Lets discover if the Romans ever met the dinosaurs through ancient fossil discoveries. Signup for your FREE trial to Wondrium: http://ow.ly/fWm130skwQk
This animated history documentary is a part of our How They Did It series on daily life in the past. In this episode we focus on the topic of ancient fossil discoveries. In theory such events seem plausible given the fact that today, common people will stumble upon such fossils. It stands to reason then that people in the past would also have bumped into dinosaur fossils as nature brought them to the surface or individuals dug down to encounter them.
The episode begins with a discussion of what we even mean by the term fossil. This is actually a quite generic term which can mean almost any preserved trace of past life. We then discuss the various means by which this might occur. The primary one being permineralization which results in the stereotypical stone dinosaur fossils.
Next we explore the numerous pieces of evidence which would support the claims that people from the past did indeed encounter fossils. This comes in both direct and indirect forms. Some amazing examples include fossil finds within Egyptian tombs, the reported discovery of massive giants beneath the earth, and anecdotes about fossil galleries such as the one created by Emperor Augustus. We finally finish with a recap of what can be concluded from this evidence. In the next episode we will explore how dinosaur and other pre-historic fossils may have influenced ancient mythology of things like dragons, giants, and cyclops.
As a big fan of dinosaur documentaries growing up, and of course Jurassic Park, I am amazed that I had never heard of this topic and am so happy to bring it to you today. Hopefully it serves as a more grounded discussion of dinosaurs and humans than the latest Hollywood movie Jurassic World Dominion (which I will totally still go after watching the off-the-rails madness that is the Jurassic World Dominion trailer). Let us know if you think the Romans ever found real dinosaur bones and what sorts of episodes you would like to see next!
Credits Research = Chris Das Neves Writing = Chris Das Neves Narration = Invicta Artwork = Penta Limited Editing = Penta Limited
Sources and Suggested Reading "The First Fossil Hunters" by Adrienne Mayor "Natural History" by Pliny the Elder "The Histories" by Herodotus "Description of Greece" by Pausanius "Book of Marvels" by Phlegon os Tralles "Greek Questions" by Plutarch "Life of Apollonius of Tyana" by Philostratus
Though the process of fossilization is quite rare, over millions of years nature has actually
hidden large numbers of these treasures across the world. Typically it is the paleontologists
who set out to uncover such specimens. Yet at the same time, it's not uncommon for construction
workers, miners, or random people to simply stumble upon them. This raises the question,
did people in the past also encounter fossils? And if they did, what on earth did they think?
So today, let's see if the Romans met the dinosaurs.
In particular, their series, Introduction to Paleontology, hosted by Dr. Stuart Sutherland,
was particularly instructive for our episode today. Its 24 parts cover a huge range of topics,
from the basics of geological scale, to fossil formation, taxonomy, and more.
Episode 16 on dinosaur interpretations is especially revelatory, as it shows how even
modern researchers can have trouble piecing together the clues from our past. My mind was
blown by the sheer amount of work that has gone into bringing us the knowledge we enjoy today.
Right now, Wondrium is offering a free trial, which you can start by clicking the link in the
description below, or visiting wondrium.com. I highly recommend that you take a look at what
they have to offer, and dive into the material that you are most interested in. Enjoy!
I figured it would be helpful to start our discussion on the subject of fossils themselves.
The term fossil is actually quite broad in its definition, encompassing any preserved remains,
impressions, or traces of ancient organisms. Given our level of expertise and technology today,
all of these scraps of evidence prove vital in piecing together the clues from the past.
However, in antiquity, we must imagine that the more subtle fossils were easily overlooked by our
ancestors in favor of the more flashy specimens, which today draw modern audiences to museum
exhibits. Therefore, in this video, we will be primarily focused on the big guns of paleontology,
namely the fossilized bones of large creatures.
So how did these even get created in the first place? Well, the basic idea is that there has
to be some means of preservation which connects the original organism to our time today. Getting
from A to B, though, can take many different paths depending on the material type and the
environment. The most traditional depiction of so-called stone fossil formation is per
mineralization. It involves the animal being buried in sediment shortly after death. This
helps stave off scavengers and decomposition. Under the right conditions, water-borne minerals
can enter the cavities of the organism, eventually crystallizing and taking the place of the original
material. This will typically occur around ancient sources of water, like rivers, lakes,
and ocean beds. However, fossilization can occur through other mediums like ash, tar,
resin, and permafrost, which may be able to preserve more of the organic material.
Yet other paths result in impressions, casts, molds, and remineralization. Some processes
take thousands of years, while others take far less than that. Studies have even shown that the
right material, under the right conditions, can even be fossilized in a matter of weeks.
But this is just the first part in a fossil's journey. If they ever get preserved in the first
place, they must then manage to survive against the elements over the millennium. Here, they might
face destruction from any number of threats like gradual weathering or sudden upheaval.
Thus, only a tiny, tiny fraction of organisms from the past make it into our world today in
any recognizable form. But even with such slim odds, there are bound to be survivors when you
consider the trillions of creatures which have existed over the millions of years of Earth's
history, and the fact that almost all land was at one point underwater. Thus, it should be no
surprise then that we eventually end up stumbling upon many of these fossils today. And on the
geological scale, our today is pretty much the same time as the yesterday of antiquity, and so
we should expect that ancient people were also bumping into fossils of their own. But beyond
conjecture, what sort of evidence do we have of this actually happening? Well, we actually have a
lot of evidence, so much so that I've actually had to cut a lot of it from this script. Admittedly,
much of it comes in the form of written records, but the most concrete evidence we have does
indeed come in a physical form. For instance, the ancient Egyptians appear to have regularly
collected and offered bones to Set, god of the deserts. We know this because researchers have
found deposits and linen-wrapped bones at his various temples. In one region alone, more than
three tons of these have been discovered. Once examined in a lab, these black bones of Set
revealed not just the presence of contemporary animals, but also the petrified remains of
extinct species dating back tens of thousands of years, and in some cases, even millions of years.
Owing to Egypt's dry environment, it was apparently quite common for people to stumble
on all kinds of fossils. This was especially true in areas prone to sandstorms, where for
thousands of years people had ventured out to mine natron for the mummification process.
Here is how the 2nd century Greek writer Phlegon of Trallis puts it,
quote, In Nitri in Egypt, bodies are exhibited that are unencumbered and plain to see. The bones
do not lie mixed together in disorder, but are arranged in such a manner that a person viewing
them recognizes some as thigh bones and others as shin bones, and so on with the other limbs.
The far-traveling Herodotus has more to say on the types of finds across the ancient world.
Though many of his tales are obviously false or exaggerated, such as his claim that India
was home to giant gold-mining ants, some appear to have had a seed of truth. For instance, he
writes that, quote, In Arabia, opposite Bhutto, I went to try and get information about flying
snakes. On my arrival, I saw skeletons and spines in incalculable numbers. They were piled in heaps,
some were big and others smaller. This seems fairly consistent with the reports of other
contemporaries in the region, as well as the findings of more modern researchers in these
sorts of dry environments. In addition, Herodotus also describes other types of fossil remains which
were encountered. For instance, on the hills of Egypt, he discovered the remains of shells and
mollusks, from which he inferred that the land must once have been underwater. In Scythia, he mentions
how the locals told of a rock with imprints three times as large as any man's. Apparently, distant
India was also home to many fossil discoveries. Here's how Philostratus puts it, quote,
The land is girt with dragons of enormous size. Not only are the marshes full of them, but the
mountains as well, and not a single ridge is without one. The dragons of the foothills have
crests, of moderate height when young, but they grow with them and extend to a great height when
they reach full size. The bodies of plains dragons are sometimes found with elephants, a great reward
for hunters. Their tusks resemble those of swine, but more twisted and sharp. They say that in the
mountain dragons are stored stones of flowery colors that flash out all kinds of hues. They
also tell us that a great many dragon skulls are enshrined in the center of the great city of
Paraka, close by the mountain. As we broaden our search, it turns out that ancient authors drop
continuous hints of fossil discoveries in their works. While it will be impossible to relay them
all, I wanted to at least give you a sense of the scope of these anecdotes. A mound broke open in a
storm near a small city in Upper Lydia, and some bones appeared. A figure resembling Pan
was found inside a slab of rock split open in a chaios quarry. When a mountain in Crete was
cleft by an earthquake, a skeleton 46 cubits long was found. Around Munda, there are stones that
contain the likeness of a palm branch, which appears when they are split open. In Iberia,
various stones resemble the trunk of an oak, or look as though they contain millet, grains,
fish bones, ivy leaves, scorpions, and tree roots. The Gedrosi who live by the river Arabis meet the
doorways of their houses out of the monster's jaws and use their bones for roof beams, many of them
40 cubits long. The governor of Gaul wrote to Augustus that a large number of dead Nereids
were seen on the shore. During the rule of Tiberius, in an island off the coast of the
province of Gaul, the ocean revealed more than 300 monsters of marvelous variety and size.
Long after the battle of Plataea, people used to scour the fields for valuables and bones.
They found a seamless skull and a jaw which had a continuous ridge of bone in lieu of teeth,
and a seven and a half foot long skeleton. About four years ago, Himneos of Skopelos,
a friend of mine and his son found a similar wonder on the island of Ikos. While digging up
some vines, the earth rang under the shovel. When they cleared away the dirt, there lay exposed a
When the Carthaginians were surrounding their territory with trenches,
they found in the course of their digging two giant bodies. In the Chimerian Bosphorus,
there was a sudden earthquake that tore open a ridge and discharged huge bones. The skeletal
structure was 24 cubits. The local people then cast the bones into the Miotis Sea.
Such reports seem quite consistent with the discovery of fossils in our own time,
where nature brings them to the surface or when we inadvertently dig down to find them.
However, we should still remain skeptical when it comes to the veracity of these reports,
which are rife with exaggeration. This danger was actually something that people in the past
were wary of as well. Fascinatingly, the author Philostratus remarks on this, saying
But even if you doubt these stories because they happened so long ago,
it's hard to contradict events of our own day. Recently, an excavation on the banks of the
brought to light Ariades, a giant 45 feet tall. And less than 50 years ago,
Segeum, across the Hellespont, disgorged on one of its headlands the body of a giant.
I myself sailed to Segeum to witness exactly what had happened to the land as well as the giant's
size. Many others sailed there too, from the Hellespont, Ionia, and all the islands in Aeolia.
The huge body was visible on the cape for two months.
Naturally, people would often seek to collect such fossils. They seemed to show up quite often
in temples, but there were many others who showed interest in them as well. In this regard, it seems
that the Roman military commanders were quite fond of scooping them up on their expeditions to
foreign lands. Here is how Plutarch describes one such incident, where the general Sertorius
captured Tingis in Mauretania, where the giant Antaeus was supposedly buried.
Skeptical because of the enormous size of the burial mound, Sertorius had his men dig it up.
It is said that the skeleton was 60 cubits long. Sertorius was dumbfounded and, after offering a
sacrifice, he reburied the skeleton. He personally confirmed the local story and paid honors to
Antaeus. Other commanders were certainly less polite. Pliny notes that in the east,
quote, the skeleton of the monster Cerus was transported by Marcus Scarus from the town of
Joppa in Judea and shown at Rome among the rest of the marvels of his Aedal ship. It was 40 feet
long, the height of the ribs exceeding the elephants of India, and the spine was one and a
half inches thick. Roman emperors too were avid collectors and no expense was spared. Augustus,
for instance, is reported to have had his own private gallery. Here is how Suetonius puts it,
quote, at Capri he had collected the huge skeletons of long-dead sea and land monsters,
popularly known as giant's bones, and the weapons of ancient heroes. This habit may have begun
in his career when, following the battle of Actium, the future emperor's victorious troops
had brought back the legendary tusks of the Caledonian boar. Pausanias tells us that upon
examination their circumference was three feet. These relics were apparently dedicated in a
special garden of Dionysius which was themed after the mythical hunt of this beast. Perhaps
in commemoration of this we see silver coins being minted around this time with the boar on the
reverse. Augustus's successor Tiberius carried on this interest in fossils. He apparently expanded
the complex at Capri and likely would have added to the fossil museum himself. The author Phlegon
reports one particularly remarkable detail about this collection. Following a series of earthquakes,
quote, in the cracks of the earth huge skeletons appeared. The local people were reluctant to move
them but as a sample they sent to Rome a tooth from one of the bodies. It was greater than a
foot long. The delegates showed it to Tiberius and asked if he wished the hero to be brought to him.
Tiberius devised a shrewd plan such that, while not depriving himself of a knowledge of the hero's
size, he avoided the sacrilege of robbing of the dead. He thus summoned a certain geometer, Pulcher
by name, and bade him fashion a face in proportion to the size of the tooth. The geometer estimated
how large the entire body as well as the face would be by means of the weight of the tooth.
Hastily made a construction and brought it to the emperor. Tiberius, saying that the
site of the model was sufficient, sent the tooth back to where it had come from.
Given how much we struggle today to make modern reconstructions from ancient fossils,
I shudder on behalf of paleontologists to imagine the monstrosity which the Romans must have
conjured up in the attempt to bring the past to life. This brings up an interesting question.
What did ancient people even think about all these fossils and could such discoveries have
influenced their mythologies? Are mammoth skulls the inspiration for cyclopses? Are triceratops
the source for dragons? We'll be diving into that rabbit hole in our second episode.
For now, I wanted to conclude this video with the following commentary. Based on everything we've
discussed so far, it seems clear that the people of antiquity were quite familiar with the discovery
of fossils both through indirect reporting and direct exposure. Though again, I want to wave
a giant red flag here. I use the term fossil in the broad sense of being just some preserved
evidence of past life. Using a more specific definition would be problematic and it would
be irresponsible for me to claim that any one story is proof that the Romans definitively
dug up things like dinosaur fossils. Consider the following sequence of events.
Some original creature dies, traces of it are fossilized, these bits erode and get scattered
over the millennia, someone finds them, someone reports this, the story gets passed along and
translated over thousands of years, we read about it today, and finally I make a video
and take creative liberties in what art should accompany the script to best excite our audience.
How likely is it then that we are anywhere near guessing what was actually dug up in the first
place? And was it even dug up at all? After all, these reports of findings often read like
fisherman's tales with preposterously large dimensions that exceed anything in the known
record today. In addition, such stories often mention the bones as being found alongside
enormous coffins or gigantic desiccated human bodies which for sure cannot be true. So where
does this leave us? Well, certainly it's possible that some Romans dug up something like a T-Rex skull
but we can't say for sure whether this was or was not the case. If that leaves you a bit
disappointed and you'd like to indulge in a bit of fantasy with me, then check out this awesome
shirt that the art team made which captures the essence of the way I wish history really was.
Also, be sure to head on over to our Patreon to grab some art downloads for the episode.
A huge thanks to the patrons for funding the channel, we couldn't do it without your support.
A big thanks also to the researchers, writers, and artists who put this episode together.
Be sure to like and subscribe for more content, and join us in part 2 as we discuss how fossil
discoveries may have influenced ancient mythology.