Temperate Gas Giants

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
A while ago, I made a video about temperate ice giants, one of my favorite types of planet.
A temperate ice giant is exactly what it sounds like, an ice giant where temperatures are similar
to Earth. This makes an environment that is simultaneously extremely alien, with no solid
surface and harsh weather, but also unexpectedly Earth-like. A lot of ice giants have surface
gravities similar to Earth, and that, combined with habitable temperatures and the fact they
have water rain, it's probably the most Earth-like environment you could possibly get on a planet
There are probably many temperate ice giants in the universe that you wouldn't even need a
spacesuit to be on, just a breathing mask. Other than the air isn't breathable,
it could be fairly comfortable. But ice giants have bigger cousins,
temperate gas giants. These are large gas giants in the habitable zones of their stars where
temperatures are right for liquid water to exist. I've covered several of them on my channel already,
especially my Grand Tour series, where a few systems I've covered have a temperate ice or
gas giant. Upsilon Andromedae has Maserati, a planet so large it borders on being a brown dwarf.
Muari has Quixote, with a very similar orbit to Mars, around a star larger than the sun.
I've also mentioned planets like the temperate gas giants Melchiates and Piruana in other videos.
But we know of dozens of temperate gas giants, and they're all different, both from each other
and compared to ice giants. There's likely a much wider range of sizes temperate gas giants can be
in comparison to ice giants, for example, ranging from only marginally bigger than Neptune to
several times larger than Jupiter. There are a ton of different gas giants in the habitable zone,
and it's very difficult to make generalizations about all of them that will be true for all of
them. So for this video, I'll be talking about a few specific temperate gas giants I find interesting
to hopefully get a glimpse into the range of environments these planets can have.
But first, when people talk about gas giants in the habitable zones of their stars,
the topic of habitable moons usually comes up. I've talked about this a lot, but to put it simply,
the bigger a planet is, the more likely it is to host a large moon, and the larger the moon is,
the more likely it is to be interesting. Bigger planets form with more material around them,
meaning they have more material to form moons. This either results in a greater number of small
moons, or a smaller number of larger moons. This is easily seen in our solar system. Jupiter,
the biggest planet, has four large spherical moons, the biggest of which is bigger than
Mercury in radius, and only a few hundred kilometers smaller than Mars. Saturn, three
times less massive than Jupiter, only has one moon of this size, but has several smaller ones.
Uranus's largest moons are only as big as Saturn's smallest spherical ones.
However, this isn't always the case. Earth has a moon that rivals Jupiter's moons in size.
Neptune has a captured dwarf planet. But even though there are exceptions, the general rule
is the larger the planet, the larger the moons. This will likely be true for temperate gas giants
as well. The biggest one will have higher chances of hosting large moons. But then again, the larger
the gas giant, the stronger the magnetic field and tidal forces, which could be a problem.
Again looking at our solar system, Jupiter's magnetic field and radiation belts are a death
sentence for its inner moons. Io is the most volcanically active object in the solar system.
If it weren't orbiting Jupiter and somehow kept the same level of activity,
it would have an extremely thick atmosphere. But because it sits directly within one of Jupiter's
radiation belts, the atmosphere is stripped away faster than it can form, leaving Io airless.
Radiation levels on Io are so high that even with shielding, you'd be dead in a matter of hours.
The same is also true of Europa and Ganymede to a much lesser extent. On Europa, you'd be
dead in days, and Ganymede is likely far enough away for radiation to only be a problem on the
timescales of years. Callisto is far enough away to be outside the radiation belts, but also far
enough away the tidal forces are so weak it doesn't have any geologic activity, leaving it airless
But moons with atmospheres around gas giants can definitely exist. Titan has a very thick one,
though that's mostly because it's extremely cold. Colder objects have an easier time holding onto
atmospheres, because the air on them is moving slower, making it harder to speed up to the point
where it would escape. Triton has a thin atmosphere as well, though one thick enough to host clouds.
So, habitable moons around temperate gas giants could very well exist, but they have to be in
delicate balance. The gas giant has to be big enough to have enough material to form a large
moon, or it could just get lucky like Earth and Neptune did. That moon then has to be big enough
to hold onto its atmosphere with the higher temperatures of the habitable zone. Then it
has to be close enough to the gas giant or other moons to have geologic activity, but not too close
to where the radiation belts would strip it away. And even if everything goes perfectly, and you get
a large moon with geologic activity and an atmosphere, it could still just as easily become
like Venus or Mars instead of like Earth. Habitable moons are probably extremely rare,
but definitely possible. But remember, there are a lot of environments habitable zone objects can
have. If you assume an optimistic habitable zone, the solar system has four objects inside it,
Venus, Earth, the Moon, and Mars. All four of these worlds have wildly different environments,
and there's no reason to think the same wouldn't be true of moons. A moon being planet-sized and
in the habitable zone does not automatically mean it has a chance of being habitable.
But anyway, they're also probably more likely around larger gas giants. Which is why of all
the temperate gas giants I'm aware of, I think Majority is the most likely to host a habitable
moon. I talk about Majority in a few videos, like a grand tour of Upsilon Andromedae, so I'll keep
this section short. Upsilon Andromedae d, which was officially named Majority in 2015, is about
10 times the mass of Jupiter and in the habitable zone of Titowin, a star slightly bigger than the
That large mass, combined with a large star, means Majority could very well have formed with
more than enough material to host moons the size of Mars or Earth, though this is not known for
certain. Whether that mass is split between several smaller moons or one big one, for example,
is another problem too. We don't currently know of any moons around any exoplanet, let alone
habitable ones around Majority. But Majority, being so large, has probably the best chance
of any temperate gas giant I'm aware of, though there may be other planets out there with better
chances that I've missed. But this video is going to be about temperate gas giants themselves,
not just their moons. Majority is so large it's bordering on a brown dwarf in size,
meaning it likely has a ton of internal heat and very high surface gravity. Despite being so
massive, it's almost exactly the same size as Jupiter in radius, meaning it's very dense,
and so has very high surface gravity and temperature. You wouldn't be able to stand
if you were on Majority due to the high gravity, which is likely only a bit less than the surface
gravity of the sun. It would also get very hot very fast as you descended into the planet.
This is true of most temperate gas giants, though most to a much lesser extent than Majority.
They have surface gravities much higher than Earth, making them less Earth-like than temperate
ice giants. I should also quickly clarify what surface gravity means in this case, because gas
giants don't have surfaces. From what I can tell, surface gravity in terms of gas or ice giants is
calculated from the point where the density of their atmosphere is the same as the surface on Earth.
So when you say Jupiter's surface gravity is about 25 meters per second squared,
that's being calculated from the point inside Jupiter's atmosphere where there are similar
pressures to Earth at sea level. Anyways, Majority's orbit isn't very circular. It has
an orbital eccentricity of 0.3, meaning its orbit is more of an oval shape than a circle.
For some reason, of the temperate gas giants I researched for this video, this seems to be
pretty common. Quixote, the planet I talk about in Grand Tour of Muare, has an eccentricity of 0.12.
This is much higher than the orbital eccentricity of Earth, but Mercury's eccentricity does get up
to this level. And the next temperate gas giant I'll talk about, Trimobe, has an eccentricity of
0.34. HD 153950 b, officially named Trimobe, is about 2.7 times more massive than Jupiter at
minimum, and orbits an F-type star called Repedo at about 1.3 AU, 30% further than Earth orbits the
Sun. It takes about 500 days to make a full orbit of its star, but because of its elliptical orbit,
it has very extreme seasons. While Trimobe's temperature has not been directly measured,
it likely varies from 2 to 102 degrees Celsius, or 35 to 215 Fahrenheit. So depending on what point
Trimobe is on at its orbit, it could either be cool enough to allow for liquid water to exist
on it, or hot enough to boil it. Like other elliptical gas giants, this could lead to
changes of weather during Trimobe's year, which is seen very clearly on planets with even more
drastic orbital eccentricities, which I'll talk about in later videos. Assuming its minimum mass
is accurate, Trimobe could easily host moons much larger than Ganymede, but again, we can't say much
about its habitability. Though it would be very interesting if Trimobe hosted a moon with oceans.
When Trimobe is at its furthest point from Repedo, the water will be on the verge of freezing over.
But when it's at its closest, the oceans will begin boiling away, only to cool off again,
repeating the process over and over in a 500 day cycle. Not a particularly habitable environment,
but an extremely interesting one, assuming we get lucky and it exists.
This is just my own speculation and I'm going off the top of my head here, but I think that if a
moon with oceans was in an orbit like this, it could pretty easily enter a runaway greenhouse
state. Water vapor is a powerful greenhouse gas, and if for a few weeks or months of every orbit
the temperature rises to the boiling point, that's going to release a ton of water vapor
into the atmosphere, which may linger even after the moon cools down, making it a steam planet.
Unfortunately, we know a lot less about Trimobe compared to Majority, so I can't say much else.
But after all this talk of tempered gas giants with elliptical orbits, I started trying to find
one with a normal circular orbit, and those do exist. The first one I'll talk about is Melchiades,
or HD 93083b. To be honest, I'm mainly only talking about this one because 1. I like its name,
and 2. It was one of the first planets I ever talked about on this channel,
though that video is several years old at this point and I wouldn't rely on it.
Melchiades is about the mass of Saturn, and orbits its small K-type star Macondo at about
half the distance Earth orbits the Sun on a 143-day orbit. It still has a decent orbital
eccentricity of 0.14, which is between the eccentricities of Mercury and Mars.
But what's interesting about Melchiades is a 2007 study suggesting that its L4 and L5
points would be stable for long periods of time, which would mean that planets would be able to
exist there. Lagrange points are areas where the gravities of two objects cancel out, leading to
objects inside them tending to stick around. We call those objects inside these points Trojans,
and Jupiter is thousands of Trojan asteroids. They're 60 degrees ahead of and behind Jupiter
and share its orbit. But planets are much larger than asteroids, and so are likely unstable after
short periods of time inside Lagrange points. But there are highly specific cases where they
could be stable, and Melchiades is potentially one of them if this study from 19 years ago is
correct. And the study found that it should be possible for there to be Earth-sized planets
in the Melchiades and Lagrange points. Now Lagrange points being capable of hosting
planets and planets actually being there are two different things. And again, this study is also
from 19 years ago, so it could be very out of date by this point. But as far as I'm aware,
it hasn't been refuted, though if I'm wrong about that, just correct me in the comments.
Melchiades isn't the only planet identified in the study, however,
as six other tempered gas giants are also potentially capable of hosting Trojan planets.
In all of these cases, if a Trojan planet did exist, it would also be in the habitable zone,
and so could have a chance of being habitable. Speaking of multiple planets in the habitable
zone, that can happen with tempered gas giants as well. Though it's probably decently rare,
because large planets tend to destabilize other planets nearby. So for two or more gas giants to
be in the habitable zone, a lot of things have to go right, or the habitable zone just has to be
big enough to host them all. Which brings us to HD 34445. This system has a sun-like star and at
least one confirmed planet orbiting around it, the tempered gas giant HD 34445b. But there are
five other unconfirmed planet candidates in this system, and one of them, HD 34445f, is also in
the habitable zone. The five additional planets were suggested to exist around 2017, but a 2021
study suggests that planets E, C, and D were false positives caused by stellar activity,
F wasn't found at all, and G remains unconfirmed. It's safe to say that currently, these are not
strong candidates for existing. But if planet F does exist, which doesn't seem very likely,
then that would mean that this system hosts not one, but two tempered gas giants close to one
another. HD 34445b, the only confirmed planet in the system, is at least two-thirds the mass of
Jupiter, and the unconfirmed F is at least 11% Jupiter's mass, about a third the size of Saturn.
This would make it more similar to Neptune in size if it exists at all. Studies of this system
suggest that if all these planets do exist, they would be stable. So even if planet B is the only
planet confirmed to actually exist, this place shows that systems with more than one tempered
gas giant can't happen. If both these planets exist, it may be a possibility that they have
especially small moon systems, as they're separated by less than half an AU. Having
giant planets that close will make hosting moons on long, far away orbits difficult.
But anyways, tempered gas giants are definitely a very unique type of planet. Unlike tempered
ice giants, many of them have much higher surface gravities, and far more chances for habitable
moons. They also have a much wider range of potential sizes, with the unconfirmed HD 34445f
being at minimum less massive than Saturn, and majority being 10 times bigger than Jupiter.
A ton of them also have strangely elliptical orbits, leading to drastic seasonal changes.
We've discovered dozens of gas giants in the habitable zones of their stars,
and we'll likely only find more as we keep searching. And hopefully we can find out more
about the ones we already know of. Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed, check out my other videos
about space and space exploration.
