Secret History of the Denisovans - Revealing an Incredible Ancient Discovery!

Genetic History
7 followers
In this video, we'll explore the question of whether humans, Denisovans and Neanderthals are the same species. We'll compare and contrast the three groups, and see if there is enough evidence to support the theory that they are all the same species.
Are humans, Denisovans and Neanderthals the same species? This is a question that has puzzled anthropologists for years, and it's still an open question. In this video, we'll explore the evidence and see if there is enough to support the theory that these groups are all the same species. After watching this video, you'll be able to make a decision about this controversial topic!
#ancienthumans, #denisovan, #neanderthal
Comments are disabled for this video.
During the 20th century, anthropologists believed that Homo erectus had lived over the wide terrain
of eastern Asia from the early Pleistocene, followed by the advent of a more sophisticated,
but still primitive, groups in China during the mid-middle Pleistocene.
However, recent finds or re-identifications of other archaic hominins, including Homo
floresiensis from an Indonesian island, Neanderthals, and Denisovans from southern
Siberia, and an extraordinarily robust mandible from Taiwan all provide new insights.
This new research seeks to present a phylogenetic model of different ancient Asian hominins
dispersed from southern Siberia to southeast Asia and India by including these most recent
discoveries. In this video, we show how these paleo-anthropological facts inform the taxonomic
identity of Denisovans, and the admixture event with modern humans using this new paradigm.
The question has even been proposed, are Denisovans and modern humans descended from
the Javanese Homo erectus? At 800,000 years old, the Sangiran skull from Java raises the
intriguing possibility that Homo erectus reversed its migration and returned to East Africa.
Reverse migrations from Asia to Africa are not logically expected, but nonetheless could have
happened. Although the historical geographic range of Java Homo erectus is unknown, it is entirely
probable that it was ubiquitous throughout the Sunda region. Because of this, the lineage has
been called Sunda Homo erectus. If so, the Australo-Melanesian ancestors must have encountered
them during their migration, which could have led to introgression of their genes. However,
the discrepancy with the reported divergence time between the Siberian Denisovans and modern
humans may not be a problem, if the former was an admixed population between the local primitive
hominins and Neanderthals as discussed previously. The divergence time between Javanese Homo erectus
and Homo sapiens is likely much older than 1.2 million years ago. As previously observed by
proponents of the multi-regional hypothesis of modern human origins, if this Homo erectus group
was the source of the Denisovan DNA recovered from Oceania, this event would explain some
skull characteristics similar to those of Homo erectus in fossil and extant Aboriginal Australians.
The subsequent spread of later populations, and ensuing genetic overprinting can be used
to explain the lack of Denisovan DNA in the current populations of Sunda, including Indonesia.
Even though the fossil record for Asia is currently quite limited,
it is always beneficial to carefully consider what we can and cannot infer from the materials at hand.
Thus, the concept that Javanese Homo erectus is the southern Denisovans is plausible and merits
more research. Of course, it's also possible that the southern Denisovans fossils have not
yet been found, or are still unidentified in existing fossil collections. Before we draw this
conclusion, however, it is necessary to examine other potential circumstances more closely.
The middle Awash valley in Ethiopia is where the fossilized hominid known as Bodo man was found.
To comprehend the origins of our species, Homo sapiens, Bodo and Herto man are essential fossils.
These ancient people may have been distant cousins of the Herto modern human populations
that lived in the same region. The 600,000-year-old skull, known as Bodo man,
is one of the earliest ancient remains that we may regard as being closer to Homo sapiens,
and is most likely an ancestor of the modern human populations that first appeared in East
Africa 200,000 years ago. Bodo man exhibits archaic traits that truly show a split between
The glabella interrupts the extremely thick, double-arched superorbital torus.
Throughout the fossil record, it has the widest nasal opening below the nasal bones,
a projecting and broad middle face. Finally, the morphological continuity that the African
Bodo-Carbwe-Herto specimens demonstrate over time is astounding. For instance, the change
to a lighter superorbital torus, although maintaining a double arch, and the appearance
of more contemporary zygomatics. The Carbwe skull from Zambia and the Bodo skull,
according to Spanish anthropologist Roberto Cés, also share features with Asian specimens
of Homo erectus, such as the Sangeran 17 skull from Java, Indonesia.
These features include broad zygomatics, thick superorbital torus, long and sloping forehead,
sagittal keel and broad nasal aperture. Russian researchers had been aware of Denisova
cave in the Altai region of Siberia for some 40 years, but it wasn't until the location received
widespread notice thanks to the publishing of a particularly unusual mitochondrial
DNA sequence, named Lineage X, from a fragment of a human finger bone. According to the sequence,
the Siberian Denisovans split off from the ancestors of modern humans and Neanderthals,
less than one million years ago. In contrast, a draft of the whole genome from a finger bone
was later published and suggested that the Denisovans were quite closely related to Neanderthals,
it also revealed that portions of similar DNA were present in extant Melanesians,
likely as a result of ancient introgression from a Denisovan-like population.
The early analysis left many concerns about the Denisovans unsolved.
Now, the latest research reveals that Denisovans inhabited the cave for a considerable amount of
time, and that they had less genetic variety than living Europeans. Hence, it's possible
that Denisovan and Neanderthal presence in the cave fluctuated, or had gaps over a long period
of time before being replaced by modern human habitation. Remarkably, this cave is only 200
miles from China, opening the door to the possibility that Neanderthals traveled all
the way to East Asia and mated with Asian archaic humans. Denisovan samples are hard to come by,
though, so the chance to get fresh information is crucial even when samples aren't well preserved.
The study connects two disciplines, paleoanthropology and ancient DNA,
that have been essentially constant sources of the remarkable in recent years.
Since 2010, paleoanthropologists have been in an unanticipated situation,
they are aware of a recent hominin group for which the only substantial source of
knowledge has been the genome sequence. The Denisovan group offers one such example.
Several concerns regarding the Denisovans remain unresolved despite in-depth analyses of ancient
DNA and tooth morphology. How can the conflicting mitochondrial DNA and nuclear DNA signals
regarding their link with Neanderthals be resolved, for instance? One theory is that more
ancient, mitochondrial DNA lineages were introduced, together with the identified
archaic introgression into the Denisovan nuclear genome. This was in addition to the detected
archaic introgression from Neanderthals. Another possibility, however, is that the
proto-Neanderthal and Denisovan samples still have diversity in ancestral, mitochondrial DNA
lineages that were lost in later Neanderthal and modern human evolution. This idea is supported
by the similarity of the Denisovan mitochondrial DNA, to the mitochondrial DNAs recovered from the
400,000-year-old proto-Neanderthal fossils in Spain. Possibly, novel variants shared by
contemporary humans, and Neanderthals within the last 400,000 years have even supplanted
older mitochondrial DNA lineages in them. This is in keeping with their considerably more recent
mitochondrial DNA coalescence dates. How the Denisovans fit into the larger
narrative of human evolution over the past million years is a second, even more basic question.
They belong to a larger Neanderthal lineage, as their nuclear DNA clearly supports, but their
divergent mitochondrial DNA, and their primitive tooth morphology conflict with this classification.
Larger fossil and DNA samples of the Denisovans, who are still only known from incomplete fossils
at a single cave site, would be useful in this regard. Intriguing and unexpected are the latest
discoveries of these Denisovans, and genetic proof of their hybridization with modern human groups
is now found in islands Southeast Asia, Australia, Papua New Guinean and Melanesia.
The introduction of Denisovan genes into current humans is concentrated in Oceania.
This indicates that the southern Denisovans, the introgressing ghost population,
lived well south of the Altai Mountains in Siberia, and possibly even across the Wallace Line.
Sunda is a lost landmass in island Southeast Asia, that was drowned by rising sea levels
around 10,000 years ago. This landmass included Indonesia and Malaysia, and the seas that
separate these regions including the Gulf of Thailand. Seoul was the supercontinent of Australia,
Tasmania and Papua New Guinea before rising sea levels separated these three regions,
leaving them separated. Thus, given that Denisovan-like individuals likely lived
in an area from which we already have a reliable fossil record, which of the known
fossil discoveries could genuinely be Denisovan ancestors? Although fossil samples exhibit
significant morphological variability, none of the later archaic Chinese fossils or comparable
material from Sunda or Seoul have produced ancient DNA sequences to date. The mandibles
of fossils from China, such the Penghu mandible dredged from the sea near Taiwan, and the other
fossils, indicate that these two specimens are unlikely to represent the same species of human.
Lineage X, the ghost population, seems to be as good a moniker as any for this mysterious human
group, until more complete Denisovan material is retrieved, or until additional ancient DNA
that is Denisovan-like is isolated from other fossils in Asia or Oceania. Another theory that
fits with this is that the Siberian Denisovan was not a legitimate taxonomic group, but rather a
population of Neanderthals that had mated with a local primitive hominid. In other words, the
reported presence of both the Denisovan and Neanderthal DNA in the same Denisova cave is
attributed to individual, genetic variation within the same population, rather than alternating
occupations by different subspecies. Some of the group members inherited unmixed Neanderthal
nuclear DNA, while others did not, and the more ancient mitochondrial DNA identified for the
Denisovans. In any case, the discussion suggests that the southern Denisovan may not be identical
to the original Siberian Denisovan, and that the former may be represented in the known fossil
samples from South or Southeast Asia.
