Cooper Smith from the America First Policy Institute joined NTD’s News Today to discuss the changes to ICE that Democratic lawmakers are demanding. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
So a major sticking point here is the honoring of ICE detainers.
On the radio this morning, I heard the person in charge of a major prison that serves the
Minneapolis area saying she will only release prisoners to ICE if ICE has a signed judicial
warrant. She says she won't accept a warrant issued by the DHS itself, aka an ICE detainer.
Now with us to explore is Cooper Smith, Director of Homeland Security and Immigration at the
First Policy Institute. Cooper, great to see you. Thanks for coming on this afternoon.
The prison I brought up just now says it's simply following the law.
Should ICE be obtaining judicial warrants more often?
Well, ICE both uses judicial warrants and administrative warrants. And I think that
list of 10 demands that you were just reporting on a moment ago from Chuck Schumer and Jeffries
basically would abolish ICE as we know it. And included in those 10 demands
are the requirement that they use judicial warrants, which if that were to go through,
ICE would have no ability to remove the 15 or 20 million people who came here under Joe Biden.
So I think that particular demand, along with a few others, are going to be non-starters
for John Thune and the Republican Party. And like I said, I think that list would effectively
abolish ICE as we know it. And it seems to me that their true goal here is to end immigration
enforcement altogether. Well, Cooper, go into this for us. How exactly would requiring them
to get judicial warrants impact them to that degree? Sure, because then ICE would have to
go to a federal judge every time they wanted to conduct an operation. And again, we're talking
about a scale of a problem here, 15, 20, potentially more millions of people who came here,
especially under Joe Biden's term with open borders policies. So just due to the scale
of the problem created here, if you were to require ICE to only use judicial warrants,
it would effectively neuter the agency and render them completely useless.
Well, on that point, critics of the deportation operation say, well, this is the law.
Where exactly do we stand on that? Well, yeah, the law also says if you have no legal right to
be here, then you should be removed. So I find it really ironic from the left who's saying that
this is immigration law. Well, if they read Title VIII of the U.S. Code, they would know that
entering the country illegally is a crime. If you come again, it's a felony. Unfortunately,
the Department of Justice doesn't have the resources to prosecute all of those cases.
But back to the reporting that you just said about Tom Homan, you know,
when we talk about smart enforcement, we're talking about sanctuary jurisdictions. Of course,
ICE operates in 100 percent of the country, in all 50 states, all day, every day. And I think
what the administration is doing here is trying a different approach as it relates to sanctuary
jurisdictions, which, in my opinion, should be ended completely. But unfortunately, that would
take an act of Congress. And as we know, they can't even seem to pass a budget in relation to
DHS at the moment. Well, Cooper, on that point, as you say, Homan said 700 agents have been
withdrawn from Minneapolis. Democrats on their side are calling for more targeted operations.
Do you expect major changes there in Minneapolis? Well, I do. Look, I think Tom Homan and the
president said, you know, after the last couple of weeks that they need a new approach and they
need smart enforcement. They need to go into a safe jail setting to get these violent criminal
aliens out. I think it's also important to remember that, as you reported on, 4,000 criminal
illegal aliens have already been removed from Minneapolis since Metro surge started. But going
back to the beginning of the Trump administration, we're talking about 10,000 people who've been
removed from that state. So, you know, I don't think we're going to see a huge change in those
numbers. I think the numbers will continue to tick up. I think mass deportation will continue.
And that's what the president has indicated. And I just want to note some of the people
lifted out of Minneapolis during this operation have committed terrible crimes. I think oftentimes
this gets overlooked. Staying on the point, the president said his deportation operation
maybe could have used a softer touch. He did say you still need to be tough.
What do you think that means? Particularly, where do you think this lighter touch may come in?
Yeah, again, going back to my original point, I think what they're doing here,
when he says softer touch, it's in relation to sanctuary jurisdiction policies, right?
Going back to the beginning of the Trump administration, they've been trying to get
rid of sanctuary cities, either by, you know, taking their resources from them or outright
banning them altogether. Congress has been working on that as well. But while that works through the
courts and through Congress, what the president and Tom Homan are saying is, OK, maybe that
particular model didn't work in a sanctuary jurisdiction. Perhaps we need to negotiate more,
come to an agreement. And my hope is what I think will happen is if Tom Homan is able to
successfully negotiate with local sheriffs, with the mayor, with the governor, perhaps that can
serve as a model for other sanctuary states and other sanctuary jurisdictions, whether that's
California and Illinois, New Jersey, New Mexico, other states who are against the president's
immigration priorities, but who nonetheless need to comply with federal law and should.
And Cooper, Homan says that over there in Minnesota that local officials are open to
cooperating more with ICE on these. But when you listen to some of the local officials,
it doesn't seem so clear cut. Are we waiting, for example, for this to play through the courts?
Particularly, I want to go back to the original point on these ICE detainers and the legality
of actually having states and local authorities enforce them. Is it going to be a watershed
moment here? I mean, potentially, I think you could see it working its way through the courts,
but I'm not really sure. Again, I don't imagine that Congress is going to agree to this. This is
not going to be a possibility for the Republican Party to come to the table on judicial warrant
reform as it relates to ICE. Again, I think members of Congress realize that President Trump
was elected overwhelmingly on a simple promise, and that was to deport people here who have no
legal right to be here, especially those with a criminal record, gang members, rapists, human
traffickers, and the like. And that's what the American people want. And additionally, I'd point
to recent polling that just came out from Harvard Harris saying that 73 percent of all Americans
want criminal aliens deported. Seventy-three percent. So all this kind of gusto about the
president's poll numbers are tanking on this issue is just totally nonsensical. The American people
want criminal aliens removed, and I think reform to judicial warrants is not going to be on the
table. Interesting. Cooper, finally, Democrats also demanding that ICE agents show ID and don't
wear face masks. Republicans say it could put their safety at risk. But how is this demand any
different from, say, regular law enforcement and their requirements? I think there's two issues
here. One is on body cameras, which you've seen both parties have come together and said,
you know, we're going to get $20 million to ICE for body cameras. They're going to roll it out,
as Secretary Noem said, starting in Minneapolis. Also important to remember that ICE has used body
cameras. They've been exploring them and paying for them for the last four or five years. They
just needed more funding. They're going to get that. As it relates to face masks, again, these
agents are facing an 8,000 percent increase in death threats against them, according to the
Department of Homeland Security. Eight thousand percent. And it's not just the agent. It's
unfortunately their families, it's their children who are getting involved in the doxing. So I think
they do need to be protected. They do need to have that ability to keep the masks on. And I don't
imagine that Republicans are going to change their mind on that issue. It's incredible what's
happening. Cooper Smith at the America First Policy Institute. Cooper, thank you.