2026 Regular Session - Day 13 - Comments on HB 312 | Rep. TJ Roberts

Kentucky House GOP
24 followers
Jan 23, 2026
I believe a reality check is in line for this body before we take this vote.
Because safety does matter.
The numbers support the notion that Americans are safer in a well-armed society.
Defensive gun uses from the Department of Justice National Crime Victimization Survey,
the numbers vary, but the conclusion they ultimately came to is that every year there
is anywhere between 500,000 to 2.5 million defensive gun uses in the United States.
The National Gun Violence Archive maintains that it's 2,000.
The reason for that discrepancy, Mr. Speaker,
is that those are the instances where the firearm is actually fired.
This varies significantly.
Another study from the same institute showed that for home invasions,
in 31% of incidents where a person defended themselves,
the mere mentioning that they are armed is sufficient to dissuade an attacker,
to dissuade an invader.
Once that firearm is shown but not fired, the number rises to 91%.
These are just what we know of.
Further, we can look to the injury reports for those who have been the victims of any violence.
For men, from the same Department of Justice study,
for men, if you comply with an attacker, you are 140% more likely to be injured
than if you defended yourself with a firearm.
If you fought back without a firearm, it rises up to 150%.
The numbers are even more stunning for women.
Women who comply with an attacker rather than defend themselves with a firearm are 250%
more likely to be injured.
If they fight back without a firearm, that's 400%.
We shouldn't ask Americans to put themselves into harm's way
when they are confronted with an attacker, whether armed or unarmed.
Now, to the point about the issue with children.
Any death of a child is tragic and should be prevented.
But the CDC, when they made the assertion that it is the number one killer of children,
they lied through their teeth and delegitimized themselves as an institution.
First, the CDC in that study did not include infants,
although they include infants in every other study relating to children.
Second, they included 15, 16, and 17-year-olds when they didn't include those age groups
for other safety studies with the CDC.
When you accounted for those discrepancies and actually condensed the numbers,
it goes down from first to 19.
Perhaps that's not a good talking point for the stump speeches.
But to the points of other studies as well, on studies pertaining to gun control,
the Grand Corporation, which is the corporation that looks to statistical significance
and the reliabilities of studies,
showed that there were more than 22,000 studies on gun violence and gun control.
And out of the studies, only 123 showed that it met minimum competence.
And the ones that make the headlines are not the ones that meet minimum competence.
As to the point of alcohol use, that is not a constitutional right.
The right to keep and bear arms is clearly enshrined and has been in our country
for almost 250 years.
And to the point of hunting, which by the way, I'm sure there are folks in this chamber
who remember the days when school children would have a firearm on their truck rack
during hunting season.
And there weren't an epidemic of violence at the time.
So it's not the presence of firearms.
There's clearly something else.
I reject that premise.
But the Founding Fathers, when they enshrined the Second Amendment,
they were not on a hunting trip for deer.
They had just finished a revolution against a tyrannical government.
The Second Amendment is our insurance policy.
These young people, yes, the prefrontal cortex doesn't fully develop
until well after one hits the age of 18.
That is correct.
But we trust them to drive.
We trust them to vote, which can have an effect on four and a half million Kentuckians.
But ultimately, there is a secret to this.
Every 18 to 20 year old who wants to carry a concealed firearm
probably already does in this Commonwealth.
I'll take the fifth on if there was ever a point where I was one of those 18 to 20 year olds.
But that's a point that we have to consider.
But further, we don't restrict constitutional rights in other areas because of misuse.
We don't initiate prior restraint because someone might defame another person
in violation of the First Amendment.
In violation of the Fourth Amendment, we don't get rid of the warrant requirement
because someone might conceal evidence in their house.
We don't override the Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial
because a jury might get a verdict wrong.
And we don't disregard the Eighth Amendment prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment
just because someone might get a sentence less than what they truly deserve.
So ultimately, Mr. Speaker, it is nonsensical to me that the right of lawful Americans
should ever be rendered forfeit just because somebody chooses to abuse theirs.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
