What happens to a family home after it is passed down? In California, voters approved Proposition 19 in 2020 with the promise of helping seniors and wildfire victims. For many families, the outcome has been sharply different from what they expected.
We look at how Prop 19 affects family decisions around inherited homes. We also examine changes in property tax assessments and how higher ownership costs can affect rental properties with long term tenants.
In this episode, we speak with Lalit Kundani, partner at Bridge Law LLP, estate planning attorney James Burns, homeowner Robert Locke, and Susan Shelley of the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, who explain how the law works, what many families missed, and what options still exist.
00:00 - Intro 01:28 - Background and Intentions Behind Proposition 19 03:08 - Details of Property Tax Reassessment 14:24 - Strategies to Mitigate Tax Increases 23:38 - Client Experiences and Strategies 30:23 - Impact on Tenants and Rental Properties 36:09 - Legislative Efforts to Address Proposition 19
Property taxes could go up a lot for a lot of Californians who are inheriting property from
their parents. Because there was a proposition, Proposition 19, that Californians voted for
in 2020. A lot of people when they voted for this proposition they had no idea this will be the
outcome. Today we're going to review what's happening with property taxes and Proposition
19's impact. We're going to discuss with different kinds of experts across the board to find out
what's happening with this and what is the solution to it. It was sort of a deal that was
you could inherit the primary residence of your parent with certain strings attached and those
strings which have now come to light are very hard to meet. We're going to be hit with a huge
tax reassessment on those properties to the point where we will not be able to afford keeping them
affordable rental properties. I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Lalit, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you for having me. We want to talk to
you about a very important issue that's impacting a lot of families in California and a lot of
people are blindsided by a proposition that we voted for, Prop 19, and majority of Californians
voted for that's causing people's taxes, inheritance taxes, to go up. Can you tell us
what happened with this proposition? Yeah, it's a fascinating story and I used to call it back when
it was on the ballot. I called it the wolf in sheep's clothing. It was a proposition that took
some time to get back on the ballot. It was initiated by the California Association of Realtors
and the National Association of Realtors and the whole meaning behind the proposition was to create
more fluidity in the market, the real estate market. If more Californians were forced to
sell their property, then it was going to do its job. But of course, you can't just come out and
say that. Like many propositions, they had to find a sheep to dress up the wolf in and the sheep was
55 and over, elderly, wildfire victims, victims of natural disasters. So they dressed up this
proposition in the guise that if you voted for this proposition, you would be helping those that
are disadvantaged. You would be helping seniors who couldn't sell their property because if they
bought a replacement property, they were going to pay a higher property tax. So Prop 19 promised to
help those seniors. If they were wildfire victims or victims of natural disaster, Prop 19 was going
to help them. A lot of Californians, they ended up voting in that direction. But oddly enough,
you would think that if it was something as simple as that and as nice as that,
that it would have passed overwhelmingly. And of course, it only passed 51 to 49. And that again
is a sign that there was more going on. And so that is where the wolf part of the Prop 19 comes
out. And what that was is what we're all sort of faced with. When parents pass away or even in
situations where parents and children co-own property, maybe for lending purposes, the
proposition means that now the property tax is going to go up the minute you take someone off
that deed or the minute you transfer a property from the parent to the child or even in situations
where a child had special needs and now the child inherits that property, the property tax goes up
to fair market value. And that is the disaster that we're all sort of dealing with in one way,
shape or form. As someone reporting on California's economy and policies every week,
unfortunately, I see the middle class shrinking in California. Some of it has to do with our
policies. And there is another side to this that we are facing major inflation here and across the
country. Unfortunately, the dollar has lost 10% of its value just this year to date. That's why
more and more people are turning to real assets to protect their financial future, like physical
gold and silver from American hard-fought gold. Unlike paper assets, these tangible investments
can't be controlled or devalued by inflation or bad policies. You can have them delivered
straight to your home or securely stored in a tax-advantaged gold IRA, giving you a safe,
reliable way to safeguard your wealth no matter what happens in California or the rest of the
country. American hard-fought gold has an A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau and
thousands of five-star reviews. And right now, when you call, you can get up to $15,000
in free silver with your first purchase. Call 866-595-2304. That's 866-595-2304 or text
KALI to 65532. Make sure to text KALI to 65532. Beat the system and protect your wealth with
something real today. When you mentioned this property tax goes to market value, can you explain
how this Prop 19 works? So as we all kind of have heard about Prop 13, which passed in 1978,
the voters overwhelmingly passed Prop 13 in 1978 that said, regardless of what happens to the fair
market value of your property, we're only going to increase property taxes by the rate of 2%
a year. When Prop 19 showed up, what effectively happened is we got rid of what was called the
parent-child exclusion. And that parent-child exclusion came in 1986. It was called Prop 58,
which said when the parent passed away and the child inherited the property,
if it was the primary residence of the parent, then the property tax would not go up regardless
of the price. As long as it was the primary residence of the parent and the child inherited
it, there was no reassessment. That was a law since 1986, regardless of the value of the home.
As long as the parent lived in it as the primary residence, the child could inherit it. And so what
was happening for decades was that children would inherit the property, the primary residence,
and they would choose, you know, do I want to live in it? And do I want to work it out with
my siblings? Who's going to live in it? Do I want to rent it out? Do I want to have my child live
in it? And there was a lot of flexibility that was available to the child in that example.
And these weren't necessarily huge homes. I mean, these are everyday families across California who
could take advantage of that choice, that flexibility, which essentially is what Prop 13
promised, is you're going to get the property, but you're going to pay a two percent increase a year.
And that was the rules that we all sort of agreed to. When Prop 19 was on the ballot,
they promised that this would stay intact. What they failed to mention is that this would stay
intact, but the property tax could still go up. So it was sort of a deal that was,
you could inherit the primary residence of your parent with certain strings attached.
And those strings, which have now come to light, are very hard to meet. For example, the child
has to move into the property within one year of the date of death of the parent. That's not a long
time for any family to sort of deal with the aftermath of the death of a parent. But within
one year of the date of death, you physically have to move into the property. You have to know
to fill out certain forms. And if you don't fill those forms as the child on time, you're going
to lose the property tax. Not only that, this is the part that I think, again, angered most
Californians. Even if the child knows to physically move in within a year, to fill out the magical
forms by the certain deadline, your property tax could still go up in that situation. That was the
problem. Because Prop 19 said, again, the strings attached said, your property tax will stay to the
same up to a certain point. If the fair market value at the time that the parent died was more
than a million dollars above the assessed value, then you're going to pay a higher property tax.
So this whole notion that, oh, we're not going to disrupt the primary residence,
which is what a lot of the proponents of Prop 19 promised. We're not going to mess with this.
They absolutely ended up messing with it. How does it work now with the investment properties?
So really, generally speaking with investment properties, and we should include vacation homes
and secondary homes. There's a lot of Californians who have two primary homes, but they're forced to
identify just one. So let's call all of those investment properties. What happens now is
investment properties, generally speaking, are going to get reassessed at fair market value.
So under Prop 19, if there's a secondary home and that secondary home is passed when the parent
dies, the property is going to get assessed at the fair market value. The old rule in California
under Prop 13 and the various props that came in the decades following Prop 13, again, were more
lenient on those secondary properties. I think it was a well-balanced, reasoned system that they
came up with. They said in the old rules, they said, if you have a secondary property and you
want to leave it to your child, you can leave it up to a certain dollar amount. What that dollar
amount was, was it was a million dollars of assessed value per parent. So if I was married
and I had secondary properties, I could leave $2 million worth of assessed values
unchanged. Anything above that, my kids would have to pay the difference. Again, Prop 19 100%
removed all of that overnight. You're helping people in California with this. Can you tell us
what are you hearing from your clients? Here are the calls that we're getting.
There's a lot of misinformation. Many callers, especially older ones, go, well, I was told that
I'm under Prop 13 and we have to explain to them. Prop 13 is sort of a fiction today
because it can't be read in isolation. It has to be read with Prop 19. So the stories that we're
are, I can't keep the family home because I moved in and I thought the property tax was going to
stay the same, but now the assessor is telling me that the property tax actually went up.
Is there anything I can do? That's one story, class of stories we are dealing with.
A second class of stories, which again, I think the writing was on the wall, but this is the
realities of how propositions work, are folks, younger Californians who have saved up to buy
their first home. And when they did, they did so because the bank said, sure, you could buy the
home if your parent is going to be a co-signer on the loan. And what happened is the parent had to
be untitled according to the banks. After Prop 19, when that parent passed away, that parent's
ownership went to the child. That is a change in ownership that has caused a reassessment.
A third version has to do with folks who are dealing with non-primary homes. So this is a
vacation home. This is a rental home, or this is the business of the parent. A lot of Californians
were investors. They held a lot of rental real estate and they wanted to pass the rental real
estate. It's a family business. They want to pass the rental real estate to the children who are
involved in the rental real estate business. All of those properties, 100%, are going to get
reassessed when the parent passes away. So the children there are looking for strategies. Is
there something that we can do to keep the property tax the same or not get reassessed at fair market
value? The problem with this is there is no good and bad here. There's just realities. The reality
is when property tax stays the same as it was intended to under Prop 13, we're all winners.
This isn't a rich and poor. My experience is that if you have rental properties get reassessed at
fair market value, the big losers are the people who need those rental properties. It's the renters
of California. Who's renting? A lot of low and middle-income Californians need to be in that
rental space. When they're forced out because the owners can't afford those rental properties
anymore, we're all worse off. Who's going to buy that rental property, that 40-unit rental property
that was owned mom and pop, who can't afford it anymore because the property tax is now
through the roof? The big purchasers are going to be corporations. They're going to change those
into luxury condos. The renters are left back in the streets. If they can't afford it,
they're moving out of the state. When you go back to 2021, if we had that power to go back to
November of 2021, it passed 51 to 49. If two or three percent of Californians really knew about
the wolf in sheep's clothing, I don't think we would be here today. The reality is if we could
get this back on the ballot, my prediction is most Californians overwhelmingly are going to
try to repeal Prop 19. Now, Lalit, is there a way to overcome this? Is there any way to deal with
this if it doesn't change, if the rules doesn't change? Is there anything people can do to avoid
these tax increases? It's a great question. There are very limited strategies that we have where we
can still offer some hope. It's not for everyone, and it's going to depend on the numbers, meaning
what is the assessed value of your property? What are you going to use it for? Are you going to
move in or are you not going to move in? But there are still parts of Prop 13 that gave us
the legal community strategies that we can offer to clients. And so, yes, the short answer is
we can put some band-aids on the solution, and in some situations, we can still salvage
the investment properties. Generally speaking, investment properties are owned not by
individuals, but we put them in LLCs for various reasons, asset protection reasons,
or lending reasons. But for the most part, LLCs in California today are still governed by Prop 13,
not Prop 19. So if we can turn the property into an LLC, we will fall still under the 1978 Prop 13
legislations. And under the Prop 13 rules, there are different rules when it's in an LLC, for
example, of what constitutes a change in ownership of the LLC. So if we play around with the numbers
the right way, and if we have time, this is essential. If you call the lawyer and you say,
mom and dad is on their deathbed, is there something we can do? Probably not. But if we
have two, three, four years to implement a strategy, then yes, it's inconvenient, it's expensive,
and it could be cumbersome. But for some families, many families, they can take advantage
of those strategies. Now for primary residences, it's a bit easier. It's just about educating
clients. If you're a child, and one of the siblings is going to move into the property,
and if you fill out the paperwork in time, then you might still fall under the exception under
Prop 19's primary residence. But you got to know that the property tax might still go up,
because that million dollar cushion might not be enough. And lastly, there are really intricate
rules in California called joint tenancy rules and co-tenancy rules. And if you're dealing with
an attorney who is familiar with those rules, there may still be ways to salvage the property
tax and not have to move into the property. So I would tell clients, yes, there are strategies out
there. For me, for my law firm, for lawyers, sure, we can make some money helping clients do that.
But if I had a magic wand, I would much rather go back to the old rules. Because again, the real
losers here are all of us. And so yes, we can fix and respond to Prop 19, but what would be even
better is we get rid of Prop 19. You mentioned these ways, how solid are they? We are hearing
that even counties have confusion about implementing these Prop 19. Can you tell us about it?
Anytime a proposition is passed, there's an irony that develops, which is we go to the Board of
Equalization and we go to the assessor and we say, how are you going to implement these rules?
And their response is a good one. We don't know because this wasn't our idea.
So it creates a window of uncertainty. And so the good news is over the course of the
past three years, four years, five years since we've had Prop 19, some of those answers have
sort of, some of those solutions have been answered. For example, one of the things that
was uncertain when it was passed is when you say a child needs to move into the primary residence,
what does that mean exactly? Now we know it means that one of multiple children
has to move in within one year of the date of death. We didn't know that for a period of time.
Another thing we don't know still today is what if the child moves out of the primary residence
at some point, can the property tax still stay the same because they moved in within one year?
So it's not clear.
And because it's not clear, we're forced to be conservative in our advice.
So we tell folks our belief is, and I think most practitioners will say this,
if you move out of the primary residence, all bets are off. The county can go back and reassess
it because it's no longer the child's primary residence. Has it been stated as such? No.
But in the absence of that endorsement by the Board of Equalization, then I think that's going
to be the way it's going to play out. Unfortunately, there's a lot of negativity
and anxiety right now, even in a beautiful place like California. I'm constantly running to people
that are facing depression. Even they have a lot of things materially. No matter what you
and your family are going through right now, there is still hope. Imagine surrounding yourself
for two hours with pure beauty, amazing music, colors that we don't see in this world anymore,
and a message of hope and inspiration. Shen Yun is coming back to California.
I've been going to the show for the last 14 years. And every time I go, I see smiles on
the people's faces when they're leaving the theater. And the expressions are in a way that
it's hard to explain. But there is this joy coming from inside. And I want you guys to
experience that. If you want to take a break from all the negativity and anxiety that's out there,
make sure to give yourself this experience. It will really lift your soul. Shen Yun is currently
performing in Northern California and soon will come to LA area and Southern California.
Make sure to get your tickets right now before they sell out.
This is what you've been waiting for. Shen Yun. Get tickets now at ShenYun.com.
What about retail and restaurants? Like if you have a family restaurant
and you own the location, parents pass it to the kids.
We're telling folks, if you have rental property, if you have a restaurant, if you have farmland,
if you have any kind of business, you should take advantage of Prop 13. Move the property in an LLC
and use the rules of the LLC in your favor. Again, we need time to implement that strategy.
But when it's a larger commercial owner, say of a strip mall or say of commercial shopping plazas,
these are triple nets and triple nets generally get passed over to the stores in the plaza.
Meaning the taxes and the other cost utilities will get passed to the renters.
Correct. This has created another problem, which is if the owner of the commercial plaza
don't put it in an LLC or don't know that they can salvage the property tax,
their philosophy is, what do I care? I'm just going to pass these property taxes on
through the triple net to my tenants. Who are these tenants? Mom and pop store owners.
Where are they going to pass the cost to? The retailers. So this is the waterfall effect we get.
If people come to you guys or go to another attorney and structure this, put it under an LLC
and the taxes stay the same, is there a chance to face penalties later if the government comes
back and says, you guys, this is a workaround? There's always a risk. And so this is why it's
really important to know what you're getting yourself into before you go through these
strategies. Yes, we have maybe some conservative approaches to salvaging the property tax with time,
but you need to speak to your lender about this. You need to speak to your insurance company about
this. You need to survive the runway. And if any of those three things trip up,
the strategy doesn't work. Now, where we get involved with the assessors or the board of
equalization is if you try to do too much too soon. So if you go too fast too soon and try to
do what you should be doing in two years and two days, you're running a huge risk, a huge risk.
We now go to James Burns, who's a estate planning attorney, to see what's happening to his clients.
Well, the first thing I'm seeing is a lot of people are unaware of it. They come in to my
office thinking that they're going to just take over mom and dad's house and they're going to do
what they want with it. There may be more than one sibling involved in this inheritance. And then
we have to rain on the parade and tell them, well, back in around February 2021, when this law came
into effect, it limited your ability to enjoy that property directly from your parents and receive a
step up in basis in the property tax. So now with Prop 19, we have to inform them that only one child
may move into that home and claim it as their personal residence. Then you have to run the
numbers. What was mom and dad's tax base? What's the current credit? Currently the credit with a
little adjustment is about $1,044,000. And that would be above their base. And then you kind of
calculate out from there if there's any overage. And roughly the overage is about 1.1% of whatever
is above that credit, mom and dad's base. And that'll be the new tax base versus somebody having
a complete reassessment at today's fair market value, which for most families will force them
to have to sell. And they have to do that within a year period. Do you see this is causing challenges
for you and your customers, your clients? Can you tell us what you see in this situation?
Well, there's always family dynamics. So the thing that we see often probably two or three times a
year is that there's always one sibling who remained at home with mom and dad until they
passed. They now believe it'll be very easy for them to take it over as their personal residence
and the other children want to sell. And that person's a holdover. So this thing leads into
family discord where now you got to practically sue this sibling, treat them like a tenant,
take them to court and try and have them removed under an eviction. The other thing is that people
are, again, unaware of this law. So most people think that they're going to do
as what had been done for years and years, which is we'll all hold onto the property
and we'll just rent it. This is California property. Let's just keep letting it appreciate
and hold onto it. But when you start calculating the numbers of this new reassessment, especially
if nobody's going to go qualify for the Prop 19 credit, you start factoring in your insurance
costs these days after our wildfires and other incidents, then you have to now take a look at
whether or not there was any loan on it. So one that we had here recently, which was very
interesting, we had all of these, the trifecta. Somebody's a holdover and believes that you go to
them. Two, dad had taken out a reverse mortgage. So we have this reverse mortgage umbrella over
things, which means now there's a loan and debt servicing to deal with. You're going to have the
reassessment and you've got insurance because this person doesn't automatically get mom or dad's
insurance. Everybody has to re-qualify for insurance these days. And it has changed within
the last year. What if none of the kids go and live in the parent's house? What will happen?
Does it go to market value? It does go to market value. It'll be reassessed fully
at today's market value and reassessed. And that'll be the new tax base. Do you see people
selling now because they cannot afford the taxes? Is the taxes significantly higher?
Overwhelmingly, I think most clients are coming to the conclusion, we're just going to sell it.
And I think by design, the Proposition 19 was created to place people in a position where
they have to sell and create inventory in the marketplace here in California.
As an example, if you had... Because this is a classic example I even see in most neighborhoods
down where I'm at in Elisa, Vallejo, which is you might've gotten into a place at 250,000.
Maybe as time has gone over, it's worth a million. Some places are going over a million too. You're
going to have some overage. It could go from a person qualifying and just making things about
$3,000 extra a year to $15,000. So in most cases, we're seeing equation leading about $11,000 or
more type of tax burden because of the Prop 19. And you are concerned about this. Can you tell us
why? Well, I'm concerned about it because we look back to what Proposition 13 was all about
and our ability to have some reliance on our property taxes and where it's going to go.
And the freedom to exchange your property intergenerational. You work hard your entire
life. You put some things aside. You maybe suffer and withhold from enjoying other things so that
you can own this. You want to leave this to your heirs, your children, so that they can have a home
and they should be able to do whatever they want with it, whether that's rented out,
living it. And that won't be available anymore because when you run the numbers purely on the
reassessment because of Prop 19, the intergenerational family transfer, we used to
that the family exclusion has been eviscerated. It's gone. You used to be able to have a million
dollars of credit for any other property you owned. So you and your spouse, if you both passed,
you'd be leaving your children $2 million for all your other rentals or properties that you own.
All of that's gone. When people come to you, what do you recommend to them? I'm recommending that
they try and participate in local government politics and maybe seek their local lawmaker
to see if there's any way to do a recall on this because I really believe some type of
mischaracterization was perpetrated on the general public from the fact that they don't even know it
exists to they don't understand how it's applied to once they learn what the consequences are,
the kind of results and reactions I'm getting out of people is just staggering to me. So I'm
recommending finding out if there's any grassroots organizations because some are looking for
signatures. They need those signatures badly so that they can get things on the ballot. And the
only way that they're going to do that is by public participation. This affects almost everybody who
owns a home here and has any thoughts, ideas or dreams of sharing that home and transferring it
down to the next generation. We are hearing that the tenants may get impacted as a result of this
proposition. So now we go to Robert Locke to see how his tenants may get impacted once he inherits
his parents' properties. My parents owned residential rental properties dating back to
the 1960s and as those properties grew in value the tax base maintained. Now with Proposition 19
when they eventually pass away, myself and my siblings will inherit those properties
and we're going to be hit with a huge tax reassessment on those properties to the point
where we will not be able to afford keeping them affordable rental properties. In one instance,
actually a lot of them, the tax base will go up like $20,000 plus a year. So that's
what is that? $1,500 a month. A month that I can't roll into the rent. I mean if we're
charging $2,500 and we're going to now say here's another $1,600. First of all, we can't do that.
It's illegal. Second of all, I wouldn't do that to our tenants. So that's going to put us in a
position where we're going to be forced to sell these properties and that's something we're not
interested in. We're interested in keeping these for another 1,500 years and offering them as
affordable rental properties. But with Prop 19, it's almost like we're handcuffed. Like we have
no choice. Either we come out of pocket on each of those properties $20,000 a year and our rental
or property management becomes a negative. We're making no profit and it just doesn't make sense
to me. Tell us about these properties. How much are you charging? How big are these and how would
the tenants get impacted? So most of the properties that we have that my dad bought in the
mid to late 60s are typically three-bedroom, two-bath residential properties. Anywhere from
1,400 to 2,200 square feet. And we've maintained these properties at an affordable rent. Matter of
fact, some of our tenants have been in these properties for over 20 years. We prefer that
because I know people that grew up with me that their parents had one or two rental properties
and they're having a turnover every three, six, twelve months because they're charging
4,500 or 5,000 a month because that's the going rate. And they're having this huge turnover.
We're consistent with having affordable rents, fair affordable rents. And we love our tenants.
They love us. Most of them didn't realize when they voted yes on Prop 19. How much do you think
their rents will go up in a sense for these properties that you guys own? Well, for our
properties by California state law or in that particular area, we cannot raise the rent more
than 10% per year. So $1,600 on a $2,500 rent doesn't do the math. It will take you five,
six years of raising. It looks like you can get 250 year adding that 250. So it'll take five,
six, seven years for us to include the property taxes, but that's five or six years,
20,000 per property. And if we own 10 properties, it just doesn't make sense for us to keep. We
just can't. My brothers and sisters and I, we're just normal people doing our normal work. Yeah.
I grew up helping my dad with those properties. Yes. I grew up knowing everything about those
properties. Yes. I know the tenants. Some of them are nurses, firefighters, a policeman.
They have no idea that this is going to happen. And Robert, you said that you guys
have this philosophy of keeping the rents low so that you can keep the tenants.
How much lower are you compared to the market? So in the instance of the police officer,
the property that he lives in, I believe his rent is $2,600 a month. And if you go on any
of the popular websites and look at what the rentals are in those areas, they're $4,500 to
$4,800. Wow. Why are you guys doing the model you guys are doing? It took me 57 years to realize,
but my dad's actually smart. And when I was a kid, he used to tell me, you know, Robert, I want
to help good people be the most successful they can and not take advantage of them because this
is a small city, small world, small state. It'll come back to you in tenfold, whatever you do,
if you do something negative or something positive, it comes back to you tenfold.
And that's always been his philosophy. It's also my philosophy. And so his whole thing was
ask for the rent to be a modest rent where you can pay the bills on the property,
make a dollar or two after everything's paid and keep them in those properties at an affordable
rate for as long as they want to be there. If they want to be in there for 15, 20 years,
great. We're helping them. But again, I see around our rental and I see other people I grew
up with, their rental properties have turnover, turnover, turnover, turnover. Who can afford
$4,500 to $5,000, sometimes $6,000 as a nurse and a mechanic on a property? You're living to pay the
rent and that's it. And my dad is not about that. And that's why his relationship with his tenants
are the way they are. They send him Christmas cards. They send him thank yous. Every time I go
over there to help my dad do the annual maintenance inspections, they absolutely love him. Long ago,
when I was a kid, one of the people pulled me aside and said, if the world had more people
like your dad, it would be a better place. Now we go to Susan Shelley, who's part of the Howard
Jarvis Association, who were the organization that championed the Proposition 13 to see what
they're doing about this, if there is any solutions coming across the state to change
this Proposition 19. The first thing that's getting worked on is some legislation to fix
some of the immediate problems. Prop 19 was very poorly drafted. And the assessors, after it passed,
they went to the legislature with a list of things that had to be cleaned up in follow-up legislation.
And the legislature did a little bit of it, but other problems persist. So fixing some of these
small, individual problems doesn't get at the whole solution. The whole solution is to go back
to what we had under Proposition 58, which was a reasonable amount of exclusion from reassessment
for properties transferred from parents to children. That was very valuable to people.
And they didn't know they were giving it away when they voted on Prop 19. But some of the
legislation that's going to fix some of the problems is Senate Bill 288 from Senator Kelly
Seyarto. And what that does is it fixes the problem of the one-year time clock. Under Prop 19,
you have one year from the date of transfer. If it's your parent's principal residence and you're
the child and you want to make it your principal residence, you have one year from the date of
transfer to get that all sorted out and move in and fill out the homeowner's exemption form that
you are now the owner-occupier of this property. The trouble is that sometimes people go through
probate, and probate does not cooperate with that one-year calendar. So people cannot inherit the
property with the tax break because they can't take ownership within the year. So what SB 288
would do is reset the one-year clock to start at the point where there is a court decree in probate.
So when the probate is completed and someone can actually take ownership, then they have one year
to make it their permanent primary residence in order to get that little bit of a tax break, that
one million dollar exclusion from reassessment that's available under Prop 19. The other thing
that's happening is SB 623 and Senate Constitutional Amendment 4. And what this does is it helps
disabled veterans and other veterans keep the homeowner's exemption in effect. Because currently
if you claim the disabled veterans exemption, which can be worth quite a lot of money every year,
or the veterans exemption, which is worth less, you cannot take the homeowner's exemption also.
The homeowner's exemption is only worth $70 a year in tax breaks. However, in Prop 19 it is
the criterion for allowing your kids to inherit your house and get that tax break under Prop 19
for moving into it. They have to claim the homeowner's exemption. The parent has to claim the
homeowner's exemption, and the child has to claim the homeowner's exemption. But that means that
veterans cannot claim the veterans exemption or the disabled veterans exemption. That's
completely unfair. So this is something that the assessor in L.A. County, Jeffrey Prang,
has wanted to fix. And Bob Archuleta, with the support of the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers
Association, is carrying that bill. And that is SB 623. So the first one is Senate Bill 288,
and the second one is SB 623. And people can call their lawmakers and urge them to pass these bills.
It's really important. And if you don't know who represents you, you can go to findyourrep.legislature.ca.gov.
And then you just put in your address, and it will give you the contact information
for your state senator and your state assembly representative. And the representatives
actually pay attention to these calls, right? Each call matters, from what we have heard, right?
Absolutely. Absolutely it does. Because many times they think people don't know about these things,
that they don't care about these things. But every phone call that comes in, they assume that
there are many more people who feel that way, and just didn't get to the phone yet. So definitely,
it has a big impact. That's SB 288 and SB 623. Yes on both of those. And then there's a third one
that's still in the works. This is from Senator Sayato. And this would assist in situations where
there's a disabled family member, a disabled child of the parent who owns the house, who is living
in the house. And it's not the parent's permanent residence because it's the residence of the child,
and the child can't be on the paperwork for various reasons of not being able to. So this
would fix that problem. I don't think that has a bill number yet, but it's in the works to fix
people in that sad situation where a disabled relative is living in the property, and it's
winding up excluded from the Prop 19 tax break. So these are things that the Howard Jarvis
Taxpayers Association is working on to alleviate specific problems that people are having.
Now, there are some ballot initiatives, and you guys tried one, right? And right now,
some people are trying. Can you tell us what's happening with the ballot initiatives?
Well, we tried twice at the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, and we could not get
enough signatures. At this moment, it's based on the number of votes for the last election
for governor. It's, I think, 8% of the number of votes that were cast for all candidates
for governor. So right now, the number is about 875,000 valid signatures to get a constitutional
amendment on the November ballot. And we were able to get 500,000, 550,000, but we couldn't
get enough to get it on the ballot. We did try twice. We could try again. There is another
volunteer effort from some of the volunteers who worked on the HJTA efforts. They are trying again.
They filed an initiative, and I don't have their website handy, but they are trying,
and you could probably find it with a search to get signatures on petitions. It's very,
very difficult to do that. It really requires the whole state to be aware of the situation and aware
of the problem. But interestingly, the legislature could fix this right now. They could fix it with
a two-thirds vote in each house of the legislature. They could put it on the June ballot. They could
put it on the November ballot. They could fix this problem for the people of California,
because this is for regular people. This is not for East Coast billionaire trust fund
baby investors. This is regular California families, and they're suffering because of
this provision in Prop 19. Susan Shelley with Howard Jarvis Association. It was great to have
you back on California Saturday. We'll check in with you later to see where this is headed.
Thank you, CIMAC. What do you think about Proposition 19? Do you think it was a good
idea to increase taxes for the people that are inheriting properties, or do you think it's better
to keep it the way it used to be before? You can always email us at cimac.californiainsider.com
or comment. We read all of your emails and comments. I'm CIMAC Kourami. This is California
Insider, and we'll see you next time.