The Role Of The British Royal Family And Influence On Politics _ Our History

Museum Mysteries
14 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 28, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The annual state opening of Parliament is a magnificent royal event,
but it's not just a glittering show. Beyond the diamonds and gold, red velvet and ermine,
the entire ritual symbolizes the role of the monarch at the apex of the British political
system. A system of government that has not changed in its fundamentals for hundreds of years.
The monarchy is absolutely central to the political system of the United Kingdom
and this means for example we're largely the last ancien regime state, the last truly medieval outfit
in full working order anywhere in the advanced world. Most of our institutions were formed in
the middle ages and you could argue that the genetic code, the DNA of any institution
is formed obviously when it comes into being and you get mutations around the edges thereafter but
it's still recognizably the same and as we're ancient and settled have been on this particular
political patch for a very long time with roughly the same borders with very few breaks of any kind
that we are still on medieval DNA. Most people today tend to assume that despite the trappings
the political role of the monarchy is wholly symbolic, long since stripped of any real
significance. In fact the monarchy continues to have a great impact on the character of British
politics and the Queen herself still plays the pivotal role in the political system. Parliament
itself has its origins in the court of the English kings of the middle ages and sitting
today in the former royal palace of Westminster it is still a fundamentally royal institution.
Madam Speaker, the Queen requires the attendance of this honourable house
immediately in the House of Peers. The symbol of the sovereign's authority,
the mace, rests on the table between her majesty's government and her majesty's opposition
and all bills must receive royal assent before they become law. But while the same institutions
still exist, what has changed since the middle ages is the balance of power. The British Prime
Minister is the strongest chief executive anywhere in the Western world because he's largely taken
the absolute powers of the monarchy unto himself or herself. It's quite wrong to think they shifted
to Parliament. The line is always that sovereignty is the Queen in Parliament. Most of the powers
that matter stopped halfway between the palace and Westminster in number 10 Downing Street,
either exercised by individual secretaries of state or by the Prime Minister. All the ones
that matter, peace, war, recognising countries, unrecognising countries, are royal prerogatives
but they're carried out for the Queen by the Prime Minister. So those powers are royal powers
but they're put into commission with civilians, properly elected civilians I have to say,
but still the basis of that power is royal. And while the Queen no longer has the absolute
powers of her forebears, she still plays a central role in the system and retains two of the most
important powers in the political life of the country. The power to dissolve Parliament and
the power to appoint the Prime Minister. In March this year, the Privy Council of senior cabinet
ministers assembled at Buckingham Palace following the Prime Minister's decision to call a general
election. The Queen's power to dissolve Parliament is the most important surviving power under the
prerogative. The Queen of course exercises it on the advice of her ministers and has just agreed
to the Prime Minister's request for a dissolution. The proclamation, the terms of the proclamation
are actually approved in a meeting of the Privy Council and at that meeting the Queen signs the
proclamation itself and this is the document which the Queen has just signed. I will take
this to the Crown Office in the House of Lords where the great seal is kept, where this
document will be sealed and that will have the effect forthwith of dissolving Parliament. And
while the Queen has never forced a dissolution or refused one, it remains an important power.
Suppose you had a government which refused to go to the country after its five years were up.
Could the Queen dismiss it? Quite possibly she could. Suppose you had a government which wanted
a dissolution at a time of national emergency, perhaps at a time when you had a threat to the
currency. Could the Queen refuse a dissolution at that time? Possibly again she could. In emergency
circumstances the sovereign could exercise quite considerable influence. The Queen's other more
sensitive prerogative power is that of appointing the Prime Minister. Most of the time this is the
formality of appointing the captain of the winning team. But when she does have to exercise
her powers she risks being drawn into a political controversy. In 1963 Harold Macmillan, the Prime
Minister, had to retire because of ill health. Very graciously the Queen came to the hospital
to consult with Mr Macmillan on the appointment of his successor. As the Conservative party didn't
hold leadership elections then, the Queen had to make the choice herself. Rab Butler was the
strongest candidate, but on Macmillan's advice the Queen chose an outsider, Lord Hume. Lord Hume
accepted Her Majesty's invitation. He was now on his way to number 10 as Prime Minister, an office
few people until recently ever thought would be his. Now Alec Douglas Hume was a very controversial
choice. There were three other candidates including R. A. Butler who many thought should have been
chosen. However it wasn't for the Queen to intervene in the internal processes of the Conservative
party. It wasn't for her to question the way these processes had worked out. Had she done so that
would have been controversial and possibly even unconstitutional. Nevertheless the palace was
caused some embarrassment. And mercifully for the Queen, and I'm sure to her great relief, the
Conservatives made sure that she was never so embarrassed again because that was the last time
emerged. They've resorted to for them a novel device called votes to choose their leaders
subsequently. But the Queen still faces the risk of involvement in a dangerous political controversy
if there is no clear result in a general election. Following the general election in February 1974,
although the Tory Prime Minister Ted Heath had fewer MPs than the Labour party,
he did not resign and spent four days trying to organise a coalition with the Liberals.
Well we obviously talked about the situation which has arisen as a result of the general election.
And the Queen has been attacked for the role she played. And no commitments were entered into.
The Queen said to Ted Heath, the Conservative Prime Minister, if you can form a government
I'm prepared to accept it. So despite the fact that that Tory government had been defeated
by the people at a general election, the Queen was quite prepared to give the Tories another run.
It was only because the Liberals couldn't get their act together with the Tories that Harold
Wilson then was able to form a minority Labour government. Now that is real power. So don't let
anybody tell me that the Queen doesn't have political power. She does. But this account
of the Queen's role is disputed. The Queen remained entirely passive in 1974. There was
no question of calling anyone to the palace. Edward Heath remained Prime Minister and until
he resigned there was no vacancy. But the Queen made no decisions herself. She allowed the
politicians to sort things out and then just registered the decision. And that on the whole
is how the monarchy works in the modern constitutional system of Britain. But it's clear
that situations like this put the Queen in a difficult position. In March this year all the
polls pointed to another hung parliament. And so procedures for protecting the Queen were put into
operation. The files were retrieved from the last time this had happened in February 1974.
All the precedents were brought into place and the three party political leaders were called
in for little private chats and told how they must conduct themselves. Now essentially this
fixing was done by three people, none of whom has ever been elected to anything. They're called the
Golden Triangle for short and they are the Queen's Principal Private Secretary Sir Robert Fellows,
the Prime Minister's Principal Private Secretary Andrew Turnbull and the Cabinet Secretary Sir
Robin Butler. So it was all ready to go and I think to their considerable relief however
they didn't actually have to try it this time to try and do the fixing because there's always the
nagging worry at the back of their minds that it will go wrong because there are so many possible
combinations. It only has to go wrong once and the monarchy is seen to be politicised.
The Queen's unique position in the constitution places her above the law and gives her the right
to influence acts of parliament that may affect her. Every time a piece of legislation is proposed
to go through parliament it is looked at by people on behalf of the Queen to make sure that the
Crown's historic interests are not altered. Queen's staff, the household, are very zealous in her
service. They're very anxious to protect her interests and sometimes they put up a very tough
battle with the government department about some provision in a bill which they feel is not
appropriate in relation to the Queen. For example while the royal household used to be subject to
the laws on racial discrimination it was made exempt under the 1976 Race Relations Act. It
would have happened because the palace would have made some objection about being subjected to the
procedures laid down by the Race Relations Act, industrial tribunals and the activities of the
Race Relations Commission and so on. But why is the Queen exempt from the laws that bind
everyone else in the country? Well the courts are the Queen's courts and the Queen, the sovereign,
the Crown, is the source and symbol of justice in our system. Since that is the formal position
it seems right that legislation should not be passed which would have the effect as it were of
creating a possibility of the Crown being taken to court. Action will be taken to combat crime.
The monarch's position in Britain's unwritten constitution is further protected by the rule
which prevents MPs from examining such matters as royal employment practices or the Queen's finances.
And we can't ask questions either on a weekly basis as we do to the Prime Minister
or through a select committee. That was tried and the household said we are not going to answer.
There was no way of making them answer on behalf of the Crown. If the monarchy can be criticised
in the House of Commons, if the personality of the monarch can be attacked, then inevitably that
would call sooner or later for the monarch to be able to reply to those attacks and one then gets
the argy-bargy going on and inevitably sooner or later a spokesman for the monarch saying
this and a spokesman for the other side saying that. I don't think that would be at all useful
in our constitutional life. Some things work and work well and I see no good reason for changing
what has worked extremely successfully. So the monarch does have a substantial formal role
and powers in the British constitution but equally important is the Queen's informal
influence on her Prime Ministers. It has always been Sir Winston's habit when Prime Minister
to have an audience of the Queen on Tuesday nights at Buckingham Palace. When the Queen
and the Prime Minister are in London they meet every Tuesday evening for a consultation on
government policy and it's there that a wise Sovereign can exercise a very considerable degree
of influence. After all the present Queen has known nine Prime Ministers from Winston Churchill
to John Major. The trouble is we can't really estimate how much influence the Sovereign exerts
because of necessity this influence must remain secret. It's part of the essence of
constitutional monarchy that the Sovereign's political views must remain absolutely private.
So it's not until the archives are opened in perhaps 30 or 50 years time that we will know
what influence the present Queen has exerted. I've worked for a succession of Prime Ministers who
have enormously valued what they get from their weekly audience with the Queen in terms of
very penetrating and shrewd questioning and expressions of judgment and view. Harold Wilson
was one Prime Minister who laid particular stress on the importance of his relationship
with his Sovereign. It is perfectly clear that Wilson attached or might almost say inordinate
importance to his relationship with the Queen. He really valued tremendously the hour he spent
once a week in a private audience with her. He would spend a long time preparing for it,
he would emerge from it in a state of euphoria. He had always had this feeling that people were
getting at him and that they had designs on his position and here was somebody with whom he
legitimately discussed all the great matters of state but who could not possibly be after his job
and so I think the Queen from that point of view did represent somebody very special to him.
There is also of course a Republican tradition in the Labour Party.
But in general the monarchy's relationship with the Labour Party has been remarkably amiable.
The Labour Party has come from an origin which it was seen back in the 20s, the beginning of
the century, to be a potentially subversive organisation and in those days therefore
needed to establish beyond any doubt whatever that it was not a subversive organisation and
an easy way to do that is to is to show how monarchist you are. One minister in Harold
Wilson's cabinet had had decidedly Republican sympathies when she joined the party.
As I grew more experienced in the political world I realised of course that this country
is not a Republican country, it's monarchist in a rather mild sense but still a very
sentimentally monarchist and therefore it was political suicide to fight on a Republican platform.
So I accepted the monarchy and I have to admit that I came to admire
the adaptability of the Queen and her entourage.
Prince Philip accompanied her and Mrs Barbara Castle, Minister of Transport, was there to see
the great new road link put into operation. Whatever they thought of the Labour government
never passed their lips or even their eyes. They just treated us so we were a friend of
the family who dropped in you know. This government, this government of principle.
Since the 1970s the royal relationship with the Conservatives,
the natural party of Queen and country, has been rather more difficult.
There are those who say our nation no longer has the stomach for the fight.
I think I know our people and I know they do. The royal family does not want anybody on the right
or the left to rock the boat. As long as we all know our place and all do our allotted
roles in society within the consensus that has grown up, the royal family is delighted.
And the kind of anti-consensus, radical right policies that Mrs Thatcher was introducing
to make this a much more vibrant dynamic market economy were just as anathema to the royal family
as left-wing policies because it produced the miners' strike and instead of the usual British
compromise and sell out and give the miners what they want attitude Mrs Thatcher said no we're
going to fight the miners. The first cavalry charge came a few minutes later. In the climate
of confrontation of the 1984 cold strike it was to the Queen that the wives of striking miners turned.
We were getting battered to death on the picket lines by the police.
Now we'd heard in the press at the time that Thatcher and the Queen didn't get on
and a lot of miners' wives were royalists so they said I know let's write to the Queen let's tell
her how we feel and we thought well at least we've one thing in common with the Queen she doesn't
like Thatcher and we don't like Thatcher so we'll ask if she can help so we got this petition together
a group of women against pick closures and we came we wrote and they said we could bring the
petition to the Queen and we really had a lot of faith in that petition. Although we were
some of us weren't royalists we just had the image of the Queen being the mother of the nation
and as we were mothers in struggle we thought maybe she would at least try to understand
what we were trying to do. We knew that politically she wouldn't have any power as
such to help us but that she would probably pass the petitions on to government ministers
and at least maybe if they could ignore letters directly from us then they couldn't ignore the
letter once it had been passed from the Queen. Though the palace did pass the petition on to
the government it is impossible to know whether the Queen really had any sympathy for the striking
miners because she is constitutionally forbidden from involving herself in such political disputes.
However two years later the Sunday Times caused a storm when it alleged that the Queen was
secretly campaigning against the government's policies. Its story claimed that the Queen feared
that Mrs Thatcher was damaging the fabric of British society and that her policy on South
Africa might destroy the Commonwealth. We knew that the Queen and other members of the royal family
were worried and disliked the direction that the Thatcher government was going in a whole host of
areas. We knew that because we were being briefed by members of the royal family and their surrogates
themselves. We weren't alone in that. Huge chunks of the British press were being briefed in that
way. The difference was that I was not prepared to play the game in to allow a whispering campaign
like that against the government to take root without revealing the source. The Queen's private
secretary took the unprecedented step of writing to the Times in his own name to deny the story
though he did say that the Queen had the right even the duty to advise the government.
So it is clear that far from having a purely ceremonial role in the British political system
the Queen has both formal power and informal influence and indeed rather than decline the
political role of the monarch may actually increase in the years ahead. There's a good
possibility that we'll have proportional representation in Britain within say the next
decade. Now PR would very considerably affect the role of the monarchy because after all it would
mean that almost every parliament would be a hung parliament. As a result the Queen would be actively
involved in appointing the Prime Minister not just occasionally but after every election. If that were
to become her normal level of political involvement fresh impetus might be given to the
campaign to do away with all royal prerogative powers. First of all we have to remove the royal
prerogative and ensure that the powers of the Prime Minister and government are laid down in
a proper constitution and made really accountable to parliament and secondly we have to remove the
monarch from the political sphere so that her role becomes a purely ceremonial and not a political
one. Instead of the monarch having the power to decide who should be Prime Minister it should be
a matter for a vote in parliament itself and that the Speaker should if necessary decide who should
be called on to be Prime Minister. This is what the Queen has seen happen to her distant relative
the King of Sweden now a purely ceremonial figure whose political powers have been transferred to
the Speaker of the Parliament. Opinion is divided over whether such a reduction in the Queen's
political role would benefit the constitution. Well somebody has to take the responsibility
and the important thing is to have somebody who is impartial and an hereditary monarch is much
more likely to be impartial than an elected official because an elected official however
lofty is always going to be looking back over his shoulder at the people who elected him so I think
it's the guarantee of impartiality and fairness which commends a hereditary monarch in this
situation. I think you're in very great difficulties if people say well election is a bad thing because
if you can't trust the people to elect a president why should you trust them to elect a member of
parliament why should you trust parliament to elect a Prime Minister and I think the argument
about democracy and voting producing bad results is itself funnily enough a product of the whole
anti-democratic culture we live in that somehow be better for somebody who was above politics who
we couldn't remove having the job. And with the loss of its political role the prestige and
significance of the monarchy might never be the same again. I think if the Queen lost any
constitutional role and was just a kind of decorative function I think the monarchy would
still go on but I think it would be much less of a force in uniting the country I think it would be
like the nobility the dukes and earls you know they're there and they decorate the countryside
and they have palaces and all the rest of it but they don't really matter to us because they don't
have any particular function in government. The greatest pressure for the kind of constitutional
change that might affect the monarchy comes from outside Westminster, from Scotland and from Europe.
