1v1 Live Bait Fishing Challenge Shiners Chubs

Recreational Fishing.
1 follower
Today we're testing out two live baits to see which one can catch the biggest fish.
On one side we have smaller golden shiners.
On the other larger live chubs.
We're putting three hours on the clock and whoever catches the biggest fish by the end of it wins.
But there is a twist.
We don't get to choose our baits.
Each one of us is locked into one live bait only.
And that decision is made by a coin toss.
And it doesn't stop there.
That same coin toss also decides our gear setup.
Either cheap budget gear or higher end more reliable gear.
Let's see which bait and setup can get the biggest fish of the day.
Here we are guys.
We just arrived to the spot.
This ice was scaring me.
But after drilling a few holes I think that we should be good.
And before we flip this coin to see what we get.
Let's check out what's on each side of the coin.
On the first side of this coin is the more expensive gear we have here.
First being this ice fishing rod.
And then we have this black and orange rod in here as well.
But the main difference is this automatic tip up that we have.
So if you get a bite the fish is staying on 100%.
And on the other side is this cheaper gear.
Which comes with two lightweight rods and reels.
And a very less reliable rod tip up holder.
If you choose the expensive gear.
You have to use the big live pike suckers.
These are massive and catch big fish.
Which is what we're going for.
But some fish might be intimidated by it and pass by.
And if you choose the cheaper gear.
Then your bait is live golden shiners.
These can get you a lot of bites.
But big fish might pass it up for something else.
Now it's time to hand Aaron the coin for the moment of truth.
So heads I win.
Tails you lose.
Call it in the air.
Tails.
Tails never fails.
Yeah!
Oh my gosh.
Perfect, perfect.
As you guys know tails never fails.
That's a go-to call.
I'm going with the cheaper gear with the live golden shiners.
I don't know.
I have a good feeling about the shiners today.
And Aaron's got the pike suckers.
How do you feel?
Hey, I'm confident.
You know what they say.
Big bait, big fish.
We're gonna drop these baits down.
And the three hour timer starts now.
These bigger red hooks that I'm going to throw on both of them.
For some reason the fish only bite baits with the red hook on it for me.
We're ready with our two red hook rods set up right here.
And I'll have to put this thing together when I drop it down the hole with our live bait on.
Okay guys, first thing I did and I saw Tony trying to steal my swag.
So we got these red little J hooks on right now.
Nothing too crazy.
Just simple fishing that we're doing.
We're just going to be jigging these in the middle of the water column.
And I got a good feeling about these that a big pike is going to come sweep up our pike suckers.
I got my live bait and we're here at our hole.
We're going to grab our first shiner.
Oh, perfect.
This one's pretty lively and shiny.
I'm just going to rig them right through the back.
And I'll drop them lower to midway in this water column.
There he goes.
And with this here, I guess you just set it in the ice.
Then we use the screw that it came with and drill it in.
That way nothing's pulling in our rod.
And to set this flag up, you grab this extra little metal part here.
Put it under the hook that's sticking out.
And then I grab my line.
You set it under that hook.
So once something takes this line and starts pulling it, that flag is going to fly up.
And we're just going to hear the jingle bells ringing to get me in that lead.
So this device right here literally catches the fish for you.
Let's check it out.
I have no idea how this works.
I think I just set it in this.
You get a few compartments going.
And then when I get a fish, it'll set the hook.
This guy was not lively at all.
He's just sitting in the bucket.
So I'm just going to stick bait this dude.
I'm just going to drop this sucker down.
That boy is not swimming at all.
So now that we have our automatic rod set up, we're going to grab our other little flimsy
rod and throw another shiner on here and drop it down in our other hole.
Now we're just going to sit back and relax, jig a little bit here, and then wait for a
bite on our sitting automatic rod.
We got the jawjacker all set up.
And that chub was already not very lively.
And this is where I really think I have the best chance to catch a fish.
I don't even know what this dude is.
Looks like a creek chub or something.
And he is huge.
Come check this out in the water.
This guy's literally golden.
And that's going to attract a big fish.
But he just needs to swim down.
Go down there, bud.
But I'm just going to let him swim around.
And hopefully he meets a nice mean pike that's not too friendly.
Yo, I got a fish.
Oh my gosh.
Something's pulling my rod in the water.
Oh, it's all tangled up.
I think it came off.
Yep, whatever it was came off.
That was literally crazy.
The flag flew up and something pulled my rod in the water.
So I just dropped it back down.
See if it will come back.
It was pulling drag, pulling my rod.
But when I came, it was off.
I don't know what happened.
Yeah, let's check out our bait though.
He looks a little beat up, but let's go check our other rod too.
He's been sitting here for a while.
What the?
He was at the surface.
Yo, I have something, I think.
Oh yeah, I'm on.
Oh my gosh, right when I dropped it back down.
Oh my gosh, it came off.
It came off.
Bro, that was on me, bro.
Man, you know what I did?
I just, I slowly pulled my bait all the way up.
And then when I dropped it back down, I put my rod away and I had a bite.
I had my phone in my hand and it was right here in my waders.
Do I have a bite?
I have a bite.
Let him eat, let him eat, let him eat.
He might be on, but I don't want to set the hook.
If I lose another fish, then I'm done, bro.
All right, I think it's on.
Yep, it's on.
All right, there we go.
It came off again.
Bro, what is eating this?
It was in his mouth for like three minutes.
Yo, this happened to me last time too, bro.
It's insane.
That's actually a fish though.
Oh, that was a big hit.
I'm just waiting for it to swallow it now so I can set the hook on him.
It's got off two times already.
It's on, I feel it on.
We're just gonna wait for this thing to bite it and for the hook to get stuck in his mouth
somewhere.
I think I might set it.
Finally, finally.
I'm just bringing him in.
I'm just keeping the tension and bringing him in.
Oh my gosh, that's a nice one.
What is it?
Oh, oh my gosh.
Oh dude, this is a nice one.
Please don't snap off this.
Nice one, please.
I got the cheap gear.
Now we're just going to try to land this fish.
I'm got to keep this tension on it.
Aaron, it snapped off.
It snapped off.
Oh my gosh, oh my gosh.
I tighten my drag just a little bit and on a pull, it snapped me off.
After all that time of waiting, all those bites, it just snapped off in a second.
I went over and I grabbed some new bait and my hook and I see Aaron just drilled a bunch
of holes right next to where I had them.
He's trying to get those fish.
I get it though.
I missed too many times.
I started blaming Aaron at the end too, but I know that was my fault.
I was just saying stuff to give an excuse of missing that fish.
I got my new red hook tied up.
There he is.
Only got one more bait left.
I'm just going to do the same technique, drop them down.
Set it right there in the chair again.
Let's go check our other rod too.
We're just resetting this one.
All right, something was running with this like crazy.
We're about to check it.
Oh, oh, we got a big fish on here.
We're keeping the drag loose.
When he gets up here, he's going to go crazy.
Tony, I'm going to need you to get him no matter what.
All right?
I got you, bro.
This drag, if you turn it one notch, it's literally locked
or you turn it a little the other way and then it's super loose.
This is the longest reel in ever because I'm so scared.
Oh, oh, oh my gosh.
He's pulling.
Tony, lip him for all I care.
Seriously, put some gloves on if you have to lip him.
My gloves are in the car.
He wrapped around the line.
He might break off now.
Oh, here he is, here he is, here he is.
He's wrapped around.
You got to grab it with your hand.
Right there.
I'm going to pull him up and you grab him.
Grab him.
Yes, bro.
Okay, guys, we got this nice little ice skater.
I made sure to fight him super carefully because I did not want to lose him.
And we're on like four pound line.
But this guy ate the biggest, biggest chub that we had.
And he's not even that big.
There's a lot bigger fish in here.
All right, here we go.
There he goes.
Are you confident with that fish?
It was kind of a small pike, but it wasn't a pure dink.
Tony's got two more baits left and I got one.
So I am hoping on this next one that it's the biggest fish of the day.
But that little pike ate my giant chub.
So anything can happen.
It's comeback time.
All right, my automatic rod setter that failed me earlier.
I'm going to move it now because I have a rod over there.
Let's bring him up.
I'm going to walk him down all the way over here to drop him down.
And I know that this rod holder is not going to fail me again.
I think this is where our biggest fish comes from today.
And just set this up one last time and we are good to go.
Everything is set for both of us.
And now it's just a waiting game to see who gets the next fish.
Yo, oh my gosh, my flag just went up.
Oh, something's on it.
Something's on it for sure.
Oh, oh, it came off.
I think it came off for sure.
It snapped me.
It got all tangled up right there and it snapped off.
That is insane, man.
And that had one of my last shiners on it.
So I have one more rod left and Aaron has one more rod left.
Taking my last bait over to the same area where I just lost it.
I'm going to make sure I drill this one in all the way this time.
This is my worst fishing day in a while.
What? Aaron's saying he has a fish.
Oh my gosh.
Bro, what happened right there?
Aaron might have a fish and he's fixing his reel right now.
I don't even know how that happened.
Anything?
No.
Oh yeah, I for sure have a fish.
Yep, I got something.
We're on.
Fish on.
Man, every time I miss a fish, Aaron gets one.
Fish is on.
I do not want to lose this one.
I'm going the loose drag method again on the super light line.
Dude, Tony just lost a fish.
Oh, oh, it's a nice one.
Oh yeah, he's nice.
He looks nice at least.
Please.
Oh, the bait's right there.
Oh my, he got off.
All right, I'm dropping this back down.
My bait's still alive.
He doesn't want to go back down.
Another missed one.
I'm going to hurry up and set my rod up fully so we can get this last fish.
Back to where I was.
I'm setting it in the rod holder just like that,
but I'm not attaching the line to this last hook because I don't want it to get tangled
all up in here again and snap off.
Something's on here now.
We'll just see the rod bend and start pulling.
I'm going to get him one time.
Oh, my rods, my rods fell.
Decoration.
Oh my gosh, if I lose this, if I lose this fish because this thing came undone again.
Let him eat it.
Oh, he's pulling.
Almost pulled my rod in the water.
Let him eat it, bro.
I'll let him eat it.
I think he's got it.
Oh my gosh, bro.
All right, he's got it for sure.
Let's, let's.
Here, take this.
Dude, that might be a giant.
My heart is racing.
I cannot lose another fish.
Slow and steady wins the race.
Almost pulled my rod in the, in the water.
Literally, if I didn't come over a second later.
Oh my gosh, he's pulling drag.
I'm just taking it slow and steady.
Oh, oh, he's pulling.
Look how flimsy this rod is.
Every time I just reel in, it drops 100 feet.
So what do you want me to do when you get him up here?
Just try to land him.
Don't get mad if he gets off, bro.
Trust me, I won't.
Oh, where is this thing?
Oh, oh, I just saw it.
How's it looking?
It's a chunker.
Oh my gosh.
But he's pulling drag.
Right here.
Oh, oh, he's thrashing.
Oh my gosh.
See, this is the point where I tightened it last time
when we just couldn't get his head in the hole.
And that, that was a, that was a mistake.
Oh, he's big.
Aaron, that's big.
Oh my gosh.
That's a big fish.
Yeah.
One hard head turned and recooked.
Oh no, he's.
Get his head up.
Grab him.
Aaron.
Oh my gosh.
I dang near hooked my hand.
Look at this pike.
Somehow we landed that fish.
We almost lost him when Aaron tried to grab him.
I saw him push the pike down when he was coming up.
But this is a beautiful, healthy pike.
It's still not a monster.
I still think that first one I had was a lot bigger.
But this is going to get the job done
and put me in the lead for that challenge.
Aaron still has his bait,
but we're going to end it off on this as the timer has ended.
Let's get this guy back quick.
Let's go.
I redeemed myself just a little bit and Aaron took the L.
