The Greatest Rivalry in Fencing History

Fencing
1 follower
2 Video Views·Jan 24, 2026
Fencing with Max Heinzer is one of the best things a fencer can do because he's obviously
one of the best. The year is 2008. Europe is the fencing powerhouse and two future
titans of epic fencing have just watched other fencers from their respective nations,
Switzerland and France, leave for the Beijing Olympics. With one of them failing to make the
national team and the other not even able to qualify his team, these two fencers would take
it upon themselves to change history.
Nice hit. He's working it.
Superb first period gold medal on the way here for one of these fencers. What a hit that was.
The next 12 years would spark one of the only rivalries seen in men's epic fencing,
but before this rivalry can be explained or covered, we first have to understand why
rivalries such as these are so rare in epic fencing. Unlike other weapons, the results
in epic tournaments can be quite random. An early lead and even a rather inexperienced fencer can
easily defeat the top seed for a tournament, leading to very inconsistent results. A fencer
could finish an entire season without winning a single world cup, grand prix, or zonal championship
and still have the top spot of rank one. In other weapons, like saber and foil,
the rule of right of way acts as something of a safety net for better fencers. They're able to
set up actions using right of way to at least prevent their opponents from scoring a hit.
However, epic fencing does not incorporate right of way, meaning there is no safety net to fall
back on. A hit is a hit, no matter who scores it. The first fencer to break out onto the scene,
eager to claim Europe's top spot, was Max Heinzer, a flashy Swiss fencer who in 2009
would break into the top 32 of a European zonal championship, finishing in 29th place,
shooting his rank up to number 31 in the world after some other impressive results.
At the same time, a young Yannick Borel would fight to make the incredibly strong French team.
However, due to the high skill of the French team at the time,
this would be an incredibly difficult challenge for young Borel.
Fencing tournaments are broken down into four major tournaments. World Cups, which are the
standard for gathering points, usually hosting both individual and team competitions. Grand
Prixs, which are World Cups but with slightly higher stakes, as they are worth more points and
are also significantly less frequent. Zonal Championships. These are very important. Each
zone contains one to two continents. Each country in said zone sends one team of four fencers to
compete with the other countries in their zone. These events are worth huge points, as they have
significantly less fencers in World Cups but allow very similar point distribution.
Tournaments typically range from around 32 to even 100 entries, compared to the 300 to 400
participants at most World Cups. It is also very important for each country's national team
because of the ability to much more easily acquire the points required to boost your team's rank.
The winner of each competition for both team and individual will skyrocket their points.
The other catch is that there is only one zonal championship each season. Now, with the most
complicated tournament out of the way comes the most prestigious, the World Championship. World
Championships are similar to zonal events, as each country is able to send a team consisting of three
to four fencers, who fence both in the team and in the individual event. This event is worth the
points by far, but it is also the hardest, as only the best fencers from each country qualify,
and there are typically between 200 to 300 participants at most World Championships.
So we're back to these two young fencers, one in Switzerland, one in France. Both countries in
Europe, both fencing powerhouses, and both in the same zone. Every year, to this day,
the European Championships are a spectacle, as the Europe zone boasts some of the strongest
and most skilled fencers ever to pick up a weapon. Safe to say they were quite an event,
and the perfect grounds for these two fencers to break their way into the world ranking.
The 2009-2010 season came along. If Heinzer wanted a chance to qualify for the Olympics,
he would have to give it everything he had. In order to qualify, he would either have to
along with the Swiss team, or be within the top four ranked fencers in the world who are unable
to qualify their team. If either of those options failed, his last resort was to be the highest
ranked fencer in his zone, who had yet to qualify. Meaning, he would have to be the highest ranked
fencer in all of Europe. As the 2009-2010 European Championships rolled around, Max Heinzer was ready
to bring his A game, while Borel still struggled to make it onto the French team. As countries
finalized their teams, Borel was still nowhere to be seen within the top four of France. Max used
this opportunity to show his flashy showmanship, easily making it into the top eight of the
European Zone Championship. Ending the 2009-2010 season ranked number 11 in the world, allowing him
to hold this position and rack up points for the 2011 season. This was important because it was
these points that would be used to determine who would qualify for the 2012 Olympics in London.
Borel, unfortunately, would not find the same success, ending ranked 103 in the world.
After these results, you may be wondering how this would shape up to be any sort of rivalry.
Max had every lead imaginable, and Borel was still standing in the shadow of some of the
greatest French fencers of all time. However, at this time, Borel's mindset had shifted. It was not
focused on conquering the European circuit, but rather simply entering the top four fencers in
France so he could join the team for the upcoming Olympics. The French's incredibly strong team
had easily qualified for the Olympics, ranking within the top four countries in the world,
meaning that they would send a team. The only question was, who would make that final four?
With the strength of the French team, names like Gunther Grumier were still spoken daily at the
time, who was one of the greatest Frenchmen to ever fence. There were severe doubts on whether
Borel would even be in the conversation for the French team. However, this year was about to get
even more strange. Due to a strange roulette system designed to give each weapon its own
time in the sun, this Olympic Games, the men's epee team event would be cut, meaning
qualification was different. Only two fencers from each country, Max, would be allowed to compete.
This meant Borel had a single season to climb to being ranked at bare minimum the second best
fencer in all of France. While Max had the much easier option of simply holding on to his spot
within the top 16 in the world, which he earned from the previous European Championship,
this almost guaranteed Max Heinzer Olympic qualification.
The 2011 season came about with ups and downs all around. Come the European Championship,
Max Heinzer wasn't simply going to roll his way across the finish line. No, instead, he opted to
finish in a flourish, as was something you could expect to see from him. He wouldn't simply finish
the tournament in the top 8 like last time, or even the top 16. He would climb his way all the
way to the podium, finishing with an impressive 3rd place, cementing his Olympic qualification
after finishing 8th in the entire world. Borel, on the other hand, was fighting for his life to
make it onto the French team. After being given his first opportunity to represent France at the
European Championship, Borel was determined not to fumble this opportunity. Finishing with an
impressive 11th place, and due to one of his teammates poor performances, Borel was able to
climb all the way up to rank 14 in the world, making him the second highest rated fencer in
France. Meaning that him and his senior, Gunther Grumier, would both go to the 2012 Olympics,
representing France. The Olympics would come about in 2012, and both Heinzer and Borel were eager to
prove themselves, but would both just fall short of winning a medal, with Borel falling at 7th
place and Heinzer at 12th. The next few years both fencers would work on maintaining their ranking,
suddenly fencing for more than an Olympic qualification, but now for a spot as the
most dominant fencer in Europe. This is where their rivalry truly began. For Heinzer, the years
would show just how dominant of a fencer he was, finishing with a bronze medal twice within the
three years at the European Championships, and even winning a few World Cups, leaving him ranked
as a top two fencer in the entire world. Things were looking great, not only for his individual
skill, but for the Swiss team as they were well within range for the Olympic qualification come
2016. Heinzer would cement himself in the top 8, dominating the international circuit with what
looked like extreme ease, winning tournament after tournament. Borel on the other hand,
would have a bit of a tumble, falling off of the French team once again and dropping all the way
to rank 36, then even further all the way down to rank 80, with many even considering that his
previous Olympic qualification was simply luck. As the 2014 season ended with Borel finishing in
the 80th rank and Heinzer being well within the top 8, 2015 would call to both fencers.
To Heinzer it would serve as a red carpet, for his waltz into the Olympic Games with the Swiss
team, where to Borel it shrieked of a final opportunity to regain what he lost, his place
on the French team, or else he would succumb to what many were whispering about, that he was simply
a one hit wonder, who would fade away into obscurity. The European Championship would
roll around in a classic Heinzer fashion, he was not content with simply finishing with a decent
placement and walking his way into the Olympic venue, no, he had other ideas, and with his eyes
firmly locked on the goal of European Champion, he was determined to make it happen. And it looked
like Max's dreams were coming true, as he advanced all the way to the final to fence against Yannick
Borel's senior Gunther Grumier for the title of European Champion. Grumier would defeat Max
Heinzer in the final of the European Championship, but where was his teammate Yannick Borel?
Nowhere to be seen. Unfortunately, missing his chance to qualify through the Zonal Championships,
it seemed the rumors of Borel's eventual fall off were coming to fruition.
However, the last tournaments of the season stood there, looming as a final opportunity
for Borel. A World Cup in Germany and a Grand Prix in Rio. With a good placement, Borel could
gain some momentum. Borel was off to a rocky start. However, on the other side of the bracket,
none other than Max Heinzer was fencing better than he ever had before, filled with the drive
to prove himself. Heinzer would advance all the way to the final, showing the world his signature
flashy style, gaining incredible momentum for the upcoming Olympics in Rio. However,
before him stood something that was both nostalgic and terrifying. Much like the European Championship,
before him, in the final, stood a Frenchman, daring to halt the momentum of the unstoppable
Swiss fencer. Yannick Borel had clawed his way into the final. This wouldn't be their first time
fencing. A bout in 2011 would leave Borel victorious. However, Heinzer and his coach
believed that foul play was afoot, and that can be seen through a YouTube video posted on Max's
YouTube channel, claiming that the referee won the bout for Borel. Here, they would stand again,
not for the first time and certainly not for the last. For Borel, this was everything. Everything
he needed to get the ball rolling, to prove himself, to be worthy of making the French team
and to qualify for the Olympics. Max was on top of the world, finally finishing the job he set out
to do at the European Championship, vanquishing the Frenchman in the final, with a flourish,
winning a World Cup, a feat many only dreamed of, and he would have the opportunity to win
an even more important event, the Rio Grand Prix. Heinzer was eager to gain every possible advantage
he could for the upcoming Olympics. He was seated second in the tournament, the second best fencer
in the entire world. This tournament could be his chance to grab rank one and head into the
Olympics with the top seed. However, a ghost of the last tournament reared its head in defiance.
Once again, on the opposite side of the bracket was a vengeful monster that had crawled its way
all the way to the final, trained up, rebuilt, and refocused with a single goal,
to win the Grand Prix and qualify for the 2016 Olympics in Rio.
And it worked again, this time he uses a beat to knock his opponent's blade out of the way
just long enough to launch into distance.
So Burrell now says, right, enough's enough, I'm going to come after you.
And a double is going to work much better in the Frenchman's favor, even at this stage of the match.
He's actually goading him, come and get me, come and get me.
And this time he does. Okay, I will. It's beautiful action from Yannick Burrell.
Feint into the chest, disengage to finish in the cease line. It's a mustn't rush.
Mustn't rush, he's got to build the hit up, he's got to lure Burrell in. Massive distance,
opening up the distance widely, the Swiss fencer, but Burrell patiently steps forward,
ever closer to his opponent, and when Feintzer jumped in that time, he was ready.
Burrell, they look well on their way to doing that here.
Oh, how Feintzer got away with that one, I'll never know.
Burrell's starting to feel the pressure maybe.
Oh, he's got flat-footed and the coach, the French coach comes storming out of the box.
Feintzer had him all wrapped up there, but he was unable to land a hit, and I don't know why
he's having his weapon tested, because I don't think he even attempted to hit Burrell there.
Well, as you said earlier today, it's the last gasp, your last chance,
and this is Feintzer's last chance. One point for Burrell, and he takes home the gold.
Oh, he's done it. Yannick Burrell shouts out to his teammates up in the stands. The coach
comes and dives on him. France have won six out of eight tournaments in the men's
category this season with six different fences. That is an amazing statistic
and an amazing finish for Yannick Burrell of France.
Burrell had finished the season ranked 14th in the world, and as such, qualified for Rio 2016.
As the Olympics came to pass, both Heinzer and Burrell ended just short of a medal once again.
Heinzer finished in seventh place and Burrell in fifth. Burrell would not leave empty-handed,
however, as his teammate Gunther Grumier would win bronze in individual, and together with the
rest of the French team, they would win the 2016 Men's Epee Team event. Even after winning the
team event, Burrell was hungry for more, and Heinzer still felt like he had something to prove.
This season would prove incredibly important, as it would serve as the platform that they would
begin their climb, with neither of them dropping from the top 16 in the world again until 2022.
Eager to finally prove himself in his own continent, Burrell was on fire, winning match
after match, advancing all the way to the semifinal. On the other side of the bracket,
Heinzer also advanced to the semifinal. Fed up with silver, he was eager to claim a gold medal,
no longer for rank, but for his pride and for his country. Determined, he advanced to the final,
awaiting the winner of the opposite side semifinal. Again they faced each other, again in the final,
and again a Frenchman stood in Max Heinzer's way of claiming the title of European Champion.
This time, he would not make a mistake. This time, he would prove not only to be the strongest
fencer in Europe, but also to be the stronger fencer between him and his European counterpart,
Yannick Burrell. Ammo would ensue as the stakes and tensions were clearly high. Burrell's defenses
would voluntarily be dropped when someone in the crowd, or potentially someone from one of
the fencer's camps, yelled HALT early, allowing Max Heinzer to receive an easy hit.
It wasn't me, I didn't call HALT.
Now they can call it because there's no sound on the video replay.
There's a big discussion going on. Remember the director of technique, the organizing committee,
down there talking to the referee and the video referee. Here we have the replay,
but we don't hear when the HALT is called. Yeah, no, they have decided and I think that
extra help from the organizing committee. They have a group of three that help adjudicate
questioned calls and I think that decision was made from the director of technique. They said,
look, you did call HALT and you can't allow that hit. They really came into that at all.
Another breakout of frustration. As Heinzer would stop the bout, claiming a calf cramp after failing
an attack. This stoppage would stop Burrell from launching his counter offensive and potentially
scoring a point with momentum on his side. Wrong, unsure, very unorthodox, only able to
double there. Burrell staying very calm. This is classic French fencing versus unorthodox
Swiss fencer. Comes waving his epee and then I think that's a little careless against a
tall and long reaching French fencer. Burrell can taste this. Oh, a lovely attack from Yannick
Burrell let us down at all. Superb first period gold medal on the way here for one of these
fences. What a hit that was. Right here, if Heinzer is able to close this parry on Burrell,
he will block out the French fencer, gaining momentum and allowing for an easy attack off
the line to a shaken Burrell. Unfortunately, Burrell is too strong and he would claim his
first ever European championship, defeating none other than Max Heinzer in the final.
Burrell in close quarters, lands the gold medal hit. He is the European champion,
dived on by his coach Hugh O'Brie. What a brilliant fight. Incredible. Yannick Burrell,
2016 Men's Epee champion. But what a match that was. The next season would be known by some as
the reign of Burrell. He would win everything there was to win. Grand Prix after Grand Prix,
medal after medal. When that season's world championship came around, he had no problem
taking the gold from a previous Olympic champion. He finished rank two in the world for one season
and then decided to clean rank one for two seasons in a row. Think your way out of it.
Quit thinking. While Burrell was hardly on his seat, sat down for about 10 seconds,
then up and ready to go. He's certainly up for this, is Yannick Burrell. He's not going to wait
for Leonardo Gascon to attack. And that time, Yannick Burrell didn't actually defend himself,
he just made sure that he could land a double. That brings the score into double figures for
the French fencer. 10-3 now, 15 the target. And doubles really do come into their own now,
and they will only favour the Frenchman. A copy of the previous fight, pressing forward.
Another double scored. I mean, we are now almost a minute into the second period,
and Ruben Lamardo has only scored two solo points. There's still plenty of time in the
match, but not much room on the scoreboard. Burrell not having any, still waiting around.
This is classic Yannick Burrell. It is. And what's so great about it is that he hasn't done it
by... there hasn't been any bullying, there hasn't been any sort of slugging and, you know,
really battling it out. It's all precision from Burrell. A lot of the time he's mixed it up. He's
either waited for Leonardo Gascon to attack him, and either doubled it out, or avoided the attack
and scored the point, or he's gone in and attacked himself. And the variation and the skill level
from Yannick Burrell has been quite incredible. And a single hit fittingly takes him to the target
score of 15. And Yannick Burrell, the European champion, is now the champion of the world.
There's a fabulous performance from him. That was textbook. And to hold
Ruben Lomardo to two solo points in a world championship gold medal match,
it really hats off. Heinzer would remain in the top 16 for many years to come,
even defeating Yannick Burrell in 2017, though footage of this bout has since been taken down
off the internet. Heinzer knew to find his way back into the spotlight. He trained and trained,
fighting to grow as a fencer and to regain the favor of the ranking. However,
he would be knocked out in the round of 64 in both the 2017 and 2018 European Championships.
And Burrell? Well, he would go on to win both events with ease, becoming a three-time European
champion. So 10 apiece, 11 apiece, that is five doubles. Mashalov, that was sublime.
Well, the doubles matter because it'll tick the scoreboard along. But why are they happening?
Burrell's attacking, but he's not getting rid of Mashalov's blade. You know what,
now they're in a liability. Right, another double will give the match to Mashalov if Burrell
attacks and he isn't able. Well, he's done it with a level. Okay, shoelace. It's an actual shoelace.
Sometimes fencers have been known to play for time by redoing their shoelaces,
but that one was actually undone. That's the pressure. Here it is, last hit. It's a double.
Okay, 14 apiece. The first single light on will give the win. Oh, and it's for Yannick Burrell.
Yannick Burrell defends his European title and he makes it a three-peat.
He's won this tournament three years in a row. He just, he had the momentum. Yeah, well,
he just, he willed that to happen. He just pulled his way in there.
And Mashalov is trying to close the distance there in the end.
Yannick Burrell does it again. He's defended his European championship title.
Burrell drops his mask onto the paste and Mashalov wants him carded. Yeah, I think that was said. It
was a joke. In jest. The next years were rocky, as with the emergence of COVID-19,
many fencers simply stopped practicing as they were unsure what the future would hold.
And with no one to practice with, these seasons fell mostly into obscurity. At the time,
Asian teams began to get stronger. With funding changes in Hong Kong and a change of coaching
staff in Japan, Europe's domination was suddenly in question. But that question would have to wait
until after the lockdown, as Burrell and Heinzer both waited patiently for the season in which they
would both be permitted to fence again. The year is now 2022. The Olympics for 2020 have finished.
Heinzer and Burrell finished with somewhat mediocre results. However, Burrell's teammate,
Romain Canhomme, would go on to take the gold medal in the individual event. However,
in the team event, Team France would fall to Team Japan, and the Swiss team would finish second last
in the entire tournament. It seemed that the lasting reign of the European domination was now
over. Burrell and Heinzer would each try for one more Olympic Games. They would meet in the last
16 of a World Cup, where Max Heinzer would get the better of Burrell in a bout, beating him 15-14,
and this momentum would carry into the European Championship. Heinzer was back on his game,
winning bout after bout after bout, making it all the way to the last 8,
where he won again, advancing to the semi-final and claiming a guaranteed medal.
And his semi-final was against none other than Yannick Burrell. And this semi-final would be
the last time these two fencers would ever cross blades. Neither of them were young anymore,
this would be their last attempt at Olympic qualification before retirement,
so this tournament meant everything, and you could see it in their game.
Max Heinzer would fall to Yannick Burrell, who would go on to win the tournament 15-1
in the final, winning the European Championship for a fourth time, and qualifying along with
Team France to Paris 2024. And Heinzer would unfortunately lose his spot in the Olympics
to the younger Swiss fencer Alexis Bayard, who had been waiting for this chance to
travel to the Olympics. Heinzer would then retire in June of 2024.
Burrell had one more Olympics before retirement. He had come back from a broken foot,
and one of his first tournaments back, he would defeat Gergely Tsiklossi in the final
of the Budapest Grand Prix to cement his return to the piste, and was now thirsty for the gold
medal at the Olympics. Unfortunately, the Olympics are very particular as to which videos I'm allowed
to show you, so I'll be unable to show you any of Burrell's bouts for the 2024 Olympics at Paris,
his home. At age 35, Yannick Burrell would fall in the final to Keino Koki of Japan,
and retire happy with his own individual Olympic medal. As his torch burned out,
he left a legacy as one of the greatest fencers to ever hold an epee, and his rivalry with Max
Heinzer would go down as one of the greatest in history. Both Max Heinzer and Yannick Burrell
were two of the greatest fencers in their generation, and would leave lasting legacies
with many fans, and their battle to be the champion of Europe will be looked back on for many years.
Thank you all so much for watching, take care.
