The 3 000 Year Old Discovery That Changed Royal Egyptian History

ancient literature
168 followers
Egypt, 150 years ago.
A gang of tomb raiders, led by the infamous Rasool brothers,
make an extraordinary discovery.
High on these cliffs, they uncover a secret shaft
cut deep into the limestone, a gateway into a hidden world.
At the bottom is a tomb, undisturbed
for thousands of years.
And inside, more than 50 mummies.
Nothing like it had ever been found before.
British Egyptologist Dr. Chris Naunton
is on the trail of an ancient Egyptian mystery.
What I can see is a shaft, a deep shaft,
cut directly into the rock.
Goes down about 20 meters, about 60 feet.
And it leads to a network of tunnels.
And these extend for about 100 meters, 300 feet,
something like that.
And in the walls of these tunnels,
there are niches, kind of side chambers.
The discovery is known today as the Royal Cache.
Among the mummies are 10 pharaohs,
including some of the greatest names of ancient Egypt.
But alongside legendary kings like Ramesses the Great
and Seti I is a little-known pharaoh whose
reign is shrouded in mystery, 2nd Nenre Tal.
2nd Nenre isn't as famous as some of his successors,
like Ramesses the Great or Seti I.
But the fact that he was buried alongside those pharaohs
suggests that for the ancient Egyptians,
he was every bit a part of that line of great kings.
Who is this mystery pharaoh buried among the greats?
The first clue, an inscription on the lid of his coffin.
2nd Nenre the Brave.
Why the brave?
Hidden inside the coffin was a mummy the likes of which
had never been seen before.
When we look at the front of his face,
it certainly doesn't look normal.
It's very distorted.
You may just be able to see the ends of the nose there.
But the whole of the nose, the eye on the right,
the bridge of the nose, the eye on the left
are all very distorted.
2nd Nenre is unique.
He's the only mummified pharaoh ever found
with such violent injuries.
Dr. Richard Shepard is a world-renowned
forensic pathologist.
His specialty, the investigation of suspicious deaths.
These are the two wounds to the right side
of 2nd Nenre's head.
This is a wound where actually a piece of the skull
has been forced in.
It's been smashed into his brain underneath this,
producing this large crater-like effect.
This wound has a slightly different appearance,
partly because I think a bit of the bone has broken off,
possibly as the weapon was removed.
It's flipped a piece of the outer part of the skull off.
But this, too, has actually cut through.
It's punched into the skull.
With an heroic epitaph,
understanding how he died is the key
to unlocking the secrets of his life.
Dr. Shepard turns to the only full autopsy
ever performed on the body.
It was carried out 100 years ago by anatomist Elliot Smith.
His conclusions?
2nd Nenre died from axe wounds received in battle.
Dr. Shepard is taking a closer look at Smith's report.
Elliot Smith says axe in his report,
and I'd back it up forensically for my knowledge now.
When I look at these two injuries,
what I can say is that they are both lethal wounds,
and you'd probably only need one of them to cause death,
but the two together are a certain cause of death.
The experts agree on the cause of death.
Fatal axe blows to the head.
But did he receive these wounds on the battlefield?
And if so, why risk a pharaoh's life on the front line?
In the search for answers,
Egyptologist Chris Nonton picks up the pharaoh's trail.
There's very little evidence for Sir Kenan Ray and his reign.
We know of a broken limestone doorway
and a couple of stones mentioning his name.
But all in all, relative to other kings,
we have very, very little of him at all.
Ramesses the Great built gigantic statues of himself,
and Seti I constructed this magnificent temple.
But monuments to 2nd Nenre are hard to find.
I think the reason why we have so little evidence for him
is perhaps to do with the fact
that he didn't reign for very long,
so he didn't have very much opportunity to record his name.
But perhaps the best ways of doing this,
of stamping your mark on your territory,
would be to build a temple, for example.
We know, as far as we can tell, he didn't do that.
Also unusual is the way 2nd Nenre was cared for after death.
Egyptologist Dr. Campbell Price.
You would expect, around this time,
the king, or any high elite person,
to be mummified after death.
2nd Nenre is in a contorted state.
Something clearly has gone wrong with the process of embalming,
but also with the arrangement of the body.
No attempt has been made to compose the features,
even to straighten the limbs out.
They're quite contorted from that final assault.
A violent death.
A substandard mummification.
And no grand monuments in his name.
But ancient evidence does yield two important clues
pushing the investigation forward.
First, 2nd Nenre's reign was short.
Second, he ruled at a time when Egypt was under siege.
Foreign invaders occupy the north.
They are known as the Hyksos.
2nd Nenre, a pharaoh of ancient Egypt
whose reign is still shrouded in mystery.
His body bears the marks of a violent death,
and his mummy is poorly preserved.
For Egyptologist Campbell Price, it
suggests the embalming was rushed and incomplete.
You can tell immediately that something
has gone wrong with the embalming of 2nd Nenre.
The body has not been treated in a manner you would expect.
In ancient Egypt, mummification was a sacred ritual.
The brain was removed, and salt was used to preserve the body.
A painstaking process that took several weeks
to complete.
None of this happened with 2nd Nenre.
The fact that he's so contorted, his brain hasn't been removed,
and he's not been treated with salt, strongly, strongly
suggests that he was embalmed in a hurry
in difficult circumstances, probably on a battlefield.
2nd Nenre was badly mummified following a violent death.
So far, the evidence points to a battlefield.
But Dr. Shepard is finding other clues.
If a body had been left on a battlefield
at any length of time, I would have expected to see
what's called animal predation, marks
where animals small and large had attacked the body.
Their populations have since declined,
but vultures once circled the skies above Egypt.
The aftermath of any battle would offer rich pickings
for these hungry scavengers.
But forensic examination reveals all the pharaoh's wounds
were inflicted by weapons.
So the absence of any evidence on 2nd Nenre's body
of this animal predation says to me
that there is no way he has lain on a battlefield
for any significant period of time, if at all.
If not on the battlefield, where did 2nd Nenre die?
And who had the means and the motive to kill him?
2nd Nenre rules an empire in deep trouble.
Egypt is besieged on all sides.
His immediate predecessors have failed
to secure the nation's borders.
And large parts of his kingdom
are occupied by foreign enemies.
When 2nd Nenre was on the throne,
he ruled over a territory that was only a fraction
of the size that it would have been
under the rule of previous kings.
So the glory days really were over by this point.
Egypt and the territory that 2nd Nenre controlled
was not the same size as it would have been
in the age of the pyramids before him.
Egypt is being squeezed from above and below.
For 2nd Nenre, the immediate danger lies in the north,
where the Hyksos rule over the fertile Nile Delta
from their capital, Avaris.
They have a stranglehold on the trade routes
and are starving 2nd Nenre of resources.
As Dr. Gary Shaw explains,
the Hyksos far outclassed the Egyptians in military might.
The Hyksos brought with them,
when they were expanding their territory,
advanced technology compared to what the Egyptians had.
The main one was probably chariots,
which the Egyptians didn't have at this time.
And the advanced Hyksos armory doesn't stop there.
Their soldiers used the lethal composite bow.
Made from wood and buffalo horn,
it outperforms the simple Egyptian bow
in both range and killing power.
The Egyptians were outmatched in every possible way
when it came to their military technology.
Threatened by an enemy as powerful as the Hyksos,
2nd Nenre faces a stark choice.
Live under the control of the occupiers
or risk everything in a war to drive them out.
The Egyptians suddenly woke up
to the situation surrounding them,
that they were now outmatched militarily.
And the only way to solve this problem
was to develop their society in a more militaristic way.
So what was 2nd Nenre's decision?
Chris Nonton is on his trail.
Archaeologists have been excavating a DRL ballast
for over a hundred years.
Among these ruins, they made an extraordinary find,
a doorframe bearing the name 2nd Nenre Tao.
This was once the site of a grand palace
built in the style of an imposing fortress.
If this is 2nd Nenre's lost outpost,
it's not the work of a weak and cowering king.
This would have been an incredibly impressive site
in its day.
These walls were massive.
They stood two stories high
and they would have been covered
with a layer of fine, bright white plaster.
All of this would have created a gleaming vision
in the desert, an incredibly impressive site.
This palace was built to last.
Parts of it are still standing 3,000 years later.
This is one of the massive walls
that makes up the remains
of the northern palace of 2nd Nenre.
And the palace would have been built of mud brick, in fact.
You can see those bricks here.
But although it's made of mud,
that might not sound very impressive,
but actually mud brick was the material
that the ancient Egyptians used
for all of their domestic buildings,
from the very simplest up to royal palaces like this.
And actually, in this case, the bricks are very large.
This is one of them on its side here.
And they're very finely made as well.
So these would have been the sort of highest quality bricks.
And it's incredible to think
that although it's a ruin now,
these were made by a craftsman 3,500 years ago.
And they're still standing today.
It just gives you a sense of how durable this material was.
This structure wasn't just strong, it was huge.
Well, I have here a plan of 2nd Nenre's palace,
at Terror Palace.
And you can see the full extent of what he was building,
not just the northern palace,
but the whole of the landscape.
And crucially, a second really substantial building of his,
a southern palace built on the top of a hill
overlooking the Nile.
This would have given 2nd Nenre a commanding view
of his enemies from the north.
This is the Hyksos, of course,
who for decades had been controlling the territory
to the north of this part of the world.
This was a settlement of some considerable size.
And the fortifications, of course,
suggest to us that there would have been
a substantial military presence here as well.
So it's not impossible that we could be talking
about hundreds, if not thousands of people settled here,
all part of 2nd Nenre's efforts.
It's a symbol of power built to impress.
He would have spent some time gazing north.
We can imagine contemplating his enemy,
contemplating what would be the defining moment
of not just his reign, but the period.
2nd Nenre's palace is built like a fortress,
leaving no one in any doubt about his intentions.
This palace is very much about making a statement.
It's a symbol of power and strength,
but the military dimension to this suggests
that from the very beginnings of his reign,
he had war on his mind.
But all conflicts need a trigger.
What was the flashpoint for 2nd Nenre's war?
The answer may lie hidden in an ancient text.
2nd Nenre is a pharaoh under siege.
The Hyksos and their armies occupy the north of Egypt.
At his palace at Deir el-Balas,
the pharaoh prepares for a war of resistance.
But who makes the first move, 2nd Nenre or the Hyksos?
A 3,000-year-old papyrus may hold the answer.
The ancient texts tell us that 2nd Nenre had a quarrel
with the Hyksos king, Apophis.
Apophis sent a message down to thieves
to say that he was terribly annoyed
because some hippopotami that 2nd Nenre was keeping
in a pool were making so much noise
that it was keeping him awake at night.
It's apparently on this strange pretext
that 2nd Nenre declares war on the Hyksos.
But something doesn't add up.
Apophis is hundreds of miles away.
And very few leaders would go to war over noisy hippos.
One explanation may lie in the mistranslation
of the ancient Egyptian word for hippo,
which sounds like the word for soldier.
If Apophis' request was for 2nd Nenre
to remove his soldiers, that would make sense
if he was amassing his troops at that time ready for battle.
However we interpret that,
2nd Nenre's response to Apophis' request
was to launch all out war against the Hyksos.
It's 2nd Nenre who makes the first move.
The question is, why?
To find the answer, Chris Naunton is investigating
the carvings on the temple of Medinet-Hebu.
Over thousands of years,
the ancient Egyptians recorded their beliefs in stone,
including what was expected of their godlike pharaohs.
As you move through the temple,
the architecture alters subtly
and the decoration begins to change as well.
You get scenes that concern almost exclusively the king
and his interaction with the gods.
Chris Naunton believes these reliefs outline
all that is expected of a pharaoh in ancient Egypt.
This is exactly the kind of thing that I've been looking for.
This is the kind of motif that gives us an idea
of what a pharaoh like 2nd Nenre's role
would have been in the Egyptian cosmos.
You have an image of the king,
one either side of the doorway,
and above him are standing two gods,
in this case Thoth on the right-hand side
and Horus on the left,
and they're holding these kind of cords.
But at the end of these cords,
you can see the motifs for the lotus and papyrus,
and these are symbolic of upper and lower Egypt,
the two kingdoms of Egypt.
And these two gods are tying these together,
and so this is symbolic of this incredibly important part
of what the king does for Egypt,
unifying these two lands, bringing them together.
This, of course, is something that 2nd Nenre
would have recognized and something he himself
would have wanted to achieve.
With upper Egypt in the grip of the Hyksos,
2nd Nenre is failing in his duty to his gods and his people.
As pharaoh, he has no choice but to confront Egypt's enemies
and drive them from his lands.
There is a sense from the surviving record
that he kicks off this liberation war against the Hyksos,
so I imagine he's quite a gung-ho kind of chap.
He will sense, as a pharaoh,
that he has to step into the moment.
It's fight or flight.
He has to show that he is a king.
But what kind of king?
A brave warrior on the front lines,
or something else?
2nd Nenre, an Egyptian pharaoh
with a dream to liberate his homeland
and restore its glory.
He builds an immense fortified palace.
His massing of troops outrages the Hyksos king.
2nd Nenre uses this as a justification to declare war.
To move his army to the front line,
he takes advantage of one of his greatest assets,
the Nile.
It's very likely that 2nd Nenre
had a fleet of large vessels
in order to transport the large numbers of men,
his recruits for his army,
from his base here to engage with the Hyksos.
The evidence that we have suggests
that the kind of boats that 2nd Nenre would have made use of
would have had sails, but also oarsmen,
for those days when the wind wasn't particularly helpful.
When 2nd Nenre took his armies to war,
did he lead from the front?
And if he did,
were his fatal wounds inflicted on the battlefield?
In the ancient temple of Medinet Habu,
Dr. Chris Naunton is looking for answers
carved into the stones.
Depictions of armed men,
terrible violence,
images of a pharaoh in the heat of battle.
One of the themes that's the commonest
in a temple like this
is of Pharaoh conquering his enemies,
and that's exactly what we can see here.
Pharaoh's shown on the left,
almost twice the size of his captured enemies here,
and he's holding them by the hair.
And this is conveying the message to whoever saw this
that Pharaoh is the mightiest, the most powerful,
in full control over his foreign enemies.
But whether or not this would have borne
any relation to reality is open to some question.
Gripping his victims by the hair
and preparing to strike.
Smiting.
Brutal justice visited by a pharaoh on his enemies.
But how true to life is this portrayal of a pharaoh at war?
You've got to take anything that's represented
on an Egyptian temple wall with a few pinches of salt.
These are idealized images,
images for the gods,
images for eternity,
images that do not clearly relate always to reality.
You can't show him weak.
You can't show him indecisive.
You show him victorious and glorious
and always with the upper hand.
That is the nature of Egyptian monuments.
That's the nature of Egyptian monumental presentation.
A different picture emerges back at the Cairo Museum.
The mummies that we have closest in time to second Enres,
none of them have any signs that can be attributed
to wounds inflicted during campaigning.
Great warrior pharaohs like Thutmose III,
Amenhotep II, King Ahmose.
These are all described as great warriors.
But when you look at the mummies,
there's nothing to indicate a lifetime spent
fighting enemies on the battlefield.
Of all these pharaohs with warrior reputations,
only second Enres has wounds inflicted by a battle ax.
But there are inconsistencies in the evidence.
And for Dr. Shepard, the forensics just aren't adding up.
The only information we have about the wounds
on second Enres are produced by Elliot Smith
from his post-mortem report from 1912.
And what he says in his report is,
the absence of any injuries to the arms
or to any other part of the body
shows that no resistance could have been offered to the attack.
Now, that's really very interesting, forensically,
because normally you would expect someone
in the middle of a melee, in the middle of a battle,
to receive injuries from many parts
once they begin to go down, certainly,
and for them to try and defend themselves
against those injuries.
And these are what we call defensive injuries.
And the commonest ones are on the arms and legs,
particularly the ulna, the outer part of the arm,
where the arms are raised
and blows might be struck against it.
There are gripping injuries to the hands
as they grab the ends of swords or knives.
All sorts of injuries distributed throughout the body.
So looking at the injuries that second Enres has,
the complete absence of any injuries elsewhere in the body,
the focus of the injury to the head,
suggests to me that he was nowhere near
the front line of a battle.
And it's not just Dr. Shepard's analysis
that suggests the pharaoh didn't die fighting.
Chris Naunton is finding supporting evidence
in the carvings on these temple walls.
Pharaoh's the most important person
in the Egyptian world, of course.
It would have been far too risky
to have him in direct contact with his foes like this.
He would have been perhaps on the battlefield,
but some way away protected by bodyguards.
And this is all about propaganda.
It's a message showing you symbolically
that he's a powerful head of the army.
But in fact, this wouldn't really have been
what you would have been seeing
if you were actually there with him.
The investigation has reached a turning point.
If not on the battlefield, how did second Enres die?
And who delivered the fatal blows?
Dr. Gary Shaw has a theory.
It seems to me that second Enres
must have been captured following the loss of a battle.
And I think ceremonial execution
is probably the best explanation
for the way that he received these wounds,
but doesn't have wounds anywhere else on his body.
Smiting or the ceremonial execution
of captive enemies by a war leader was a brutal way to die.
Gripped by the hair, struck with an ax or sword.
According to Gary Shaw,
this is a fate that even the pharaoh himself could suffer.
Second Enres would have been captured
following the loss of the battle.
And the enemy commander wanted to make a show
of this defeated enemy.
We can imagine the troops,
the Hyksos perhaps being lined up in front
witnessing this execution.
The wounds on the mummy paint a horrifying picture.
We have three seemingly different weapons
used on the body of second Enres.
One is a Hyksos style Asiatic bronze battle ax.
The Hyksos ax, with its distinctive flared bronze blade,
it can easily cut through flesh and bone.
The other one is an Egyptian style ax.
The Egyptian ax, simpler than its Hyksos equivalent,
but with a much broader cutting blade.
And then what might be a spear or a dagger.
The narrow bronze spear
could easily puncture bone and muscle.
First blow would have been the one above the right eye.
It comes at roughly the right height,
I would think, as if second Enres was kneeling and bound.
So the person standing could swing the ax
directly into the head.
And then we get the wound below the left eye,
which is made with the same weapon,
this Hyksos style battle ax.
Then he might have turned the weapon around
and used the handle of the weapon
to create the great heavy blunt wound
that crushed the right eye socket
and destroyed part of the face.
Then it would seem that his display might have been finished,
that the guy using the Hyksos weapon would step aside
and maybe a vassal, an Egyptian working with the Hyksos,
using an Egyptian style weapon
to create the great long horizontal wound
at the upper forehead.
The idea that different weapons cause different wounds
has always intrigued historians.
The broad Egyptian ax producing a long wound
and a more rounded puncture
that looks to be made with the narrow Hyksos ax.
The possibility that there are wounds made by weapons
from both sides of the warring factions
further fuels the debates surrounding second Enres' death.
The small stab to the neck is most likely from a spear,
a weapon used by both sides.
We then have the last wound, the one below the left ear.
It'd be quite easy to stick a spear
into the side of second Enres and finish him off.
But did this finish him off?
Dr. Richard Shepherd is investigating
this small stab wound at the side of the pharaoh's neck.
The track of the wound has passed
into the back of the left side of the neck.
It's been a real chance injury that's cut through.
This injury, so close to the spinal cord,
has huge implications for when
and where second Enres met his death.
When we look at the front of his face,
we know from the x-rays
there's extensive bony damage lying beneath these,
but these injuries are not recent.
They've healed.
Dr. Shepherd is not convinced by Gary Shah's timeline.
Healing to this extent takes time.
It doesn't happen in a day or two.
It happens over several weeks or even months.
And so we have two lots of injuries here.
We have some old injuries to his face, which have healed,
having caused severe damage,
and we have recent injuries to his head
that have caused his death.
A different story is emerging.
The facial wounds from an initial attack heal
and are followed much later
by fatal blows to the pharaoh's head.
The key to this new theory is the small wound to the spine.
It paints a startling new picture
of second Enres' final moments.
The person would be lying on the ground.
They would probably be semi-conscious initially.
They may remain conscious,
but they would be paralyzed from the neck down.
So instant paralysis is going to follow
an injury such as this.
The contorted body of second Enres
lies alongside some of the great pharaohs
in the Cairo Museum.
His death was violent,
but Dr. Richard Shepherd believes
he didn't die on a battlefield.
He is re-examining a stab wound in the pharaoh's neck.
He believes it was inflicted at the same time
as the injuries to the face,
but long before the fatal blows to his head.
This is a picture that was taken contemporaneously
with Elliot Smith's autopsy in 1912.
And what it shows actually is the base of the skull.
This big hole here is the hole at the base of the skull
called the foramen magnum.
What you can see here is a discontinuity of that circle.
This is normal.
This is abnormal on the left.
The skull at its base is damaged at that point.
The damage was caused by a spear
as it penetrated the pharaoh's neck.
Now, I think that's significant
because if we look at it on this computer visualization
of a healthy, normal human,
here we can see the brain stem is here at this point.
All of the nerves that control the body
pass through that point of the brain.
An injury here can sever the nerves,
leaving the victim alive but paralyzed from the neck down.
Was this second henry's fate?
Long-term paralysis changes the body.
The main change that can be seen
is the effect on the muscles of the body.
We have muscles that bend our hands forwards and back.
And after time, when you have a damage to the neck,
the stronger muscles in the arms
pull the hands over like this.
And these are called contractures.
And second henry's hands show this classic distortion,
this classic contracture effect,
indicating that he has had damage to his nerves
not just an hour before, not just a day before,
but a long time before his death.
Dr. Shepard's theory relies on second henry
surviving an initial attack
with injuries to the left cheek,
the right eye, and the side of the neck.
But although horrific, they were not the cause of death.
Dr. Shepard believes the fatal blows
were struck long after.
What I can see is that second henry
was lying in his bed, immobile, unable to do anything.
It's a chilling scenario.
The pharaoh returns from battle
paralyzed from the neck down.
And when his killer finally draws near,
second henry is powerless to defend himself.
He couldn't move his hands.
He couldn't move his legs.
I think an assailant has come up to him lying in bed
and from second henry's right hand side
has delivered at least two very severe blows.
We Egyptologists tend to think
that we're almost the sole guardians
of the story of what happened in ancient Egypt.
But when you get a new perspective
from somebody who's looking coldly
at the evidence before them,
in this case, the mummy of second henry,
I think we have to be open to changing our views.
And I'm happy actually that the interpretation
we have here is certainly a possibility.
The final mystery, who killed second henry and why?
Perhaps he was a Hyksos assassin
or a palace insider sent to remove a once great pharaoh
now powerless to lead his kingdom.
Whatever the circumstances,
second henry's death would not be in vain.
The war he began was eventually won.
Within 60 years of his death,
the Hyksos were defeated and the kingdom of Egypt reunited.
Second henry's contribution to Egyptian history is massive.
Although he wasn't able to complete the task himself,
he set the stage for his sons to do that,
which they did successfully.
And in so doing, they reunified the country.
They were only able to have the reigns that they had
thanks to his actions.
The full story behind second henry's death
and rushed mummification may never be known.
Killed in battle, struck down in a brutal display of power
or disposed of after months of suffering.
Second henry deserves to be recognized
alongside the other great pharaohs of Egypt.
I think second henry's role in Egyptian history
is vastly underestimated.
He played such a key position in reunifying the country.
He started this process.
Second henry gives the motivation,
the impetus for later kings to eventually expel the Hyksos
and start the new kingdom.
And then you get household names
like Thutmose III and Tutankhamen and Bramses II.
Had second henry not done what he did,
you probably wouldn't get the new kingdom,
which is an interesting thought.
Second henry paid the ultimate price
in the struggle to free his kingdom.
But he began the fight that allowed the pharaohs
who succeeded him to rule a unified Egypt
for another thousand years.
This fallen king earned his epitaph.
Second henry, the brave.
