Rights Groups Release Report on Impact of UK's Home Office Rules on Hong Kong Immigrants

Live News Network
1.4K followers
243 Video Views·Jan 27, 2026
UK Welcomes Refugees, West Midlands Hongkonger Support CIC, Hong Kong Labour Rights Monitor, and Re-Water CIC, and other rights groups hold a press conference at 6:30 a.m. ET on Jan. 27 to release a report on how U.K's new Home Office rules are set to tear Hong Kong families apart and block over billions in private capital from entering the UK economy.
Good morning, everyone, distinguished guests, members of the press, and our audience joining
us via the live stream.
My name is Cathy, and it is my honor to serve you as the moderator today.
Please note that the press conference is a bilingual event.
The first half has already been held in Cantonese.
We now proceed with the English session.
Now, let's begin.
We gather here today to address a matter of profound significance for tens of thousands
of Hong Kong families, the Earth Settlement Proposal introduced by the Hong Kong office
late last year.
The report we are launching today amplifies the voices of 1,725 affected individuals.
This report is supported by four organizations from Hong Kongers.
First, UK World Health Organization.
Our findings provide robust evidence to the public and the government that this proposal
will result in a systematic exclusion for the 50-plus DNA community.
These policies ignore their deep-seated anxieties regarding the future, undermine our historical
commitment, and even overlook their tangible contribution to the whole British society.
Through this launch, we aim to assist the government in fostering more equitable and
inclusive policies.
First, let me introduce our speakers joining us today.
So, Derek Lo, representative from the leftmost.
Derek Lo, representative from West Midlands Hong Kong Gross Support CIC.
In the middle, Dai-Hsien Lee, director of the West Midlands Hong Kong Gross Support CIC.
And next to me, Christopher Mo, executive director of the Hong Kong Labor Rights Monitor.
Our agenda for today is as follows.
I will begin with by outlining the research background and methodology.
Following this, Derek will present a detailed analysis of the core findings in his capacity
as a researcher, including the risks of counter-flight and the talent journey.
We will then hear further insights from our representatives from the Hong Kong Labor Rights
Monitor and the West Midlands Hong Kong Gross Support CIC before concluding a Q&A section.
Let us first examine the context of this study.
Since the introduction of the British National Overseas Visa in 2021, over 170,000 Hong Kongers
have arrived in the UK.
At its inception, the policy was framed as a unique and generous response to an unprecedented situation.
In a regional policy statement, the then Home Secretary, Priti Patel, was explicit in her commitment.
She states, and I quote,
My offer to the BNO citizens is a very generous one.
I am not imposing skills tests or minimum income requirements, economic needs tests or caps on numbers.
They do not need to have a job before coming to the UK.
They can look for a job once they are here.
This promise was the foundation of trust.
It was presented in a way for the UK to fulfil its historical obligations to the people of Hong Kong
under the Sino-British Joint Declaration.
Regrettably, White Paper 4048, published late last year, represents a sudden change of the rules in the middle of the game.
By introducing academic level English requirements and minimum income threshold,
the government is erecting a retrospective policy barrier.
Many in the 50-plus demographic made the difficult decision to migrate based on the explicit understanding
that they would only need to be self-sufficient, not necessarily high earners.
This sudden shift pushed them towards a dead end, where settlements become impossible.
For those who have already uprooted their lives, this is not just an administrative change.
It is a breach of a fundamental promise that threatens the survival in the UK.
Our research was born out of this urgent necessity to quantify these impacts
and fill the gaps the government's own impact assessment regarding to the older migrants.
To ensure our data is both credible and authoritative, I would like to detail our research methodology.
This study was conducted in January this year, specifically targeting BNO visa holders in the UK aged 50 and above.
Recognising that this demographic is often more discreet, we utilised the Snowball sampling,
reaching out through regional churches, community organisations and trusted networks.
Ultimately, we secured 1,725 valid responses.
When cross-referenced with the Home Office statistics, our sample covers approximately 3% of the specific population.
In the academic research, 3% is a significant coverage that grounds our findings' high statistical significance,
providing a precise reflection of the community overall trend.
Beyond the numbers, we also performed a qualitative analysis on the response containing negative emotion terms,
such as depression or despair, translating the core statistic back into the human cause that they present, delivered by the policy.
Our data reveals a heart-wrenching core issue.
In an attempt to filter those who contribute to the society, the government is actually operating on a set of flawed assumptions,
effectively excluding a group that is economically self-sufficient and has already made substantial contributions to the UK's assets and social fabric.
I will now hand over to Derek, who will provide a comprehensive breakdown of the data regarding the capital flight and talent drain.
Hello, I'm Derek. I'm the volunteering researcher for this project.
This study was a joint effort. We worked with a few organisations and I would like to express my gratitude to them and also our volunteering team,
which includes scholars, volunteers and organisation representatives.
In this research, our target was female visa holders aged 50 and above.
We also used both qualitative and qualitative approaches.
We commenced this project in a very short period of time, just under 30 days, I believe.
The team conducted a broad online survey and we used Snow Rover sampling to reach into this relatively closed social circle.
We've collected 1,725 samples and each covers about 3% of the specific demographic, which gives it a high statistical significance.
We cross-referenced our data with the Home Office 2021 BNO report and the latest 2025 Immigration Quarterly Statistics.
Furthermore, we searched for key words to analyse emotional sentiments and we also looked specifically at three groups.
Firstly, those aged 65 and above. Secondly, women and those with both high education and high SS.
We did this to see how the policy excludes people.
At first, we would like to talk about some economical impacts.
Firstly, this study exposes the economic fallacy as the government thinks it can filter contributing migrants via salary threshold.
The data confirms this assumption fails completely for the 55-plus group.
Our analysis shows this is not a group as we should think we would have think of, and it is a young-born cohort.
40% are aged between 50 and 54, yet upon arrival they face a mismatch.
Full-time employment dropped to below 20% while the number of retirees surged above 35%.
More than 80% believe the new rules ignore the difficulty of older migrants' face and more than 50% say that age itself is a massive barrier to real employment.
Here lies the critical contradiction.
Relying to the original policy, more than 80% quit well-paid jobs to make huge life changes and they shift to SS-based lifestyle.
The survey finds more than 80% of families use savings for daily spending and only 36% rely on working income.
In fact, nearly 40% live on passive income like investment or pensions.
Where does this money come from?
Just under 70% of them use savings and 66% sold their Hong Kong property.
Are they a burden? The data says no.
One of 1,725 respondents only once mentioned that they rely on partial public funding.
This proves the group as an absolute zero-burden democracy.
They even pay the IHS and use the private health care, reducing pressure on NHS.
Each acts as a self-funded resident.
It injects liquidity directly into the British economy.
So forcing them into a wage model punishes them twice.
Firstly, they face an age discrimination at work.
Secondly, they lose settlement rights because they can't get high-paid jobs.
This ignores their human capital and destroys their plan to be self-sufficient as a holder.
Therefore, firing this group, reduced by fiscal burden, makes no sense.
More than 90% of them say that the policy ignores their assets' reality, which is high assets.
More than 95% urge the UK would lose law-abiding, self-sufficient residents.
This is why nearly 60% demand proof of assets until income threshold.
For those aged 65 or above, the shock.
More than 80% have fully retired and only 1.4% work full-time.
With more than 80% relying on savings, a thoroughly accelerated threshold blocks their path to settlement.
Also, the language barrier is huge.
Over half say that the B2 requirement creates survival anxiety.
More than 90% demand age exemption.
Without this, these vulnerable seniors face forced migration.
Because BNL families rely on intergenerational care, this will separate families and cause humanitarian disaster.
Government calculations often look only at income tax.
They ignore VAT and stamp duty.
For this group, consumption often exceeds that of wage earners.
This generates continuous VAT.
Also, more than 60% sell property in Hong Kong.
They are likely putting that money into UK housing and generating stamp duty.
Defining contribution only as work income is wrong.
If the policy forced them to sell off, the supply shock would destabilise local housing markets.
Our analysis reveals a potential national cost.
Because of Hong Kong's rule, 94.6% of our interviewees face a double bind.
Without UK's permanent residence, ILR, they cannot withdraw their NPF.
This is the NPF deadline.
The BNL visa is not recognised as a proof of permanent departure in Hong Kong.
94.7% say that the new policy has disrupted their plans.
Based on the data and the Home Office estimates of 55,000 arrivals,
we estimate the NPF assets held by this group is 36.4 billion Hong Kong dollars,
that is 3.64 billion pounds.
If they are forced to leave, the UK risks a capital flight of 3.43 billion pounds.
This is a massive capital indeed for the UK economy.
More than 80% agree that this affected their property buying plans.
If we talk about property buying using the November 2025 House Price Index,
this large capital could buy over 12,400 homes by cash.
This is only using their pensions, not mentioning their own capital.
If strict rules force them out, this capital will never enter the UK.
Their private capital will leave, and this is definitely an economic goal.
Beyond NPF, there is a direct capital flight.
Nearly 90% warn of more separated families, and more than 60% say that the policy...
This is worse than the TALENT group.
TALENT group means those with high education and both high income, not high assets.
Nearly 100% say that they will withdraw funds from other places in the UK,
and they can easily move elsewhere or return to Hong Kong.
This triggers a chain reaction.
Firstly, loss of deposits.
Secondly, property sell-off.
Thirdly, reduced consumption.
And because of BNO family value ties, apparently the young workforce will fall,
and the UK will lose both capital and labour.
Then we should consider sub-costs.
Nearly 70% use their savings, over 60% sell their property,
and 60% of them quit jobs in Hong Kong.
These were investments based on the 2021 promise.
By changing it now, the government is effectively taking these sub-costs.
This damages UK's reputation.
Global talent will see the UK as a high regulatory risk.
The loss of confidence will cost far more than any savings from a policy.
Nonetheless, there will be a large talent drain.
The study identifies this policy as a dangerous elite purge.
We have a TALENT group, which defines as graduates over HK$1 million in NPS.
In their pensions alone, having HK$1 million, which is £100,000.
And only this group make up 13% of examples.
And the government should fight to keep them.
Yet, nearly 80% expect to fail the new requirements.
And this is an elite paradox.
94% call it moving the goalpost.
And 77% of this group cannot meet the wage rules because they basically do not rely on wages.
And more than 90% say the rules ignore their essence.
And nearly 80% say that this destroys their retirement plans.
The mismatch causes extreme reaction.
30% of them are planned to leave.
And this is higher than average.
If the policy insists on wages, it expels capital holders.
It creates adverse selection as exactly opposite of attracting talent.
And also we will mention discrimination and injustice.
The policy also disproportionately impacts on women.
This could be indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010.
Women are nearly 60% of the respondents.
The number of family caregivers double after moving.
In this group, women do over 76% of family care.
Women often do unpaid work so the younger generation can work.
And unsettlement penalises these women.
It causes a dilemma.
Abandoned care for low-paid works or either face a revibration.
The strongest backlash comes from the breach of legitimate expectations.
Nearly 100% understood that they would settle after 5 years.
94% of them understood that there was no minimum income requirement.
More than 80% saw this as a humanitarian and not economic route.
To move, the most moved because of no income check clause.
Nearly 100% viewed this pivot as a broken promise.
This erodes trust.
Subjecting humanitarian migrants to strict economic metrics after they have burned their bridges.
This is mortally contentious.
Finally, the humanitarian disaster.
It has triggered a mental health disaster.
Nearly 100% believe the promise is broken.
We have recorded 35 cases involving death, suicide or depression.
Without us asking, they write it in their own words.
This indicates a risk of life.
Take two cases.
Firstly, telling us they like suicide.
Secondly, telling us they already have anxiety and depression.
These highlight the human cost behind it.
Raising the English requirement to B2 is literally an administrative violence.
74% of them support exemption.
18% of them already force rejected English proof.
These barriers push legal residents to become illegal migrants.
That's ridiculous.
If this policy is unchanged as proposed, the earned settlement will be a total policy failure.
It ignores asset space consumption.
It triggers a time drain.
It loses billions in capital.
This sparks a humanitarian crisis.
If the government wants to reduce burden, it can't.
The result will be a lose-lose.
We urge the government to order a splash.
Maintain existing arrangements.
Thirdly, recognise diverse contributions.
Fourthly, prevent discrimination.
Fifthly, maintain English exemption.
Lastly, alert business staff.
This is my presentation.
Let's hand it back to our host.
Thank you.
Thank you, Derek.
Through that clear breakdown of the data, it clearly shows from the report,
this new policy will not just provide and offer an economic disaster loss to the country,
to the family and the individual,
and also create an affordable humanitarian crisis.
The evidence shows that the policy shift is a significant economic loss.
Beyond the statistics, we must also address the tangible impact on labour rights
and everyday lives of our Hong Kong community members.
To provide this insight, I would like to invite Christopher Ng,
Executive Director of Hong Kong Labour Rights Monitor,
and Tsai-Hsien Lee, Director of West Midlands Hong Kong Resupport CIC,
to share their professional expertise and frontline observations.
Thank you very much.
Thanks for having me.
First of all, I would like to say I believe the government conservation document
should not confuse economic migration with the BNO visa scheme.
As the two are based on fundamentally different principles,
the BNO vote was introduced in response to the Chinese government's imposition
of the National Security Law in Hong Kong,
which breached the joint declaration and undermined Hong Kong's freedom.
On moral and historical grounds,
the UK offered the BNO scheme as a lifeboat for Hong Kong people.
Any adjustments to language or income requirements,
aimed at attracting specific types of categories,
should therefore not apply to the BNO vote,
whose purpose is humanitarian rather than economic.
Among the more than 180,000 BNO Hong Kongers
who have already relocated to the UK,
many will become eligible to apply for indefinite leave
to remain within the coming months or years.
Changing the requirements at this critical stage
would undermine the UK government's original commitment
and violate the legitimate expectations of the approved applicants.
Such an approach would constitute a breach of trust.
We therefore strongly urge the government to honour its promise
by maintaining the existing B1 and English language requirements
and by not introducing a minimum income threshold.
Survey findings show strong opposition among middle-aged and older Hong Kong migrants
to the proposed introduction of additional thresholds.
Over 85% of respondents described the proposals
as moving the goalposts and deeply unfair.
More than half believed they would be unlikely to meet the new requirements,
while about 85% lacked confidence in passing them.
Imposing excessively high thresholds
would leave many feeling excluded
and would one-timer to the government's stage goal of promoting social integration.
The prospect of sudden change to BNO conditions
has already caused significant distress within the community.
Many respondents reported anxiety, feelings of betrayal
and fears of being forced to return to Hong Kong or be separated from their families.
These proposals have clearly generated serious uncertainty and psychological pressure.
We urge the UK government to clarify its position as soon as possible
and to confirm that settlement requirements will remain unchanged.
The consultation also adopts a very narrow definition of contribution to society.
Contribution should not be measured only by income.
Many middle-aged and older Hong Kong migrants rely on savings from Hong Kong to retire early
or can only work very limited hours due to low-declining health.
Adapting to a new labour market and workplace culture here in the UK
can be very challenging at this stage of life.
The proposed minimum annual income threshold is impassable and unreliable
and would disrupt plans made prior to migration.
Finally, we urge the UK government not to overlook Hong Kong people
who are ineligible for BNO status and are currently seeking political asylum in the UK.
Like BNO holders, they were forced to exit due to persecution
for resisting the evasion of Hong Kong's freedoms.
Under the proposed reforms, even recognised refugees would face an extension
of the qualified period for settlement from 5 years to 20 years.
The UK's own responsibility towards Hong Kong must extend to these persecuted political refugees,
ensuring that their settlement conditions remain unchanged.
Many are young people who have already sacrificed greatly in our struggle for democracy.
Please do not allow them to become a forgotten group.
Thank you.
Thank you, Mr Tan.
On behalf of the West Indian Communist Party, I just want to mention a minor group
which we believe to be a spoiler to another consists of Hong Kong workers
who rely on employment in the UK to make a living.
Our organisation has received many cases where uncertainty over the length and stability
of visa status has negatively affected their employment opportunities.
In addition, the income requirements under the new policy may result in a longer time
being required to obtain permanent residence.
This could create an adverse cycle.
Furthermore, visa renewal involves sufficient costs, making it more difficult for them to
access and instead increasing the likelihood that they may need to rely on social welfare in the UK.
In light of the above, we sincerely hope that the UK government will conduct a more comprehensive
policy impact assessment of the proposed new policies and engage in meetings and discussions
with more Hong Kong migrant groups in the UK in order to better understand the potential
impacts of this policy on Hong Kong migrants.
Finally, we urge the UK government to carefully reconsider whether it is appropriate to proceed
with those policies so as to avoid a loss-loss situation to both the UK society and Hong Kong migrants.
This is my voice. Thank you very much.
Thank you for both sharing from the both honoured guests.
We now consider that the new policy not just impacting all immigrants, the 50-plus BNO
visa holders and also about asylum seekers or those who are now seeking to get asylum.
We will now open the floor for questions from the press.
We welcome inquiries regarding the research findings, policies, recommendations or the
insights shared by our speakers.
Please raise your questions and state your name. Thank you.
Thank you. I think the Q&A section, we already satisfied in the Chinese part.
Thank you everyone for joining today's press conference.
We are going to deliver a message to the British society and also the whole UK government.
Stand with Hong Kong. Fight for justice.
Thank you.
