LIVE: Senate Foreign Relations Committee Examines European Energy Security

Live News Network
1.4K followers
27 Video Views·Feb 4, 2026
The Senate Foreign Relations Committee holds a hearing at 2:30 p.m. ET on Feb. 4 to examine European energy security.
Witnesses:
Geoffrey Pyatt, senior managing director, Energy and Critical Minerals, McLarty Associates; distinguished fellow, Global Energy Center, Atlantic Council, Washington, D.C.
Dan Byers, vice president of policy, Global Energy Institute, U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Washington, D.C.
Member Murphy, a chart I'm going to share with everybody here as we start this hearing
that shows some alarming figures with you all.
Before I get into that, I need to officially state this hearing of the Senate Foreign Relations
Committee will now come to order.
On this iPad here, I've got a live tracker of European purchases of Russian energy since
the start of the invasion in Ukraine.
Now, we're not allowed to have big PowerPoint presentations here, but bear with me.
This thing's just clicking down or clicking up, I should say, euros.
And right now it says 219 billion, 221 million, 431,104, now let's jump to 581 euros that have
now been invested in Russia in purchasing Russian oil and Russian gas.
It's called Russianfossiltracker.com if you want to see it yourself.
And it goes back to the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
So the number right now, as I mentioned, about 220 billion euros.
As of December, the EU had provided around 200 billion euros of aid to Ukraine.
European purchases of Russian energy are funding the largest land war in Europe since the
Second World War.
I just want to set the stage with that before we get started.
I want to thank our two witnesses for being here today to discuss such an important topic.
And a great deal of thanks to Ranking Member Murphy for his participation and help in
organizing this hearing.
Our bipartisan cooperation on these issues will shine a light on some of the good work
Europe has done to sharpen security, as well as the policy changes the EU can enact to
ensure the continent's energy security.
Now on to our witnesses.
Geoffrey Payette is a distinguished fellow at the Atlantic Council's Global Energy
Center and a senior managing director at McLarty Associates.
Prior to his current positions, he had a long and distinguished career at the U.S.
Foreign Service, serving as Assistant Secretary of State for Energy Resources, as U.S.
ambassador to Ukraine and Greece, and other senior postings both abroad and in Foggy
Bottom. He has extensive experience working on European energy security issues.
We are grateful he could be with us here today to share his expertise.
Thank you. Dan Byers is vice president of policy at the Global Energy Institute at the
U.S. Chamber of Commerce, where he focuses on environmental and regulatory issues.
He previously served as a staff director for the House Energy and Environment
Subcommittee, as an official in the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy
and on the White House Economic Council.
Mr. Byers is deeply knowledgeable about energy regulation and energy markets.
We're grateful he could be here today to share some of his knowledge with us.
So on to the matter at hand.
Energy security is national security.
Both the United States and Europe have become increasingly aware of that fact over the
last four years, creating an opportunity for us to collectively build a resilient energy
production and transport network that would form the bedrock of our economies.
The European Commission's recent regulatory reform is a step in the right direction,
aligning block wide regulations with more pro energy, pro business, pro market policies
and passing that reform to creativity and courage.
I'd like to commend the European People's Party and their voting partners for the good
work they've done on that package.
But there's still a lot more to do.
Clearly, all of Europe must recognize that it cannot function or recognize its economic
and security goals without baseload power, and it must enact further regulatory reform
to modernize the European energy ecosystem.
The continent has an opportunity to permanently end its resilience, its reliance on
Russian energy, providing true independence and autonomy for America's partners on
the other side of the Atlantic.
Without enacting further regulatory reforms, Europe may find itself staring down the
barrel of resuming Russian energy dominance or extortion, putting itself back into the
vulnerable position it found itself in 2022.
If Europe learns nothing else from the Russian invasion of Ukraine, let it be that
energy security and supply chains are vital to national sovereignty.
Compromises can't be made in those matters.
We must work together to ensure those networks, resilience and survivability.
I remember a trip I took to the Baltics a few years ago.
I remember hearing the story about once upon a time, the nuclear reactor that existed
there that was dismantled, taken out of production as a request to join the EU.
And they took me up to the Baltic Sea where I could see a beautiful new LNG import
terminal. But once upon a time, Lithuania used to be a net energy exporter.
And after actions taken, short sighted to remove the base load power of their nuclear
power station, they became an energy importer.
And of course, with the Russian invasion of Ukraine, that problem clearly was further
exacerbated. I encourage our European partners to take a realistic view on building
reliable energy infrastructure.
One need look no further than Spain and Portugal to see the dangers of overreliance on
intermittent sources.
The entire Iberian Peninsula found itself without power last year, underscoring the
vulnerability of countries that fail to maintain a diverse set of energy sources.
And to be clear, where I stand on here, I want to see a diverse energy portfolio.
I just want to see more electrons and more base load power and more diversity of energy.
As the West builds the economy that will drive our countries forward, base load power
will become even more important, whether it be for data centers, manufacturing or
defense production. Reliable power is the backbone, certainly of future prosperity.
The United States and many of our partners and allies stand at the ready to work with
Europe to increase energy supply, be it oil, gas, nuclear, hydro or renewables.
The reinvigoration of our economies will require a holistic, truly all the above
energy approach. And I believe Europe must act now, enacting the regulatory reforms and
infrastructure investments necessary to sign long term energy import and development
contracts and ensure the continent's future.
Prosperity and security are dependent on such changes.
And I look forward to continuing to work with our European partners to build a more
secure future for both Europe and the rest of the world.
Now, I'd like to recognize the very distinguished member and ranking member for his
comments, Senator Murphy.
Thank you very much, Senator Dane. Thanks for pulling this hearing together.
Really looking forward to hearing from our witnesses today.
When Russia launched its full scale invasion of Ukraine, it didn't just shatter the
postwar inviolability of Europe's borders.
It exposed this glaring strategic weakness in European security and energy
architecture, deeply and dangerously dependent on Russian oil and gas.
For years, Europe's reliance on Moscow's pipelines wasn't just an economic
vulnerability. It was a geopolitical lever that Vladimir Putin had designed and could
pull at any time to coerce his neighbors and fracture democratic consensus,
especially in Europe. That leverage became painfully clear when Moscow threatened to
cut off energy flowing through Ukraine to the rest of the continent.
And Europe was left scrambling to ensure its citizens had enough power to keep their
homes. Ultimately, this is a good news story in that Europe did not bow to Russia's
demands. Instead, the EU has worked successfully to end the dependence, their
dependence on Russia and improve its energy security.
Europe used to buy almost half its gas from Russia.
Now that figure is down to 20 percent, with a new commitment to buy zero oil or gas
from Russia by 2027.
In yet another example of Putin's miscalculations, what he intended as a leverage
to try to split Europe has ended up reducing Russia's influence on Europe.
Now, the Biden administration, assisted by a bipartisan consensus in Congress, helped
Europe make this transition.
For example, at Ambassador Pyatt's urging, I led a bipartisan effort to allow the
Development Finance Corporation to finance strategic energy projects in Europe,
something that had not been allowed under the law prior to that change.
I want to thank Senator Johnson and other Republicans who helped make that change in
law happen. But President Trump threatens to unwind a lot of the progress that Europe
has made, in part because he constantly injects frictions into our relationship with
Europe that causes Europe to spend all of its time trying to plan and plot its response
to Donald Trump instead of staying united in its efforts to fight back against Russia's
political leverage.
Trump's rhetoric and his policy towards Europe has been wild.
It's been erratic. He levies tariffs that have nothing to do with the United States and
are instead simply punitive.
He threatens war with Europe over, unbelievably, Greenland.
He's pulled the U.S. out of nearly every important international organization where the
United States and Europe traditionally have built strength to confront Russia and China.
He praises Putin, gives Putin the legitimizing photo ops that Putin so badly desires.
And, of course, Putin stands and cheers as Trump injects such instability into the U.S.-
Europe relationship that Europe spends its time managing that relationship instead of
making more down payments on its efforts to become fully energy independent of Russia.
But it gets worse.
So, listen, I am a supporter of getting American LNG to Europe.
I believe that's a really important near-term and medium-term bridge.
But I ultimately want a world in which Europe and the United States are energy
self-sufficient. The sun does shine in Europe.
The wind blows. Nuclear power works.
But President Trump's war on non-fossil fuel energy is really bad for European energy
security. We need to make advancements on solar and wind technology and technology
controlled by the United States and Europe, not technology controlled by China.
Small-scale nuclear has got to be on that list as well so that Europe can permanently get
itself off oil and gas.
Being dependent on Azerbaijan or Saudi Arabia or Venezuela or Iran isn't much better
than being dependent on Russia.
And then to top it all off, when the United States does get involved in these short-term
alternatives, which I think are incredibly necessary to Russian oil, corruption creeps
in. Reports are coming out of the Balkans suggesting that President Trump is providing
critical American support for an energy project that is being led by two individuals
whose qualifications are simply that they helped Donald Trump overturn the 2020
election. Joseph Flynn and Jesse Banal have no qualifications to build a pipeline in
the Balkans. They are being pushed by the administration to get involved in this
project because they are close to the president.
So there are lots of topics for today's hearing.
I think it's vitally important.
There are lots of places where the chairman and I agree, especially when it comes to
the short-term work we have to do to shore up Europe's energy reserves and their
flows. A lot has gone right in Europe.
They have made this hard pivot off Russian energy.
But a lot of examination is still, I think, left to do in the ways that the Trump
administration is very often standing in the way rather than helping Europe complete
this transition. Again, really looking forward to the witnesses.
Mr. Chairman, thanks for convening the hearing.
All right, Senator Murphy, thank you.
Our first witness is the Honorable Jeffrey Pyatt, Senior Managing Director, Energy and
Critical Minerals, McLarty Associates and Distinguished Fellow, Global Energy Center,
Atlantic Council. Mr. Pyatt, the floor is yours.
Great. Thank you very much, Mr.
Chairman, Ranking Member Murphy.
I'm delighted to be here.
I enjoyed tremendous support from this committee during 12 years as a presidential
appointee representing the United States around the world.
And it's a tremendous honor to be speaking now as a private citizen, but also to be
doing so on issues that my team at the State Department focused on every single day,
advancing exactly the framework that you suggested, Mr.
Chairman, the understanding that energy security is national security.
I have a longer prepared statement, which I will simply introduce for the record.
I would like to focus these oral remarks on a couple of simple points.
And first of all, Mr.
Chairman, I want to say I'm with you on the the tracker and the iPad data you showed.
And I will just recall and I expect Senator Murphy will also recall a long
evening in the winter of 2013 spent with President Yanukovych in Kiev, where the
president filibustered to explain all of the difficulties that he was living with.
But the number one difficulty was the pressure that President Putin was applying
to President Yanukovych as he was trying to navigate through the political
complexities of the Maidan.
And I think I also remember vividly many visits to Ukraine with Senator Murphy,
with Senator McCain, many others, where we talked about exactly the issue you
highlighted, which was the risks to Europe from its dependency on Russian energy
supplies and the importance of breaking that dependency as fast as possible.
I would also say in this regard, I was so pleased to see the news last week with
the Foreign Relations Committee reporting out the Shadow Fleet Act.
That's exactly the kind of measure the United States ought to be taking to write
into law sanctions against Novotek, Arctic LNG, to to harmonize U.S.
sanctions against Nord Stream two with European sanctions, because when Congress
acts in this way, the markets listen because that has the force of law and it
will last from one administration to the next.
So this is so, so important.
I want to highlight and I've also highlighted in my my written statement
the point Senator Murphy made, the dramatic progress that we have achieved
through bipartisan efforts over many years to change the European approach to
Russian energy. And I would put a particular spotlight on the regulations
that the European Union implemented just this week, which will accomplish a full
phase out of all Russian gas by 2027.
But in fact, within two months, we'll bar spot contracts on LNG.
This represents a huge win for the United States.
It also advances President Trump's vision of forcing Putin to negotiate by
signaling to him that there is a real cost from his continued war in Ukraine,
the attacks that he is waging even this week on the people of Ukraine.
And I think it hasn't been sufficiently appreciated in the Washington
conversation what an enormous accomplishment this is for American
transatlantic energy diplomacy, but also the degree to which it was enabled,
not just by Putin's strategic short sightedness and he has lost Europe as a
market forever, I am quite confident, but also by the accomplishments of the
U.S. LNG industry by our producers who have achieved massive efficiencies,
who have grown the United States into the largest LNG exporter in the world
and who have demonstrated to the Europeans that the cleanest,
most reliable and most affordable option for displacing Russian gas is American
LNG.
The other point I want to put a spotlight on for just a moment is the work that
Europe continues to do to build the infrastructure that is necessary to
remap its energy system from one that was earlier dependent on Russia to a new
one that will be oriented to the West.
One project that is emblematic in this area,
which I was proud to champion both as ambassador to Greece and then as
assistant secretary, is the vertical corridor,
which involves building infrastructure and utilizing old Soviet infrastructure
to bring gas and LNG from Southeastern Europe and especially from re-gas
facilities in Greece, northward into Bulgaria, Romania,
Moldova and Ukraine.
And just to give you one specific example,
just in the past few weeks, Ukraine's largest private energy company,
DTEK, for the first time had a delivery of American LNG,
which was landed at Revathusa outside Athens,
was then delivered to Ukraine and put into Ukraine's underground storage
facilities and then delivered to customers in Poland.
So already the vertical corridor is demonstrating its utility as a strategic
project.
The best work that I did in government is the work that others follow up on.
So I'm absolutely delighted that Jared Egan at the National Energy Dominance
Council, Secretary Wright, have all championed the same project.
And I'm confident between the alignment of the Ukrainian partners,
what Greek companies are doing and what the European Commission importantly is
doing,
we'll see this become a successful template for how we re-engineer the energy
map of Europe for an era where Europe will never again be dependent on
unreliable Russian supplies. Thank you very much.
Thank you. I will turn now to Mr. Dan Byers,
Vice President of Policy, Global Energy Institute, U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
Mr. Byers, the floor is yours.
Thank you, Chairman Daines, Ranking Member Murphy,
for the opportunity to testify today. As you said, I'm Dan Byers.
I'm with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Global Energy Institute,
where among other things,
we focus on expanding market access for U.S. exports while boosting energy
security for America and our allies. As we enter 2026,
Europe continues to take important steps to reduce its dependence on Russian
energy.
But it does still remain the world's largest buyer of Russian gas,
importing LNG and pipeline volumes worth an estimated €15 billion in 2025.
As you said, these purchases fund the Kremlin's war machine,
leave the continent exposed to significant security and supply risks.
Fortunately,
more progress is on the horizon with newly approved EU legislation last month
mandating the complete phase out of Russian gas imports by the end of
2027.
The Trump administration has strongly encouraged this development and in
December convened the Partnership for Transatlantic Energy Cooperation,
or the P-TECH Forum in Athens,
where several important business deals and policy goals were announced alongside
European leaders.
This high level political support is bolstered by the fact that energy is a
centerpiece of the U.S.-EU trade deal and further complemented by a U.S.
export industry more than ready to help the EU meet this challenge.
Already the world's leading exporter,
the U.S. has dominated global LNG project development and contracting activity
since the Department of Energy's pause on licensing new facilities was lifted in
early 2025 with more than $60 billion in new investments now
underway.
In short,
America's growing LNG supply is an obvious and timely solution to Europe's
growing natural gas supply gap and the industry is poised to deliver the
security and market stability our allies need.
Despite this progress,
a number of regulatory and investment obstacles are hampering transatlantic
commercial relationships and must be addressed.
On the regulatory side,
I want to call attention to the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence
Directive and the EU Methane Emissions Regulation.
My written testimony expands on both of these,
but in brief,
CS triple D is a sweeping law requiring U.S.
companies to align their global operations with EU standards that are not
binding under U.S.
law and it could make American companies liable in EU courts for conduct that is
perfectly lawful in the U.S.
This extraterritorial overreach is a major obstacle to enhance trade and
investment and the Chamber is leading efforts to address it.
Meanwhile,
the EU Methane Emissions Regulation,
which requires importers of oil and gas to report producer level emissions data
and meet certain methane emissions intensity standards subject to
non-compliance penalties of up to 20% of the importer's total worldwide
revenues.
This has imposed significant risks that are impeding negotiation of new supply
agreements with U.S.
gas exporters.
These concerns are not limited to the United States.
In Europe,
various industry coalitions have issued increasingly urgent warnings that the
law is quote,
unworkable jeopardizes European energy security and competitiveness and is likely
to lead to higher energy costs.
We face an equally important challenge on the investment side where a number of
strategic infrastructure projects are needed to reduce vulnerabilities and
unlock access to regional markets.
In particular,
I want to follow up Ambassador Pyatt and highlighting the Vertical Gas Corridor,
which aims to expand continuous South to North transport capacity from Greece to
Ukraine,
providing countries in Southeastern Europe,
a reliable LNG alternative to Russian pipeline gas and so-called Turkish blends
transiting into the EU from Turkey.
Despite strong political support,
the Vertical Corridor faces commercial regulatory and financing barriers that
must be resolved for it to fully proceed.
Chamber and its members are eager partners in the ongoing effort to de-risk the
Vertical Corridor and realize the LNG enabled security benefits that it could
deliver.
And before I close,
I would be remiss if I didn't emphasize both the environmental and economic
benefits that accompany U.S.
LNG's role as a guarantor of global energy security.
A study undertaken by S&P Global for the chamber last year found that LNG
exports add $1.3 trillion to U.S.
GDP through 2040 and support nearly 500,000 jobs.
Importantly,
37% of those jobs are based in non-producing states.
So the benefits extend through the energy value chain and far beyond the
locations where gas is produced and exported.
Additionally,
the study detailed the significant emissions reductions that accompany LNG
exports,
finding that among other things,
the emissions intensity of Russian LNG and pipeline gas is 44% and 59%
higher respectively than that of U.S.
LNG.
In summary,
with strong leadership and cooperation between U.S.
and EU government and industry,
targeted policy measures can unlock Europe's pathway to long-term energy
security,
support U.S.
jobs and economic growth and reduced emissions.
Thanks for the opportunity to testify and I look forward to the discussion.
Mr. Byers,
thank you.
I know I heard the name Senator McCain invoked here a couple of times and I
think it was back in 2014 when Senator McCain had that famous line about
Russia,
just a great big gas station masquerading as a country.
The more things change,
the more things they don't in terms of still true today and mentioning that
vertical corridor today,
the other exciting development you see long-term geopolitically is what's
happening.
In fact,
Senator Murphy and I are working on this on Central Asia with the Jackson Vanik
restrictions.
But as Brzezinski once said,
the Caucasus are the cork and Central Asia is the wine bottle.
You know,
popping that cork here with the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace
agreement,
now opening up a East to West flow now with energy towards Europe and
the West is to be another important part rather than seeing energy flowing North
or back to the East.
Vice President Vance,
in fact,
will be in Yerevan and in Baku.
This week.
So it's exciting things going on there,
which are really in many ways breakthrough pretty underreported around the
world.
But as we all know,
we've been watching this issue for a lot of years progress.
And that's why also Senator Murphy and I are just committed to getting those
Jackson Vanik restrictions lifted for those important Central Asia partners.
As both of you know,
that he was looking at implementing its corporate sustainability due diligence
directive,
or as you mentioned,
Mr.
Byers,
the CS triple D a regulation that amounts to nothing more than regulatory
extortion designed to drive American producers out of Europe or even out of
business.
Economic analysis that we have seen indicates that the full adoption of the
regulation could cost up to 800,000 American jobs
and over $1 trillion.
These are massive numbers.
While the regulatory omnibus passed by the EU parliament last fall,
amended the CS triple D to remove some of the more objectionable portions.
The regulation still has the capacity to cause major damage to both Europe's
energy security,
as well as global energy producers ability to do business on the continent.
Mr.
Byers,
could you tell me a little bit more about the potential economic impact of CS
triple D that you brought up part of that in your testimony,
as well as changes you might like to see to the regulation?
Yes.
Well,
thank you for that question,
Senator.
It's a top priority for our members.
I think the first thing I should mention about CS triple D,
it's economy wide.
So this is not just an energy regulation,
it hits all sectors,
automotive,
banking,
et cetera.
And it is really remarkable and unprecedented in its reach.
As I said in my testimony,
it can reach not just to any company that has more than $1.5 billion of revenue
into the EU.
They don't even need to have an employee there.
It forces them and their subsidiaries and suppliers to take certain measures to
be consistent with EU standards in their global operations,
not just their US operations.
So it can make a US company liable for actions that are completely lawful in the
United States,
liable in an EU court.
As you said in December and we were fortunate the chamber led a large effort
alongside European business and industry to
explain the harms of this to both Europe's competitiveness and the transatlantic
relationship.
So a number of very challenging provisions were removed,
including article 22,
which requires net zero commitments,
not just a commitment,
but an implementation plan for companies through their entire supply chain.
So that has been next.
That's a very positive step.
But the extra territoriality that I mentioned,
the reach into the US operations remains.
And so that's what we're going to continue to try and fix in the year ahead.
And I will say,
I think this has been recognized as a major non-tariff barrier.
And we were pleased that in the trade agreement,
the US EU framework trade agreement,
it was CS triple D was explicitly called out as a hindrance.
And so we hope there'll be continued cooperation to address extra
territoriality.
Tobias.
Thank you.
Ambassador Pyatt,
can you talk a bit more about as you see the impact that this regulation might
have on European energy security,
particularly Europe's reliance on Russian energy.
If LNG exporters are unable to do business in Europe.
Thank you,
Mr. Chairman.
And I'd like to start by underlining my own sense from having been
engaged intensively on these issues with European officials in Brussels while in
government,
but also having lived in an EU member state for six years as US ambassador.
But just as in US democracy,
a lot of these legislative actions in Europe are the product of
balancing constituencies,
competing priorities.
And importantly,
as Dan alluded to,
as regards these two big measures in the energy adjacent area,
CS triple D and the EU methane regulations,
we see a strong orientation towards pragmatism in the European approach.
It's important to remember today Europe represents 65% of American LNG imports
exports.
But more importantly the United States is 58% of Europe's supply on LNG and
closely behind the United States is Qatar.
Both secretary Wright and his Qatari counterpart have delivered strong messages
to Brussels and to European capitals about making adjustments on these
provisions.
And then I would also note that European companies,
so the CEO of Total,
the CEO of Siemens together signed a letter a couple of months ago in October
on behalf of 46 European companies calling for a full repeal of the CEO's
triple D.
So I think European democracy is functioning on these issues and ultimately I
think the driving factor is Europe's determination never again to become
dependent on Russian energy and the importance of the transatlantic energy
relationship,
which is also reflected in the EU Europe trade agreement that president Trump
reached with president von der Leyen last year.
Ambassador,
you spent a lot of time working on the ground in Europe based on your
assessment in terms of the way things are shaping up there.
Do you think the Europeans are receiving those concerns well and will make
adjustments accordingly?
I think so.
There's clearly been a adjustment in the European level of ambition.
As Senator Murphy said,
I mean Europe is very clear they want to find reliable,
affordable energy with,
as you said yourself,
Mr.
Chairman,
an all of the above approach.
But they realized that to sustain all of their wind and solar power,
they're also going to need that baseload supply.
So US LNG is going to be a critical component of the European energy mix for
decades and decades to come.
So we have to get this right.
And as I said,
I'm confident from my own conversations,
both as a US government official and now as a private citizen,
that the European,
the European commission also understands the importance of finding a middle
ground on these issues because there's really not a good alternative.
And so much of what's evolving in terms of the energy alliance between the
United States and Europe is driven ultimately not by political proclamations on
one side of the Atlantic or the other,
but by market factors and the fact,
as I said in my opening statement,
that US energy,
US LNG is the most affordable,
reliable,
and importantly,
the cleanest option.
And maybe if I can make one other observation,
especially on the issues around methane and climate impacts,
it's important to recognize the leadership that American companies are
demonstrating in this area.
So American gas producers have become increasingly efficient in terms of using
electricity for a lot of their production in terms of monitoring and capturing
and abating venting and,
and,
and flaring of associated gas.
So there's just a,
there's a very strong alignment of interest here.
And I'm very confident that the officials who are now responsible for
negotiating these issues will be able to find a constructive way forward.
Thank you,
ambassador.
Senator Murphy.
Thank you very much,
uh,
Mr.
Chairman.
Um,
let me inquire on the flip side of this equation.
I don't think it's a smart strategy for the United States to build our entire
energy relationship on hopes that Europe is going to continue to import and need
access to fossil fuels.
Europe has made a commitment to renewable energy.
Um,
that's real today is nearly 50% of their consumption comes from renewables.
It's going to be even more true in the future.
And so our relationship I think has to be built both with a knowledge that they
are always going to need some access to fossil fuels and the United States can
be a player,
but that,
um,
we are really disadvantaging the American economy if as Europe's share of power
generation continues to move towards renewables,
China rather than the United States is their primary partner for business.
So maybe I'll ask Mr.
Byers and Mr.
Pied to both sort of speak to that,
speak to the fact that,
um,
whereas a lot of time is spent on this committee now talking about LNG
appropriately,
I don't really understand what the,
what our president is doing in trying to hamstring our ability to stand up
advanced battery technology,
solar technology,
wind technology,
um,
and essentially seed that ground to the Chinese.
They will become the preferred partner of Europe if we don't have an industrial
policy in the United States that allows us to catch up.
There's just no way that without an industrial policy,
and you can tell me if you think I'm wrong,
um,
a combination of incentive and tariff that we are going to be able to be
competitive with China as Europe is bidding out a lot of work and a lot of
product when it comes to renewables.
So the question for,
for both of you on that subject.
Uh,
yeah,
thank you,
Senator.
I'll go ahead and start.
Um,
I think,
you know,
you're absolutely right.
We want to open markets into Europe for all technologies,
all of the above.
Um,
got a lot of exciting,
uh,
investment and support from us companies and a lot of opportunity there.
I think realistically,
uh,
China has the market quarter on solar panels,
you know,
and so that's a supply chain where I don't know that there's a,
there's a pathway to come in.
So I think we have to be strategic and targeted on where the opportunities are.
Nuclear is a big one.
We're really excited about opportunities in nuclear in Europe,
sort of changing its attitudes there.
We have,
thanks to your work on DFC,
I think some,
you know,
exciting opportunities for support on,
on nuclear.
Um,
and I will say on gas,
we watch this very closely,
just sort of overall energy demand,
um,
and,
and the market share that's expected in the coming years,
Europe's going to need a lot for a longterm and it's actually going to increase
in the short term over the next five to 10 years,
Europe's gas demand.
Uh,
and then once it peaks,
it's going to probably plateau.
So,
uh,
that supply gap,
and this is by the way,
with assuming continued rapid build out of renewables,
because even in Eastern Europe,
you're having continued economic growth.
Um,
and,
and that's just leading to more energy demand.
And if they,
uh,
adopt data centers,
for example,
in the same way that we are,
they're going to,
they're way behind us on that.
But if that starts to materialize in Europe,
the way it is in the U S the overall energy demand will also continue to stay,
um,
higher than projected.
And so,
you know,
we're going to need all the energy sources.
You're absolutely right about that.
But I think we have to be,
uh,
strategic about exactly where the best opportunities are for U S companies to
come in and sell products and technologies.
Senator Murphy.
I agree completely.
And I'll tell you a short story that I think illustrates the point.
Uh,
in September,
I had the opportunity to go back to Kiev and I was there for the inauguration of
Eastern Europe's largest battery storage facility.
It was a project,
um,
run by D tech,
a private energy company using technology from a company called Fluence.
Fluence is headquartered just across the river from us in Boston.
And I went to go talk to the CEO there when I came back from Kiev.
It's a fantastic story.
Fluence is an American champion in the battery energy storage space.
Their main competitors in the market today are BYD and CATL,
two of the Chinese state supported companies that are operating in battery
storage.
D tech went with Fluence because it was American technology,
but they also delivered a competitive price.
And importantly D tech is now taking exactly the same Fluence battery product
and they are developing in Poland.
So it's absolutely vital that we remain competitive across all of these spaces.
I would second Dan's point as well on nuclear and especially SMR.
When I was in government,
tremendous,
tremendous interest across Central and Eastern Europe on SMR opportunities in
Bulgaria,
in Romania,
in Poland,
uh,
and certainly in Ukraine.
And here we've got a number of American developers and I,
and I think I remember,
I used to say with my,
my counterpart,
Elliot Kang,
when Elliot was assistant secretary for nonproliferation and we were thinking
about these issues,
the global market for SMR development outside the U S is going to be decided in
Central and Eastern Europe because that's the place where you have a huge hole
that needs to be filled to replace electrons that formerly came in the form of
Russian gas.
One of the advantages we do have over China is the fact that generally when
you're dealing with the United States and with U S companies,
you are dealing with above board transactions.
Whereas when you're dealing with the Chinese or many other suppliers,
you are often required to pay bribes,
to deal with,
um,
under the table requests.
Um,
I mentioned in my opening remarks and I'll ask this question to you,
uh,
ambassador pie.
Um,
there's news coming out of the Balkans that suggests the Trump administration is
pushing,
uh,
on Bosnia,
a particular partner to help them build a critical interconnection.
And this partner seems to be run by two individuals who have no history in
actually producing energy projects,
but who were,
um,
uh,
supporters of the president's attempt to overturn the 2020 election.
I'm not,
you're free to comment on this particular,
um,
what appears to me to be grift.
Um,
but at the very least,
maybe offer thoughts on how important it is for the United States to make sure
that we aren't pushing political cronies on countries overseas,
that we aren't engaged in the same kind of corruption that China is.
This seems to me to be corruption and projects like this,
where we're pushing friends of the president who are woefully unqualified to do
the work seems to be the kind of thing that will push other countries towards
China,
not towards the United States.
So Senator,
thank you for that.
Let me answer it two ways.
First,
I would underline the point that the energy sector is particularly capital
intensive.
Most projects run in the billions of dollars and they all take many,
many years to roll out.
I lived through this during my six years in Greece,
as I was working on the Southern gas corridor,
a project that began under my predecessor as assistant secretary,
three times removed Dick Morningstar.
And it took us almost 20 years to get that project done.
And it's going to take decades for that project to return the value that was
invested into it.
But it was hugely important in terms of unlocking Southern Europe's dependence
on Russian gas supplies.
So this is a sector where industry in the market has to look beyond simply a four
year election cycle in the United States.
And so having that consistency of purpose that we have enjoyed in this area
through Republican and democratic administrations engaging in Europe on energy
diversification and on us reliability is tremendously important.
And it's even more so because of what we started talking about today,
which is the fact that we're only in the first years of what is going to be a
fundamental remapping of Europe's energy infrastructure for several decades.
As chairman Danes noted in his opening statement,
Europe made the mistake of anchoring its energy security strategy on cheap
Russian gas that has now thankfully come to an end.
It's a tragedy that it took an invasion of Ukraine and millions of casualties to
make that reality sink home in Europe.
But I am confident today that Europe will never again look to Russia as a
reliable energy supplier.
But we need to be there for the long term working with Europe with our best
companies, operating in a transparent and above board way.
And we also have to maintain trust because as I learned through 35 years as an
American Foreign Service officer, probably representing this country,
that trust is the coin of the realm when you're involved in diplomacy.
And so building that kind of long term confidence in the way that hearings like
this and a bipartisan message from the Hill can do is of tremendous importance.
Senator Barrasso.
Thanks so much, Mr. Chairman. Ambassador, good to see you again.
A couple of quick questions.
You know, American energy resources have been a lifeline to our allies in Europe.
Last month,
the United States supplied 60% of the European Union's liquefied natural gas.
Since Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February of 2022,
the U.S. has exported over 3,000 cargos of liquefied natural gas to Europe.
To put it into perspective,
one cargo of LNG provides enough heat for about a million people in Europe for
one winter month.
So do you believe the United States is a secure,
reliable and strategic energy partner?
Absolutely. Unequivocally.
And what additional efforts can the United States take to help our allies
increase their energy security?
So I think first and foremost, Senator, we need to keep doing what we're doing.
We need to continue to expand America's industry.
And I talked in my opening statement about the tremendous accomplishment of
American producers who have more than doubled America's liquefaction capacity
in recent years.
I also think we need to find a way to keep talking about the issues around
climate and the environment.
I had the opportunity for the first time in my life late last year to be in Lake
Charles, Louisiana.
And I was there with the governor and with a number of our biggest LNG
producers. But I was also there with some of the Europeans.
And they had spent the day before our conference visiting CP2 and some of the
other LNG facilities around Lake Charles.
And they all said to me one version or another of, wow,
I expected something that looked like, you know,
that looked industrial with flares and rusty chains.
And I saw something that looks more like a high-tech manufacturing facility.
And I think telling that story, and if I can make one other,
share one other anecdote in this area,
I had the opportunity as assistant secretary to travel in Western Pennsylvania
and visit some of the fracking pads operated by a great Pennsylvania company,
EQT.
And what was most striking to me about that visit,
when you see what our gas producers are doing in the Marcellus region,
these are people who are incredibly proud of the work they're doing,
but they're also producing sometimes within a mile or two of farms and schools
and communities.
So they're incredibly attentive to issues like methane and flaring and how to
produce their goods in the cleanest way possible.
We should be proud of telling that story.
I want to switch to uranium if I could, because as you know,
for years Russia has dominated the global uranium market. As of 2024,
Putin controlled roughly 40% of the world's enrichment capacity,
supplied nearly a quarter of America's enriched uranium.
So I worked on a bipartisan basis to enact a prohibition on Russian uranium
imports into the United States,
which takes full effect in two years from now.
European nations remain even more dependent on Russian nuclear fuel,
but are now trying to reduce that reliance.
As the West shifts away from Russian nuclear fuel and global demand rises,
what kind of strain does that put on our European enrichment capacity?
So I would highlight two issues on this, Senator. First of all,
I would applaud what you and others did to implement a legal ban on imports.
And I remember sitting in this very chair being asked by Chairman Risch about
this same issue, and it's tremendous to see the action.
And I think it was also important that Congress included in its ban on uranium
imports provision for a circular fund to help capitalize the investment that
we're going to have to make in order to build a non-Russian supply chain.
But I would also flag importantly that as we see a new generation of nuclear
reactors,
and if our scientists and engineers are successful with building out an SMR
infrastructure,
we're going to need greatly increased volumes of nuclear fuel supply.
So that means uranium,
it connects with what Chairman Danes talked about in terms of Central Asia,
the role of Kazakhstan, for instance, as a major uranium supplier.
And then just like every other mining and mineral issue here in the United
States, where do we source both the ores,
but also the processing that makes these commodities usable in this case for
nuclear power?
So the question is how important is it that our own Department of Energy
prioritize building out more US enrichment capacity for not only domestic use,
but also to support our allied nations?
Critically important.
Last night I had the opportunity to have dinner with the head of one of Japan's
largest utility companies in Osaka. He was here,
he had actually visited,
he spent two days in the United States visiting some of our nuclear reactors.
And Japan of course is looking at a new generation of nuclear reactors after
having spent 15 years since the Fukushima disaster,
shutting down facilities.
He was incredibly enthusiastic about what he saw happening here in the United
States. But we have to build partnerships with the Japanese, with Korea,
with Canada, with our European allies. And I should emphasize,
I talked in my opening statement about the Repower EU initiative and the
tremendous progress that Brussels has made in committing to phasing out of
Russian energy. And that includes gas, oil, and importantly, nuclear.
So Europe is going to have the same exact dilemma that our operators of reactors
have here in the United States.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Barrasso, thank you. You mentioned Kazakhstan,
back to Central Asia here for a moment.
Turkmenistan has the fourth or fifth largest natural gas reserve in the world.
One of these little known facts. Again, as we open up that East-West
corridor, it will be very important here as we think long-term about energy
security.
There have been a number of European countries that have pursued investments
in energy that will create, we believe, long-term stability for their grids.
Greece, you're an expert on Greece.
They announced last year that they'll be starting a new offshore gas drilling
project for the first time in 40 years. Croatia,
another bright spot in Southeastern Europe.
Their Kirk floating regasification terminal has opened up 6.1
billion cubic meters in annual gas supply,
fully offsetting their prior reliance on Russian gas.
For the last decade,
the Baltic states have been working to cut all ties with Russian energy.
And we're seeing the full development, as you mentioned,
Ambassador of the vertical corridor. So here's my question, Ambassador Pyatt,
do you believe that these projects represent a change in sentiment of the EU
bloc or these solely strategic investments being made by the country's most
threatened by Russia?
So Mr. Chairman,
I think these projects first and foremost are a reaction to the huge wake-up
call that Europe received at the end of 2021 and the beginning of 2022 when
Putin demonstrated his willingness to use energy as a weapon against the
European Union.
And I can remember vividly conversations with German and other officials who
insisted that Russia would never cut off supplies because Russia needed the
European market.
But in fact Putin saw energy cutoffs as an essential element of his strategy for
destroying Ukraine. And as Senator Murphy alluded to,
he thought that Europe was going to cave.
And I would give the Biden administration tremendous credit for the work we did,
including the LNG task force that was agreed between president Biden and
president von der Leyen.
And then a lot of on the ground work with our LNG producers to make sure that
Putin would fail in that effort.
So now I think you see a new generation of investment.
I would put a particular spotlight on the leading role that American companies
are playing in this area. So for instance, it's ExxonMobil,
which is working on the Greece project that you alluded to.
Chevron is playing a leading role offshore of Cyprus, offshore of Israel,
offshore of Egypt,
working to build energy opportunities to feed into that European market.
And I hope that our companies will continue to play an important role,
which is another reason why, as Dan said,
we've got to get CS triple D right, because this is a,
this is one important element of what remains despite all of the frictions.
And I was in Davos two weeks ago and the level of anxiety around Greenland was
off the chart. But over the longterm,
you have trillions of dollars of trade and investment that flow across the
Atlantic ocean.
And so we need to find a way to continue to reinforce that partnership and it's
the private sector investments in both directions,
European companies investing in energy here in the United States and American
companies investing in energy in Europe.
They're going to help to stabilize that relationship in the years ahead.
Along that investment comment you just made,
you think there's an opportunity for targeted investment or financing from the
development finance corporation or Exxon Bank that might help facilitate other
projects?
Absolutely.
And I was so grateful that Senator Murphy mentioned the work that he did with
Senator Johnson on the NDA in 2019,
which gave DFC authorization to work in Greece. When I was ambassador,
that turned into $125 million investment into a shipyard that otherwise would
have gone to China. And there are,
there is potential for DFC to do more on the vertical corridor,
to do more on transmission lines, to do more on gas storage,
hopefully to do more also on battery storage,
which is going to be such an important part of the story for Europe and for the
United States as we seek to stabilize our grid and in all of the above
environment where we are also going through a super cycle of expanded demand.
Senator Murphy.
Thank you very much.
Just one final question and keep you on the spot.
Ambassador Pyatt,
you really have been our sort of most adept and capable,
capable ambassador over the last two decades,
turning around the US relationship in Greece,
but then also helping to midwife Ukraine through its most turbulent,
troubled time. On Thursday,
January 26th the president announced that Putin had agreed to pause attacks on
Kiev and other cities because of the freezing temperatures.
Obviously Russia's directing attacks at Ukraine's energy infrastructure.
And then on February 2nd, just a few days later,
the biggest attacks of the year came attacking Ukraine's energy infrastructure.
A bunch of us Democrats and Republicans got a closed door briefing yesterday on
the situation in Kiev and it's dystopian right now.
The fact that there's virtually no electricity that is reliable amidst the
winter that is already off the charts with respect to record cold.
Instead of criticizing Putin for these attacks,
President Trump tried to explain it away saying that the moratorium on attacks
had been secretly postdated and in fact what Putin was doing was outside the
moratorium instead of doing what any human would have done,
which is to talk about the immorality of making families and children free
deliberately. That's a, that's a war crime.
I just want to ask you, you know,
what do you see as the path forward to try to shore up in the short term
Ukraine's energy infrastructure? They're not through this awful winter.
It probably will just harden their resolve to continue the fight.
Airstrikes very rarely have the intended effect,
which is to cow a population into acquiescence.
But what should our role be as a Congress and as a country to help stop this
deliberate assault on Ukraine's energy infrastructure?
What are some next steps to get us out of this moment?
Thank you Senator Murphy. And I think you put it very well.
I would just emphasize first and foremost your point about the humanitarian
catastrophe that Putin is inflicting on Ukraine today.
It's about minus 20 degrees in Kiev right now.
The situation is extremely difficult and we need to understand Putin is
attacking civilian energy infrastructure,
conducting what is unambiguously a war crime because he is failing on the
battlefield and he's trying to break the will of the Ukrainian people.
I am very confident that he will fail in that regard,
but we need to be doing everything that we possibly can to help them in that
regard. First and foremost, we need to call it out for what it is.
I was very glad to see Senator Graham and others speaking out in exactly these
terms this week. Second,
I think it's important that the United States continues to find whatever
resources we have available that can be brought to bear to source the materials
that Ukraine needs to keep the lights on. When I was in government,
I led the G7 plus task force that was created by Secretary Blinken in order to
support Ukraine's energy infrastructure.
I had a team of officials in the Energy Bureau that was working every single day
to find transformers and switchgear and generators and working with all of our
allies.
That's an effort that generated more than $5 billion of equipment,
most of which was not paid for by the American taxpayer and a lot of which was
sourced from American manufacturers.
I understand that there are still certain accounts that are floating out there,
which related to the demise of USAID,
IECA funds and others that could be channeled for this purpose.
And I hope that that will happen quickly.
But just underscore that USAID was a critical player for a long time in helping
to shore up Ukrainian energy infrastructure, correct?
USAID, Department of Energy and the State Department's Energy Bureau under
Secretary Blinken's directive.
And I must say it's a source of great satisfaction to me that when I go back to
Ukraine,
that effort is still very well remembered precisely because it touches every
single Ukrainian civilian.
Senator Graham's comments were strong, but he is not the president of the United
States. He is not the secretary of state.
We need the White House to be condemning the war crimes that Putin is committing
rather than as President Trump was excusing or explaining them away.
But appreciate your comments.
Senator Murphy, thank you.
We're going to wrap this hearing up by just thinking as we're exchanging
thoughts here today.
It's worth thanking the Indian government for their agreement on Monday to continue
to reduce and end their Russian oil imports.
I was over in Delhi two weeks ago working with the leaders there in India and I
was glad to see President Trump, Prime Minister Modi come to agreement on that
trade deal. But importantly,
India's work to continue to reduce its dependence on cheap Russian oil.
Without objection, today's complete agenda,
as well as all written statements and letters that have been sent to the
subcommittee will be included in the record.
Sincere thank you to our witnesses today.
I think we had a thoughtful back and forth,
thoughtful dialogue on some very serious issues that are facing Europe and
providing us with the benefit of your testimony.
For the information of members,
the record remained open until the close of business tomorrow.
We ask that witnesses to respond as promptly as possible.
Your responses will also be made a part of the record.
With the thanks of the committee and a warm thanks to my ranking member,
Senator Murphy, this hearing is now adjourned.
