the smartwatch that changed my mind about smartwatches

Technical Sea
259 followers
I'm Becca, I take deck outside.
Let's talk about the smartwatch that actually takes me there.
Crushin' it!
As a tech YouTuber, I'll admit it,
I am incredibly spoiled.
I get sent the most expensive phones,
the most specced-out cameras,
and of course, top-of-the-line earbuds too.
And increasingly, I'm getting glasses.
These are the Meta Oakley Vanguards.
They're aimed at athletes,
and they have a Garmin integration.
So when I got them in,
in order to unlock all of their potential,
I needed to get a Garmin watch too.
My instinct was of course to go big,
a 400 970, a Phoenix 8.
But then I stopped,
because I didn't want to spend $800 on a watch
that I was gonna use for a few weeks
and then probably never touch again.
You see, that's how it's always gone for me
in smartwatches.
As much as I love the idea of a tiny computer on my wrist,
in practice, my use of them always goes like this.
I get a nice watch set up,
I commit to wearing it,
but then it starts pinging me every four seconds,
it dies way too quick,
I forget to charge it,
and eventually I realize that I actually don't want
my phone strapped to my wrist at all times.
So this time, I decided to do something I almost never do.
I hit up smartwatch guru
and good friend of mine, Victoria Song,
and I said,
what is the absolute cheapest Garmin watch that doesn't sell?
And she pointed me towards this,
the Garmin Forerunner 165.
It's entry level, it's two years old,
and I got one refurbished on eBay for 186 bucks.
Now I fully expected to use it while testing the Vanguards
and then stash it in a drawer and never use it again,
like all the other watches that have come before.
But to my surprise,
this watch, despite some serious downfalls,
has been the only smartwatch I've continued to wear.
Give me all of the buttons always.
On the left-hand side, you have three buttons.
The top one turns the display on or off,
or long press takes you to deeper settings.
The bottom two arrows act as up and down buttons
with the middle button long press
taking you to deeper settings about whatever you selected,
and the bottom long pressing taking you to your music.
But then you got two more buttons on the other side.
This top one that says run when you're on the home screen,
it'll have you start a workout,
and this bottom button, well, that's just a back button.
Of course, you can also just touch the display,
but since I got buttons, I rarely touch the screen,
especially if I've got gloves on or I'm running
and therefore have really poor touch accuracy.
I will never understand the decision
by smartwatch manufacturers
to take all buttons off of their smartwatches.
I mean, with a screen this small,
it is incredible to have physical inputs.
And now that I've used a watch
and fallen in love with a watch
that has this many buttons,
well, I never wanna go back.
Well, folks, we might just have the most perfect day
for some snowshoeing.
This sounds so silly to say,
but this watch is not a phone.
Oh, yeah.
Nor is it really a companion device for your phone.
Sure, you can see your phone's notifications.
It vibrates when you get them,
but responding to anything on this is hell.
And therefore, I don't do it.
I don't wanna do it.
I'm not pulled away from my life to do it.
I just see that I got something waiting for me
back on my phone when I decide I wanna pick it up.
Oh, but let me see my heart rate.
I bet it's like through the roof.
Oh, my God.
167.
Let's go, baby.
But technically, it is a smartwatch,
so what's smart about it?
Well, that leads me to pro number three.
This thing is, of course,
loaded with health tracking features
that you would qualify as smart,
but I've also been able to invert the smartwatch idea.
This is the first wearable
where I feel like I am smarter
because I am wearing it.
Since October, I've learned more about my health
than with any other watch that has come before.
This watch absolutely focuses on training metrics,
and it puts them front and center
without dumbing them down
or slapping fancy branding on everything.
The signature feature is called Body Battery,
and yes, that is some level of branding,
but it actually makes a lot of sense.
It monitors your energy levels throughout the day,
and it tells you if you're ready for a hard workout
or if you need rest.
And you can watch it in real time
to get a sense of how you're doing at this very moment
rather than just in the morning
or just at night like with other watches.
And because the metrics are so front and center
and they're always changing,
I find that I actually pay attention to them,
and I tend to them.
This is hard.
What are we at now?
Oh my God, 174.
Yikes.
That's good though, right?
It's good to get some cardio.
Another metric I love is recovery hours.
When you finish a workout,
the watch analyzes your heart rate,
the intensity of the session,
your current stress levels,
and then it displays a time that you should wait
before doing another strenuous workout.
Nine, four, let's go.
It's been really fun to see how my body
is doing in real time,
and it has been actually motivating
to get recovery hours.
Man, there is nothing more satisfying
than doing a workout
and just seeing a huge chunk of recovery hours
hit my watch.
Woo!
It's an incredible feeling.
And maybe some people feel motivated like that
with closing rings,
but that just never really did it for me
in the way that recovery hours does.
The last thing that this watch has
over every other watch I've tried before
is battery life.
I hate charging watches,
and this one's no different.
I don't love charging it either.
I mean, proprietary chargers are the bane of my existence,
but there's two differences
between Garmin and everyone else.
I only ever have to charge this watch
maybe once a week,
and the charger plugs into the watch
instead of magnetically connecting to points.
So I don't have to set it down slowly
or really make sure everything is aligned at all.
For a proprietary charger,
that ain't the worst.
But of course, this watch is not perfect.
In fact, it has some of the very worst UI there is,
especially when compared to all of the amazing things
made by this video's sponsor.
You see, in 2026,
it is not hard to have a well-designed anything, really,
but especially not a website.
This is Framer.
It's a no-code website building tool
that looks, feels, and works just like a design tool.
It allows you to launch any website or marketing campaign
without needing a developer.
I recently used a Framer template to overhaul my link tree,
and I am never looking back.
But you can also migrate a site from Webflow or WordPress.
You can start from scratch and design something of your own.
You can even turn a Figma design into a site.
And in minutes,
you'll have something that looks professional
for hosting a resume, a link tree like I did, a portfolio.
Or with Framer's full CMS,
you can grow something larger over time like a blog.
There's a link down in my bio
for when you're ready to up your site's game.
Thank you, Framer, for sponsoring this video.
Now, Garmin, please,
take some tips from these Framer designers.
It's surprisingly easy
to unlink the Garmin devices of today.
You have the knowledge, excuses.
From the clunky Garmin devices of my childhood.
As a brand, what an incredible shift.
Garmin, you have done it.
But unfortunately,
some of your heritage is still seen in your software.
First and foremost, it's the multiple apps.
If you want to install watch faces,
third-party integrations, or customize your device,
that's in Garmin IQ.
But within IQ,
the organization of apps versus watch faces
is all over the place.
For example, if you hit trending apps,
the page is 99% faces,
which I guess are apps technically,
but not what I'm looking for when I think of apps.
And if you're trying to search for an app,
you can, of course, filter results.
But if you click on an app
and then go back to search results,
your filters reset.
And in the home screen,
it is a never-ending page
of seemingly random categories of faces and apps.
The user experience,
and therefore the discoverability here, is zero.
You have to know exactly what you want,
what you're looking for,
and dive into the app with that in mind.
Unless, of course,
you just want to be scrolling
through random watch faces for eternity.
So that's the first critical app.
And then the second, of course, is Garmin Connect.
That's where all your metrics are kept.
And this is fine.
You know, your metrics are front and center
and easy to read,
but getting to activities
and the real guts of the data
takes so many clicks.
And lastly, since I have an older watch,
I don't have native snowboarding
or indoor climbing workouts,
which means I categorize them as other workouts,
which is annoying
when you're trying to go find your workouts
within the app.
And of course,
I could download a third-party app
for either of those activities,
but that means using the Garmin IQ app.
Oh, and it's just a horrible cycle.
As much as I love this watch,
I don't wear it all the time.
For example, I don't like wearing it when I type,
which is a lot,
because I don't like the band
pushing against my wrist.
And when I dress up
and head out for the night,
I take it off too.
I don't think it looks particularly cute on me.
But in those moments
when I'm not wearing my watch,
I'm usually wearing a smart ring.
This is the Ringcon Gen 2,
which I like,
but I have some issues with,
and that's for a whole nother video.
But I just wish that these two things
talk to each other
so that when I wasn't wearing one,
the other one still had all of the information,
all my body information.
And I've heard that if I had an ultra human ring,
I could get them to connect,
or I could use like Health Connect
or something of that sort.
But that doesn't feed into my body battery,
which is a Garmin exclusive metric.
And that's one of my favorites.
And recovery hours also,
it doesn't feed into another one of my favorites.
And so Garmin,
smart ring, when?
Or better yet,
when is there gonna be
some sort of wearable protocol
like there is for smart homes with Matter?
It'd be incredible.
I mean, this is all my data.
I should be able to give it to anyone I want,
and they should be able to read it from any device.
Who wouldn't wanna get their heart rate up?
And this!
All right, so that's the story
of how a cheap Garmin smartwatch
completely changed my mind about smartwatches as a whole.
As someone who is increasingly experiencing phone fatigue
and also lives a very active life,
this sort of device just fits my world really well.
That doesn't mean it's for everybody,
but wow, I was surprised at how much
that meant it was for me.
Let me know what watch you're rocking down in the comments.
Thank you for listening to a longtime smartwatch papoor
fall in love with a Garmin for the first time.
If you've already fallen in love with a Garmin,
oh my gosh, well, why didn't you tell me sooner?
As always, I appreciate the hell out of you,
and I'll see you on the next one.
