WTF Just Happened to Silver

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Silver is getting crushed today.
At one point, silver prices were down 37%, they're still down to roughly 30%.
But all it does is goes to show not just the volatility, but it exposes the underlying
process that are taking place here, processes that I've talked about with none other than
Mike Green for an expert opinion, an expert position on flows, reality, all of the fundamentals
that are missing and now being priced into, or priced back into, precious metals like
silver.
So, Mr. Mike Green, thank you very much for joining us here at Eurodollar University.
Really appreciate your time.
We got to start with precious metals, right?
That's the topic of conversation.
Everybody's convinced that gold and, I mean, silver's rise is just absolutely insane at
this point.
But the idea that gold is going up because it's the other side of the dollar.
So the dollar has to be on its way out.
Everybody around the world is moving to some other currency or some other arrangement.
Therefore, we have to look at and focus on the gold signal as somehow it can only be
one thing, right?
Well, I mean, I guess my problem is that the price of gold is crashing in silver terms.
And since silver is really money, right?
We should be all worried about gold because it's crashing in silver terms.
No, this is very straightforward.
I mean, it's the same underlying philosophy that I have around most of my work around
passive that ultimately it's the flows that matter.
Gold is a relatively small asset class.
You know, Bitcoiners highlighted it for years that gold's asset value as a market cap was
a target for where Bitcoin would eventually end up.
But the simple reality is that when you're talking about a 5 trillion, now 10 trillion
dollar asset and you try to take sums out of 70 trillion or 200 trillion when you think
about global equities or you reallocate resources from purchasing, you know, the Chinese trade
surplus is increasingly being routed away from treasuries and into things like gold
for understandable reasons.
And there is some legitimacy to those components.
But the simple reality is this is an element of trying to fit a camel through the eye of
a needle.
Right.
It's a small market.
The people who hold it, hold it passionately.
And as a result, you need to entice them to sell it to you at higher prices.
This is it.
It's not a signal of anything except for speculative activity in gold.
Yes.
It's it's from it's a matter of interpretation, right?
I think that's the biggest problem is OK.
Gold is doing something and everybody's trying to figure out what it means and what it signals,
what it signifies.
And so the idea is if gold price is soaring, it has to be something huge.
But I think what you just said is one of the key points that I try to make to people.
Look, if gold really was what people want it to be, which is the dollar's doom, then
why don't we see it in other marketplaces?
For example, the U.S. Treasury curse.
You better believe if the dollar was on its way out, especially if it was some kind of
inflationary debasement process that's taking place, whether through government or through
private processes, we would see it in other marketplaces.
But as you said, gold is a relatively small part of the overall financial architecture.
So you've got to ask yourself the question, is gold picking up something that nothing
else is? If gold is saying the dollar is going to be replaced or even just inflation,
inflation is about to break out in a way that we haven't seen since the 1970s, shouldn't
we see that in other places as well, not just in the gold market specifically?
I would expect us to see that.
And unfortunately, I think you've articulated one of the many reasons why people persist
in this, right? I have to buy gold because the dollar is collapsing, that your expectation
is that will preserve wealth in an environment in which inflation is incipient and it's
running out of control, et cetera.
It's you know, it's the same narrative that exists around Bitcoin hodling.
I actually wrote a piece earlier in 2025 talking about this specific phenomenon that
effectively how much of the firepower of gold had been robbed by the new digital gold
and Bitcoin. When I did the analysis that suggested that, you know, if the flows that
had gone into Bitcoin went into gold, it would suggest a price of gold somewhere in the
$10,000 range.
I didn't think that you would ultimately get that because I don't think 100 percent of
the flows are going to move in that direction.
But, you know, the $5,000 level was actually one that I posted and said, you know, this
is a likely outcome given the fact that people are now suddenly reevaluating gold is as
distinct and an alternative to Bitcoin.
And that has largely played out.
We are also seeing, you know, the components of this that are in fact real and I think
are really important for people to appreciate is that the deteriorating relationships with
China in particular in the aftermath of the U.S.
confiscating Russian reserves or freezing their access to them made it very clear to
the Chinese that if they're going to run a trillion dollar trade surplus and they want
to ultimately access that in any form, they can't simply store it in treasuries as they
might have done historically.
They began to reallocate that caused gold prices to start to rise, even though U.S.
retail investors, as we can see through things like these shares outstanding in GLD, the
ETF, were actually selling gold.
And once those two actually aligned, people saw gold prices start to rise.
They, you know, adopted the dollar debasement narrative and the, you know, the Trump
administration is for a weak dollar, etc.
That ultimately added additional firepower to the trade.
And now what we are actually seeing is increasingly these trades are being expressed in
options. We're seeing particularly in silver extraordinarily elevated levels of
volatility on the implied option surface.
Many platforms that retail participants trade on, things like Robin Hood, etc., actually
don't disclose those metrics.
They simply tell you the price of the option, which is significantly cheaper than the
underlying for very obvious reasons.
It is a derivative as a limited payoff on certain events.
And they're speculating, you know, this is giving a low price tool for people to
speculate with. And we are seeing that evidence in the elevated levels of options.
So this is this is a meme stock at this point.
It really is not actually telling us anything about the underlying fundamentals, except
for the important observation that the trade relationships with China and the United
States have deteriorated.
And the U.S. government's use of weaponizing the dollar and treasuries has backfired to
a certain extent. But don't I think there's, you know, a couple of things there.
Yeah. The retail, especially when it gets to silver, I mean, silver is gone.
It's not even parabolic anymore.
It's just basically straight up.
And I don't know anyone who believes or should believe that any market that goes
straight up is a good thing.
I mean, yeah, it's fun on the way up, but this is not going to end well in any number
of historical exam. I mean, the last time we saw silver do something like this was
1980. I mean, you're at the height of the Great Inflation.
It goes straight up and it goes straight back down.
And it was the same underlying phenomenon.
Exactly.
Brothers trying to corner the silver market and effectively driving price and absorbing
supply. These markets, the underlying supply, you know, again, you've heard many of
these narratives used by Bitcoiners over the years.
The supply of gold is inelastic.
It rises roughly 2 percent a year.
Now, that means that the majority of gold we have was created in the last 50 years.
But the other flip to that is it means that if the prices rise, you have to entice
existing holders to sell.
And the way you entice existing holders to sell is you offer them more money.
Yeah, the prices go parabolic.
So I think there's another interesting question here that we just kind of touched on
briefly is, OK, if we have a dollar debasement taking place and you expect, OK, gold
goes up, silver goes up.
Sure. Let's stipulate that.
But why haven't we seen Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies respond in the same way?
And so I think the question I think a lot of people should ask themselves is why does
there seem to be a rotation?
As you said, the flows into Bitcoin were robbed from going into gold.
Now they seem to have reversed.
And I think a bigger, more interesting question is why that might it might be the
case. Why isn't why aren't flows going into Bitcoin in the way they used to and
instead being rechanneled into gold?
What is the what do you think is the thinking that goes into that decision making?
Well, I think ultimately, I mean, I have shared these charts publicly on this.
You know, the ETF introduction under Bitcoin contributed to a significant quantity of
the rise. Again, it was more money flows into an asset of limited supply that requires
you to buy it from existing holders, which requires you to incentivize them by paying
higher prices. The move that we have seen at various points in time have been tied to
things like BlackRock adopting Bitcoin as as a portion of a model portfolio, suggesting
that people have an allocation to it that mechanically drives flows into it.
We saw last year in 2025, the only growth in Bitcoin was really tied to the the flows
that occurred at BlackRock through their Bitcoin ETF and into the model portfolios until
you can create a catalyst for people to say, well, I need more Bitcoin.
And it certainly is in a use case at this point.
The speculative component to it is there.
And we are actually remarkably close to basically cost basis for most investors in
Bitcoin. Now, through these ETFs, the aggregate cost basis is somewhere in the
neighborhood of $80,000.
We're in that $80,000 to $90,000 range.
It's been a disappointing experience for a lot of people.
And so I don't think it's that hard to get to, you know, to convince them to abandon
it and move to the next shiny metal.
It really is what it feels like.
I think, unfortunately, it also ties in with an environment in which most U.S.
households, for reasons that I've discussed and other things, are increasingly
frustrated and believe the system is not in their interest.
That makes it very easy to fall prey to, you know, marketing pitches that say something
along the lines of the dollar is collapsing.
You're going to lose everything.
This is Weimar Republic all over again.
And there's no possible way to know if that is actually true or not.
From most positions, you and I are skeptical of it.
I like to use the Adam Smith line.
There's a lot of ruin in a nation before things really fall apart.
But that's the simple reality is, you know, people are afraid.
They are worried about their position.
They are worried about their children's status.
And as a result, it becomes very easy to say, well, it's all going to hell in a hand
basket. I should get out first.
Yeah, I think there's a discussion that a lot of people should be having, not just in
between people like you and me, but there is definitely this this idea, widespread idea.
And it's not wrong that something isn't right about the system.
And so things like Bitcoin and gold become, as you said, just momentum plays at this
point. If there was something to the dollar, you know, go back to the statement I said
before. If there was something to the dollar's collapse, it wouldn't just be in gold or
one asset class at a time.
It would be widespread.
The conversation I'm having right now is the one that I'm trying to bring to you at
Uridalu University Live next month, February 2026, President's Day weekend, small
group, small setting, individual, intimate conversations with experts, their wealth of
knowledge and opinions, their perspectives and accessing them in a way you will not be
able to get anywhere else.
And let's face it, given everything that we're seeing all across the economy, the
markets, AI bubbles, credit cycles, you name it.
Now's the time to be able to do this.
And that's what we aim to give you at Uridalu University.
If you are a serious investor, we've got just a couple of VIP slots available.
There's a link in the description to sign up for those.
And if you're just somebody who's interested, you want to show up on Monday, we've got
all day seminars with our speakers in a small room, small setting, same idea.
Access these people up close and personal.
Get to them, get their expertise, their wealth of knowledge.
So that's February 2026, President's Day weekend, Uridalu University Live, link in the
description with all the details.
You are not going to want to miss this because it's going to be fun.
It's going to be educational and it is going to be, as I keep saying, and I hope you can
tell, it's going to be important.
