Does the truth still matter?

vlogbrothers
172 followers
Feb 3, 2026
In which John doesn't know how to effectively participate in an information distribution system that values attention over accuracy.
----
Subscribe to our newsletter! https://werehere.beehiiv.com/subscribe
Learn more about our project to help Partners in Health radically reduce maternal mortality in Sierra Leone: https://www.pih.org/hankandjohn
If you're able to donate $2,000 or more to this effort, please join our matching fund: https://pih.org/hankandjohnmatch
If you're in Canada, you can donate here: https://pihcanada.org/hankandjohn
Good morning, Hank, it's Tuesday. I'm having a very hard time talking about what is currently
happening in my country, but I'm also having a very hard time not talking about it. Like,
two weeks ago, a two-year-old child was kidnapped by the federal government despite a court order
not to do so. Many people have died in the custody or at the hands of immigration officials
in the United States, and it is very difficult to trust the official accounts of those deaths when,
in the two cases that have been videotaped, federal officials have clearly and obviously
lied. But I worry that even in saying that, I have lost the 2% of people who are going to watch
this video who I really want to reach. I simply don't know how to talk about this stuff online
because we are so profoundly, unprecedentedly siloed in our information distribution systems
that we simply don't hear each other, and when we do hear each other, it's very difficult to
actually listen to each other. I mean, it's not like this video is going to reach a representative
sample of America, Hank. According to a recent Nerdfighteria census, more people in this
community voted for Jill Stein than Donald Trump. I can't reach across the aisle effectively because
no people on the other side of the aisle are going to hear me, and in turn, I don't hear them.
What I hear are the most obnoxious, despicable, and outrageous takes among those I disagree with,
and then I extrapolate that all people I disagree with must share those takes,
thereby hardening my silo. I don't know how to break down those silos. I can't even convince
my own MAGA family members that people who were murdered were, in fact, murdered. Like,
even though Alex Preddy had both hands on the ground and was disarmed when he was shot 10 times,
it doesn't look like murder to some of my family members. Even though 67% of the homicides this
year in Minneapolis have been committed by ICE, they still feel that the streets are unsafe and
need to be made safer. I guess I can talk about it from a historical perspective, since I've read
a lot of history. The rule of law in the United States has never been applied fairly or justly.
I mean, from witch hunting to lynchings to executions, state-sponsored, state-sanctioned
killing have long been part of the American story. On that level, I suppose there's nothing new here,
but here's what is new, at least in my view. The executive branch of our government is claiming
and being allowed to claim widespread powers to detain people living inside the United States
without much interference from the other branches of government. Or I suppose I can talk about it
from a religious perspective, which might resonate across ideological lines. I believe in a God who
chose to be born human to poor parents in a foreign land. This God grew up to preach good
news to the poor and the hungry and the imprisoned. This God literally said,
I was a stranger and you took me in. But at this point in the video, I fear I'm only preaching
to the choir, who will of course tell me that I'm right, and if anything, I'm not going far enough.
And I worry all that does is harden our silos. Which of course means that I have my own unchecked
cognitive biases, but I don't know how to check them in a world where my information distribution
system has the architecture it currently has. I mean, do the people who respond to memes and
deepfakes with their own memes and deepfakes have the right approach? I don't know. Does that
undermine whatever credibility I have with those who might disagree with me, or does it in fact
encourage resistance to an increasingly authoritarian government? I really don't know what
the right strategy is, and I'm not convinced that anyone does, because while there are many
precedents for our current historical moment, in none of those cases was the social internet as
big a deal as it is now. Our ways of distributing information in the past were much slower and less
fractured. If I sound a little freaked out, Hank, that's because I am. I am heartbroken, I am enraged,
but I am also scared. This level of divisiveness, the willingness to tell big and easily disprovable
lies, the blaming of disenfranchised communities, the failure of institutions to rein in government
overreach, all of that should scare us, but does that mean I should be on Twitter or X? Does this
video make anything better or indeed anything worse? I don't know. I do think real-life collective
action matters, protests, videotaping, making one's voice heard inside and outside the ballot box,
but I don't know what, if anything, to be doing online. That said, Hank, there is mounting
evidence that despite everything, the truth does retain power. I often feel like the social internet
just reinforces people's pre-existing worldviews while further isolating them from countervailing
information, but I'm starting to think it's not that simple. Like, polling indicates there are
real changes happening among the U.S. voting public, which has shifted by over 20% on the subject of
ICE just in the last few months. So at least for now, I think the truth does have some power that
I worried it had lost amid the memes and deepfakes, which, for the moment at least, is where I am
finding hope, albeit, I will confess, a bit of a thin-lit hope. Hank, I'll see you on Friday.
