame to see all of this work go to waste.
The thing is, it doesn't even have to be perfect.
Football is probably the biggest sport in the world,
and even there, there are some fairly major issues
with stuff like refereeing and governance.
But that doesn't mean that fencing
can keep going on like this.
Sports like Olympic boxing and weightlifting
have faced similar problems,
and we really don't want to follow in their steps.
So yeah, guys, that's the video.
To be honest, I could talk about this for hours and hours.
As always, I'd love to hear what you think
in the comments.
And if you want to support the channel,
head over to the Patreon.
I've also recently launched the Slicer Saber podcast.
Occasionally, I'll post the episodes on YouTube,
but most of the episodes will be on Spotify,
Amazon, or Apple Podcasts.
Thanks for watching.
See ya, bye.
