Magic, Myths & Legends: 16 Best Fantasy Shows on Prime Video

Myths and magic
3 followers
In this video, we break down 16 must-see fantasy shows packed with magic, epic battles, and unforgettable worlds.
#FantasyShows #PrimeVideoFantasy #FantasySeries #PrimeVideoShows #BingeWatch
Hi! Welcome to Film Finds. Today, we're counting down 16 must-see fantasy shows you can watch
right now on Prime Video. From magic and monsters to witches and vampires, there's something
here for every fantasy fan. Don't forget to hit subscribe and ring the bell so you won't
miss our next list.
Number 16. Gryphon, 2023 Let's jump right in. If you're craving
high fantasy with a modern edge, Gryphon delivers a fresh take on the classic reluctant
hero narrative. Based on the best-selling German novels, this six-episode prime original
follows a trio of teenagers drawn into an alternate dimension ruled by a terrifying
beast. What sets it apart is its moody atmosphere and striking world-building. Think Stranger
Things meets The NeverEnding Story, but in German. It flew under the radar internationally,
but fans of dark teen fantasy consider it a hidden gem. If you're up for a short binge
with a lot of lore, Gryphon is your portal.
Number 15. Sanctuary, 2008-2011 Before Prime was packed with original content,
Sanctuary stood out as one of its earliest sci-fi-fantasy hybrids. Starring Amanda Tapping
from Stargate SG-1, the series explores a world where mythical creatures, called abnormals,
are very real and very dangerous. The show's use of virtual sets was groundbreaking at
the time, giving it a surreal digital aesthetic that still holds up today. Though it ended
after four seasons, Sanctuary built a loyal fanbase and remains a cult classic. It's
one of those shows that helped shape the early identity of streaming-era fantasy.
Number 14. Mayfair Witches, 2023 Anne Rice's universe expanded again with Mayfair
Witches, the moody, magical sibling to Interview with the Vampire. Alexandra Daddario leads
as Dr. Rowan Fielding, a neurosurgeon who discovers her dark, supernatural lineage.
The show blends medical drama, generational trauma, and shadowy covens into a sleek gothic
horror vibe. While Season 1 had mixed reviews, Season 2 is already showing stronger storytelling
and deeper worldbuilding. If witches with secrets and southern gothic vibes are your
thing, this one's worth the incantation.
Number 13. The Librarians, 2014-2018
Imagine if Indiana Jones, Doctor Who, and Buffy the Vampire Slayer had a baby. That's
the Librarians. Noah Weil reprises his role from the TNT movies, joined by a quirky team
protecting magical artifacts from falling into the wrong hands. It's light, fun, and
full of campy charm, mixing adventure with a weekly mystery-of-the-week format. The show
quietly ran for four seasons and still has a dedicated fanbase. If you want fantasy that
doesn't take itself too seriously, start checking out The Librarians.
Number 12. The Magicians, 2015-2020
Think Harry Potter, but for emotionally damaged grad students. The Magicians begins with a
group of students at Brakebills University learning real magic, and discovering it's
nothing like the fairy tales promised. The show evolves into a subversive, genre-bending
epic full of dark humor, shocking twists, and raw trauma. It may have started niche,
but by season five, it became one of sci-fi's most critically praised series. This is fantasy
that asks, what happens when magic isn't enough to fix you?
Number 11. Merlin, 2008-2012
A King Arthur retelling with youthful energy and a lot of heart, Merlin reimagines the
legendary wizard as a young man in hiding. Colin Morgan and Bradley James shine as Merlin
and Arthur, whose bromance carries the emotional weight of the series. It's packed with dragons,
destiny, and surprisingly dark plot arcs, all wrapped in BBC's signature fantasy flair.
While it flew under the radar in the U.S., it's a beloved cult hit across the globe.
For a mix of myth and magic, Merlin is one of TV's most endearing fantasy tales.
Number 10. Preacher, 2016-2019
If you like your fantasy sacrilegious and soaked in blood, Preacher is your chaotic
blessing. Developed by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg, this adaptation of the cult comic
follows a Texas preacher possessed by a divine force, giving him the power to command others.
It's absurd, violent, and relentlessly bold, with standout performances by Dominic Cooper
and Ruth Nega. While never a mainstream hit, it became a favorite among fans of twisted
genre TV. It's heaven, hell, and everything in between, all delivered with a cigarette
and a shotgun.
Number 9. The Strain, 2014-2017
Vampires, but make them viral. The Strain, based on the novels by Guillermo del Toro
and Chuck Hogan, offers a horrifying twist on vampire lore, more plague than fangs.
Corey Stoll plays a CDC doctor caught in the middle of a spreading ancient evil. The show
balances body horror, conspiracy, and mythology over four intense seasons. It's not for the
squeamish, but if you want your fantasy with fangs and fear, this one delivers.
Number 8. Carnival Row, 2019-2023
A noir fantasy mashup that oozes style, Carnival Row imagines a world where mythical creatures
are refugees in a Victorian dystopia. Orlando Bloom and Cara Delevingne lead the cast in
a tale of love, revolution, and wings. Visually stunning and politically charged, it attempts
ambitious worldbuilding even if not every thread lands. Season 2 wrapped the series,
giving fans closure, though not without debate. Still, it's one of Prime's boldest swings
in the fantasy space.
Number 7. Good Omens, 2019-2025
An angel and a demon walk into the apocalypse and decide to stop it.
Based on the beloved novel by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett, Good Omens thrives on
the chemistry between David Tennant's Crowley and Michael Sheen's Aziraphale. It's witty,
eccentric, and loaded with biblical satire and British charm. Season 2 stirred both love
and controversy with its bold emotional swing, and Season 3 promises even more surprises.
End times have never been so fun.
Number 6. The Leftovers, 2014-2017
Not traditional fantasy, but The Leftovers deals with the unexplained in the most haunting
ways possible.
Created by Damon Lindelof, it explores the aftermath of 2% of the world's population
suddenly vanishing. With stunning performances from Justin Theroux and Carrie Coon, the show
is meditative, mysterious, and emotionally raw. Though never a ratings hit, it's considered
one of the greatest shows of the 2010s. If existential fantasy is your flavor, The Leftovers
will destroy you in the best way.
Number 5. Grimm, 2011-2017
What if your day job involved hunting fairy tale creatures? Grimm follows Nick Burkhardt,
a homicide detective who discovers he's a descendant of guardians who protect humanity
from supernatural threats. It blends police procedural with German folklore in a surprisingly
seamless way. Spanning six seasons, it quietly built a strong fan base and explored its deep
mythology with care. It's classic monster-of-the-week TV, with a dark fairy tale twist.
Number 4. Penny Dreadful, 2014-2016
If gothic horror and literary monsters are your vibe, Penny Dreadful is a haunting delight.
Eva Green gives a career-defining performance as Vanessa Ives, a medium entangled in a spiritual
war. Featuring characters like Dracula, Frankenstein, and Dorian Gray, it's prestige horror with
operatic depth. It only ran for three seasons, but its visual style and emotional power left
a lasting mark. Sexy, scary, and sorrowful, this is horror-fantasy elevated.
Number 3. The Originals, 2013-2018
Vampires with royalty issues? Sign us up. The Originals, a spin-off of The Vampire Diaries,
centers on the first family of vampires reclaiming New Orleans. It mixes supernatural politics
with messy family drama and stylish bloodshed. Though often overshadowed by its parent show,
it built a darker, richer mythology that won over fans. If Vampire Diaries is teen angst,
The Originals is ancient vengeance.
Number 2. The Wheel of Time, 2021-2025
Amazon's answer to Game of Thrones is big, bold, and brimming with prophecy. The Wheel
of Time, based on Robert Jordan's sprawling fantasy series, stars Rosamund Pike as Moiraine,
a sorceress guiding a potential messiah. It's full of magic, political intrigue, and a world
with rich lore stretching back thousands of years. Season 3 solidified the show's footing
after a rocky start with stronger pacing and deeper character work. If you love epic fantasy
with prophecy and peril, this is one you don't want to skip.
Number 1. The Vampire Diaries, 2009-2017
Say what you will, but The Vampire Diaries defined an era of fantasy TV. Set in the haunted
town of Mystic Falls, it's a cocktail of vampires, witches, doppelgangers, and love triangles
that only gets more addictive with time. Nina Dobrev, Ian Somerhalder, and Paul Westinghouse
became icons of the genre, carrying a show that juggled camp and complexity surprisingly
well. Eight seasons later, it spawned two spinoffs and a fandom that's still going strong.
It may be dramatic, chaotic, and completely over-the-top, but that's exactly why it works.
And that's our list of 16 must-see fantasy shows on Prime. Which one's your favorite?
Or did we miss a hidden gem you love? Let us know in the comments. We'd love to hear
your picks. Thanks for watching Ubey Film. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and we'll
see you in the next countdown.
