Cardiologist and metabolic expert, Dr. Bret Scher (@metabolicmind) and PragerU CEO @realtalkwithmarissa unpack why decades of government nutrition advice have failed. Dr. Scher explains how flawed dietary guidelines contributed to America’s mental and physical health crisis. He explains that food and lifestyle should be the foundation of real preventive medicine. Together, they explore whether the keto diet can lead to weight loss, mental health and even a possible solution for children struggling with depression.
0:00 Medical “Chaos” & Why Questioning Matters 1:11 From Cardiologist to Metabolic Health Advocate 4:41 The Nutrition Advice That Keeps Failing Patients 8:07 Meat, Saturated Fat, and the Problem With Weak Evidence 14:02 Why One-Size-Fits-All Medicine Doesn’t Work 17:08 Taking Control: Labs, Biomarkers & CGMs 19:42 Keto Explained: Not a Trend, a Metabolic Switch 25:01 Keto + Mental Health: Depression, Bipolar, Autism Questions 36:13 School Lunches & Guidelines: Why the System Serves Carbs 43:31 Meds vs Lifestyle: Aspirin, Statins, GLP-1s, Supplements & First Steps
A lot of the pharmaceutical companies, a lot of the food industry, like why is any organization
that is creating medical guidelines taking funding from drug companies and from food
organizations?
What is the wrong advice that you think physicians have been giving on metabolic health?
Healthy whole grains, high carbs, low fat, that is what is being promoted, which is exactly
the opposite of what we need.
There's so many questions about how to cure kids with autism.
We've seen in studies and in real world practice that people can completely change the way
their brains are functioning when they're running on ketones.
Today, everything seems to be politicized, including medicine.
It should not be a political issue, though.
So anything that defines it as blue or red issue, that's where it could potentially hurt.
This is about people, not politics.
Dr. Redshair, it's good to have you here.
Thank you, Marissa.
It's my pleasure.
So as you walked in, I said that it's very, a very interesting timing for you to come
in because we're in the middle of medical questions and chaos.
And we don't know if the trustee experts, we don't know who to rely on.
And your answer is, well, there's always medical questioning and chaos.
So maybe that's a good thing.
Maybe it is.
Right.
I mean, I think asking questions is healthy.
The problem is sometimes when I guess when people want the status quo to continue and
then you ask questions, it gets really uncomfortable.
But I mean, when did asking questions become a bad thing?
I think we should promote more of that.
Yeah.
You know, I think that the status quo in general is easier, right?
It's easier to just keep doing what we've been told.
It's easier to not have to wreck our brain over how to become healthier.
It's certainly an easier thing to do.
And I think humans generally want what is easier, not necessarily what they have to
work hard for.
Yeah.
But then there's the old question.
How's that working for you?
I think we can say in the experiment that we've seen in our population over the past
40 years, it's not working so well from a health standpoint.
Yeah.
Sadly, it's not working.
I'd like to just let's get a little bit into your background.
You started as a cardiologist, right?
What drew you into that field?
Oh, gosh.
Going back to my medical school days and my residency days.
But cardiology for me was just always such a magical field because you really sort of
span all aspects of medicine, right?
Like there's the sort of the emergency room type feeling of there's a heart attack happening,
all hands on deck, do whatever you can.
There's a little bit of the surgery aspect that you're using your hands and you're doing
really kind of interesting things to help people.
And then there's kind of the primary care aspect where you're helping people with their
blood pressure and their cholesterol and their long-term risk.
And you're seeing them over time.
So it sort of spanned all those aspects of medicine, which I thought was so interesting,
where you could really help people and have an impact on people's lives.
And, you know, as we get into real life of medicine, so to speak, you realize that your
perception may or may not be correct and frequently not, but that was certainly what got me excited
in the beginning.
And I was all about it.
I loved it.
So you went from being the Dr. Heart guy to the Dr. Heart and Gut guy.
Is that a fair statement?
How did you go there?
Well, I guess I went from being the traditional cardiologist to being the metabolic cardiologist,
is how I would phrase it.
And really this transition towards metabolic health.
Because I think it was a discussion we just weren't having enough of.
And part of the reason why is because it's harder to help someone improve their metabolic
health through lifestyle than it is to give them a pill for their cholesterol.
No question about it, right?
A pill for your cholesterol is a lot easier.
So that's where a lot of the research was focused.
You know, I love those cartoons.
I feel like I quote this cartoon all the time of the person looking for their keys under
the lamppost.
And they say, oh, is this where you lost your keys?
And they say, no, I lost them down the street, but this is where the light is.
So I'm looking here.
And we tend to do that in medicine a lot.
We tend to look where the light is.
And so the light quickly came to cholesterol, medications.
And so that's where the focus was.
And it's not that it was wrong or completely off base or had nothing to do with health,
but I think it came at the expense of maybe some of the more important factors, including
metabolic health.
So that was part of what led me to focus more on cardiometabolic health.
And that led me to low-carb nutrition and ketogenic interventions.
You know, I was very lucky when I started this Wellness Center with a friend of mine.
I knew nothing about low-carbon keto because I was not taught anything about it.
And it was through him that I started to learn about it.
And then I started to look and realized there was research on it.
And why haven't I heard about this?
And I guess that's why I felt like I had to shout it from the rooftops because nobody
was talking about it.
And it was something that could really, really help people who are struggling with their
weight, with their type 2 diabetes, with their blood sugar, with their metabolic health.
And that only improves people's lives.
And not that everybody needs to go that route, but gosh, so many people could benefit from
it.
So that was a very long answer to your question of how I started as a cardiologist.
And I still practice cardiology, but I focus on preventive cardiology and really focusing
on metabolic cardiology.
When this doctor, friend of yours, started talking to you about food and metabolic health,
what was your first reaction?
Because oftentimes when I talk to doctors about nutrition, they'll say, yeah, that's
great and everything, but here's a pill that's most likely going to work better.
Was your reaction similar to most doctors?
Well, my reaction was I really wanted nutrition to work and have an impact.
But unfortunately, we sort of learn by experience that what we're teaching people and how we're
talking to people about nutrition doesn't work.
You know, like how many times do you sit down and have a well-meaning conversation with
a patient and say, you need to eat less and exercise more and really focus on your healthy
whole grains and your high carbohydrates and lower your fat.
And they come back six months later and nothing's changed.
So you're right in your chart, you know, lifestyle interventions did not work.
And then what's next is a pill.
Happened all the time.
You know, there's an old saying, if you're a teacher and when one of your students is
failing, OK, maybe it's on them.
But if you're a teacher and half your class is failing, it's on you as the teacher.
So as a medical profession, if people aren't following the medical advice, if people aren't
doing what we're telling them to do from a nutrition standpoint, and not just one, not
just two, but the majority of the population, maybe it's on us.
Maybe it's the wrong advice.
And I think that's the that's sort of the insight that the medical profession has just
lacked. You know, it really has been a doubling down of the same nutrition advice, only
stronger, only even less fat, even more healthy, high carbs.
And that's a point where we have to say, no, it's clearly that's just the wrong advice
for the majority of the population.
And we need to we need to be more introspective about that and change it.
What is the wrong advice that you think physicians have been giving on metabolic health?
Is it that we should be eating more oatmeal for heart healthy?
Yeah, that's part of it.
So the first the first wrong advice is that we don't even really know how we're defining
metabolic health, which is part of the problem, because I think so what is metabolism?
Right. What is metabolic health?
It's how our body takes in nutrients and transforms it into energy.
Right. Very simple, but it's not so simple because we're taking in nutrients and we want
to use those nutrients, being the carbs, the fats, the proteins.
We want to use those for energy.
We don't want to end up storing them.
All right. And then and part of the problem is when you give advice that doesn't work
or people don't enjoy.
Right. We're talking about food.
We're not talking about something like reading a book.
I don't know. Or some we're talking about food.
There's emotion involved.
We are very emotional people.
We get hungry.
We have cravings.
We eat emotionally.
There is culture around.
There's culture around food.
Absolutely.
So to think that we can be I actually call it arrogant, that we can be arrogant enough
that we know the one way everybody's supposed to eat.
It just it boggles my mind.
And I think we clearly have the experiment that it has not worked.
So reducing saturated fat, reducing animal products, healthy whole grains.
They give this air of good and bad for food and ignores what the food does to how it makes
people feel.
How hungry are you?
What does it do for actually giving you nutrients?
And, you know, animal products are some of the most nutrient dense foods there are.
So to have a policy that really wants to restrict those is restricting one of the most
nutrient dense foods that has the highest amount of bioavailable protein and really
fills you up and people enjoy.
And these are concepts that that we can't ignore.
And I think that's what our sort of our health crisis is telling us, you know, that
we can't ignore those.
Well, you're a heart doctor, a cardiologist.
It is usually the heart doctors that would tell us to not eat meat and not eat eggs and
not drink milk because of cholesterol.
So how what is your reaction to that?
Yeah, my reaction is we focus on very low quality evidence to make very confident
recommendations, right?
So a lot of the evidence we have in nutrition come from these large population studies
where all you do is observe what's happening and there's no actual intervention.
So a lot of people say, well, yeah, that's the same study that we found for smoking and
cancer.
Well, yeah, for the connection between smoking and cancer, there is what's called a
hazard ratio of like 15 to 20.
And that's you can say how strong is the effect of the one thing on the other, right?
On tobacco and on cancer.
Well, when it comes to things like red meat, saturated fat and heart disease or cancer,
it's like one point three, one point four, not 15 to 20 like it was with smoking, but
one point three, one point four.
So the quality, the level and there's so many other problems with those studies.
But the level of the evidence is so low for us to then say, well, this is clear.
We have to eat in this way.
It it really elevates the evidence to try and make it represent something that it's
not meant to.
And it ignores the fact that we don't eat just saturated fat.
We don't eat just meat.
We eat a diet.
Right.
So are you eating your burger with the bun and the ketchup and the fries and the Coke?
Right.
The classic.
Or are you eating a rib eye steak with some broccoli and cauliflower and avocado?
Your body is going to handle those meals completely differently, but certainly the
studies don't differentiate between those and our recommendations don't differentiate
between those.
So I think we need to get away from talking about specific foods or even specific
nutrients and instead talk about what is the diet that you're eating?
What are the combination of foods that you're eating and how does that impact your
metabolic health as we define it by your fasting insulin level, your HDL and triglycerides
blood levels, your visceral fat, your body composition, and not just whether or not
you have type two diabetes, which for decades was sort of how we define the
metabolic health.
So it really is sort of a reframing of things.
Um, yeah, but I think the main thing is realizing that we, the way we eat is more
complicated than we want to make it.
Saturated fats, bad red meats, bad grains are good.
Not really.
If you already have type two diabetes or metabolic dysfunction, which unfortunately
is a growing percentage of our population.
You know, there's some estimates that 93% of our population have some element of
metabolic dysfunction.
93%.
I mean, it's fascinating.
It's, it's kind of mind boggling.
And over 70%, um, meet criteria for, for overweight or obesity.
I mean, the numbers are just staggering.
So it's clear what we're doing is not working, but it's also clear that we can't
make one recommendation for everybody because that population that is metabolic has
metabolic dysfunction is going to tolerate the so-called healthy whole grains and the
healthy carbohydrates much different than somebody who is metabolically healthy and
active and has a completely different metabolism.
We can't pretend that there's one diet for both people.
Why do you think there's such a chasm between mainstream medicine and I guess you
would call it holistic medicine, holistic with a WH.
The WH.
Yeah.
Well, one, it's a very charged word, right?
A lot of people want to interpret that differently.
You know, some people want to interpret that word as it's amazing.
You're looking at the whole person and you're trying to take an approach that is
more broad.
And other people always say like, Oh, you're just trying to do what, what modern
medicine isn't doing.
And there's a bunch of quote unquote quacks, right?
You can, you can interpret that one word so differently.
It's a very polarizing word, but at its core, if you're talking about looking at the
whole person and you're talking about taking a broad approach and not focusing just on
one aspect, it makes total sense that that's the way we should be practicing.
I mean, people are, are people.
We're not a lab value.
We're not a diagnosis, right?
We're people.
And how, how one thing we do impact something else completely, right?
I mean, we've learned it's a very charged topic, but, but statins for treating
cholesterol.
I'm a cardiologist.
I am a believer of using statins to treat cholesterol in the right patient for people
with heart disease, for people at very high risk of heart disease, it has a role, but
we also are learning that that can increase somebody's risk of type two diabetes and
metabolic dysfunction, right?
So it's not just treating the LDL.
We want to treat the LDL, but we really want to treat the cardiac risk.
So if one treatment is worsening another aspect of cardiac risk, we have to consider
that to me, that's what holistic means, right?
So, but the word is so charged.
I almost never use that word because I know people might misinterpret it.
Do you think that gap is becoming smaller?
The gap between holistic practitioners and traditional doctors?
Yeah, I think it's becoming smaller because more people are talking about it right now
on social media and you know, this concept of root cause medicine and concept of
functional medicine.
We're hearing so much more about it that I think the gap is starting to close and
we're starting to see some research and we're seeing, you know, just endless
amounts of, of, um, patient success stories.
Um, but nothing's perfect, right?
You know, it's still not clearly defined what it is or how you practice it, right?
So it's, uh, so there are still some questions, but I think what you're saying
is the gap, I think absolutely is closing because we're just hearing about it so
much more and patients are demanding it.
You know, I don't want a bandaid for my problem.
I want to know what's causing the problem so I can get rid of it.
Do you think it's doable to expect doctors and physicians, especially with a
over 300 million individuals to be able to create a medical formula for each
patient?
I mean, it, it sounds honestly somewhat confusing, right?
Because sometimes some patients should eat keto.
Some patients should not eat keto.
Some patients should take statins.
Some patients shouldn't take statins.
I think one of the reasons why conventional medicine as we know it has
worked is because the physicians could go through medical school.
They could be given a formula for how to treat a patient.
They can be given a chart and they can be given a computer where they could look
things up and basically align a certain symptom with a certain medication and,
and, and basically merge them.
And it's why from, from operational perspective, it must've been a lot easier
to manage, especially when you're talking about millions and millions of, of
patients in the case of functional medicine or holistic medicine, when you
have to create a special roadmap for every single individual that you're
treating, it becomes very complicated and also becomes complicated for the patient
to advocate for themselves because we don't know what to ask for.
I don't know how to go to you as a cardiologist and say, well, here's what
I'd like you to help me with because the roads are becoming very confusing.
Yeah.
I mean, you bring up a great point and a lot of it comes down to how is our, our
medical practice structured and gosh, I feel for the doctors who are in the
system, right?
And they have 15 minutes with a patient if they're lucky, and then they have
tons of charting to do after that.
And you're exactly right.
You know, how are you going to have that individual conversation and come up
with that individual plan and that type of structure, whereas people who practice
outside the system, which fortunately now my practice is outside the system, I can
spend an hour with my patient, right?
I can give them that individual, that individual advice, and I'm not running
from patient to patient like that.
And so it is hard when you're in that system, no question.
And it's much easier to say, here are the guidelines.
Here's how you're supposed to practice.
A, B, and C is what the patient has guidelines say, treat it A, B, and C.
But let me ask you, do you want to be treated that way?
I mean, do you want to be treated like a number and, and, and just a guideline?
I would guess not.
I certainly don't.
Um, so it's a, it's a, gosh, it's a perplexing question.
How do we transform medicine from where we are to get more individualized?
And, you know, a lot of the answers has to be, it doesn't
all fall on the physicians, right?
They need logistical support.
They need, whether it's coaches or dietitians or, you know, PAs, nurse
practitioners to help with more of sort of the one-on-one individual structure
of a plan, and then the physicians oversee it, right?
You could see how there are different.
You could put different things in place to try and move that direction.
But it seems like a long way between here and there, but that's why I'm thankful.
I can practice the way I practice.
And so many, so many physicians are able to break out of that
system to really help people.
So many patients that I'm aware of are starting to look at their own blood results.
I mean, there are all kinds of programs that you can download an app and take a
look at your, at the results and possibly make decisions where you're not going to
prescribe yourself things, but you can prescribe yourself food,
which food is medicine too, right?
And so you're seeing more of that where people are saying, well, it looks like
based on my blood type, or it looks like based on my markers that are coming in
through my blood results, I should possibly change my diet and eat different things.
What are your thoughts on, on the individual trying to take
that kind of responsibility on?
You know what, Marissa?
I love it.
I think it's fantastic.
You're okay with us working you out of business?
That's not a bad thing.
If, as long as we're, you're focusing on the right parameters of metabolic
health, which is what I'm so passionate about is metabolic health, which I
think medicine in general kind of avoid.
And, and that gets back to this sort of dietary recommendation
that we started talking about.
Do I care that you eat a specific diet?
Or do I care that you're getting the health results that you
want and that I want for you?
That's what I care about.
So the diet that you use to get there may not be the diet that everybody
thinks is the quote unquote right diet, but it's your right and your ability
to experiment, to see what gets you there and measure the outcomes.
I love that people can order their own blood tests now and don't
have to get it from a doctor.
I love that they can interpret their own blood tests.
Now, of course it can set things up for depending on who's influencing
you and depending on kind of what kind of advice you're getting.
There's certainly some risk there, but I think it really empowering people
to take charge of their health and realize that they can change their
nutrition, they can change their lifestyle and they can see the outcome
of their, of their actions is just so amazing.
I mean, take continuous glucose monitors, a CGM, a little monitor you
just put on your, you know, on your belly or on your tricep, which gives
you a continuous reading of what your blood sugar is doing, such amazing
information, you eat the healthy oatmeal and see your blood sugar spike, or
you eat the healthy oatmeal and see your blood sugar barely move, you're
going to know how you respond to that healthy quote unquote oatmeal, right?
Same thing for a steak and vegetables, same thing for, you know,
your fruit smoothie or whatever.
A lot of things that have this sort of healthy halo are not so healthy, but
until we can take charge and advocate for ourselves and have the technology
and the, the test to be able to measure it, then we're not going to know.
So I'm a huge fan of people sort of taking, taking that step.
What do you think about the keto diet?
What do I think about the keto diet?
I've been, I've been promoting in the keto diet for, for decades now,
not necessarily for everybody though.
And the reason why I promote it so much is because I feel like modern
medicine, contemporary medicine shuns it and, and they shouldn't.
And ketosis is a powerful medical treatment.
I mean, it is, it is the one diet that actually completely changes your metabolism.
So in our modern world, we're burning glucose for energy, primarily
almost always burning glucose.
Well, our body can also burn fat for fuel.
Um, and it's not until we reduce our carbohydrate intake enough that our
body can sort of flip that switch and start burning fat for fuel and primarily
instead of glucose for fuel and in the process create ketones.
Now this has a tremendous number of different effects.
One of which is providing our brain with a different fuel of ketones.
And we know people with epilepsy, people with various diagnoses of mental
illness, people with cognitive decline, we've seen in studies and in real
world practice that people can completely change the way their brains are
functioning when they're running on ketones.
So that's one amazing thing it can do.
And secondly, it really improves metabolic health because when you're,
when you have insulin resistance, you have trouble utilizing that glucose for
energy.
You end up building up more glucose and storing it high insulin levels.
Well, ketosis can turn all that around.
So I'm a huge fan of ketosis as a medical intervention for, for
treating medical conditions.
Um, unfortunately it's been sort of shunned as a fad weight loss diet that
is the quote unquote unhealthiest of the weight loss diets, but that just
completely misunderstands what it's all about.
Well, this is why I wanted to speak to you, a cardiologist, because usually
people will say that keto can be really hard on your heart and on your kidneys.
Yeah.
Would you recommend keto for a child?
Absolutely.
Yeah.
So that's how it started.
Actually.
It started in childhood epilepsy, that ketogenic diets were used in babies and
in young children to treat retractable epilepsy.
And now we have decades of research and clinical guidelines to support that.
So it's, we know it's safe and effective.
And, and interestingly, one thing that does kind of get confusing is, is that
type of keto diet is a very extreme keto diet, what's called a four to one keto
diet, which means for, for every gram of carbohydrate and protein combined,
you have four grams of fat.
So it was a very low protein and very low carbohydrate diet, but it worked
amazingly well in this population.
Now we're learning though, you get the same effects with, with, with a broader
or I guess less restrictive keto diet, which is more of what sort of the modern
keto diet is where you can have 20 to 30% of your calories from protein and 70% of
your calories from fat and maybe 5% from carbs, that type of structure can
still give the same benefit.
So it can be safe and effective for kids.
It can be safe and effective for adults.
It can be safe and effective for elderly.
It can, you know, the, the, the concerns about it are often overblown.
What about the concern about a child's kidneys as they grow up eating too much
meat, for example, or fats?
Yeah.
There's zero evidence that it's harmful.
Zero evidence that it's harmful.
Zero evidence that it's harmful to eat meat every single day, even for children.
Sounds amazing.
Right.
It's so contrary to everything.
You know what it sounds, it sounds like a twilight zone.
That's what it sounds like.
It's a medical twilight zone yet again.
Yeah.
So, you know, where's the, where's the burden of proof in this discussion is the
burden of proof that meat, a completely natural food that we've been eating all
throughout evolution is harmful, or is the burden of proof that it's not harmful?
Right.
I would say the assumption is that it's natural food and we should be eating it.
Um, you have to prove to me that we shouldn't be.
And the, the level of evidence that people try to cite for that is, is just insufficient.
Um, you know, kidney function is a perfect example.
There is a belief that a ketogenic diet is harmful for the kidneys.
Well, there've been two or three recent publications.
Um, one of a physician's practice, Dr.
David Unwin, his, his clinical experience and one from Virta health and Dr.
Thomas Weems, which shows exactly the opposite that people following ketogenic
diets improved their kidney function.
But yet there's this belief that it hurts kidney function.
So, so how do you, how does one exist?
And, and a big part of it is just a bias.
It's just an anti-keto bias because we're taught plant-based we're taught low fat.
Um, and we're taught low animal products, right?
So anything that goes against that, we're going to have a bias against.
And I get that, right?
I get that.
If you truly believe what you've been taught and you don't take a step back
and you say, well, wait, how is this different?
And what is the research really showing?
And so, yeah, it's a big part of my job of what I do at metabolic mind.
And coalition for metabolic health is combating these beliefs, which
simply aren't based in reality.
You mentioned keto diet and mental health, bipolar depression, all of these things
that we're seeing our children grow up with, do you think that children should
be put on a keto diet with the possibility that it would help them work
their ways out of being medicated?
That's a good question.
And that's a harder question to answer than if somebody already has a
diagnosis of depression, bipolar disorder, certainly treatment, resistant
depression, schizophrenia, and they're trying the medications and they're just
not getting the treatment that they want.
They're not getting the results that they want in those cases.
I'm a huge proponent of a ketogenic diet.
Um, and that's a big part of what we do at metabolic mind is try and share
resources and share education, both for the clinicians and the individual
about how ketogenic diets can work.
And bazooki group funds research, um, to help promote that or to help investigate
this and to what we're seeing from, from pilot trials is, is incredibly effective.
like what have you seen that's been effective?
Have you seen children possibly get off of antidepressants after changing their
diet, maybe being also activated, having meaningful experiences throughout the day
what are the chances?
I've become very, very focused on trying to get kids off meds because I'm, I worry
and I see what it does, the numbing, the lack of focus, the inability to sometimes
even build relationships for, for some of these young people.
I think one of the reasons why we're seeing young people struggle with dating
these days is because, you know, partially they're numbed from social
media and the virtual world.
And partially they're numbed because of the medications that they're on.
Right.
And so I think everything comes down to diet and lifestyle, but is.
I don't want people to be misled.
I don't want people to be misled, to think that if they just changed their
diet and lifestyle, they could live without the potential supplements
that they might need.
And so how do we find a balance?
How do we not mislead the public and, and create a common sense formula
for thinking through this?
Oh boy, that's a great question.
And you bring up a fantastic point that it's not just all about food, right?
There are so many other factors.
How are you sleeping?
How are you moving your body?
How are you managing your stress?
How are you using social media?
All of those play into it.
Um, in addition to what are you eating?
What are you drinking?
What substances are you using?
All of that plays into it.
But you're, when you ask specifically, should it.
Kids go on a ketogenic diet.
We have a lot less evidence for mental health for children that the pediatric
evidence is mostly around epilepsy.
The evidence that we're gaining now regarding ketosis and mental health is
mostly in adults, although there was a recent trial that came out or a pilot
trial called the kind study, which was in college age kids, um, which showed
significant improvements in depression scores, um, after 12 weeks on a ketogenic
diet and you hear the, you know, people sharing their experiences and how it
changed their lives.
And I mean, it's, it is remarkable.
So I think we still have to stop short of saying everybody should be on a ketogenic
diet and everybody's going to improve their mental health.
That we're, we're, we're certainly not quite there.
Um, but to, to use it as a treatment for people who are struggling with the
treatment that they're already getting is for me, a sure thing.
The second you mentioned college dorms, I just think about the
dining hall and what's there.
Uh, and I know you wrote about it in your book, which is super interesting.
And I think people with college age, uh, children and, and college age students
in general should read it because, and imagine it, there's also a lot of
confusion about you're, you're on campus.
You're hungry.
We used to be told that you need the carbs in order to focus.
Remember that doctor?
I was like, Oh, you need your carbs in order to focus.
And, and you will then go to the dining hall and it's full of carbs.
It's not just about processed foods.
And when you talk about carbs, could you expect a teenager or a college age
students to grow up without eating carbs?
Well, that was part of what was so fascinating about this study that they
did at Ohio state university.
Dr.
Jeff Bullock and his team at Ohio state.
And a big part of it was just that question.
Can we even get college students to stay on a ketogenic diet for 12 weeks?
And you know, what's the likelihood that's going to happen, right?
And I can see skepticism from so many people remembering
exactly what it was like.
But they did, they absolutely did.
And, and 16 of these individuals stayed in ketosis for the 12 weeks and,
and to hear their reports, it wasn't that hard.
How did they do?
No, they, they did fantastic.
I mean, when you look at their depression scores, they reduced by 70%.
A hundred percent of those who completed the trial reduced their depression
scores by an average of 70%, which is remarkable.
Um, now of course, small trial, you know, motivated individuals
who wanted to try this, but you know, why wouldn't you want to do it?
If you can get that kind of success, they had support, no question.
They had support from the dietitians.
Um, it could be challenging for just anybody to go out and do it on their own,
but this showed that it can be done and it can have an impact.
And this was a group where a hundred percent who completed improved
by an average of 70%.
Now, you know, it was a motivated group.
They wanted to get better.
They were having support for the diet, but why wouldn't you try this?
If, if you had depression, if you were living with depression and you weren't
seeing the results you wanted, why wouldn't you try it?
And there are other studies going on.
Um, we're funding the study with called the child bipolar network, which is a
network of, of hospitals, uh, looking at ketogenic interventions for a pediatric
population for adolescents with bipolar disorder.
And then there's a sort of a real life study at CMHRC children's
mental health resource center.
Where they are, um, instituting ketogenic diets on their, on their families and
really learning what it takes to support a family, to help a family, to help the
kid, uh, maintain ketosis and see what kind of improvements they're having.
So we're learning a lot more about ketogenic interventions in the younger
population and the effects on mental health.
But so far it all seems incredibly encouraging.
Um, and the research is going to keep continuing and we just have to keep
asking ourselves, like, why wouldn't we try this?
If it could potentially help someone with clinical guidance to
make sure it's safe and effective.
There are so many questions about how to cure kids with autism.
There are questions how they got autism to begin with, but do you think keto
diets could actually help kids with autism?
Is there any evidence in that?
Yeah.
So there's, there's a space where there's not a lot of research evidence, but
there is growing clinical evidence.
So one of the, one of my favorite things that I get to do as the host of the
metabolic mind podcast is to talk to experts, talk to all these amazing people.
So recently I talked to a Dr.
Tracy Gertler, who was talking about her experience using
ketogenic interventions for epilepsy.
But a lot of the patients she worked with don't just have epilepsy.
They have epilepsy and they have a diagnosis of an autism spectrum disorder.
And what you notice is the seizures get better, but so do so many of these
characteristics that are attributed to autism.
So is it the ketogenic diet?
You know, something about the way the brain is healing.
So there's something there for sure.
The question is, you know, for whom and how do you do it and for
how long and what are the impacts?
That's what research is going to have to figure out.
But gosh, it seems so encouraging from what we know at this point
that it could be something.
Is it possible the improvement in the mental health of the child or these
adolescents is not necessarily keto, but it's simply that they're not eating
processed foods and bagged foods?
Yeah, that's a great question too.
And I think when it comes to the brain, I'm fairly confident that it is keto
because what we see is that the brain uses ketones incredibly efficiently.
It uses the ketones for fuel, for energy.
And a lot of the times, whether it's, you know, imaging studies to see how the
brain's using glucose or what we can see in a number of patients who are diagnosed
with mental health disorders, that they have a, what's called a hypometabolism of
glucose.
They're not using glucose very well.
Well, ketones bypass that and allow the brain to efficiently produce energy or
transform energy from the ketones.
So I think when we're talking about the brain, the ketones really have something to
do.
Now, if you're just talking about losing weight, improving your metabolic health,
being healthier in general, a lot of times reducing the processed foods and the refined
carbohydrates and the, you know, the added sugars, sure, that's going to have a pretty
dramatic impact just by itself.
So it's not just what you're taking out of your diet, it's what you're putting into your
diet that makes the difference.
A little bit of both, for sure.
Yeah.
What about activation?
What about how you spend your days?
Could that be a supplement or, or maybe even in lieu of keto, if, if a child is busy or
doing things that they enjoy, have meaning in their lives, maybe being part of a study
gives them meaning and that's taking them out of depression?
Yeah, it's a fantastic question.
And like you, you brought up the point of social media and phones and you know, if,
if your release is just scrolling, scrolling, scrolling versus if your releases is
volunteering and helping others, right?
We know we can improve our wellbeing so much more by helping others, right?
Or if you're in active and engaged and have a purpose, no question, those are two very
different scenarios that are going to impact your mental health and probably your
overall health really significantly.
So yeah, it's, it, we spend so much time talking about food, which is crucial, but
it's not all about food, right?
When we look at all these societies that, you know, live the longest and are
healthiest, even though there's some, some debate about the, the, how that's defined,
but they tend to have a purpose, right?
There's this concept of finding your purpose in life and living a purposeful life.
And I think it's so powerful that that's something we should focus on and talk more
about.
You wrote about the six building blocks for a healthy life.
Yeah.
What are some of the crucial ones that you think we should be aware of?
Yeah.
I mean, one of them is finding your purpose for sure.
Like living a purposeful life, no question, but you know, you can say on the one hand,
they're simple, like how you move your body, how you nourish your body.
How you manage your sleep.
They sound so simple, but they are so amazingly impactful when you, when you can
really prioritize them and emphasize them.
So if you're talking about college kids, right?
What happens to their sleep?
Completely disrupted.
That's going to affect their mental health.
That's going to affect their physical health, right?
What happens to their nutrition?
Frequently that gets disrupted too.
That's going to affect their mental health.
That's going to affect their physical health.
So really trying to focus on these pillars and not just giving them lip service, but,
but internalizing how important they are to your life and all aspects of your life.
It's just, it's crucial.
What do you think about younger kids?
What do you, if you could envision what a perfect dining hall would look like, what
do we need to take out of there and what should we put in?
And is there a chance that it can actually be done on this large scale in given how
large our schools are?
There absolutely is a chance it can be done.
Pragmatic, something pragmatic we can actually do.
But we have to change the guidelines of what the government says is a healthy diet in
order to do it.
I want you to walk in and see your, your chicken, your steak, and your fish.
And next to that, to see your broccoli and your cauliflower and your, your bell
peppers.
And next to that, see your avocado and your olives.
And next to that, uh, then you get a little bit of fruit and you get some of the,
maybe the, some potatoes and that's it.
Right.
If that's what you get, that's what you're eating, right?
Do you think Maha is a positive thing for the medical community?
I know it's politicized.
And so, you know, when, when the case against OxyContin came out in 2007 and it
took forever until it was concluded, maybe I don't think it was concluded until
2020.
So many, many years.
I don't think it was a politicized issue.
Today, everything seems to be politicized, including medicine.
And so now every time the FDA comes out with any sort of new recommendation or
observation, it seems to be highly politicized.
On the one hand, maybe we're waking up as Americans because there's a larger pulpit
and platform for change.
On the other hand, there seems to be quite a lot of resistance because medicine has
become so politicized that you have half of the country pushing against any one of
the even obvious decisions, such as taking out food dyes from our diets.
Is Maha overall a good thing or a negative thing for America?
Yeah, it's a very topical question.
And anything that elevates the discussion of health and how our public policy is
impacting health is a good thing.
Anything that gets us talking about that and focusing on that is a good thing.
This should not be a political issue, though.
So anything that also makes it a political issue or suddenly defines it as blue or red
issue, I think that's where it could potentially hurt.
But I'm not saying that Maha is doing that, but unfortunately a reaction is kind of to
politicize this.
So we absolutely need to elevate the discussion.
We need to be talking about it more.
We need to make metabolic health a national priority.
But this is a public issue, not a political issue.
This is about people, not politics.
And I think so we have to approach it that way to realize, look, this is about making
people healthier.
Like, how can we be against that?
I think that some of the organizations that have pushed against Maha are the
organizations that have been around for a long time and were able to get away with
saying whatever it is that they said, food pyramid being upside down included, whether
it's the AMA or the CDC.
And it sounds like there are a lot of new organizations that are now coming together,
not necessarily funded by pharma, but funded by philanthropists, some of them you're
involved in.
And so are these new organizations ones that are going to receive the same credibility
given that they're new?
And do they have enough funding to even withstand the old organizations?
It seems like there's a fight between some of the new organizations and the older ones.
Yeah.
I mean, there's definitely a battleground, I guess you could say.
It's the battleground of medicine in America.
Yeah.
And, you know, who's funding some of the older organizations, right?
A lot of the pharmaceutical companies, a lot of the food industry, like, why are they
taking funding?
Why is any organization that is creating medical guidelines taking funding from drug
companies and from food organizations?
Like, that should be such an obvious thing that we do not allow because you can always
say, oh, we're not being influenced.
We need money to keep the lights on and we're going to make medical decisions.
We're not going to be influenced, but we're humans.
We're influenced by money.
We're influenced by, you know, so that should be an obvious discussion.
So who is funding the new organizations?
Plaintiff attorneys?
Well, you mentioned philanthropy, so this is definitely a role for philanthropy.
Now, you know, in general, philanthropy is not going to be able to compete with, you
know, multi-billion dollar, you know, companies and pharmaceutical companies and
food industry companies.
But, you know, the Coalition for Metabolic Health, I think, is a perfect example
funded by philanthropy with the idea being, look, what we're doing is not working.
So we need to convene the experts, the scientists, the clinicians, the business
leaders, the nonprofits, the advocates to figure out what we can do differently to
focus on metabolic health, make it practical, make it effective, and how do we
implement it?
And this wouldn't have happened without philanthropy, unfortunately, because
people who are in, you know, who are in the status quo want to continue the status
quo.
It's uncomfortable to break out of it.
And it takes somebody sort of from the outside without those influences to come
in.
And that's where philanthropy is, is amazing.
And what the Bazzucchi family has done with their philanthropic efforts, I hope
is an example for everybody to see what we can accomplish outside of industrial
influences.
Do you think the Coalition for Metabolic Health will have an impact on school
lunches?
Yes, I do.
How so?
I do.
I, well, I think by targeting the dietary guidelines, anything that can change the
dietary guidelines to be more whole food focus, to reduce the limits on saturated
fat, to understand that the quote unquote healthy carbs are not healthy for
everybody, to allow more options, anything that's going to impact the dietary
guidelines that way is going to trickle down to the school lunches.
I mean, it sickens me when my kid comes home and says, you know, their lunch was
pizza and muffins and low fat milk.
And I mean, that is just, that is not nutrition in anybody's book, but somehow
that is a dietary guidelines approved lunch.
So we absolutely need to flip the dietary guidelines to change them because they
are so influential in, in, in policy of what we can and can't feed our children
and our elderly and our military and everywhere in between.
You know, we talked a lot about food.
I want to talk a little bit more about prescriptions and medication.
You mentioned statins for LDL and cholesterol.
I'd love your thoughts on some of the other medications like blood pressure
medication, aspirin.
My mom's told that she should take aspirin every day.
Do you have any thoughts on that?
My first thought on medicine is we just rely on medicine far too often.
Um, it's easy.
Um, it can be effective, but at what cost?
So something that aspirin is the perfect example, right?
Aspirin like seems so simple, right?
Aspirin comes with a real bleeding risk.
It used to be that we kind of recommended aspirin for everybody.
And then the science was showing actually it's more harm than good for
the majority of the population.
Something as simple as aspirin, right?
So if that's the case for aspirin, well, what's the case?
What are we talking about for statins or for GOP ones or for so many other
medications, we sort of lose this risk benefit analysis because the
assumption is often that the risk is very, very low when in reality it's a
little bit higher than we think.
And look, all you got to do is watch a, you know, a football game on TV.
And at the end of the football game, you're like, wow, I just saw 20
different medicines I need to ask my doctor about because the, all these
commercials that, that make you seem like, oh, these medicines are great.
I got to talk to a doctor about it.
And, and it really has sort of tainted this risk benefit analysis where
something as simple as aspirin, we, we've learned through research that
actually it's riskier than we thought.
And not everybody should be taking it.
So when do you know to push back against the physician that
tells you take aspirin every day?
Oh God, isn't that so hard?
As an individual, you're not trained, right?
You don't know, you didn't go to medical school.
You didn't, but, and this is where social media is really sort of a mixed
bag because so many people are talking about it and raising red flags, but what
credentials do they have, where are they getting their information from?
It's the wild west.
There's no, you know, and so it has to be this mix of physicians being open
minded and being open to questions and questioning their own advice.
And those are the physicians you want to seek out.
You don't want to seek out the physicians who just do cookbook medicine, but the
ones who really want to learn about you as an individual and weigh the risk
benefit for you as an individual.
And I hope we're getting more and more of those physicians and as a patient,
hopefully you have an opportunity to seek those physicians out.
Well, it's hard to discern who is that physician that you can trust that is
going to look for the bigger picture.
What about semi-glutides?
There's a new one now, Retitrutide.
Yep.
Every other month there is a new one.
Yeah.
Well, look, I mean, these medications are being hailed as the weight loss
miracle and in a way they are, I mean, they are more effective, safer, and more
effective than any weight loss drug we've had.
And with the obesity crisis that we have, the timing is certainly necessary,
but it's the same thing.
It's relying on a medication to quote unquote solve the problem.
Is that a long-term solution?
Is that an economic solution?
What about the side effects?
And, you know, we know now with real world evidence that, you know, less than
a third of the patients remain on the medication at a year.
So what happened to all those thousands of dollars in that weight loss that, you
know, they gained the weight back and the money's gone and it was a very
expensive failed experiment.
So we can't rely on the medications solely.
We still have to realize that lifestyle interventions are absolutely crucial and
a cornerstone of metabolic health, of weight loss, of type 2 diabetes.
And the medications can still have a role, but we can't fall back on the
medicines as the one and only solution.
Is there any research or evidence that the semi-glutides can cause any
damage?
I mostly don't hear about that.
I hear that it's expensive, that people gain the weight afterwards.
And usually people's answer is, you know, that's fine.
Like, I just want to be skinny for the summer and therefore I'll go on whatever
semi-glutide it is.
And I'm willing to throw the money at it.
I mean, people will throw a lot of money at vanity.
You know that.
And so, but the question is, is there an actual risk in getting on these
semi-glutides?
Is there actual research that can hurt your metabolism or hurt your body long
term?
Yeah.
They're, they're definitely concerning side effects.
I mean, there's risk of pancreatitis, there's risk of, of stomach paralysis,
you know, there's risk of thyroid cancer.
There's the risks are, they, they click up.
Now, is it a high risk?
You're 50% of the people are going to have a serious complication?
No, no, it's, it's a, it's a small percentage, but that really has to factor
into what benefits am I going to get out of it?
How long am I going to stay on it?
And what else am I doing?
I think that is, that is so important because, and look, I guess, you know,
addressing it for vanity is one thing, but trying to treat your type two
diabetes, to treat your severe obesity, to improve your metabolic health.
I mean, those are the outcomes that we want.
And if those aren't the longterm outcomes that we're getting, then what are we
doing?
Right.
So we have to ask ourselves, what else can we do to help, to help achieve those
longterm outcomes?
Supplements have become a big conversation.
What do you, what are your thoughts on creatine?
You know, a funny story about creatine.
So, um, my son is a teenager.
He loves to work out and he's a wrestler and he's super strong.
He asked me about creatine two years ago.
And I said, ah, you don't need creatine.
You don't need supplements.
Creatine can be risky.
You don't want to do it.
And then I started to learn about it.
And I learned about the mental health benefits of creatine, not just the muscle
benefits, but the mental health benefits of creatine.
I'm taking creatine.
My son's taking creatine.
I'm a big fan of creatine.
Creatine for children?
Well, he's a teenager.
Okay.
He's a teenager.
So I don't know about younger than that, but, um, yeah, I'm actually a big fan of
creatine now.
Um, I think looking at the research and what's been done, the mental health
benefits, and of course the physical and muscular benefits with very little to no
risk.
Now supplement supplements aren't regulated as much.
You want to make sure it's, it's pure creatine.
I don't want to, you know, recommend any specific brands, but people need to do
their research to make sure it is a reputable brand and that it's pretty much
pure creatine and, you know, still talk to the doctor before doing anything.
But I, I'm a, I'm a converter.
Um, I did a great podcast with Dr.
Nick Fabiano talking about creatine and the mental health benefits of creatine
specifically for depression.
Not just muscle, but actual mental.
Yeah.
Specifically for depression.
There's some, there's some impressive results.
Um, and then we keep learning more and more about it.
Any risks in taking creatine?
Very little.
You know, there was a thought that it's harmful for your kidneys, but, but in
reality it can just, it can change a blood test for, for kidneys, but not clear
that it really hurts kidney function.
Now, if somebody already has kidney disease or if they have liver disease or if they
have other medical conditions, of course you have to be careful because it hasn't
been studied in every single, every single medical condition, but it's
really pretty well tolerated.
Any other supplements that you love?
I'm a big fan of magnesium.
Um, I think a lot of our food is kind of deficient in magnesium
the way we're growing food.
Um, and if you're a low carb, you may lose more magnesium.
So I think I'm a big fan of magnesium.
Um.
What do you think about everybody's been told that they should take vitamin D?
Yeah.
I think we need to get more sun.
That's what we need.
We need more sunlight to help our bodies create natural vitamin D.
Now, for those who, who can't do that or don't want to do that, then if I think
of vitamin D supplement is pretty reasonable, um, you know, checking your
blood level, of course, and making sure it's in the right range and working
with your provider, do you think we need a lot of supplements doctor, or can we
get most of what we need through food?
We should be getting most through food.
Now, if we are eating a nutrient dense diet, which for me is going to include
a lot of animal products, um, high protein.
I'm not high protein.
When I say high protein, people think lots of different things, but certainly
higher than what is currently recommended from a protein standpoint.
Um, and then eating an omnivore type diet, you're going to get just about
everything you need, even though the food is deficient in nutrients because
of the way it grows and all of that.
And that's why I recommend magnesium for a lot of my patients.
Um, not necessarily everybody, but for a lot of them, because I think our food is
going to be, you know, tend to be deficient in magnesium, but, but yeah,
like most of the supplements we, we should be able to get with food.
Now, if you're eating a very restrictive diet, if you're eating a vegan diet, of
course, you're going to need supplements.
Um, you know, now people are eating carnivore diets and we're, we're
learning whether or not they're, they're going to need supplements or not.
But if you're on sort of a wide end of the spectrum, maybe you are going to
need supplements to, to, uh, make up for something, but you know, good whole
foods, omnivore diet should give you most of what you need.
What do you eat?
What do I eat?
I eat a whole foods, omnivore diet.
You know, I'll, I'll start the day either not eating breakfast or having, you know,
three eggs with some smoked salmon and cheese and a bell pepper, right?
That's a common breakfast for me.
Lunch is usually a Cobb salad or leftover veggies and salmon.
And then dinner is steak, ground beef, chicken, um, salmon with, you know,
broccoli, cauliflower, bell peppers, avocado, um, sugar, wine, alcohol, any of
that coffee, so coffee, coffee for sure.
Black coffee couldn't live without it.
Well, maybe I could, but I wouldn't want to.
And then sugar.
No, no sugar.
Well, certainly no added sugar.
I'll have some dark chocolate here and there, but yeah, certainly no, no added
sugar.
Um, what else do you ask?
Wine, alcohol on occasion.
Yeah.
You know, on occasion, uh, some wine, but definitely not the sugary mixed drinks or
those types of things.
Right.
Like, and you asked about coffee.
What is Starbucks?
Is Starbucks a coffee store or is it basically a sugar store?
I see Starbucks as a sugar store.
I still go to Starbucks often and get my black coffee, but I'm in the minority
getting the black coffee.
Everybody else is getting the sugar drinks.
So gotta be really careful about, you know, what we're drinking and how much sugar
we're, I mean, that's, that's again, the no brainer, right?
The no brainer.
If you want to improve your health, what do you get rid of?
You get rid of the real sugary Starbucks drinks or not to pick on Starbucks because
so many other companies are doing it, but that's the no brainer, but that we can't,
that that's part of the human nature about the way you want to call it addiction or
the draw or the joy of it and the emotion of it, right?
It's hard to get rid of despite being so obvious.
It's so hard to take on a new lifestyle right away, right?
For people who are used to eating all of the things that are at any food court that
we find, what are small steps that you think we should start with just right away?
Just give us a piece of advice of how to get started so that we can keep going.
Yeah.
And it all, of course it depends on where someone's starting with, but the simple
things like don't drink your calories, right?
Like we got in this concept of fruit juice being healthy.
How did that happen?
Take all the fiber away from it, concentrate the sugar and it's still healthy.
I don't understand how that became a thing.
I mean, that's just exactly the opposite.
So don't drink your calories.
Not even the cold press juices and all of those.
Yeah.
Even those that are there, they're masquerading as health, but they're really
just, they're, they're simple carbohydrates that your body's going to absorb and is,
is going to adversely affect your metabolism.
So yeah, get rid of those things.
You don't need them.
Eat your food, eat your whole foods.
Get your, get, get your nutrients from your foods.
Don't drink it.
I think that's a very simple thing that could help a lot of people
and, and bring back protein.
Absolutely.
Bring back protein, any natural source of protein.
Um, I think we need more of, I think we're becoming protein deficient and I
saw, you know, I saw there've been a number of articles about this recently
with, of course, now processed food companies trying to jump on the protein
craze and add protein to their processed foods, right?
That's not the protein I'm talking about.
I'm talking about whole food, real protein sources, focusing on that.
So no protein shakes.
Protein powder, protein shakes, protein bars.
Um, I'm a mixed on those because some people struggle to eat
adequate amounts of protein.
So if you really are trying to eat whole foods, protein and not getting
enough of it, then a good quality, um, protein shake, okay.
Uh, or a good quality protein bar.
Okay.
But defining quality is, is certainly an issue, but really
defaulting back to trying to get it all from food as much as possible.
Interesting.
Well, thank you for coming on.
It was great.
And I will stop drinking my calories.
That was my pleasure.
Thanks for having me on and for having these important discussions.
I mean, so much of what we're learning, we have to sort of unlearn and relearn.
So having these discussions is great starting point.
So thank you.
Thank you, doctor.