Introduction to Jurisprudence.

History of Law
11 followers
#law #philosophy #education
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations & Further Reading:
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014).
R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020).
J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Hello everybody and welcome to a new series on the subject of jurisprudence.
This lesson is going to take an introduction to the subject of jurisprudence,
talk about some of the ways in which we define the subject,
some of the major theories of the subject,
the importance of this subject, as well as the scope of the series
that we are going to be covering over the next weeks and months on the Law Academy.
Now, this is the first lesson to the subject of jurisprudence.
Now, we are going to ask essentially the following questions.
We're going to be asking the first question, which is probably the most pertinent
for an introduction to jurisprudence course, which is, what is jurisprudence?
That is something that is going to be important for us to explore and examine
and to really get our heads around at the start of this series of lessons.
We're then going to talk about why jurisprudence is important.
This is often a question that is asked by law students specifically.
Now, because this is an open course for anybody who wants to have a look
and to watch this content, this might be content that is consumed by law students.
It might be content which is consumed by other students.
So, for example, philosophy students.
And so, as a result of this, the ways in which you view jurisprudence
may be indicative of which subject you are particularly studying.
For a lot of the time, and for a lot of people, the subject of jurisprudence
is one that is seen by at least law students as not particularly relevant
or important, and then at least by philosophy students
it is considered to be more important.
So, really, how you view jurisprudence at the outset is something
that can be indicative of your general approach.
Now, as a result of that, I would encourage anybody and everybody
who is watching this lesson, who is studying or maybe has a background
in any of these subjects, to put in the comments down below straight away
what your initial thought process and understanding and attitude
towards jurisprudence is at this early venture.
Do you think that jurisprudence is important?
Do you think it is a very useful and very important, as I said,
and vital part of study?
Or do you think that it is actually useless, not important,
and is just a tick-boxing exercise that you have to do
as part of your university course?
I'd be very interested to see how these attitudes actually lie
on the kind of law versus philosophy spectrum,
whether or not you're a lawyer or a philosopher.
And I sort of have an idea in the back of my mind already
as to what, depending on what subject you are doing,
what your general approach to jurisprudence will be.
We will also talk about some of the most important theories of jurisprudence,
arguably the two most important theories,
one of them being linked to the person who is pictured
at the top of the screen here.
Again, for those of you who want to engage with this lesson
in a bit more detail, put in the comments down below
who the person who is at the top of this screen actually is,
and I'll pin and I'll like and I'll heart the right answer
at the bottom of this YouTube video.
And then I'll finally think about and talk about the scope of this series,
so what we're actually going to be covering in this series,
but also what's important as well is what we're not going to be covering,
what areas of jurisprudence are not going to be part of the scope of this series.
Let's begin. What is jurisprudence?
Now, just like with a variety of different parts of law
and different areas of philosophy, sociology, criminology,
the concept of jurisprudence, in inverted commas,
isn't one which is necessarily easy to define.
It is a thing that you study and that you understand
more than a thing that you define.
We can get an etymological definition, i.e.,
what the word and the derivation of that word comes from,
but that doesn't necessarily give us any indication
as to how that word is used and how that word is defined
in today's colloquial understanding of the English language.
Now, things are made worse with the word jurisprudence
because the word jurisprudence is often used,
at least within the context of the legal tradition,
to refer to two different things.
It can be referred to as case law.
So, for example, if I'm talking about international law,
public international law, I might refer to the jurisprudence
of the International Court of Justice, the ICJ,
and that would be referring to the various cases
and the various precedents that are established
by the International Court of Justice,
or jurisprudence within the context of the criminal law,
within the common law jurisdiction of England and Wales.
Again, that refers to case law.
But that's not the kind of jurisprudence
that we're going to be talking about in this series.
That is the kind of jurisprudence that is going to be dotted around
all of our lessons on all of the various topics
relating to both domestic and international law,
as well as European law as well.
In fact, what we're going to be talking about
in this series of lessons is the idea of the philosophy of law,
or legal theory, or legal philosophy,
however you want to define it,
however your university defines it,
however your particular textbook defines it.
So we're going to be focusing on the latter of these two definitions
in this series of lessons,
and avoiding the idea of case law,
talking about the idea of the philosophy of law instead.
Now, ultimately, if we go to Blackstone's Law Dictionary,
we can see from Garner in 2009
that the concept of jurisprudence
and the tradition of jurisprudence that we understand today
is sort of born out of the 18th century, the 1700s.
And this will become very clear when we start to look at
one of our major theories of jurisprudence,
this being legal positivism.
We'll see that some of the most important approaches
from both the legal and the philosophical side of jurisprudence
comes out of the 18th century,
comes out of the works of people like John Austin,
John Stuart Mill, Jeremy Bentham, etc., etc.,
which sort of bridges the gap between law and ethics,
law and philosophy, law and politics.
And so as a result of which,
our modern understanding of where jurisprudence comes from
derives out of the 1700s,
the 18th century, should I say.
And despite this, however, it should be noted that
even though our modern understanding
and the sort of development of jurisprudence
comes out of this period,
the idea itself of jurisprudence
and some of the most fundamental philosophical principles
of jurisprudence pertaining to the idea of rules
and the idea of laws are actually far more ancient than that.
The first of our major topics on the idea of the natural law
comes out of the works of individuals such as Aristotle
and then into the sort of Christianization
and the Catholicization of academia
and the intellectual movements.
And this is, of course, what takes place in the ancient times
as we transition from ancient history
into the sort of early medieval period.
So even though jurisprudence is an 18th century development,
shall we say, the theories themselves derive
and are far, far older than that.
Now, jurisprudence in this context
would therefore be defined as, say,
the philosophy of law or the theory of law
or legal theory, etc., etc., etc.
And so for all intents and purposes,
this is actually a philosophical course,
but it is one that is important for any law student
who is also looking to have a deeper and richer
understanding of the law as well.
And this is really where we get into the question
of why we should study jurisprudence.
What is the purpose of studying jurisprudence?
If you are somebody who is a law student,
you might think, well, I don't really want to study jurisprudence.
Why do I have to sit in a seminar room
and discuss the philosophy of law
when I could go and revise the criminal code?
I can go and revise various tort cases
and actually these are going to be more important to me
in the real world as a corporate solicitor in London.
Well, in reality, jurisprudence is very, very important
and it sort of bridges the divide that we could say
exists between the descriptive and the normative study of law
because the vast majority of your studying of law,
especially in law schools in and around the world,
as I know in great detail,
is focused on the descriptive realities of law.
If you are doing an undergraduate degree in law in the UK,
for example, you will take exams
where you will just be given a problem question
and you will be told to apply the law to that problem question.
It's a very descriptive endeavour.
It is essentially asking you to identify the issues at hand
and to apply the law to those issues.
It's not particularly very normative.
It is asking essentially, what is the law?
How does the law work? How do we apply the law?
That is essentially it.
Now, if you go to maybe a better university
in the United Kingdom or elsewhere around the world,
you might also have the ability
to challenge the fundamental nature of law.
And one of the ways in which you can do that
is through the study of jurisprudence
because jurisprudence and any other theory of law
and legal theory invites us to challenge
the fundamental nature of the law
and ask not necessarily descriptive questions
but in fact ask normative questions.
So we could be asking questions such as
what the law ought to be?
What should the law be?
Why is the law right or wrong in this particular context?
Why is one case here more controversial than this other case?
And then the next question is, what fundamentally is the law?
Now, you might be thinking, well, that's a sort of descriptive question.
Why would I be studying that in jurisprudence?
Well, when we talk about what fundamentally is the law,
we're not asking the question as to
what is the descriptive nature of what a particular law says.
So when I say what fundamentally is the law,
I'm not asking, for example,
what does it say in sections 27 and 28 of the Land Registration Act.
I'm actually instead talking about law as a general abstract entity.
What actually is law?
What does it mean for something to be law?
What is the law fundamentally at this deeper and richer understanding?
That is a question which is, as you can probably imagine,
far more philosophical in nature.
I've already mentioned the two theories
that are going to be cited on this slide already,
but I'm going to do it again just for the purposes
of this particular lesson.
As mentioned previously in an earlier slide,
I noted that despite the fact that the jurisprudence
that we understand today comes out of in and around the 18th century
and that, in fact, the first time the word jurisprudence
is cited in English language is around the late 1600s,
these ideas and theories are often based on theoretical approaches
to philosophy which date back as far as the ancients,
so people like Aristotle.
In my mind, at least, there are two important theories,
and this is really where we're going to spend the majority
of our time studying jurisprudence.
We're going to talk a lot about natural law theory,
and we're going to talk a lot about legal positivism.
Essentially, natural law theory is where seemingly a lot
of the earlier approaches to law have derived and developed,
and then legal positivism is one that kind of came onto the scene
and has had a huge impact and has had a huge influence
over all of jurisprudence to this very day.
So we're going to be spending a lot of our time talking
about natural law theory, legal positivism,
the strengths and weaknesses of each of these theories,
the history of each of these theories,
as well as the variations within each of these theories
coming from different philosophers.
Essentially, that's going to take us to looking at the scope
of this series.
Now, the scope of this series is going to be looking
at the following structure.
Now, this is the same structure as you would find
in any jurisprudence or philosophy of law textbook.
Now, I'm going to be citing the various references
and citations and bibliographies at the end of each of these videos,
in the description of each of these videos.
I'm going to be following two, three, even four different sources
in order to construct these lessons.
But ultimately, every single jurisprudence textbook
or philosophy of law textbook that I have seen, at least,
covers these topics in roughly this order.
It seems to be the standard, a bog standard order.
It's the same way that, for example, negligence is the first taught
that you study in any kind of taught textbook.
So we're going to begin, for example, by talking about natural law theories.
This is where, for the most part, people begin to talk about jurisprudence
on account mainly of the age of natural law theory
because natural law theory dates back, as I've said,
to ancient philosophy.
We're going to divide this topic into three main lessons.
We're going to talk about the ancient influences,
the definition and origins of natural law theory.
We're going to talk about the impact of Christianity
on the natural law movement.
So that means moving into the more medieval part of natural law theory.
And then we're going to finish by looking at how natural law theory
influences and impacts jurisprudence to this day
by looking at some of the more modern theoretical approaches
to the subject.
We will then talk about arguably the most important
of the jurisprudential theories, depending on where you sit
in terms of the philosophy of law,
this being the concept of legal positivism.
We're going to be talking about the origins of legal positivism
and the influence of philosophers such as that of Austen.
We'll also be talking about various critiques of Austenian
legal positivism, the approaches that Austen actually took
when it came to approaches relating to positivism.
We will then talk about the influence of arguably,
at least in my opinion, the most important jurisprudential philosopher
of all time, potentially, that being the work of H. L. A. Hart
and his approaches to legal positivism.
We will then talk in the final two lessons about the critiques
of legal positivism, which were levied and presented
by the likes of Dworkin, and then finally the influence
of Joseph Raz on the legal positivist movement.
This does not mean we're going to be finished with these two theories,
however, because we're going to then talk about law and society.
Law and society focuses on sociological and post-liberal approaches
to legal theory.
This means talking briefly about Durkheim and Weber.
Weber, not that much, given the fact that he doesn't actually
cite that much about law in his writings,
because he's a sociologist.
And then we'll talk about Marxist interpretations of law.
We're going to keep the Marxist interpretations of law
in this section to just the traditional Marxist understanding of law.
So we're going to just talk about what, for example,
Marx and Engels said about the legal traditions
within this topic, because then in the final topic
we'll talk about further alternative theories,
which essentially builds on those Marxist interpretations of law
by talking about modern Marxist and anarchist approaches
to legal thought, talking about feminist approaches
to legal thought, and then building upon both of those
and talking about post-modern influences on legal philosophy,
which includes critical legal theory as well as critical race theory,
which is, of course, the most controversial of all of them,
at least in recent times, the most controversial of all
the theories of jurisprudence and the philosophy of law.
This is the major structure of this series of lessons,
and I want to just finally end on what is absent from this series,
because despite the fact that this is a jurisprudence course,
we are not going to be diving into too deep the issues
relating to the philosophy of specific areas of law.
So, for example, I'm not going to talk in too much detail
about the philosophy of human rights or the philosophy of criminal law.
This is not because they're not important, but it's because
I believe they merit their own subject and conversation,
their own separate series of lessons, because they are
far more detailed and far more interesting.
And potentially, after we have studied this general jurisprudence course,
we might go into and dive into, for example, the philosophy
of human rights law, because then we can build upon
our understanding that we've learned from this course
and then start to talk about how that applies to those areas
as well in future lessons time.
