How Carrick Has TRANSFORMED Man Utd In Just 5 Days

EURO SPORT
31 followers
47 Video Views·Jan 23, 2026
Comments are disabled for this video.
Michael Carrick completely changed Man Utd's tactics and dominated Man City in a 2-0 win
after just five days in charge.
I'll be breaking down the new defensive shape of Man Utd, how Kobe Meinu has become
a key part of their midfield, and why Carrick doesn't even play with a striker.
So how did Carrick improve Man Utd so quickly?
And what problems did he solve right away?
Well, to understand this, let's break down each part of the team, starting with the defence.
So Man Utd's previous manager, Ruben Amorim, set up with three centre-backs, and their
goalkeeper frequently passed to one of them during build-up.
And their passing network shows that very few passes were played from the centre-backs
into midfield.
Check out Lenny Yoro in possession here.
A pass to Ugarte is difficult because he's sandwiched between two Aston Villa players.
The other central midfielder, Bruno Fernandes, is too high up the pitch to play into, so
Yoro is forced to play backwards.
Aidan Heaven faces the same problem, and is forced to pass sideways.
Luke Shaw passes to Kunja, who dropped deep to receive, but Villa remained comfortable
with Man Utd offering minimal threat through the middle of the pitch.
And Aidan Heaven's pass map shows that this was a consistent problem.
The majority of his passes were safe, played sideways or out wide.
And just three of his passes were played into the opponent's half.
This is where we see the first big change from Michael Carrick.
Because he switched their formation from a 3-4-2-1 to a 4-2-3-1.
Now they averaged just 32% possession against Man City, the least they've had this season.
But the way the centre-backs used the ball, it totally changed.
In comparison to Heaven's pass map under Amirim, let's have a look at Harry Maguire's.
Because it shows fewer sideways passes, and more intent to go and play the ball forward.
Alongside him, Lissandro Martinez played long-distance forward passes which were typically aimed
to the left-hand side of the pitch.
But this wasn't because of a lack of central options.
It was down to Carrick wanting to focus their play down that left flank.
Here's Martinez in possession with Luke Shaw as an option out wide.
Rico Luis is drawn out of position in anticipation of the pass.
But Luke Shaw's positioning is a decoy, allowing Martinez to play a disguised vertical
pass to Bruno Fernandes.
And with Kobe Menuh in close proximity, Bruno is able to quickly play the ball into him.
And this attracted several Man City players to one side of the pitch.
So Man Utd switched play to exploit the huge space on the right.
Another huge difference in Carrick's set-up was the use of his full-backs.
Ruben Amirim, of course, used wing-backs in his system, typically Dorgu and Deleux.
And you can see from their touch maps that most of their touches were very high, pushing
into the final third.
During build-up, the high positioning of the wing-backs meant that they weren't usually
involved.
So opponents were able to isolate the back three from their only forward options, the
midfield.
In Carrick's back four system, the full-backs are much deeper.
And this sees them have more touches in their own half, and that helps them during build-up.
On the left, Luke Shaw completed the most passes from the Man Utd back four against
Man City.
He holds a crucial role in progressing the ball into central areas.
Lamens plays it to Shaw here, who's in a deep starting position.
From there, Luke Shaw's instruction is to play the ball centrally, with striker Brian
Mbumo dropping deep to receive.
And this unsettles Man City's defensive shape.
Right back Rico Lewis presses the ball, and Kushinov is forced to cover the space that
he's vacated.
Luke Shaw drives forward to target this space, after helping the team progress the ball from
deep.
And this brings us to the midfield, where Carrick has already fixed another problem.
Here's Man Utd's passing network against West Ham under Ruben Amirim.
You've got Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes, who made up the midfield partnership.
But the distance between them here, it was an issue.
Casemiro frequently collected the ball from the back three, whilst Bruno played much higher.
And without that close passing option, it resulted in Casemiro taking five touches of
the ball before passing it backwards.
A Man Utd slow tempo made it pretty easy for the opposition to defend.
The same problem occurred higher up the pitch, with Casemiro receiving here.
Bruno stays high, but the passing lane is blocked.
Casemiro's only option was to pass sideways.
But Carrick's system really addresses this issue so brilliantly.
Man Utd now have a three-man midfield, as opposed to a two.
And check this out.
This is Casemiro's passing network from the Man City game.
And it shows that he regularly linked up with Mainu and Bruno Fernandes, forming a much
stronger connection.
So what changes took place for this to happen?
Well, to fully understand this, we need to zoom out, guys.
We're going to have to use the wide angle for this bad boy.
Casemiro and Kobe Mainu are close together.
When Deleuze switches the ball, they move in tandem to the other side of the pitch,
keeping the distance between them short.
We can see a 4-2-4 shape revealing itself, with Bruno staying high.
Mainu moves towards the ball and then goes away, dragging a Man City player with him
to open that passing lane to Casemiro.
Now, if we zoom in on Casemiro, we can see he's already scanning to check Bruno's positioning.
He receives the ball and he's able to play quick.
A quick forward pass with his first touch.
Despite Casemiro and Bruno being far apart, it's Mainu's clever movement that helped
them link up.
And he hadn't started a single Premier League game this season before Karrick arrived.
But now he's played a crucial role, becoming a go-between for players around him.
Don't believe me? Check this out.
Dorgo is in possession and Mainu gets really close to receive the ball.
After another quick pass, their close interchanges drew the attention of four Man City players centrally.
And what that did was it created space out wide to play the ball into and progress up the pitch.
But of course, this is a three-man midfield and one person that we haven't focused on yet
is Bruno Fernandes, who was absolutely stunning in this one.
Now, under Amirim, Bruno played in quite a deep role within the two-man midfield.
He got on the ball deep in his own half, with most of his touches in the middle third
and very few coming in the final third.
And this role saw him link the play rather than making things happen high up the pitch.
His attacking metrics took a drop.
An average of two passes into the penalty area per 90 is the lowest in six seasons.
But in Karrick's system, Bruno stays higher.
His heat map shows us that he spent most of his time in the opposition's half.
This is really cool. This is Bruno's passing sonar against Man City.
And it shows us that he rarely passed the ball backwards in this new role.
Bruno's higher starting position and Karrick's use of rotations were key to this.
And if we move to the wide camera here, we see exactly that.
Casemiro has the ball and Bruno is positioned high.
He moves to create a passing lane for Mbombo to drop into.
Ahmad then targets the space that Mbombo vacated and Bruno plays him in.
Look at how each player swapped positions here to complete this lovely move.
Bruno had freedom as well.
He also drifted over to the left-hand side to create overloads with Dorgoo and Shaw.
Like here, where Bruno receives from Shaw and plays a quick one-two to progress down the left.
This frees Dorgoo to become the spare man and he attacks the space in behind.
Bruno's high starting position also allowed them to create a front four when counterattacking.
With three bodies around him,
Bruno does what he does best by playing his teammates into dangerous areas.
Next up, we need to talk about the wingers.
Because out wide against Man City, Karrick set up with Dorgoo and Ahmad.
Under Ruben Amirim, both of them were used as wingbacks fairly frequently.
This meant that they weren't their primary focus in attack,
as there were three forwards in front of them too.
Their deeper starting position meant they were often the out ball for the midfielders
and they often received the ball on the back foot rather than being fed in behind.
And because of that, opponents could get players behind the ball
and interrupt any chance of Ahmad performing a take on.
Now, their average positions against Man City were also quite deep,
but with just 32% possession, they were naturally going to be that little bit deeper.
But in reality, their positioning was absolutely key.
Under Amirim, Dorgoo frequently held the width kind of on his own.
But now, when Bruno plays a ball into Dorgoo,
Shaw is already on his way to support him,
allowing Man United to have a pair on the left-hand side.
That's something that you might hear called double width.
And with Bruno coming over while Shaw holds the width,
Dorgoo is able to target the space in behind.
Look at this throw in.
Several Man United players come close, forcing Man City players, of course, to join them.
But cast your eye all the way on the other side.
Keeping his distance.
Yep, there he is.
Ahmad.
Bruno gives it to Kunya, and he instantly turns away to look for Ahmad in that space.
And then we see another rotation as Ahmad drops deep with Kunya,
then taking up the right wing spot.
And then who pops up at the back post to score?
The other winger, Dorgoo, allowed to remain high and target the box.
The final forward to analyse is Brian Mboma,
who was playing in a completely different role in this game.
Under Amirim, Mboma was brought into the side
to operate as a right attacking midfielder in the front three.
The bulk of his touches took place around the corner of the box,
and this positioning meant that he mainly received the ball to feet.
And because of that, opponents were able to get tight to him when shaping up to shoot,
resulting in difficult chances for him.
25% of his shots took place outside of the box this season.
This is Mboma's shot map.
The shots in yellow have a lower XG value, meaning they're a lot more difficult to score.
But under Karic, Mboma is playing in a new role as a striker.
His heat map looks completely different, and he's now a lot more central.
And there are two key aspects to this heat map.
Let's look at this part first.
So for this goal kick, Mboma takes a very important position,
because what he does is he remains parallel with Bruno Fernandes.
And that allows Man United to have a player either side of Rodri.
When Bruno moves over to the right, Rodri is watching him and the ball.
But by having Mboma dropping slightly deeper, it means that he's a central option.
And once he receives the ball,
he's able to play a quick bounce pass with Bruno due to their close proximity,
allowing Man United to utilize lovely rotation
as Ahmad moves to the middle where Mboma was with Deleux holding the width.
Now let's look at this area.
Due to Mboma being a natural winger, he's happy to gravitate into those positions.
And with his technical ability, Man United feels safe
in playing it into him and surrounding him with bodies for quick interchanges.
From there, Ahmad is able to play in Deleux,
making the late run and they overload the box.
And it almost results in a great chance.
Carrick has completely changed Man United after just one game in five days,
and currently they sit fifth in the table, just one point off the top four.
Someone else who's drastically transformed is this man.
To see why he's more dangerous than Erling Haaland, click here.
