Why Galileo Died In Jail For His Discoveries

Inventions and Inventors
25 followers
160 Video Views·Feb 2, 2026
Galileo Galilei is arguably the most important scientist to ever live.
He perfected the first telescopes, turned them towards the universe,
and what he discovered changed the course of history forever.
Galileo provided the first real evidence that the Earth is in orbit around the Sun.
This belief went against the Catholic Church,
resulting in perhaps the most scandalous and saddening trial of the last 500 years.
Stephen Hawking said that Galileo is more responsible for the emergence of modern
science than any other human to ever live, and Einstein called him the father of modern science.
And despite all of this, Galileo spent the last seven years of his life under house arrest,
and to answer why, we need to go back to the beginning.
The year is 1564, and Galileo Galilei has just been born in Pisa, Italy,
the same year that William Shakespeare and the great artist Michelangelo will also be born.
When he was eight, he moved to Florence, perhaps the most beautiful city in the entire world,
thriving in the middle of the Renaissance period.
Galileo's father convinced him to attend the University of Pisa where he would study medicine,
but he wasn't passionate about medicine. What he loved was mathematics and science.
He left the university after just four years without actually getting his medical degree.
This same year, he began teaching mathematics in Florence. Just three years later,
he would return to the University of Pisa, but not as a student, as a mathematics professor.
And it's in Pisa where Galileo made his first significant contributions to science.
Aristotle, arguably the most influential natural philosopher of the last thousand years before
Galileo, believed that objects will fall at a rate proportional to their mass.
For example, if you dropped one ball that say weighs one kilogram and another that weighs
five kilograms, the five kilogram ball should fall five times faster than the one kilogram ball.
Galileo thought that this was wrong. And so as the story goes, Galileo went to the leaning
tower of Pisa and drops two objects from the top, one heavy and one light, but they are both
roughly the same physical size. He drops them and watches as they fall to the ground,
striking the floor at nearly the exact same time. But why does this happen? The force of gravity is
proportional to an object's mass. The more mass, the stronger gravity pulls on it. The more massive
an object is, the more force is needed to accelerate them. This additional force that is
given by gravity perfectly cancels out the additional force that is required to accelerate
the object, meaning all objects fall at the same rate in a gravitational field if you ignore air
resistance. But this wouldn't be the last time that Galileo took on the ancient Greeks.
After his three years in Pisa, Galileo moved to Padua near Venice, where he would work as a
professor of mathematics for the next 18 years. And it's here in Padua where Galileo would
fundamentally change our understanding of the universe forever. At the time, the Catholic church
and by extension, essentially everyone in society believed in Ptolemy's view of the universe. Ptolemy
was a Greek scientist living in Egypt in the second century CE. In his view, the sun and all
the heavenly bodies rotated around the earth. Aristotle had already proposed that everything
above the earth was perfect and incorruptible. But at the time of Galileo, many if not all
astronomers believed in a different system proposed by the Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe.
In this system, all the planets and the stars in the sky orbited the sun, while the sun orbits
the earth. Just before Galileo's birth, Nicholas Copernicus published his work on the revolutions
of celestial spheres, in which he argued that everything in our solar system, including the
earth, orbited the sun. At the time, the book was met with some mild controversy and didn't receive
any major support. Most people just assumed that it would be proven wrong eventually. Copernicus
died the year his work was published. But for Galileo, he wanted to understand exactly how the
universe worked, and which of these systems was true in reality. So what he did next changed
everything. In 1608, glassmakers in the Netherlands had been making unbelievable progress in creating
quality lenses. It was only a matter of time before someone put two lenses together and noticed
their magnifying capabilities. A glassmaker named Hans Libesche from Middelburg created the first
telescope. He submits a patent for his creation on the 2nd of October 1608. In the patent, he
described his creation as a Dutch perspective glass used to see things far away as if they were
nearby. The most powerful tool of the scientific revolution has just been invented. Over a few
months, the word of this invention spreads throughout Europe, eventually making its way
to Galileo in June of 1609. At the time, Galileo was just 45 years old. When he hears about the
invention, the best telescopes in the world were capable of increasing human vision by just a
factor of three. But Galileo thought he could do better. He immediately travels home to Padua from
Venice and that night begins creating his own telescope. It takes him just a few days to have
his first prototype. He even learns how to perfect his own lenses from scratch. After just two months
of development, his creations have become so good that they are capable of eight times magnification.
But instead of turning it to the stars immediately, he first demonstrates its abilities to Venetian
lawmakers, offering it to them as a gift. Seeing its military potential, they accept his offer.
Galileo's final telescope is 20 meters long and 37 millimeters in diameter. It is capable of
magnifying objects by 20 times. When I visited Florence, I looked around in the Galileo museum
and these are his original telescopes that he actually did use to make these observations.
After perfecting his creation, Galileo finally decides to do something that no human before
him has ever done. Point a telescope towards the cosmos, revealing its deepest secrets. He first
points the device towards the moon, seeing craters, grooves and mountains. This is in contrast to the
accepted belief of the time that the moon was a perfect smooth surface, unlike the earth. Three
months after he was able to create the first telescope, at 5pm on Thursday the 7th of January
1610, Galileo is in his garden in Padua with his newly developed telescope. He is about to change
the course of history forever by doing something that seems really simple, pointing his telescope
at Jupiter for the first time in history. Galileo sees three fixed stars that are extremely close to
Jupiter. Over the subsequent nights, he continues to watch, noticing that these objects appear to
wander like satellites around Jupiter. They appear to become obscured by the planet and just
six days later, Galileo notices a fourth object in orbit around Jupiter. They were seen to change
their position relative to Jupiter but always stayed in a straight line. These are of course
the moons of Jupiter, Io, Europa, Ganymede and Callisto. He initially tried to name the four
moons the Medesian stars, after the Medici brothers, a notable family in Italy. This helped
him to secure prestigious positions at the University of Pisa but the names didn't stick.
These moons of Jupiter would forever be known as the Galilean moons. He published these findings
along with his observations of the moon in a short book titled Sidereus Nunculus. This translates to
the starry messenger and the results were not received well. People believed that his lenses
were defective and what he was seeing was simply an illusion. Aristotle had described the cosmos
as being filled with these perfect, unchanging bodies. God had made a perfect universe. Who was
Galileo to say that he didn't? And if everything in the universe was supposed to be orbiting the
earth, how could there be moons orbiting Jupiter? The people this offended the most,
the Catholic Church. The most prominent figure in the Catholic Church at the time was Cardinal
Robert Bellamy. Anytime they needed an interpretation of holy scripture, it was
Cardinal Bellamy that the church would look to. The Catholic Church was planning to make a ruling
to say that only bishops and councils of the church would be allowed to interpret the meanings
of the bible. No one else could, especially not someone like Galileo. Galileo was actively
arguing for the heliocentric model of the solar system, that the earth and all the planets orbited
the sun. Now importantly, Galileo did say the whole time that God's word was always correct
and trustworthy. But he also said that scripture can't contradict what is true in nature. To the
church, he was just essentially reinterpreting the scripture and saying that they were wrong.
He defended this by writing a letter to the Grand Duchess Christina of Tuscany in 1615. He says in
it that the church and science are compatible, but holds that if science tells us something that is
true in the natural world, it is just unreasonable for the church to expect scientists to ignore
their discoveries and just blindly trust the approved interpretations of scripture. He writes
for this would amount to commanding that the astronomer must not see what they see and must
not understand what they know and that in searching they must find the opposite of what they
actually encounter. Pope Paul V sends Cardinal Bellamy to visit Galileo a month before they
ban heliocentrism. Bellamy was instructed to tell Galileo about the upcoming decree as it would make
his work heretical. This meeting would turn out to be the most important meeting in Galileo's
entire life. As if he continues down this path, he would find himself on trial for heresy, his life
at risk. Remember this visit. The next year, in 1616, the Pope decrees that heliocentrism is
heretical due to it being false and contrary to the church's scriptures. In doing so, they banned
Copernicus's book on heliocentrism until corrections were made that essentially just removed all the
suggestions of the earth orbiting the sun. After publishing his results from his studies on Jupiter,
he set out to be more precise and quantify his observations, applying a systematic approach that
today we would just call the scientific method. By looking at the moons of Jupiter over a longer
period of time, he was able to roughly measure their orbital periods. But finding a more precise
calculation proved extremely hard. He continued working and his periods got more and more precise,
but something still seemed off. And then he had an idea. Maybe the orbits he was measuring seemed
to be inaccurate because the earth is in orbit around the sun. By counting for the motion of
the earth revolving around the sun, his problems were solved. This discovery did not hold with the
principles of Aristotelian cosmology. Many astronomers and philosophers just refused to
believe that a man like Galileo would be capable of making such a momentous discovery. But Galileo
had done it and he didn't stop there. He pointed his telescope towards Venus and it was showing
phases similar to those that we see the moon going through each month. Using this fact, he concluded
that Venus must also be orbiting the sun, not the earth. The Ptolemaic system for the universe was
falling apart at the hands of Galileo and the Catholic Church knew it. Seven years after receiving
his visit from Cardinal Bellamy, Galileo's friend becomes the new Pope. So Galileo chats with this
Pope about the heliocentrism problem and they agreed that he could write about heliocentrism
if he did it in a theoretical way. And so in 1624, Galileo gets to work writing probably the most
important book he will ever write. Eight years later, Galileo publishes the Dialogue Concerning
the Two Chief Systems of the World. In accordance with the advice that was given by the Pope,
in his book, Galileo writes about two fictional characters, Salviati, who argues for the heliocentric
Copernican system, and Simplicio, who is a follower of Aristotle, arguing that the earth is in the
It was believed that Galileo's character, Simplicio, was an attack on the Aristotelian
geocentrist view of the world. I mean, after all, Simplicio in Italian literally translates to
simpleton. Salviati easily won the argument, suggesting that his views were correct,
and suggesting that is what Galileo believes. The Pope reads the book and becomes furious.
The Roman Inquisition bans the sales of his book and calls him to trial in 1633 for heresy.
At the time, Galileo was nearly 70 years old and extremely unwell. He was on trial for his life.
The proceedings were conducted by 10 cardinals, all of which were personally appointed by the Pope.
Their job was to protect the Catholic beliefs. Right away, the church turns their attention to
asks Galileo what he remembers of his meeting with Cardinal Bellarmine. He says that he was
informed by the Cardinal to only speak lightly of the heliocentric model and no truth be taken
from it as it went against church doctrine. The church called Galileo a liar and said that he was
ordered by Bellarmine all the way back in 1616 not to write or teach anything about heliocentrism
at all. To prove this, the prosecutors produced a letter that Cardinal Bellarmine had supposedly
sent to Galileo after they met, recounting their discussion. In it, Bellarmine says that Galileo
was told, henceforth, to not hold, teach or defend heliocentrism in any way whatever, either orally
or in writing, otherwise the Holy Office would start proceedings against him. This seems like
case closed. Galileo was told to not talk about it, and he did, so he must face the persecution
of the church. But Galileo was a smart man, and he keeps records of his own.
Galileo dramatically brings out the original copy of the same letter that he received from
Cardinal Bellarmine. This one was written by Bellarmine and signed by the man himself.
The Roman Inquisition didn't know that Galileo still had this letter,
and this is where things get interesting. The letters were not the same. In fact,
they had one major difference. Galileo's original copy of the letter didn't say that Galileo was
ordered to not talk or write about heliocentrism in any way whatsoever, or he would be persecuted.
Galileo's letter just says that heliocentrism is wrong and shouldn't be explicitly advocated for,
and since the dialogue was a fictional story, he broke no rules.
The entire trial relied on this letter, and somewhat suspiciously, the church's copy just
happened to have this one key addition that they were using to convict Galileo of heresy.
Some scholars have suggested that the church faked their letter to bring down Galileo and
maintain their world view, preventing the church from losing more followers,
but I'll leave that up to you to decide. To make things worse, the court asked Galileo
whether he had received an imprimatur for the dialogue. This is essentially a seal given by the
church to certify that there is nothing contrary to Catholic faith, and Galileo had received not
just one, but two imprimaturs for his book. The church had brought to trial someone who had
written a book that the church themselves had approved of. This trial continued for weeks.
Towards the end of the trial, Galileo was interrogated harshly and threatened with
torture if he did not tell the truth. The case against Galileo was weak, and there were many
parties who wanted it to end quickly. Galileo's health was deteriorating, so the prosecutor
struck a deal with him. He would plead guilty to some minor offence in writing his book
for a lighter sentence. Galileo would keep his life, and they found him vehemently suspect of
heresy for his opinion that the sun is at the centre of the universe. He was sentenced to
live under house arrest for the rest of his days.
Galileo's book was banned, and all of his published works and anything else that he might
write was also prohibited. He did eventually decide to write again, writing a book called
Discourses and Mathematical Demonstrations Concerning the Two New Sciences. This book
summarised much of his work over the last 40 years, and it was smuggled out of Italy to Holland
where it was then published. Einstein highly praised this work, and it's the reason that many
people consider Galileo to be the father of modern day science. He didn't suffer in prison,
tortured for years, but his physical and intellectual freedom was imprisoned by the
Catholic Church until, on January 8th, 1642, he finally passed away in his home.
The Grand Duke of Tuscany wanted Galileo to be buried in the Basilica of Santa Croce,
but when he was condemned by the Catholic Church for heresy,
he was instead buried in a small room next to the novice's chapel at the end of a hallway.
Nearly 100 years later, he was moved to the main body of the basilica, and during this move,
three fingers and a tooth were removed, which are now on display in the Galileo Museum in Florence.
In 1718, they finally lifted the ban on reprinting all of Galileo's work,
with the exception of the dialogue. It wasn't until 1835, 200 years after Galileo wrote the
dialogue, that the ban was finally lifted. Galileo was locked up for supposedly ignoring
an order that he very well may have never received, but even if he did receive it,
it was unjust. The Church was telling the astronomer to ignore the true nature of the
universe and just blindly follow what they deemed to be correct, and if he and all of
us scientists did as they wish, I'm sure we would know nearly nothing about the universe today.
In the questions of science, the authority of a thousand is not worth the humble reasoning
of a single individual. Galileo looked towards the stars using his homemade telescope and made
observations that changed the course of human history forever, and the best part is, you can
do the same using a telescope from Unistellar. Growing up, I would use telescopes to view the
moon regularly, and I would always just be amazed at how the moon would have looked
exactly the same to Galileo as it does to me looking through a telescope today. You can see
the same ridges and craters the sunlight casts across the surface. It always amazed me and made
me feel connected to Galileo through time. But both Galileo and I were not able to see galaxies
and nebulae using our telescopes, and that's where Unistellar comes in. They create extremely
powerful and smart telescopes that are specifically designed for urban environments where
light pollution can be a problem. And while some classical telescopes can take hours to set up,
I can go from the telescope being fully packed away in this backpack to observing the night sky
in just five minutes. This is their Odyssey Pro Telescope. It's extremely powerful and capable
of viewing planets like Saturn and Jupiter just like Galileo did, as well as seeing deep sky
objects like the galaxies and nebulae you see online. And the best part is, because it's a
smart telescope, it has an integrated digital camera and processing, meaning you can do advanced
astrophotography using their iOS or Android app from the comfort of your own backyard.
The telescope's catalogue has over 5,000 amazing objects it can locate for you,
allowing you to truly explore the universe with ease. I have genuinely never used a telescope
that is so intuitive and user-friendly, while still providing professional results.
In fact, Unistellar works with NASA on their Citizen Science Program, which allows everyday
users like you and me to make real scientific discoveries. Some users actually did this for
the DART missions last year. So if you want to explore the universe just like Galileo did 400
years ago, then click the link at the top of the description and use my promo code
which will get you 20% off your telescope purchase.
