The Buddha Doubted His Own Awakening Here Is Why

People & Faith
22 followers
23 Video Views·Feb 4, 2026
The Buddha doubted his own awakening. Here is why.
It's a common belief that different religions, different philosophies are giving different
answers to the same question. But actually they come from different questions. The Buddha's big
question is, what is suffering and how can you put an end to it? That's a question that other
religions tend to leave in mystery. They point your attention to something else.
But the Buddha's focus is right here and his analysis comes down to the fact that you can
do something about suffering because you're causing it. So you have to look inside and the
reason you're causing it is not because you want to. It's because you're ignorant. The word for
avijja can also mean lack of skill. We suffer because we lack skill. But skill is something
that can be developed. In fact, you have to develop it yourself. No one else can make you
skillful. They can give pointers. They can give advice. But to become skillful, you have to be
observant of what you're doing and what you might do differently. You have to depend on yourself.
Now you do rely on other people to learn about the Dharma. When the Buddha is talking about
the different qualities that make you reliable and make you a mainstay for yourself or provide
a protector for yourself, quite a few of them have to do with your relationship to other people.
You find good people to associate with. People who have conviction in the Buddha's awakening.
People who are generous, virtuous, discerning. And you try to emulate their qualities.
You listen to the Dharma. You try to remember it, think about it so that it makes sense
and then measure your own actions against the Dharma. And you're not simply involved in listening.
You're really actively trying to search it out. As the Buddha says, you try to be easy to teach.
Now, this doesn't mean simply doing everything unquestioningly. But you show some respect.
You take on a teaching and you give it a good try. If it doesn't work, you try to figure out why.
You can't just come to the teacher and complain, this isn't working for me.
I mean, there are meditation methods where they simply tell you, just do this and do what you're
told and don't think about it. Promising that when you put your mind through the meat grinder,
it's going to come out awakened. But that's not how they teach in the forest tradition.
And that's not how the Buddha taught either. When something goes wrong, you have to try to
figure out what the problem might be. Try to figure it out on your own first. And then
you go consult with a teacher. That's what it means to be easy to teach.
Then given those external conditions, there's still a lot that you've got to do on your own.
It's interesting that when the Buddha talks about being self-reliant in many different contexts,
the big point they have in common is that you have to be mindful.
In other words, you learn a lesson and you keep it in mind. You don't forget it.
Otherwise, you can learn things, but they don't mean anything because you forget them.
You learn them again, you forget them again. It's when you're mindful. In other words,
when you learn how to keep things in mind, you learn how to remember things.
That's how you keep your storage of knowledge. All the things that you've picked up will be
available to you. It's like your inner set of tools. You get to the point where you don't
have to rely on people outside to provide you with the Dhamma. Because you've learned so much,
both from what you've heard and read, and also from what you've done. And it's there,
it's available. That's what you can fall back on. This, the Buddha said, is how you make yourself
an island. You're mindful, ardent, alert, and you keep looking into. Why is it that the mind is
creating suffering for itself? You get the mind quiet, you get it still, so that you can watch
the mind. Fortunately, the mind is something you can watch. This is where the fact of the
committee of the mind comes in really helpful. One part of the mind can watch another part of
mind. In fact, as you develop this observer, that's the alertness part. It becomes the part
that's also going to allow you to gain some discernment by stepping back from your actions
to evaluate them. If you're totally in the action, if you're committed to it, you identify with it
and you don't want it to be judged. There's a part of the mind that says,
if I did it, it must be right. And I don't want any criticisms. I don't want any commentary on
this. You see this attitude more and more around us all the time. Well, that's a recipe for disaster.
Because if you're not willing to step back from your actions, how can you learn? You make a
mistake and you don't even admit that it's a mistake. That closes off all the avenues for
learning from your mistakes. And if you don't learn from your mistakes, what are you going to
learn from? You learn words and as they say in Thailand, they decorate your mind. That's all.
They stay on the surface. But it's in learning from your mistakes that the knowledge goes deeper.
Ajahn Chah has a nice observation. He says that as you watch your mind,
the first lesson you learn is how much the mind lies to itself. Now, you're not going to see that
unless you can step back and say, oh yes, one part of the mind is trying to hide something from
another part of the mind. When you can step back like this, this is how you can really rely on
yourself. You have the voice inside that evaluates and evaluates more and more wisely,
more and more perceptively, with more and more maturity gained through the practice.
There's so much commentary on how bad it is to engage in the judging mind.
Well, it's usually the judgmental mind that's the problem. The one that jumps to judgments
without much evidence and comes down harshly with no concern for whether it's helpful or not.
What you want is the kind of judgment that's helpful, that points out where the problem is
and also points out where a solution might be a possible way of doing things better.
That's the kind of internal judge that you want to develop. The judging of a craftsman working on a
project, not the judge who's passing down a final verdict. You have to realize your life,
your practice, the path is a work in progress and so you want the kind of judgment that points out,
yeah, you're getting off the path but here's a way to get back on. The judgment that gives
encouragement when you need encouragement and can be harsh when you need a little kick in the rear.
But with the idea that this is going to be good for you, that you can get better
because of the criticism. So, try to train this observer. Picking up lessons from outside,
good examples set by other people and then develop your internal judge because that's
what you're going to be relying on. The one who, like every good judge, has a good knowledge of
In this case, good knowledge of the dhamma and can remember it, has it at his or her fingertips
and is more and more alert in applying it. That's how you become your own refuge
and that's how you answer this question. Why is it that you're causing suffering?
You see your actions more and more clearly. The internal judge helps you develop your skill
so that what you do and say and think, instead of being a cause for suffering,
becomes part of the path to its cessation. Make yourself reliable. One of the really
impressive things you learn when you read about the Buddha's awakening is how often he tested it.
He looked at it from many angles. Could he see any affluence at all in his mind?
Could he see any defilements? Was there any limitation on his knowledge?
The one limitation he admitted to was knowledge of the future and that's because, as he saw,
the future's not totally predetermined. There may be tendencies and sometimes he would make
predictions about the future, that there would be tendencies in the future, the downfall of the
dhamma, the rise of counterfeit dhamma, the disappearance of the true dhamma, monks who
didn't practice and who, as he said, spent their time searching out the tip-top flavors
with the tips of their tongues. But as for when this would happen
and who would do it, that he didn't say. After all, we do have freedom of choice.
We can choose not to be those types of people and we can work on that determination.
One thing he did know about the future was that he had no rebirth waiting for him because there
were no possible seeds for it in his mind. But he checked again and again. There's even a passage
where he talks about how, if his awakening really were the awakening of a true Buddha,
he'd have to know all about devas, what levels there were, how to talk with the devas on those
levels to see where their limitations were, how he'd been born on that particular level in the
past. The only levels he hadn't been born in were the levels where the non-returners go.
So, he looked at his awakening from all angles. That was why, when he taught, he was confident
in what he had to say. So, when we take the Buddha as an example, that's one of the main
things we should take as examples. The willingness to test our knowledge, test our understanding.
Sometimes we think that the knowledge we get from books is uncertain.
But the knowledge that comes from meditation is to be trusted. But not always. It depends
on how you treat that knowledge, the extent to which you're willing to ask questions about it
and look at it from different angles. This is where the fact of having a committee of the mind,
which can so often be a problem because the members can be pulling in different directions,
can actually be helpful. They'll be part of the mind that gets convinced about something.
But you can look around for another part of the mind that's willing to question it.
Think of Ajahn Moon in the forest. He realized very quickly that if he believed everything that
came in his visions, he was going to go crazy. So, even if it seemed to be the Buddha coming
to talk to him or Devas coming to talk to him, the question wasn't, who is this that's giving
me this information and how much can I trust that person? The question was, what does the
information have to say? Is it something that fits in with the Dharma as I know it?
If it doesn't fit in with the Dharma, you can forget about it. If it does fit in with the Dharma,
to what extent is it really useful? So, you put it to the test.
And putting it to the test means that you have to be a fair judge. It's one of the reasons why
the Buddha started his meditation instructions to Rahula with the advice that he should try to
make his mind like earth. The more you're able to be with pleasant and unpleasant things
and not let them overcome you, then the more you can trust your judgment of them
to see where they come from, to see what they lead to. So, the question isn't,
what is the source of this knowledge? A vision in the meditation or what is often called the
knowledge of the body is not necessarily a reliable source. Your body has been so shaped
by your mind and so shaped by your defilements that the body can't be trusted as a source of
knowledge either because your greed, aversion and delusion have learned how to hijack your breath
and through the breath they get control of the hormones.
So, the way you feel your body from within often has nothing to do with any wisdom at all.
It has more to do with the fact that you have certain habits. When anger comes,
you tense up the body in one way. Greed comes, lust comes, fear comes, laziness comes.
When you're feeling lazy, you can create all kinds of sensations in the body that make it
seem really convincing that you'd have to rest. So, you have to take a questioning attitude
and you have to learn how to read yourself, which means learning how to step back.
You can't spend all your time with the teacher, asking questions of the teacher
and fully trusting the answers you're going to get. You've got to test them. After all,
it is your breath. In your relationship to the body, you have a history that you should know
better than anyone else. So, when you get angry, how does the anger take hold of your breath?
When you get lustful, how does the lust take hold of your breath? What can you do to counteract that?
Use your powers of observation. Use your ingenuity. Ajaan Phuang's refrains.
But also use your powers of concentration, mindfulness. The things that make the mind
more and more steady. If the mind isn't steady, it's hard to see what's actually going on and
to pass a fair judgment. It's like getting very precise scientific equipment but putting it on
a wobbly table. The wobbles of the table will make the output from the equipment totally unreliable.
You've got to get things firmly established. And because the mind is more complex
than physical things, you have to learn how to look at things from different directions.
It's in this way that you internalize the teachings. You test the teachings at the same
time that you test yourself over time. Think about the Buddha's requirements for a student.
He wanted someone who was observant and no deceiver. Now, in the first instance,
that's someone who doesn't deceive other people but also doesn't deceive him or herself.
That's a tall order. Ajaan Chah once said that one of the first things you notice when you
really look at the mind with all honesty is how dishonest it can be. So, both the mind and the
body can be dishonest but they also have their potential for honesty. Particularly the mind.
It's the mind that we're training. We use the body to get more and more sensitive to how our
unskillful emotions can take over our sense of just who we are inside. We're living in the body
and those emotions can make the body really really uncomfortable. As they say in Thailand,
they put a squeeze on your nerves so that you feel you have to act under those defilements.
Well, learn how to resist that. This is one of the reasons why we work with the breath.
We're taking the breath back, learning to get it on our side. From the breath, it affects
other physical processes in the body as well. As you develop these habits, you do become more
and more reliable and you do begin to get some knowledge you can trust. Think of the Buddha
talking to the Kalamas. Just because a teacher says something doesn't mean it's true.
Just because it's in the text doesn't mean it's true. Everybody likes that part of the Sutta.
But he also says that just because something seems reasonable doesn't mean it's true either.
Just because it fits in with your preconceived notions doesn't mean it's true. You've got to
test and see. Does a particular teaching, a particular understanding cause harm or
does it not cause harm? And what counts as harm? And how sensitive are you to the harm that your
actions can do? So the Sutta is not the Buddha's charter of free inquiry, as they call it. It's
his indication of what standards you have to adopt if you really want to find the truth.
It's when your standards are true that you're more and more likely to run into what is true
and to recognize it as true, as something you can trust implicitly. But it has to pass the test
first. So be willing to test things. Years back, Ajahn Mahabhuva made a comment about Ajahn Suwat
to the effect that he'd already finished his work as a meditator. Word got to Ajahn Suwat
and he didn't take it as a 100% guarantee. He kept questioning. And one day, he told me after
the meal, you know, when Ajahn Mahabhuva said that, it wasn't true. So even when you get
certification from somebody as trustworthy as that, you still have to test it. After all,
you're going to be the final judge. Does your knowledge really help put an end to suffering?
Does it help you look at your habits that are unskillful and help pull you out of them?
When you've put things to that test, again and again and again, then you become a more
reliable judge. And the knowledge you gain can become more reliable as well.
