California Pipeline Closes, 100 Trucks Hit Roads: What Happens Next? | Steve Layton

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
173 Video Views·Jan 28, 2026
California's fuel system is under pressure, not because demand has fallen, but because the path from oil to fuel has narrowed. What happens when pipelines shut down and oil that once flowed underground now requires nearly 100 trucks a day on Kern County roads? Steve Layton, president of E&B Natural Resources, explains how recent infrastructure changes are affecting how oil moves through the state, with consequences that tend to surface quietly before they become visible to the public.
AI Generated·May contain errors
One of the key pipelines in California for oil has been shut down. As a result of it about 100
trucks are on the road every day in Kern County. Our guest today is Steve Layton who's running one
of these oil companies that are using trucks now and he's telling us what's happening on the ground
right now and how the oil industry in California is facing a cliff. You're down at 250,000 barrels
a day or so. If we don't do something and do it in a hurry it's going to go to zero because the
whole infrastructure that makes producing, refining, delivering the product is going to collapse.
I'm Tim Akorami. Welcome to California Insider. Steve, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. I'm very happy to be here. We want to talk to you about key pipelines in California.
They are at the verge of shutting down and you have experienced one of the pipelines have shut
down and now you're producing oil and you're trucking this oil. Can you tell us what's happening?
We have a field in Kern County. The oil goes directly from our field through that
pipeline into San Pablo Pipeline. The field itself is currently producing
somewhere in the neighborhood of 5,000 barrels of oil a day and until December
that oil was being sent via pipeline to through the San Pablo Pipeline. There are two things
that have happened. One is just the pipeline issue itself and for quite a while there had been a
concern expressed by the company that owned the pipeline about getting barrels into the pipeline.
They wanted to make sure because as permitting slowed down and less wells were drilled in Kern
County, less oil was going through that pipeline. When the news broke on the refinery closures
and volume continued to drop, there were effectively only two buyers of the oil at the
other end of the pipeline in the Bay Area. One was the PBF refinery and the other one was
the Valero refinery. When Valero in the fall of this year gave notice that they were canceling
their contracts and they were going to stop buying oil and putting shipping on the pipeline in
December, that's when things hit for us that this is happening. We've got to find another home for
our oil. Every other oil company in Kern County was having the same kind of conversations with
whoever their buyers were. There was just too much oil, not in terms of supply and demand, but in
of the market to handle it and also where it was going to go. So you had the issue of getting the
oil to market, finding somebody that would take it, and there was uncertainty until closer to
the end of the year when Valero was going to stop or if something was going to happen and that
refinery was going to continue to operate. But when that shoe dropped and they said no we're done,
then this mad rush to find a buyer for your oil started. And in this case the demand for the
product for our oil, gasoline, jet fuel, diesel fuel, asphalt and all that, that wasn't going anywhere.
But the demand for the oil as far as the companies that process it and turn crude oil into those
products, that's where there was a lack of demand and it's more of the capacity issue.
The industry was hit with not only falling oil prices on the world market, the industry was hit
with falling oil prices in terms of what we get paid for our oil in California and the world oil
price which is known as the differential. Our differential went from three percent to roughly
a 13 percent differential and you know that amounts to five or six dollars a barrel. We
ultimately did find buyers for most of our oil in Kern County and in Los Angeles. So
there was some production that we didn't have a buyer for in December, but we had enough storage
we were able to continue to produce. But the pipeline issue has a different concern to it. When
the wheels stopped turning for San Pablo they were you know somewhere around 30,000 barrels a day
was what was going through that line. So now there's 30,000 barrels a day that is stranded
needing a new home, which most people have found a home, but with us we are having to truck
that oil instead of putting it into a pipeline. So and there's about a total of 15,000 barrels
of the 30,000 that was in San Pablo that is now being trucked versus going into a pipeline and so
now what we're having to do is truck our oil to pipeline stations. You've got 15,000 barrels a day
that's almost a hundred trucks a day that are on the road in Kern County that weren't on the road
in Kern County three months ago, but now they are. You've got to move the oil. So is that pipeline
shut down now because of economics? There was an economic issue, it may still be, but the
approval of the emergency tariff request by the pipeline company, by the folks that own San Pablo
in I think it was September, the San Pablo pipeline, they put in an emergency request
so we're losing two million dollars a month. Their stated economic minimum throughput level
was 60,000 barrels a day and you know they were somewhere in the 30,000 barrels a day. So they
needed to make, they need to have 60,000 barrels a day to be profitable. Yes. But they're getting
30,000 now. Yeah, so they can push oil through that pipeline. If their economic minimums at
60,000 barrels a day and they're doing 30,000 barrels a day, then you know why they're losing
two million dollars a month. And so they were able to do it at 30,000 barrels a day but they
were losing money. And so now with the approval of their emergency tariff, that economic minimum
number would change. I don't know what it would change to but it would bring it down
because they're getting more money per barrel. But there is a physical constraint of moving.
If you get too low in that pipeline, they can't move it at all. But I believe what they're able
to do now, or we're doing, was batching the oil. There are different segments to the line
and there are segments where it takes a lot less oil to be able to run the pipeline than others.
But once you get to a point far enough north on the pipeline, that's when they need the highest
volumes to get it all the way up to the Bay Area. There are two parts to the minimum. There's one
where at some point they just can't do it, no matter what they get paid. But the economic minimum
is now something that is probably closer to where production could be going through that pipeline
than it was before they got the increase. I haven't seen anything that makes it
likely in my mind that anything's going to change with as far as operating that pipeline.
Hopefully something will happen. Do you think they're going to reopen or do you think it's just...
That is a hard question to answer. I would say no. I think it was more likely they won't open.
And some of it has to do with the lack of buyers on the other end. So Valero's gone,
so PBF is the only buyer. That's something that you would want to risk whatever capital you have
to put in if you knew there was only one buyer for your product. If that buyer's gone,
I don't know what happens to the oil that would be shipped north. Maybe there's a possibility
being able to export it, which would be fairly ironic. There are questions that I think will
have to be answered at a level outside of the oil industry, and I'm talking about
the state or the federal government, where there is enough confidence in the fact that
the state or the federal government are going to do what is needed to allow this oil industry to
continue in California. If you have this overriding environment that is full of
powerful groups that want to put you out of business, it's hard to find a way to justify
putting more money into what you need to do to stay in business. And the refineries,
more so than anybody else, face huge capital decisions because of how much money they have
to spend every few years on turnarounds on their refineries. When they go through everything and
make sure it's working right, do upgrades, it's hundreds of millions of dollars. And
if you have bankers, if you have investors, if you have shareholders, you've got to be able to
justify why you are spending this kind of money in a state that has not been very shy
about saying they want to put you out of business. We're all for somebody making a
better product that's cheaper, less impactful on the environment. If there's a better product out
there, well, that's great. That'd be great for the country, great for the world. But right now,
that doesn't exist. And until it does, we believe, as an industry, and certainly I do
personally, that we need to produce as much oil as we can locally because we're less impactful
than most, if not all, of the oil that's being imported into California when you take into
account the environmental impact of bringing a barrel of oil from the Middle East all the way
to California or from the Amazon rainforest to California. We are hands down better at what we
do, more regulated than almost anywhere in the world. And so why not produce it here? Why not
keep the money in California? Why not keep the jobs here? And that's until
something else comes along that is better. Unfortunately, there's a lot of negativity
and anxiety right now. Even in a beautiful place like California, I'm constantly running to people
that are facing depression. Even they have a lot of things materially. No matter what you and your
family are going through right now, there is still hope. Imagine surrounding yourself for two hours
with pure beauty, amazing music, colors that we don't see in this world anymore, and a message of
hope and inspiration. Shen Yun is coming back to California. I've been going to the show for the
last 14 years, and every time I go, I see smiles on the people's faces when they're leaving the
theater. And the expressions are in a way that it's hard to explain, but there is this joy coming
from inside, and I want you guys to experience that. If you want to take a break from all the
negativity and anxiety that's out there, make sure to give yourself this experience. It will really lift
your soul. Shen Yun is currently performing in Northern California, and soon will come to LA
area and Southern California. Make sure to get your tickets right now before they sell out.
Performance that truly matters. Each and every is what you've been waiting for.
Shen Yun. Get tickets now at ShenYun.com. So State just permitted 2,000 wells you guys can drill
in Kern. Do you think this is going to resolve the pipeline issue? If they all were drilled
immediately and you could just turn on a valve tomorrow, that could very well do that, but it
will take time and capital to turn those permits into actual production. And with the price
environment that we have, producers today in Kern County are getting a price somewhere in the low
50s dollar a barrel range. Six months ago it was closer to 70, and so there's enough uncertainty
that I don't see people rushing to drill wells right now. Not because they don't want to, not
because they can't get the permit, but the economics are challenging at this price, and when
you're not sure if you're going to be able to sell your oil six months from now, it's just an added
level of uncertainty. I think that will change. I think the markets are going to settle down as far
as the concern about being able to sell oil, but right now it's still very new and the wintertime
is a sort of a slow time anyway just because of weather issues of going out and drilling wells.
If those wells were drilled, if the infrastructure was there to get them on production and sell your
oil, it would it would provide enough capacity to keep that pipeline running. We've talked to
some university professors and policymakers in the state that say we don't have a lot of oil
in Kern County. That's why it makes sense in the long run to import everything. What are your
thoughts on that? I would have to respectfully disagree with that and oil fields
generally produce a lot less oil than is in the ground. I think if you looked at
most oil fields in California, you would find that there is still more oil left in the ground
than has been produced to date, and in fact, in some cases, oil fields that may have been
in production for 20 years, they may have only produced 20 percent of the oil that's in place.
So for someone to say there's not enough oil left in Kern County to make a difference in providing
production for California, it's just it's not right. Add the uncertainty of capital or you
uncertainty of the regulatory environment or people trying to put you out of business,
you know, that's that's a whole nother issue. But it does not mean there's not oil there to be
produced. And we have a field called Poso Creek Field. When we bought that field 25 years ago,
around 2000, it had all but been abandoned. Almost every major oil company in California
owned a piece of that field at one time. And from 1986 to 2000 or so, they all had walked away or
sold their interests in that field. We were able to acquire most of that field.
So it was producing somewhere in the neighborhood of a few hundred barrels a day. And over a period
of different stages of development that started very slow and ended in the first quarter of 2020,
right before COVID, production went from a few hundred barrels a day to almost 15,000
barrels a day at its at its peak point. You know, still today, we've not had any development done
since the first quarter of 2020. Still producing 5000 barrels a day. In that period, we started
the total oil in place was calculated to be about 600 million barrels. When we stepped into it,
a total of 80 million barrels had been pulled out of that field in 2000. So now, looking at what
has been produced since we acquired it, and there is another producer in there that's produced a
fair amount of oil in the field. We have produced somewhere close to 30 million more barrels in that
25 years than the 80 that had been produced from the 1940s. Within the next 10 years, we could very
well produce another 20 to 30 million barrels. And that's all we would be at the point of getting
close to producing as much that had been produced when the field was declared, effectively declared
dead by the by the major oil companies that left. So that's just one example of an oil field. So
just keep in mind what people are saying that they may be looking at just the fact that production
has gone down and the wells aren't producing much. So the thought is, there's no more to be
there. Well, in that case, I would say that oil property didn't run out of oil, it just ran out
of money. And if you make the investment, you can continue to extract oil, and you will always be
able to get more oil out of these fields. Because there just is so much oil in place. And such a
small percentage of it has been produced to date. And that that holds true for virtually
every oil field in Kern County. So oil is there, we know where it is, we know how to get it.
We just need permits, regulatory and legislative certainty, and the economics, meaning capital,
and also a reasonable oil price. You have those factors, we can drill, and we can produce. And
maybe we can't produce every barrel of oil that California needs. But I think we can produce
most of what California needs. You mentioned 100 trucks on the road. And we all can imagine the
environmental impact of this, compared to going in the pipeline. What about the cost? How much is
the cost differential on you guys versus using the pipeline? That definitely makes a difference
on how far you're having to haul it. And there are two choices. One is taking the oil all the way
from the east side of Kern County to the west side of Kern County, because that's where the pipeline
pumping stations are. And that's 100 mile or so round trip, something along those lines.
And that cost is around $5 a barrel. But the other choice, and it's not unheard of,
is, and we have, not with this round, but in the past, we have actually trucked oil,
and people do truck oil, all the way to the refineries in Los Angeles. And that is about
$8 to $10 a barrel to get to take a truckload of oil from the Bakersfield area down to whether
it's PBF, Marathon. So you actually have that many trucks going over the grapevine.
If you lose these pipelines, essentially, we could have trucks going up and down the pipeline.
Well, you do right now. I mean, we've got not up and down the grapevine. Ours are going over to
the west side of Kern County. But they're on the road now. Our oil is not going in the pipeline.
You mentioned oil is coming from Iraq or Amazon. Can you tell us the impacts of that?
The rules that are in place in other areas, and one of them is the emissions related to flaring
or venting natural gas. And that is different in different places in the United States. In
California, there is almost no flaring. Companies have flares for issues of safety, but as a
day-to-day practice, you've got excess gas. You can't get it into a pipeline. And so what do you
do? In some places in the world, they just vent it, just straight methane and whatever else is
with it into the air. In California, that's not what we do. We have to make sure that we aren't
venting any gas. We have to make sure we're not leaking any gas. And especially in the city,
there is a zero tolerance for that. If you have a leak, it doesn't matter how small it is,
you are out of compliance, which means you need to fix it. And we should. We shouldn't have any
leaks if we're operating here. And when the industry gets criticized for emissions that are
unhealthy for the surroundings, it's just not the case because we aren't allowed to do that.
If we are operating and in compliance, there wouldn't be any emissions from our operations
in Los Angeles. And so we have to do our own inspecting in addition to being inspected
regularly by the agencies to make sure that we are in compliance. And if there's something,
if there's an issue and you need to tighten the valve, we want to know that so that we can take
care of it. It's also very helpful for us as an industry to be inspected very heavily
because we want additional eyes on what we do because we want to do what's right. And if you're
a company that's operating in the middle of the rainforest and the Amazon, just from what we've
seen and heard in the news, it's a lot different than producing an oil under the watchful eye of
the state and whatever local jurisdiction in California. Do you think the state is not
treating you guys fairly? Or are the regulators or people in these bodies,
they don't want the oil industry? As far as the state or people within the state government
not wanting the industry? Yes, there are. Absolutely are. But there are also much more
pragmatic thinkers within the state and within the agencies that, you know, they understand
what their job is and what they're supposed to do. And they will enforce the rules as they should.
But that doesn't mean that they're looking for a way to put us out of business,
but to figure out what's the most efficient cost effective way of complying. And the industry has
been hit with so many things, new laws, new regulations, different challenges, not just from
the state level, but also the local level. The city of Los Angeles being a very significant one.
All of this has happened within maybe a 10 to 15 year period, say from 2010
forward, just an onslaught. And there are so many things, so many things that even overlap
one another. There wasn't much of an effort to try and pick through a lot of those things and
see things that just don't make sense. We've asked you to comply with a law that requires you to
do things and nobody, there's so much data that nobody's even looking at it. And so
they are maybe peeling away some of the things that are either counterproductive,
actually make things worse instead of making things better. You know, I wouldn't want to
make a blanket statement that everybody that's in the state government wants us out of business.
The other thing that they have to deal with, and this is the other part of the answer to the
question, is there is a lot of pressure on the regulatory agencies and the state itself
from outside groups who are very aggressive in getting to the state, trying to sponsor legislation
that may have a tagline of making California a safer place. But what the underlying reason is
for that legislation is to put this industry out of business. The thing that happens is if they
aren't being listened to enough, they will sue. They will sue the agencies. And so you now have
agencies that even though maybe they know what the right thing to do is and they know that this
is really a bad law, they're concerned about doing anything about it because they're afraid
of being sued. The industry now has been in a position where we have to consider things like
that. And you know, there's a litigation on the 1137 law, the setback law. It is a horrible way
to do business when you have made the court system the arbiter of what is necessary to
economically and environmentally soundly produce a barrel of oil. If we go one way, we get sued by
this group. If we go that way, we get sued by that group. Other than for us as an industry to continue
to push to make what we do as economic as we can, but more importantly, as in the least impactful
way. We always want to look for ways to do something that is positive as an industry and
demonstrates that yes, we are mindful that a transition can be a very good thing. And
you know, we don't want to be a roadblock. If this infrastructure collapses, what will come
next? Will we see a lot of trucks on the road or all of the oil producers will go out of business?
The reason they would go away is just because of the overall pressure for production refining
to be rigged out of California. So at that point, if you're an oil producer in California,
you can't sell it to the refineries. I don't know how feasible it would be for
us to become the state or even if we would be allowed to export oil.
That would be the only choice we'd have. Or if there's a refinery built in Nevada or Arizona,
maybe you could truck it there. You know, there's not that the pipeline infrastructure going out of
the state is very, very limited. There's gasoline from the refineries being pipelined to Arizona and
Nevada. And there are natural gas pipelines bringing natural gas in from other parts of the
world. But as far as oil, there aren't any pipelines that bring oil. And roughly 10 years
ago, there was a push by companies to bring in oil by rail into California. I know Phillips
Petroleum had a big project on the boards over on the Central Coast, and they wanted to bring
rail cars in with oil. And there's a little bit of oil that comes in by rail in California,
but they wanted to make it much, much bigger. And they couldn't. They couldn't get it permitted.
There was too much opposition. I don't know that rail is an option, but that would be another
thing to look at. And the economics might be physically possible, but whether it's economically
feasible is a question I can't answer. Do you know how much is this industry worth for California?
Yeah, the industry, there have been some recent studies. The one that I remember
put a contribution to the state in the $330 billion a year range.
So it's like a big percentage, 8, 9% of our GDP.
And you mentioned this is a cliff. How close are we based on what you're seeing?
Wouldn't say we're over the cliff now, but we are definitely on the brink. So economically,
as far as the production side goes, we're really, really close to where we are right now. And if
the trend of shutting down permitting continues, there's a good legislation that passed last year,
there was the door open for permitting in Kern County. And that is something that was a positive
thing. But if you have all these other pressures on the outside, and you look at the investment
it's going to take once you get the permits, are people going to do anything if they don't have
confidence that something else isn't going to come along in this legislative session? That is
the constant drumbeat that we have to deal with because we are one legislative session away from
going out of business. When you're talking about the amount of capital it takes to go out and
develop an oil field, you need a longer runway than one year. A lot of these projects, it takes
a few years to get your money back. That uncertainty is the thing that I think would make
it more likely that we might go over that cliff on the production side. And the bigger cliff that
we go over is this infrastructure question. What happens if six months from now, two more refineries
announce that they're going to shut down? And so that takes us down from seven to five. In 1990,
we were between 30 and 40. I think it's 34 refineries. And then you've got the issue of
we're almost closed off from being able to sell oil up north now because of the San Pablo pipeline.
So everything is shifting down to the L.A. refineries as far as production that was going
north a few years ago and in large volumes. And so if a couple of these L.A. refineries,
there's a Valero refinery in L.A., hasn't been an announcement, they're going to shut it down. But
I'm concerned about that, that if they shut down a refinery up north, are they going to
shut down the one down south? I don't know. But that's the kind of thing producers have to worry
about. And it makes them very hesitant to make investments. You've got all this uncertainty
about the oil price. You've got the world market to worry about. Now you've got this differential
problem. And then you have the threat of what's going to happen in the legislative session.
The good news is that this industry is full of people that are optimists. The track record for
an exploration well has historically been around a 10 percent success rate, yet people are still
drilling. We're risk takers. And so we're the right industry to perhaps make its way through
all of this uncertainty and concern and opposition. And maybe we're just stubborn
enough to feel like someday we're going to be able to win the argument that we, in fact,
are the best place to come to for oil, because we can get it to you for less money and most
importantly in a much safer and more environmentally friendly way. Have you thought of leaving California
based on the pressure you guys are facing? I'm going to answer that question as no, as far as
leaving California. But the other question is capital leaving California. And the industry
certainly can do that. They can, instead of investing money in California oil fields,
they can invest money elsewhere. But the reason people are in California as oil companies and
have stayed and want to stay is the incredible resource that's here. Oil fields in California
are very young in geologic terms. In the Los Angeles basin,
the oil that we produce every day is somewhere between five and 10 million years old. This
kitchen that sits down in the L.A. basin around 10,000 feet or so, maybe a little more in some
areas, this kitchen is very young and it is still making oil. Because of the way the geology is in
this state, there is more oil per square foot of surface area than any other place in the
United States. Maybe Alaska's, but at least in the lower 48. We're here because there has been
a lot of oil produced in California, but there is a lot more left in the ground that hasn't
been produced and we know where it is. And then when you add to the fact that the state as a
whole is very underexplored, there are new fields to be discovered. One of the old axioms in the oil
industry is the best place to find oil, find new oil, is in an old oil field. So we've got
such an incredible resource base at a relatively shallow depth
that you can't walk away. You've got to hang on until things get better.
Steve Layton with EMB Resources, it was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you very much for inviting me to be here. What do you think about these key pipelines
that are on the line right now? And what are your thoughts on the oil
industry in California in general? You can always email us at siamakacaliforniasider.com
or comment. We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. This is California Insider. We'll see you next time.
