what REALLY was this "GREAT PUSH" in hoplite battles? - OTHISMOS

Primordial Armor
3 followers
1 Video View·Feb 7, 2026
Join Professor Paul Bardunias and myself as we discuss one of the most hotly debated topics in hoplite warafre: the "Othismos"
Ancient Greek warfare is filled with mysteries, misconceptions and theories, however none
as infamous as the famous Othismos.
Was it literally a great push of armies, or a metaphorical pushing a position?
This topic has captivated both scholars and non-scholars alike, for basically as long
as we help hoplite warfare has been studied.
Today I am joined by Professor Paul Bardunius, an excellent historian and author of the book
Hoplites at War, which I highly recommend to anyone interested in ancient Greek warfare.
And today we are going to run through what we believe are the common misconceptions of
the Othismos and hope to shine some light into what was probably a more realistic take
on what this Othismos, this great push, really was.
So let's throw it over to Paul.
I just want to give a little talk on the Aspis itself.
So the Aspis is a remarkable shield and if we look inside the Aspis we can see that I'm
holding it in a little grip here in my hand and I have something called the porpax on
my forearm.
Sometimes it's actually even closer to the elbow up here.
And the neat thing about it is my elbow is pretty much in the middle of the shield.
What that means is rotating around my elbow is really quite easy.
Very quick.
It also means that the weight pulling my fingers here down is balanced by the weight on the
other side of the shield pulling my hand up.
So holding this up for a long time is quite easy because it just hangs from my upper arm.
As long as I can let it hang from my upper arm like this, I don't have to actually lift
it with my hand because I don't have to use my hand at all.
I just hang from my upper arm.
And I think that's actually why this shield was designed.
This shield was designed so that hoplites could stand like this for a long period of
time while they were in some sort of a shield wall formation throwing spears themselves
and protecting light, what they called naked men behind them who were throwing spears over
their heads.
So that I think is the primary reason that the shield is built like this.
The other really neat feature of this shield is that it has this depth.
And you can see it is a somewhat deep shield.
And what that does is if we end up getting all crushed together, this thing rests on
my upper chest like this and on my leg, like hopefully you can see from the side, it arches
over my midsection.
Because it arches over my midsection, no matter how crushed I get, I can still breathe.
Right now, it's all up against my body and I'm having no problem breathing whatsoever
because it's not crushing my diaphragm.
And I think that's fundamentally why these shields have this arched shape here.
And that brings us to the other thing we wanted to talk about, which is probably the most
contentious issue in all of hoplite combat, and that's ophthysmos, or what some people
call the push, the pushing in combat.
I think it's been completely misunderstood by both sides in the academic world.
On the one hand, we have this group that dominated the thought of most of the 1900s that what
they did was like a rugby scrum.
The men would run at each other at high speed in a huge formation, smash into each other
like rutting rams, and then immediately start to push each other and try to break up their
formations by pushing in a concerted push of all the ranks at once.
On the other side, they thought that this whole notion of pushing was completely just
describing hard fighting, like you would say that ships were pushed off of the sea and
pushed into the shore.
They're not actually physically pushed, they're just sort of herded off the sea onto the shore.
There's a middle ground between that, though, and the middle ground between that comes up
when you realize what probably is happening when you have large crowds of men together
on these battlefields.
This is how I got into studying hoplites, because I study large crowds of insects and
animals and how they move in herds and swarms.
What you see is this sort of group movement that only happens to humans during things
like crowd disasters at concerts, or when there's a panic in the streets sometimes
and people get crushed.
We see that, and they die through asphyxia, where their diaphragms are crushed and they
die standing up, actually, and then they'll fall and they'll be trampled.
They're usually actually dead by the time they fall.
You could fight as a hoplite in this crazy density where we end up crushed together,
and I can stay alive because of this aspis.
If not for the aspis, I would not stay alive.
Now, there's some ramifications to this on what athismos is.
For one thing, the old notion that you ran at each other at high speed to crash into
each other like rams doesn't make any sense in terms of the physics involved, because
no matter how hard you run at another line of men, as long as you have, let's say, four
ranks of men, you just all get absorbed together.
Nobody's getting knocked over when there's four ranks of men.
You could run any number of men into my four ranks of men, and you will not push them off
the field immediately.
They will come to a halt when they hit my four ranks of men.
That's just the way the physics of interacting crowds work, and it's because you're not coming
at me at a solid mass, you're coming at me as sequential rows of men hitting, so each
one just gets absorbed.
Now, we have also shown that through experiments.
We've shown that it doesn't matter if you run at the enemy, you're not going to just
sort of knock them off their feet and push down.
You can do it to one rank of men, but you can't do it to a whole bunch of men.
The other thing that we see is if you are actively trying to push the way that some
believe you did, which is through the shoulder sideways like this, if you're pushing this
way, that sounds good, because that's how I would push something just as a single person.
I would push through my shoulder, right?
Some have claimed that the shield was designed for this exact thing, to go into the shield
to push.
Like many things with hoplite combat, that works great if you're alone, but once you
start to put men together, you can't do it, and the reason is, one, you can't actually
push through my body this way.
You cannot really push with any force, and the more you push on the back of my body pushing
me this way, why don't you push on the back of my body?
The more you push on the back of my body like this, I may start off this way, but when we
get a ton of force on my back, I always collapse like this anyway, and I collapse standing
up.
So everyone in the Thismos, when they're under high pressure, are always standing like this
anyway.
How are we generating force against the enemy force?
We're literally leaning against them.
So all the men behind me are leaning against me like this.
This means two things.
It means, one, I'm leaning, I'm not actively pushing.
It's not my muscles that are doing this anymore.
Now I'm just leaning, and I'm hoping to survive getting squished.
Because of that, I can do it for a long time, because I'm not actively pushing as much as
leaning, and you notice my whole right arm is free.
So my right arm is free.
Now I can go to the sword, and I can use a sword.
If I'm in a rank behind, I can still use my spear over the top of the men in front.
So it's not a tactic where I either push or I fight, it's I fight, and we all push.
I kind of liken it to a knife fight in a mosh pit, because that's what it's kind of like.
You're having a situation where the men are just closely crowded together, still fighting.
Obviously, shorter weapons are better, and not surprisingly, we see in the period when
we get the deepest ranks of hoplites, we also seem to see some of the shortest swords.
These things that are sometimes called encaridia, or daggers, that are used by Spartans and
Thebans and other people.
Hmm, is there anything else you want to say about Othysmos?
Yeah, I think something else is, as you said, people often treat it as though armies marched
up and pushed, as opposed to, I think it's more of a circumstance as opposed to the way
of war.
So I think you would have seen lines clash, maybe even pull away again, and they clash
and pull away again.
You'd see some spear fencing in between that.
I think mainly that Othysmos, the push, is more referring to when combat gets up close
and personal, when you are in a push, and when you're using swords.
As you say, we see sort of an evolution in the archaic period, we see, especially for
the period, pretty long, decently long swords.
And we get to essentially kitchen knife sized swords in the 300s.
So we sort of see this evolution into really tight, and we can demo this, if we're up close,
and we're sort of pressed, a long sword is not helpful.
So my sword's up close in this air pocket, I can grab it easily, and I can now go over
the top, I can get around, I can go through eye holes, through neck holes.
I can do all sorts of stuff with a really small sword, if I had a long one, I'm now
having to go up here and fence around, whereas if we're in a lighter, sort of less packed,
dense formation, I might want a longer sword.
I can harmonious blow, you can get around, I can reach you in different areas, but once
you sort of close that formation into a push, a tight press of shields and swords, a small
sword is going to be a lot more helpful.
And this is important, because if I am correct, and he is correct, and this is how they're
fighting, it explains certain things about the swords, like why are they smaller, right?
What are the targets of the swords?
The targets are these little chinks, like the side of the neck.
Really importantly, one of the big targets for a sword in this sort of athysmos press
is the back of the neck, and you might say, well, how do they get in the back of the neck?
And the reason is, I stab and miss him, right?
I'm going to drag the sword across the back of his neck, doing what's called a draw cut,
and that is, that would be devastating to the back of your neck, but look at the back
of my neck, right?
This is a feature we have on these TYs, is this big neck tab sticking up.
This big neck tab completely protects the back of my neck from that draw cut, right?
Same thing with him, often on these, you'll see a lip on these, on the back here, that
lip catches that blade, so it can't get up into the back of his neck.
And you can see, just in the shape of the, especially the Xiphos, more of this, it has
that leaf where it gets thinner.
That is, as you demonstrated in one of our previous videos, with the tomato prop, it
just slices, and I mean, that would be, you're done.
Yeah, no, a strike like that would be horrifying.
The other thing is, with athysmos, it's a mistake to think that athysmos, as we said,
is a sort of, simply a tactic.
It's something that arises as you're moving through other types of fighting.
So if we look at how hoplites fought each other, I think, they ran up to each other
and charged, right?
You can stay still, I'll just run.
They run up to each other and charge, and they stop at spear range, and they fight with
spears, the whole line stops, and you might think it's difficult to do, but it's actually
very easy to stop a whole line of men from running.
We've done this many times, it's not hard at all for a whole rank of men to just stop
at the same time, you know, against a target.
And we probably have some video you can put in there.
Yeah, probably.
And so that's one issue that people thought you had, like, oh, how are you going to stop
at the end?
The answer is, pretty easily, it's actually not that hard to stop.
But then, we would go through some spear fighting for a while, and two things can happen.
One, I could get really tired, right?
And if I'm really tired, and I'm not blocking well anymore, I have two choices.
One, get back out of range, which I can't do because there's people behind me.
Or two, just give up spear fighting, and just move in now to sword range, right?
Because you think of it like a boxer, if you see a boxer in a match, and he's tired, and
he's getting beaten up, he can either try to dance around and evade, or he can move
into a clinch.
And in many ways, I think ethismos is like that.
It's happening when men are having their spears broken, so your spear breaks, which is probably
pretty common.
These are very light spears.
Or for whatever reason, you're overmatched, you just, you're done spear fighting, he's
a great spear fighter, I'm not, let's go to the sword.
You end up shield to shield, right, fighting, let's say even this far away at first, right?
But over time, you're fighting, you're fighting, you're fighting, you're getting closer, and
as you're getting closer, the guys behind me are trying to keep me in the fight.
So this whole crowd phenomenon happens, just exactly how you have a crowd phenomenon in,
you know, one of these disasters in a, in a theater or something.
They're coming up behind me, they're pushing me, and I'm, they're not throwing me into
him.
That's not how it works.
But they're just coming up to help me out and support me.
But they're helping me, and the helping me is making me have to fight a little closer,
a little closer, a little closer, until we get to this crowded step, where at this step,
I might not even be fighting him, I might be fighting him.
Because we're already in this deep, deep crowd, right?
And then once we fought like that for a while, it's possible that the men behind me can unpack,
and then he and I can literally just be like, you know, break off and move away.
And we can go back to spear fighting, or we can step all the way back and hurl curses
at each other for a half hour until we get brave again, and then go back to fighting.
So when we think of these battles, it's not just, it's not like a cycle or a sequence
that's obligate.
These different things can happen, sometimes in different order, and definitely they can
go from one to another, right?
So it's not just like, here's phase one, here's phase two, here's phase three, they run away.
They can have this happen for a long time.
Importantly, the unit I'm in can be spear fighting, and the unit next to us could be
in a thysmos, and the unit over there could be unengaged, I might just be standing at
each other throwing curses at each other.
The whole line didn't have to do the same thing at the same time, and that's something
that I think is difficult for people to grasp, because they think of a phalanx as the whole
line, but that's because phalanx is kind of a terrible word for what they really are.
Thucydides had a better term, and that was parataxis, and parataxis just meant taxis
or units lined up next to each other, alongside, like a string of beads, and in that string
of beads, one side is winning, and then maybe down the other side of the string of beads
they're losing, right?
In most of these hoplite battles, there's a point in the middle of the line somewhere
where one group is winning, and right next to them they're losing.
This was very common.
So you can't think of this thing as one unified front that just does the same thing.
It's all a mishmash of different combats within these different groups.
So there we go, our thysmos, hopefully we cleared that up a little bit for you, and
let us know what your thoughts are in the comments, myself and Paul will be scouring
them and hopefully be able to respond to most of them as well.
Of course, a special thanks to Paul for taking the time to film this video with us, finally,
in person again for our second video, we filmed them in one go.
If you haven't seen the first video, we were talking about overhand versus underhand spear,
so I'll link that down below if you are interested.
Thanks very much for watching this channel, special thanks to our channel members who
continually support the channel.
If you yourself would like to go the extra mile to support the channel, then I've just
started a Patreon page, and of course, YouTube memberships are a great help.
But if not, no worries at all, liking and subscribing is a great help, and sharing these
niche videos around to a wider audience can really boost the channel up.
So thanks very much for watching this video, hopefully catch you in the next one.
