Poland was Celtic The Przeworsk Mystery

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
4 Video Views·Feb 7, 2026
In this video I explore the origins and the early development of Poland's Przeworsk Culture. Whilst this culture has usually been seen as Germanic by most scholars (both western and eastern European) it's origins aren't entirely clear. In terms of material culture it bears strong resemblances to both Germanic and Celtic cultures, which is why it can be seen as somewhat of a hybrid.
When we think of Iron Age Northern Europe, we primarily think of two different groups
of peoples.
The Celts, who we associate primarily with ancient Gaul and Britain, and the Germanic
people who occupied Germania and Scandinavia.
What we often forget, however, is that the groups ancient and modern scholars refer to
as Celtic or Germanic were neighbours and influenced each other in profound ways.
And one culture for which this is particularly apparent is the so-called Przeworsk culture
It displays certain characteristics which we usually either associate with the Germanic
North or the Celtic South, but rarely both.
In this video, we are going to take a closer look at this peculiar hybrid culture in the
heart of Iron Age Europe, with a particular focus on which elements showed greater similarities
to its Germanic neighbours to the North, and which made it more similar to the Celtic Latin
culture to the South.
And if possible, we will also try and answer the question if the direct predecessor of
this culture, the Pomeranian culture, was originally Germanic, Celtic or perhaps something
different entirely.
But first, let us take a look at the different elements that contributed to the development
of the Przeworsk culture, starting with the Latin culture.
This culture had developed in Central Western and Western Europe during the Middle Iron
Age from the preceding Hallstatt culture, and both of them are usually thought to have
been manifestations of early Celtic groups.
During the Late Iron Age, when the Przeworsk culture formed, it stretched from the Atlantic
coast in the West all the way to Bohemia in Austria in the East, but its influences could
be felt at places much further afield, stretching as far as Britain, Denmark and Anatolia.
Its counterpart in the North was the so-called Jastorf culture, which is often thought of
as one of the earliest manifestations of Germanic culture, and it had formed there around the
middle of the 1st millennium BC, around the same time the Proto-Germanic language developed.
This culture was located in what is roughly north-eastern Germany today, but similarly
to the Latin culture, it too exerted influence over its neighbours, including the Jutland
Peninsula, north-western and central Germany, and north-western Poland.
It just so happens that the culture from which the Przeworsk culture developed, the Pomeranian
culture, was located right in between those two highly influential cultures and was influenced
to similar degrees by both, leading to the development of somewhat of a hybrid which
would dominate much of Poland and even some of the lands beyond for centuries to come.
The influences from both Germanic as well as Celtic groups are most apparent in three
main areas – settlement size, technology and borough customs.
Let's take a look at each of these in the following.
Whilst the Jastorf culture was characterised by small villages and farmsteads, the Latin
culture gave rise to northern Europe's first towns and cities, which functioned as political
and economic centres for the surrounding countryside.
As might be expected from the intermediary Przeworsk culture, its settlements fell somewhere
in between in terms of size.
Their most important function was apparently as metalworking centres, which the people
of the Przeworsk culture mastered to a degree that rivaled that of their generally technologically
more advanced Celtic neighbours.
According to some scholars, they even surpassed them, particularly when it came to the production
of weapons, most prominently among them spears and swords of higher quality.
The importance of these instruments of war is exemplified by their prominent appearance
in Przeworsk burials, as well as by the existence of elaborate smith burials, identifiable by
the tools of their trade.
This suggests that weapons and the art of making them were held in high esteem among
the people of the Przeworsk culture.
Whilst these burial practices were fairly new, older customs were also carried over
from their Pomeranian ancestors, meaning that they cremated their dead and buried their
ashes in dugout pits which were then filled with earth.
This practice is referred to as pit cremation burials, and in this regard the Przeworsk
culture differs from the neighbouring Jastov culture, which buried its dead almost exclusively
in urns, a practice they had adopted from the earlier, and quite aptly named, Anfield
culture.
Later on, this custom seems to have spread to the Przeworsk culture as well, and by the
first century BC, most Przeworsk individuals were buried in urns.
Interestingly, not all of the ashes of the deceased were deposited into the urns directly
however.
Some were also deposited inside a pit around the urns, almost like a hybrid between the
two different burial customs.
Such customs are usually one of the most stable aspects of prehistoric material cultures,
so changes in it often reflect profound changes in the world of the living as well.
This begs the question, what caused this development?
Could it be the result of Germanic people moving into the territory of the Przeworsk
culture, or did they simply adopt the practices of their northern neighbours?
The fact that the indigenous practice of the cremation pit graves wasn't replaced entirely
but rather adapted, with the urn element from their northern neighbour, suggests a synthesis
of both practices and maybe both people as well.
Another notable difference between the Jastov and the Przeworsk culture is observed in the
Whilst the former is characterised by its relatively few and comparatively low quality
items, the latter exhibits a rich array of goods among which the aforementioned weapons
stand out the most.
Some of these burials, particularly inhumation burials, which we are occasionally confronted
with in the southern ranges of the Przeworsk culture, rival the lavishness of their Celtic
counterparts to the south, from where they were potentially adopted.
Apart from certain burial customs, the Przeworsk culture also seems to have adopted certain
types of fibulae from the Celts, as well as the pottery wheel, to produce higher quality
ceramics than their Jastov counterparts.
But the Jastov culture also influenced the clothing of the Przeworsk people, with Germanic
belt buckles being found throughout the Przeworsk territory.
In summary, these developments suggest that the upper social classes of the Przeworsk
culture came under heavier Celtic influence than the lower classes.
But even they seem to have adopted certain practices and goods from their southern neighbours.
At the same time, we shouldn't forget that the centrepiece of Przeworsk burials by the
1st century BC was the urn, a practice which they had presumably adopted from their Germanic
peers to the north.
So in conclusion, both southern and northern influences are visible in the Przeworsk culture,
leading to its unique hybrid status between the Germanic and Celtic worlds in regards
to their material culture.
But what about their linguistic affiliations?
As language is one of the primary categories which ancient and modern scholars used to
classify a population as Germanic or Celtic, it would be prudent to take a look at this
aspect as well.
Unfortunately, as is the case with all broadly northern European cultures of this time, the
people of the Przeworsk culture were illiterate, so we have no accounts by themselves to help
us make a decision, which is why we need to turn to outside sources.
The earliest relevant source to our investigation are the commentaries on the Gallic War by
Julius Caesar.
Whilst he primarily campaigned on Gaul, he also made two forays into Germania during
this time and repeatedly dealt with a variety of Germanic tribes in and outside of Germania.
Based on similarities in burial customs, we have reason to believe that some of the people
he came into contact with during this time originated among the Przeworsk culture.
As Przeworsk-style graves dated to roughly the time of Caesar's campaigns in Gaul have
been found both in southwestern and in western Germany.
This doesn't mean that the whole area had suddenly become part of this culture, but
probably can be interpreted as small bands of Przeworsk individuals moving into territories
which until recently, in the case of southwestern Germany, had been dominated by the Latin culture.
In fact, western Germany at the time was still culturally part of the Latin horizon, although
things had started to change as is shown by the arrival of groups of Przeworsk people
as well as people associated with the Jastow culture.
But how do we interpret these results?
Caesar generally divides Germania into two cultural zones.
A western area, which he connects to the Belgae in northern Gaul, and an eastern area, which
is the homeland of what he terms the Suebi.
Because he previously states that he generally divides groups like the Belgae, the Gauls
and the Aquitani from each other on the basis of different languages, customs and laws,
we can assume that the Suebi differed from the western Germani in these regards as well.
This in turn means that one of these groups might not have been Germanic in a linguistic
sense originally.
Because Caesar earlier stated that the western Germani and the Belgae are related, we can
assume that they also spoke related languages.
The Belgae are usually thought of as a Celtic speaking people, although some linguists have
proposed that they originally spoke another Indo-European language that was neither Celtic
nor Germanic.
The same linguists suggested that this language was also spoken by these western Germani,
which, according to them, is apparent in certain shared grammatical innovations and even in
a supposedly pre-Germanic and pre-Celtic vocabulary that survives to this day in that region.
So we can assume that the western Germani probably didn't speak a Germanic language
originally, which also fits the archaeological record much better, seeing as western Germania
at the time was still mostly dominated by a regional variety of the Latin culture, with
particularly close ties to the territory of the Belgae.
But what about the Suebi?
We do know from personal and place names that a Germanic language was spoken in the territory
occupied by the Suebi, and their expansion went hand in hand with the dispersal of Germanic
languages throughout large parts of central Europe in later centuries.
That and the fact that their homeland roughly coincided with the territory of the Jastav
culture, which in turn developed around the same time as Proto-Germanic developed, strengthens
the case for the Suebi being Germanic speakers, and that again is highly relevant in the context
of the Przeworsk burials which we find in western and south-western Germania during
the 1st century BC.
Caesar tells us that 14 years prior to his arrival in Gaul, some of the Suebi had settled
on the western bank of the Rhine under their leader Ariovistus, and he was one of Caesar's
chief adversaries in the early stages of his campaigns.
Even though Ariovistus was defeated and his Suebi expelled from Gaul, Caesar on several
occasions tells us of other groups of Suebi pushing west into the territories of the western
Germani, in some cases even displacing them, and he also states that this has been happening
for some time, perhaps for as long or even longer as Ariovistus had been in Gaul for,
meaning decades.
The fact that this coincides with the presence of Przeworsk groups in the region suggests
that Caesar and perhaps the western Germani saw the people of the Przeworsk culture as
Suebi, and thus probably as speakers of Proto-Germanic.
But just because the people of the Przeworsk culture spoke Proto-Germanic at that time
doesn't mean that they had always spoken this language.
As we have seen, the Przeworsk culture was influenced heavily by the Jastav culture and
resembled it in terms of burial customs by the 1st century BC.
If the people of the Przeworsk culture had not spoken Proto-Germanic originally, they
may have adopted it at the same time they adopted the burial customs of the Germanic
Jastav culture.
A little later, around the middle of the 1st century BC, the Jastav culture in turn started
adopting the practice of adding weapons to their burials from the Przeworsk culture,
indicating that communication between both cultures was relatively easy.
These developments led to the two cultures becoming more alike, perhaps making it difficult
for outsiders to differentiate between them.
The shared burial customs may point to shared religious beliefs further blurring the lines.
So in conclusion, the Przeworsk culture seems to have been built upon a native Pomeranian
foundation, which was heavily influenced by both Germanic elements associated with the
Jastav culture from the north, as well as Celtic elements associated with the Latin
culture to the south.
By the time people belonging to this archaeological culture are first identifiable in the historical
record, they are characterised as Germanic by Roman sources, probably based on certain
similarities with the Jastav culture, particularly a shared Proto-Germanic language and perhaps
also similar customs and beliefs expressed in related burial practices.
This is in spite of the fact that in terms of material culture, the people of the Przeworsk
culture were also quite similar to Central European Celts.
Because we only hear about these people from the middle of the 1st century onwards, we
can't say for certain whether the Przeworsk culture and particularly its predecessor,
the Pomeranian culture, had always been Germanic.
Because the Proto-Germanic language had only developed around 500 BC and is usually associated
with the Jastav culture and southern Scandinavia, it is unlikely that the Pomeranian culture,
which had formed during the 7th century BC, was originally Germanic.
That being said, according to some linguists, the changes that led to the development of
Proto-Germanic might have been triggered by contact of people of the Nordic Bronze Age
with people from the Urnfield culture, to which the Pomeranian culture can ultimately
be traced back.
So it is possible that the people of the Pomeranian culture spoke a language closely related to
Proto-Germanic, which is why their descendants, the people of the Przeworsk culture, could
adopt this language relatively easily.
But what are your thoughts on the Przeworsk culture and this theory?
Do you think they spoke a Germanic language or maybe a Celtic language or something else
entirely?
Let me know in the comments below.
And if you enjoyed the video, make sure to check out my other videos on related topics,
such as the previous one on the genetic evidence of the Germanic migrations.
If you want to learn more, there's a link to my Patreon below, where you'll get access
to over 300 pages worth of academic essays written by yours truly on this and on other
related topics.
All support is greatly appreciated.
But for now, thank you so much for watching and I'm looking forward to seeing you in
the next one.
