Nick is a highly qualified Acupuncturist and Researcher based in the UK.
This lecture was given at the '2018 World TCM Acupuncture-Moxibustion Health Conference' at Cambridge University, Jesus College.
Here, Nick examines the correlations between the Meridians of Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine, with Western Anatomical Structures and Systems. In part one I cover; The Vascular System The Nervous System Fascia and Connective Tissue
He also provides some evidence for the working mechanism of Acupuncture, introducing the Fascia/Connective Tissue Hypothesis, and some of the fascinating implications of this theory.
Understanding the channels in relationship to real anatomical systems and structures is essential to fully understand Acupuncture practice.
Good afternoon everyone. Today I would like to talk to you about the acupuncture channels,
these things we work with every day in our practice. So of course in traditional Chinese
medicine these are the main pathways where Qi and blood flow in the body. The acupuncture points of
course being the main nodes or areas where we can affect the flow of Qi and blood in the channels.
And really the central premise of treatment is that by needling, twainarring, using our various
treatment modalities by regulating this flow of Qi and blood we can treat disease and return the
body to health and homeostasis. So the channels definitely predate point system historically,
it's quite interesting. The first references we have are in the tombs of Ma Hongrui and
these texts and images talk about the channels more in a health cultivation practice,
Daoyin exercises, breathing exercises. And it's not until we get to Neijing,
Yellow Emperor's classic, where the channel and point system is systematized within the
context of Chinese medicine practice, within the context of acupuncture, within the context of
massage and herbs and these kind of things. And then the classics further systematize
the channel and point system throughout Chinese history. But the channel system as we know it
today still remains relatively unchanged since the time of Neijing and the Han dynasty.
So are they real? Do they exist? Are they physical structures, tangible things we can feel?
Or are they, as some researchers suggested, an abstract concept because you can't find an
absolutely exact equivalent in western medicine, western anatomy. And the original mistranslation
of Jingluo as meridian may have led to some misconceptions, especially in the west,
as to the exact nature of the channels we're working with as practitioners.
So today we're going to look at the first three, blood vessels, nerve pathways and fascia and
and we're going to look at the anatomical correlations between these systems and
tissues and the channels of Chinese medicine. I'm hopefully going to discuss the other two
hypotheses in a separate lecture, so please do keep your eyes open for that on my YouTube channel
and website. Let's start with the thrusting vessel and the chongmai with the aorta and the vena cava.
Now clearly there is a direct anatomical correlation between both of these channels
in the way they flow in the body. The aorta and the vena cava are of course the largest artery and vein
in the body respectively and the chongmai in Chinese medicine is described as the sea of blood.
So not only do the pathways mirror each other almost exactly, the chongmai gives a vascular
description and of course the ancient Chinese would have been able to feel the pulsing of the
aorta through the abdomen upon pressure, so there's no doubt in my mind when they talked
about the chongmai they were directly referring to the aorta and the vena cava. Moving on to the
heart and the lung channel which also very closely follow the pathways of the ulna and the radial
arteries below the elbow and as we can see in this image the yin channels of the arm generally
follow the arterial blood flow out of the chest from the axillary artery down into the brachial
artery and then finally dividing into the ulna and the radial arteries as they go past the elbow.
The ulna artery is arguably a slightly closer match to the heart channel with the radial
artery flowing somewhere in between the lung and the large intestine channel.
And here again we see the liver channel which follows the pathway of the great saphenous vein
and the great saphenous nerve. Now it's very interesting that the yin channels of the arms
flow out of the chest towards the hands just as the arterial blood flow flows out of the chest
towards the extremities and the yin channels of the legs it's the opposite, they represent the
venous return from the extremities of the feet upwards towards the abdomen. So this certainly
gives us a vascular explanation for the channels. So I don't think it's any coincidence
that this is the case that the Chinese believed that the qi flowed in these particular directions
and of course if you look at the history of bloodletting in Chinese medical history
clearly this acupuncture had its developmental roots in bloodletting practices as well so all
of this supports the notion that there was a very definite connection to the vascular system when
they were talking about the channels. Unfortunately it gets a bit more complicated because there are
other systems and pathways involved. So many researchers have suggested that the channel
system is a kind of primitive attempt to describe the nervous system as we know it today
and of course this wouldn't have been quite as easy to tangibly see and feel
as the blood vessels and of course the homeostatic regulatory functions of the nervous system in
western medicine you could argue more closely reflect the more holistic view of the channels
in Chinese medicine as acting as this whole body regulatory system. The system that's able to
regulate the processes between the different organs, the various tissues and glands and of
course we can definitely see descriptive similarities in the kind of nervous sensations
we get when we can feel a nerve with the descriptions of qi flow in the body. I'm sure
as practitioners we will have the experience of needling a point and the patient getting an
electric kind of shot down the arm or up the leg wherever we may be needling.
So I think that's a very interesting correlation and certainly as was alluded to earlier the
neurological mechanisms of how acupuncture works have been quite well studied. We clearly know
this is part of what's in an acupuncturist clinical effect is medium of action via the
nervous system and again I've just got some examples here to show you because it's clear
that although the channels mirror the artery flows they also lay closely to the nerve pathway.
So here we can see the ulnar nerve running down the inner aspect of the forearm here
very close proximity to the heart channel. The median nerve runs exactly according to the
cardio channel and the radial nerve somewhat frustratingly flows somewhere in between the
sort of lung and large intestine channels as well. So again some of the correlations vary back some
are a little bit looser but generally there's a very strong correlation in channel pathways
and of course you can do this with all the channels. I've just picked a few to show you here
that are quite interesting. This is one of my favourites. So if you see here right at the top
where the common perineal nerve branches into the superficial perineal nerve
and the deep perineal nerve respectively at full blood 34 and then follows the pathway of the
stomach yangming and full blood xiaoyang leg channels. Again we put direct anatomical
comparisons to the channel systems in western anatomy. Another very interesting correlation
between the nervous system and the channels in Chinese medicine are the back shoe points
which of course are located along the spine roughly located anatomically over their respective
organ. The heart shoe roughly located over the heart itself for example and here we can see in
this diagram in western medicine that each organ is actually innervated by one or more synthetic
nerves which emerge from the vertebral spaces and then travel to send signals to the organs
themselves. A really interesting correlation. So I think we can make a hypothesis for Chinese
medicine in what happens when we needle the back shoe is that we're somehow stimulating or
releasing or affecting these synthetic organ nerves which are then giving signals and passing
information to the organs themselves. Now I would love to see this tested in some research at some
point needling the back shoe and then seeing what kind of effect we can get on the organs themselves.
So clearly the vascular system and the nervous system provide part of the explanation for what
the channels are but neither system fully explains the channels in its own right and I believe really
the best way to look at the channels in this respect is that they represent a collective
grouping of all of the most important channels in our body. All the most important veins, arteries,
nerve pathways, lymphatic vessels, connective tissue planes that they represent the sum total of all
these channels which actually travel in very similar anatomical lines and pathways throughout
the body and these pathways are the meta channels of least resistance, most efficient communication
and transportation throughout our body and that this really is the best way to understand the
channels of Chinese medicine and fascia may be the anatomical substrate which can unite all these
channels into one system. Now fascia is a matrix of connective tissue that runs throughout our body
connecting us from head to toe and originally when we first discovered fascia we thought it was really
responsible for maintaining our structural integrity and our posture but the more research
that was done on it we started to discover that it acts as a whole body regulatory system in its
own right. It actually functions somewhat like the nervous system on this level as it regulates
communication between the nervous system, the blood vessels, the circulatory system, the endocrine
system and the immune system into one webbing of connective tissue. So in this sense we can think
of the fascia as connecting the body not only anatomically but physiologically. This is really
relevant to acupuncture and Chinese medicine theory which is of course based on this premise
that there's this fundamental meta system in the body, this fundamental regulatory system which we
can affect all the other systems and tissues and kind of has a hierarchy on top that can affect
and have a secondary effect down from these systems and I think it's good evidence to suggest that
the more research is done the more we'll find that this may be fascia and of course the parallels between
acupuncture and other fascial therapies are very striking. You know there are many modalities
within sort of acupuncture, umbrella, tweenar, moxa, cupping, gua sha, all of these therapies
we're directly working with the connective tissue, we're working with the fascia, that's what first and
foremost what we're stimulating and of course palpation was a very common part of diagnosis
traditionally in Chinese medicine is sort of sadly declining a little bit as a diagnosis method so
I'm hoping this will encourage you all to get your hands on these patients tomorrow morning
and start to feel these channels a bit more for yourselves as well and of course I think the
development of the channel system and the discovery of the channel system was certainly palpation and
touch and exploration of people's bodies was probably a big part in the development of
mapping out the channel system so there's a lot of research that has
very real correlations between the acupuncture channels and very real fascial connective tissue
lines through various methods we've got computer constructed models, dissection, MRI scans, ultrasound
scans, various different methods have shown these close associations and maybe some of the most
interesting is Myers and his anatomy training through dissection, Myers showed these pathways
to be in undeniably similar locations to the acupuncture channels and the sinew channels
and about 50% of his dissections have been confirmed with others, confirmation of others
still pending, so I don't suppose I need to tell you which channels these are, anybody?
the lateral line, very good, and the superficial back line, the bladder, yes I heard it, very good
these are real tangible structures that exist, this is not an abstract concept or you know an
esoteric metaphysical line that we're working with, this is real connective tissue we're feeling
that we're needing, so this is really one of the key things we want to figure out what is going on
and there's been some interesting research done certainly that shows that when we need an
acupuncture point on a channel we get measurable effects distally down the same channel and those
effects are far more clear than if we need them off the channel and perhaps more interestingly
we've got very real biochemical changes that happen when we stimulate fascia and when we
make a conclusion or a theory on the working mechanism of acupuncture that incorporates the
neurological hypothesis and the neurological explanations for acupuncture mechanisms as well
so when we needle the fascia this produces various biochemical changes in the body
fibroblasts and mast cell proliferation various other immune cell activity it affects the blood
vessels and the sensory nerves by stimulating the fascia and the connective tissue by stimulating
we are having a knock-on effect on all the other systems and tissues in the body
and this theory could very easily explain the wide-ranging clinical effects of acupuncture
the wide-ranging actions that i'm sure many of you see in our clinics every day
this fascia may be the key to kind of unite all these different tissues and systems
into one theory that we're working with so i think there's a lot of promise in this
this is a fascial connective tissue hypothesis and researchers like Langevin
in particular have been the main sort of researchers and proponents of it and really
it's by working with the fascia kneading and stimulating the fascia and having a secondary
effect on all these other systems which is helping bring the body back into homeostasis
so thank you everyone i hope you have enjoyed the talk i hope it's encouraging you to think
of the channels as a real entity a real entity we can see we can get our hands on in order to
when when these patients come in our doors we can actually get our hands on them feel what's going
on a little bit more get a more tangible grasp of their pathologies and their illnesses and i think
it's it's a great tool to look into these things and to help us understand and get better results
thank you very much