In this investigative documentary, forensic geologist Scott Wolter utilizes state-of-the-art 3D microscopic technology to re-examine the Bat Creek Stone, a mysterious artifact unearthed from a Tennessee burial mound in 1889. While long dismissed by mainstream scholars as a hoax, Wolter’s analysis of weathering patterns and relative age dating suggests the Paleo-Hebrew inscription "For the Judeans" is a genuine ancient relic.
Odyssey is your journey into the world of Ancient History; from the dawn of Mesopotamia to the fall of Rome. We'll be bringing you only the best documentaries that journey into the mysteries and ruins of worlds long lost.
Subscribe so you don't miss out!
:european_castle: You can now become a History Hit member right here on YouTube! Join for access to a new exclusive documentary every week, and access to over 160+ of our documentaries presented by world renowned historians like Dan Snow, Eleanor Janega, Tristan Hughes, Mary Beard, Matt Lewis and more.
The history that we were all taught growing up is wrong.
My name is Scott Wolter, and I'm a forensic geologist.
There's a hidden history that nobody knows about.
There are pyramids, chambers, tombs, descriptions.
They're all over the world.
We're going to investigate these artifacts and sites,
and we're going to get to the truth.
Sometimes history isn't what we've been told.
As a forensic geologist, I rely on the study of rocks
to learn more about our own history.
And throughout my career, there have been several artifacts
that I constantly return to.
One of them is called the Bat Creek Stone.
Though small in size, it's considered
one of archaeology's biggest mysteries.
I first learned about it during an unrelated investigation
back in 2008.
I was examining some cave inscriptions
with a woman named Leslie Kalin when
she told me about the stone and how it's
inscribed with strange writing.
I was immediately intrigued and had to know more.
The Bat Creek Stone was discovered back in 1889
in a Native American burial mound
in Loudoun County, Tennessee, along with jewelry
and nine human skeletons.
The writing on the stone was first
thought to be a form of Cherokee script.
Later, it was determined to be an ancient form of Hebrew.
Why would a stone with Hebrew writing
be buried in a Native American mound?
After years of research, a possible connection
began to emerge.
Could the stone be an ancient Hebrew land claim, possibly
from the Lost Tribes of Israel?
The Lost Tribes of Israel are 10 tribes
that disappeared from the Holy Land in 722 BC
after the Assyrians waged a bloody battle against them.
To this day, no one knows if they died, escaped,
or assimilated into the population.
Some believe they traveled to America
to build a new Jerusalem.
The Smithsonian officially owns the Bat Creek Stone,
but it's housed at the McClung Museum in Knoxville, Tennessee.
Leslie's father, a Cherokee elder,
helped me get permission to study the stone, which
I examined in 2010.
Now, I'm returning to Tennessee to examine it
using state-of-the-art technology.
I hope looking at it with a 3D microscope
will help determine if the stone is
an ancient relic of the Lost Tribes of Israel
or something else.
Before my re-examination, I'm meeting with Leslie Kalin
again to see what she knows about this mysterious artifact
and any connections between the Lost Tribes of Israel
and the Native American site where the stone was found.
So aside from the inscription, is there
any evidence of an early Hebrew connection with people
or places in Tennessee?
I think that some of my people believe
that we might be descendants from the Lost Tribe.
My grandfather told me that he felt
that we had a Jewish connection, maybe even possibly be part
of the Lost Tribe of Israel.
There is a group called the Central Band of Cherokees.
They believe that they are direct descendants
of the Lost Tribe of Israel.
On my way to the McClung Museum, I
can't stop thinking about what Leslie said.
As a scientist, I focus on facts.
But in this case, I can't ignore the oral tradition.
If some Cherokee people believe they're connected
to the Lost Tribes of Israel, maybe there's something to it.
Here it is.
All right.
Just got it fresh off the exhibit for you.
I'm really excited to look at the Bat Creek stone
with the new technology, this Keyence 3D microscope
that's going to hopefully help answer the question,
is it authentic or not?
And that's part of why you're studying it.
There is some controversy about the stone.
Can you give me just a brief synopsis
as you understand the history of the Bat Creek stone?
Yeah, I mean, it has a very interesting history.
It was part of the Smithsonian's Bureau of Ethnology's mound
survey that Cyrus Thomas was leading
to try to understand what they call at the time
the mystery of the mound builders,
of who actually built these things.
And one of those excavations was done in Loudoun County,
Tennessee at the intersection of Bat Creek
with the Little Tennessee River.
And they excavated a couple of mounds there.
And one of them was a burial mound
where they actually found the Bat Creek stone.
A scientist named Cyrus Thomas was
in charge of the mound survey.
Initially, he thought the mounds were
the work of some advanced race which no longer existed.
Eventually, he went on record with his belief
that the Cherokee people were somehow
connected to the prehistoric mound builders.
Some critics believe John Emmer,
the field archaeologist working on the project
who found the Bat Creek stone,
may have planted the artifact to get in good with his boss.
He was actually at one point fired from the Smithsonian
and was rehired.
And this was one of his first projects after being rehired.
Did that actually influence him in what he did or didn't do?
And that, we'll never know.
Beyond the Bat Creek stone, there
are other stone tablets and other things
that clearly were hoaxes.
You have found fakes.
There are things out there.
I have found fakes.
But I have also found things like the Kensington Runestone
is absolutely genuine.
The Bat Creek stone is one of the classic examples
of bad science run amok.
Everybody's got an opinion.
And you know what they're worth in many cases.
The rocks don't have bad days.
They don't care.
They just are.
So we go back to the science.
And I always say, I let the rocks talk.
The Bat Creek stone was found in a Native American burial mound
in the 1880s.
Some people think it's a hoax.
They suspect the guy who found the stone faked its inscription
to get in good with his boss at the Smithsonian.
I'm not buying that.
I think the stone may prove Jewish people made it
to America before Columbus.
This artifact could even be connected
to the Lost Tribes of Israel.
They're famous for vanishing without a trace in 722 BC.
Some Cherokee people in Tennessee
think they have a connection to the Lost Tribes.
I've studied the Bat Creek stone once.
But now I'm back in Tennessee to examine it
with the latest technology.
If I can figure out how old the carvings are on the stone
using 3D analysis, it would go a long way
towards solving the Lost Tribes mystery.
I want to show you something here
that I think is pretty important.
This is the very first picture taken
of the Bat Creek stone, 1894.
If you look in this area right here, there are no scratches.
Right.
But in this 1971 photograph, you can see
there are two scratches.
Clearly.
Clearly they were added after the stone was found.
Right.
Do you have any thoughts on why that might have happened
or how that may have happened?
Well, I mean, there's two things that could happen.
It could have been accidentally scratched
in some form or fashion, or it could
be somebody trying to do some sort of early testing
before 3D imaging to see what it's made of
and how easy it is to scratch and things like that.
We will do some test scratches like that sometimes.
What's important about this is these
serve as excellent control samples for me
to compare with the original inscription
to see if they're the same.
Hopefully this machine can tell us some more today.
We start by examining the modern scratch.
I'm not sure if this mark was made accidentally or on purpose.
It doesn't matter.
What does matter is that this scratch may
be able to help prove the authenticity of the Bat Creek
stone.
When they scratch the stone, it will
generate secondary material that's left behind.
And we see that here in the freshly scratched surface.
Whenever you scratch a stone, you leave stuff behind,
deposits from making the mark.
The fact that we see residue in this microscopic view
speaks to the fact that this is a recent carving.
Because we're looking at a recent scratch,
it would make sense some of that material is still there.
No polish marks.
Clearly rough.
I mean, it's something that was intentional,
but not to be beautiful.
Yes.
So let's take a look at the original inscription.
If it was fresh like the scratch,
we would see secondary material in there,
and we don't see that.
Well, as you can see here, we don't
have any of those deposits that we saw on the fresh scratch.
They're completely gone.
It's clean as a whistle.
It's completely weathered away.
The weathering is key, because to get that weathering profile
took time.
We've got nice rounded edges, and the polished surface
looks nothing like the fresh scratch.
Right.
In Emert's notes, the first time he mentions the stone,
he said it was a polished stone.
You can see the scratches going into the grooves
after it was carved.
So clearly, that indicates the inscription was carved first,
then it was polished.
The inscription on the Bat Creek stone
was clearly polished, unlike those new scratches, which
weren't polished at all.
By polishing it, that tells you that they're
treating this with care, that it has meaning to them,
and maybe even sacred.
If Emert faked the inscription, it
would look newer, more like the modern scratches.
But the inscription looks really old.
So here's the question for you.
Can that be faked?
You can make a charge that somebody did something
anytime you want, but making it stick
is the key thing.
We've talked a lot about the inscription,
but we haven't really talked about what it says.
One of the top Semitic scholars in the world at that time
has translated the inscription as for the Judeans.
The Judeans were a Jewish people who
occupied a mountainous region called Judea, which today
is Israel's West Bank and the northern Negev Desert.
The region was named after the biblical tribe of Judah,
one of the lost tribes of Israel.
If the Bat Creek Stone really does bear the inscription
for the Judeans, it could be a significant clue
that suggests the lost tribes came to America.
There's been some other interpretation as well,
nothing too drastically different.
How old do you think that is?
How much older do you think that is than those modern scratches?
The type of work that I do is what
I call relative age dating.
It's older than this.
It's younger than that.
We know this is this old.
It's in between, so it has to fall somewhere in the middle.
By looking at the weathering of the original inscription,
comparing it with the modern scratches, to me,
that says it wasn't made during modern times.
Amard said he pulled it from the mound.
I've seen no evidence to question that.
The other thing I think that's very important
is this double-barred cross of Lorraine, which
was used by early Jewish groups and is
a symbol of the crucifixion.
That would not be consistent with the lost tribes of Israel
if it represented the crucifixion.
I mean, we're talking about a group that disappeared
around 700 BC.
And the crucifixion, obviously, is 800 years
later in this particular case.
Yeah, obviously, wrong time.
After taking a closer look at the cross of Lorraine,
I still don't have enough information
to definitively connect the lost tribes of Israel
with the Bat Creek Stone.
Still, this is a mysterious artifact with Hebrew on it.
I've looked at others, too.
They make me wonder, who created them, when, and why?
I'm very comfortable that the Bat Creek Stone, all evidence
here, to me, indicates that it looks to be a genuine artifact.
But there are other artifacts that
have been found in North America,
pre-Columbian artifacts with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
I've investigated Ohio's Decalogue Stone.
It has a shortened version of the Ten Commandments on it,
written in paleo-Hebrew.
Same story in Las Lunas, New Mexico,
where there's a similar artifact, also called
the Decalogue Stone, with the Ten Commandments on it.
And in Arizona, more Hebrew, on the Tucson-led artifacts,
a collection of authentic ritual objects
pulled from the desert in 1924.
I have to wonder if all these things are markers on a trail
left by Hebrew people long ago.
There's a person that I'm going to go visit and talk
to a little bit more about the Bat Creek Stone
and about some other artifacts.
Part of the science of all this is actually having a dialogue
and talking to different scholars, different
perspectives and expertise.
We've had a good exchange today.
But now I want to ask you, Tim, are you
convinced by what you've seen here today
that the Bat Creek Stone is a genuine pre-Columbian Hebrew
artifact?
Well, Tim, you are the curator here at the McClung Museum
that houses the Bat Creek Stone artifact.
We've just spent a good part of the day
looking at brand new data.
So based on everything you've seen,
do you think that the Bat Creek Stone
is a genuine pre-Columbian Hebrew artifact?
I'm not completely convinced yet.
But you did show me some things today I didn't expect.
There's some potential other things
that need to be done before I can say,
yes, you have an authentic stone.
But your mind is open.
Oh, as a scientist, your mind's always open.
I have to say that I'm convinced this is a genuine artifact.
But I'm all about collecting more data.
I'm going to go see if I can find some more evidence
of some early Hebrew culture coming to North America
prior to Columbus, long before Columbus, possibly
the Lost Tribes of Israel.
I'm on my way to see an artifact expert named Hugh McCullough.
He studied the Bat Creek Stone and other artifacts
found inside the burial mound.
A while back, Hugh showed me another allegedly Hebrew
artifact called the Decalogue Stone in Cushocton, Ohio.
Today, we're meeting in another part of Ohio
at a national park known for its mounds.
Well, Hugh, it's good to see you again.
Good to see you, Scott.
Welcome to Ohio.
Tell me what you found in Tennessee.
I understand you looked at the Bat Creek Stone down there?
I had a chance to look at the artifact
with my new technology, the 3D digital microscope.
I was able to confirm that the weathering of the inscription
is indeed old.
There's no question that the Bat Creek Stone is not a hoax.
It's a genuine artifact.
And the fact that it's paleo-Hebrew
says to me that it has to be an early Jewish group that
created it, possibly the Lost Tribes.
Well, I agree it's a Jewish artifact.
So I think it's very exciting.
Tell me a little bit about the testing
that you did back in the 1980s.
There were some wooden ear spools found with the stone.
Wooden ear spools.
Tell me a little bit, what are those?
The Hopewell and many other cultures
use these ear spools.
They're just decorative ear spools.
They stretch the ears.
We were able to get a carbon date on those.
It was somewhere between 32 and 769 AD.
So, Hugh, based on the data, it doesn't look
like this is the Lost Tribes, who were probably
around 722 BC.
This is something more in the first century, right?
If you look at the inscription here,
here's your photo of the Bat Creek Stone.
And the style of the letters most closely
matches that of the Jewish war coins of the 65 to 70 AD.
The letter style matches almost perfectly.
There would have been an incentive at that time
for Jewish people to emigrate.
Because if they stayed behind, they
would have been nailed to a cross or fed to the lions
or enslaved.
Around 70 AD, Jews and their Roman rulers
were fighting over unfair taxation,
disrespect for the Jewish faith, and accusations of theft.
The rebellion, known as the Great Revolt,
was eventually crushed by the Romans.
Four years later, Jerusalem was captured.
And 100,000 Jews were killed or sold into slavery.
The big question, did other Jews escape and find
their way to America?
There's another piece of evidence
here, too, that jumps out at me is this double-barred cross.
That's probably one of the earliest,
if not the earliest versions, of the Cross of Lorraine.
The Cross of Lorraine is symbolic of the crucifixion,
which would have been sometime in the middle
to late first century, consistent
with an early Jewish group in the first or second century.
All the testing that you had done,
the testing of the ear spools, and the script
all do overlap about what time?
Around the first century AD.
So you've got consistency from different points.
Now we have the geology work that I've
done as far as the weathering indicating that it's very old,
that it's not a modern hoax.
Based on all of this, we have apparently
a first or second century Jewish artifact
found in a Native American Indian mound.
And its historical importance cannot be overstated.
I'd agree with you there, Scott.
But there's one more piece of evidence
I want to show you, which is even bigger in a sense.
I'm interested.
Let's go.
It's becoming clear to me the Bat Creek
stone and the ear spools found in the same burial mound
don't go back far enough to be connected
to the Lost Tribes of Israel.
I keep wondering, who left these things?
And what does it all mean?
So this is a photocopy of a map that
was made by the US Army Corps of Engineers, 1823,
of some earthworks here in Ohio.
Earthworks, also known as mounds,
are intentional changes in land level.
These sculpted piles of rocks and soil
are often ancient, mysterious, and massive.
What does this portion up here look like here?
Well, that looks like a menorah.
Right.
Is that what that is?
Well, that's what it looks like.
The menorah, also called a hanakia,
is the symbol of Hanukkah.
The eight-day Jewish holiday celebrates the rededication
of their temple after years of fighting.
The Hanukkah story tells how soldiers
who recaptured the temple had only enough oil for one night.
But miraculously, it lasted for eight.
So let me get this straight.
Somebody in the distant past built this earthwork
that's traditionally Native American
in the shape of a menorah?
Well, if we didn't have the Bat Creek stone and the Decalogue
stone, we'd be totally bewildered.
A Jewish idea like this is not so strange after all, maybe.
Experts believe the Hopewell people
built both the hanakia earthworks on the Army Corps
map, as well as all the mounds surrounding us here
at Hopewell Culture National Park.
I mean, that looks like a lamp, an oil lamp.
Right, it looks like the oil lamp
that was supposed to have burned.
What else can it be?
Yeah.
Well, let me ask you this.
This is a beautiful place, but why didn't you take me here?
This map was made in 1823.
But by 1848, it was pretty much plowed over and not visible
from the ground anymore.
So it's been basically destroyed.
Right.
So it was a huge structure.
This is only 13 acres here, and this is 100 acres.
Wow, almost 10 times bigger.
We know that Thomas Jefferson was actually
very interested in this particular earthwork.
It goes back to 1803, even, when he was president.
He asked a general to draw these very same earthworks.
The reason for Jefferson's interest?
The Louisiana Purchase.
The US bought Louisiana from the French.
They had taken it from the Spanish.
Jefferson wanted to prove others were here in America earlier.
So Spain couldn't say Louisiana, or any other land,
belonged to them.
I recently investigated the notion
that Lewis and Clark were assigned to look
for evidence of Welsh contact.
I looked at the Brandenburg Stone as one possibility
that that may have been carved by the Welsh.
He was also interested in the possibility
of the lost tribes of Israel.
So he even asked Lewis and Clark to look for them.
So he was covering all the bases.
Roman, or Greek, or Phoenician, he
would have been just as happy to prove it wasn't the Spanish.
I think there was a diplomatic interest there.
I'll bet you in his back pocket he had this right here.
You know, an earthwork like this, I mean, to me,
this just screams an early Jewish culture.
But there's something more that's significant here.
This is a massive mound.
This isn't something done by one, or two, or a few people.
This involved a lot of people, right?
This earthworks would have required a whole community
years to build. The whole community
was dedicated to building this particular symbol.
And therefore, it's a much deeper involvement
with the indigenous culture than the other artifacts.
I would agree with you.
I think collectively, though, they're all important.
It seems clear to me that these artifacts don't have anything
to do with the Lost Tribes.
Others may be, but not these.
So it begs the question, if the Lost Tribes didn't create
these artifacts, who did?
By studying the Bat Creek Stone, a mysterious artifact
found in a Tennessee burial mound more than 100 years ago,
I confirmed that its inscription is much older
than its discovery date.
It's carved with a message.
For the Judeans, Judea is a region in Israel,
and the writing style is consistent with Jews
after the turn of the first century.
Could a group of them have been here in America at that time?
That would rule out my initial theory,
the Lost Tribes of Israel, who went missing
from history much earlier.
But I think there's a chance the Lost Tribes' descendants
might be responsible.
I'm going to meet a local rabbi.
If I can learn more about the history of Jewish people
coming to America, it could help me solve
the mystery of the Bat Creek Stone and the menorah-shaped
mounds I just learned about.
I'm investigating ancient Hebrews
here in the United States.
And I want to try to figure out who's responsible.
But I want to know a little bit more about early Jews coming
to America.
What do you know about that?
So what we do know is that Columbus came in 1492.
And with him, he brought Jews.
And the first question that begs is, well,
why on earth would he do that?
And he believed at the time that there were potentially
in the New World these lost tribes.
You would want people who he thought
could communicate with them.
Well, that's interesting that Jews traveled with Columbus.
Aren't there some rumors that people thought that maybe
he was Jewish himself?
There's a big controversy.
And I'll leave this to historians to resolve that.
But even if he wasn't Jewish, he certainly
had Jewish companions, understood the Jewish community,
and was keen on discovering the lost tribes.
There was a lot of persecution going on, wasn't there?
Up until 1492, we talk about historically
as the golden age of Spain for the Jews.
And things had been going there pretty well.
Jews were relatively left alone to thrive
in business and religious tradition and what have you.
And then we get this edict in 1492.
And people were left with just a horrible choice,
either die by the sword or convert.
Though 1492 is best known as the year Columbus
sailed the ocean blue, it was also
an infamous year for the persecution of Jewish people.
There was the burning at the stake of 24 Jews in Germany
and the expulsion of 100,000 in Sicily.
The worst persecution, the edict of expulsion
in Spain, which gave Jews four months to leave Spain,
either convert to Judaism, convert to Catholicism,
or face death.
The rabbis, some said, better to survive.
Even if you have to convert to Catholicism,
your life is more important.
And others said, no, it's better to be a martyr
and to die than to ever worship in ways that are inauthentic
and you don't believe.
Tens of thousands of them died.
But we also know that thousands of them
converted to Catholicism and still maintained
their religious Jewish traditions at home.
We call those people who were forced to convert conversos.
So they were secretly Jewish, but they
were outwardly Catholic.
These conversos, or what are sometimes
also called crypto-Jews, were practicing Catholicism,
but practicing their Judaism in the closet.
Everything from lighting candles in private on Friday nights
to refraining from eating pork and following the kosher laws.
So these conversos really tried to maintain
some sense of their Jewish identity,
and they carried that to the new world with them.
We know that many of the conversos, the crypto-Jews,
made their way to the northern frontier of Mexico
and what is now New Mexico and the American Southwest.
It makes perfect sense.
I mean, this is something that many people have done,
many religions have done, is come to the Americas
to practice freedom of religion.
Even today, there continue to be many Latino families who
are outwardly practicing Catholicism or Christianity,
but who privately continue to observe
some of these Jewish rituals that have been
passed down to them over time.
Well, in this case, you're talking
about modern-day people that are practicing
rituals that date back possibly as far as the 15th century.
I've been looking at artifacts that go back much further.
One example is the Bat Creek stone,
and the language is early Semitic script
that some scholars say dates back to the first century.
So I'm really interested in trying
to get to the bottom of this and find anything
I can that might be related.
Is there anything that you know of that could possibly
be related to what could be ancient Jewish writing?
I can't claim to the veracity of this,
but there is a woman in New Mexico
who claimed to have found this on her father's property,
and there are some historians who
believe that this evidence is early, potentially
Semitic or Hebrew writing.
Perhaps there's something there.
What the rabbi is showing me isn't
the only carving with a Hebrew connection in New Mexico.
There's another one called the Las Lunas Decalogue Stone,
and the Ten Commandments are carved on it in paleo-Hebrew.
Maybe there's a connection between that boulder
and the petroglyph pictures which the rabbi is showing me.
The thing that's really jumping out
is it looks weathered.
If this is down in New Mexico and there's any possibility
that this could be old Hebrew or old Jewish writing,
I'm going to have to check this out.
My investigation, there's one thing I know for certain.
Much of what we think we know about our history is wrong.
We know Jewish people came to America with Columbus,
and the Bat Creek Stone proves they came here
in the first century too.
But there may be others, perhaps the Lost Tribes,
who came here even earlier.
And the people I'm about to meet may have found proof.
Are you Stacey?
I am.
This is my friend, Ron.
Hi, Ron.
I'm investigating the likelihood that there
were ancient Hebrew tribes, people that came here
from across the Atlantic going back at least hundreds
of years, perhaps thousands.
I recently talked to a rabbi friend of mine
back in Minneapolis who said there were
Hebrew carvings down here.
Tell me about them.
We have found several on my dad's land up here,
and Ron found many of these all around New Mexico,
all of these drawings that we're anxious for you to look at.
Well, I've got these pictures from a friend
of mine, Jimmy's ranch.
So what are these?
They're ligatures that's written in a script form that
makes it easier for people that know the language
and people that don't to understand in a picture.
I mean, the earliest communication that humans had
was through pictures.
Maybe that's what we have going on here.
These look fascinating.
Maybe we should go take a look at them.
What do you say?
Let's go.
You have a four-wheel drive.
It's pretty rough and remote out there.
I got a cup.
Let's go.
I'm in New Mexico looking for ligatures.
They're symbols that take on new meaning when they're combined.
They could be evidence that Jews came to America
long before Columbus.
Maybe they were clues left by members of the legendary lost
tribes of Israel, Jewish tribes that
went missing in 722 BC.
I'm heading to the discovery site to see for myself.
So Ron, you have to tell me.
How did you find these things?
I was building these roads through here
and got out of the bulldozer and ran across.
Just saw this over here on the side of the rocks.
This is not the first time I've seen evidence here
in North America of early Hebrews coming here.
I mean, I've looked at the Decalogue stone, the Bad Creek
stone, the Tucson-led artifacts.
And the Hanakee earthworks absolutely
suggest that there were early Jews here in America
long before Columbus.
And we certainly weren't taught that in school, were we?
No, no.
Wow, what do you think of that?
Well, Ron, not only is it rugged out here, but it's remote.
I mean, why would somebody come out here
to carve a hoax or graffiti?
I mean, nobody would see it.
This whole panel is full of carvings and up there, too.
It would be easy to assume these are Native American petroglyphs,
but I don't think they are.
I've never seen anything quite like this before.
You see this dark surface on this rock?
This developed over at least hundreds of years,
probably thousands of years.
You can actually see where some of the edges have spalled.
You see how it's almost white, sort of a tan color?
Well, that's what these would have looked
like when they were first made.
But they're dark.
They're almost black, like the background rock
that they're carved into.
This is definitely not modern.
This is my handheld portable microscope.
And you can see how dark that is.
You know, another thing that jumps out at me right away
that I'm sure you guys have noticed,
that they didn't take a hammer and chisel.
This was carved with rocks.
And they used a pecking technique.
Can you see that?
It's like it's pitted.
I saw something on the way in that could help us
put a date on these carvings.
It's the sort of thing many people frown upon.
But as a geologist, I can find some value in it.
It's graffiti.
Let's go take a look at this other site.
That's what I wanted to show you.
You can see that this is fresh looking.
It's carved into the same dark surface.
This one's dated 1892.
It looks like it was carved yesterday.
Some other carvings here, 1925, 1924, 1919.
And they all look fresh.
I mean, this is just a quick and dirty comparison.
But you can see this looks a lot different than what
we have back there.
It's pretty dramatic, isn't it?
It's definitely older than 120 years,
easily hundreds of years old.
Who knows how far back?
So at this point, it becomes important to talk
to the experts in this script.
And my question is, do we know what this script is?
Right.
Well, we did reach out to a few experts.
And they dated it to the 15th century BC.
15th century BC?
BC.
That's 3,500 years ago.
It's a script that predates the Hebrew alphabet.
OK, what's it called?
It's called Old Negev.
Old Negev is an ancient script.
Experts believe it was developed by ancestors
of the biblical Abraham, who worked in the Egyptian mines
in West Central Sinai.
The laborers needed a way to express
their language in writing.
Some consider Old Negev to be a precursor to Phoenician,
paleo-Hebrew, and early Arabic scripts.
The name Negev came up when I examined the Back Creek
Stone in Tennessee.
Its inscription reads, for the Judeans.
The Judeans lived in what's now the northern Negev Desert.
The people we reached out to gave us
some rough translations of this.
So it's read right to left?
It's from right to left.
So we're talking in this area here, woe and sorrow,
on this inscription in here.
OK.
And then we move over here to this.
And this would be to cover or veil.
This one right down here would be sunburnt or black.
And it's talking about brothers and relatives, fellow man,
and for him to cry out or call for help.
Talking about woe and sorrow and sunburnt,
there is a rock shelter here.
It would provide protection from the sun.
So maybe this is where they took refuge during a long journey
and took the time to carve this.
And we're talking Old Negev script.
That's 3,500 years ago.
The weathering of this inscription
could certainly be that old.
My gosh, that's 700 years before the Lost Tribes.
Well, we don't know if this is that old.
But if it is that old, I mean, that would be amazing,
wouldn't it?
It would.
That is so interesting that you say the Lost Tribes,
because there is one figure on here
that a friend of mine who lived in Israel for several years
said is associated with the tribe of Judah.
This isn't the first time in this investigation
that the name Judah has come up.
The Bat Creek Stone inscription reads for the Judeans
in paleo-Hebrew.
Judea is a region named after the tribe of Judah.
The tribe of Judah, that's Jesus' tribe.
And if this is indeed 3,500 years old,
that would be 1,500 years before Jesus.
So this would have been his distant ancestors
that could have used this script.
But the other possibility is that this
could have been a group that came later.
We don't know.
Sometimes people will use outdated languages
far into the future.
I mean, the Catholics still use Latin during mass.
And in our culture today, Latin is essentially a dead language.
So the Lost Tribes being responsible for this,
I guess, is still on the table.
Whoever this group is traveled far and wide, it sounds like.
There's going to be archaeologists
that are going to watch this, and they're going to scoff.
When what they should be doing is respecting the work
that we're trying to do here.
The argument that the oceans were
these vast, impenetrable barriers, to me, is ridiculous.
Here, yet another group probably did come over here
in the distant past.
The Bat Creek Stone is physically small compared
to a lot of things I investigate.
But there's a big mystery attached to it.
After studying the Bat Creek Stone with my 3D microscope
and meeting with someone else who studied it,
I'm convinced it's not a hoax.
I think it was left in America by a 1st century Jewish group.
But I can't say for sure who they were or why they left it.
I no longer think the Lost Tribes were involved.
The timing's just not right.
But the Bat Creek Stone does connect early Jews
with pre-Columbian America.
Decalogue stones with the Ten Commandments.
Earthworks shaped like a menorah.
And strange petroglyphs in the southwest
also point to unexpected Jewish visitors to the New World.
Whatever happened to the Lost Tribes of Israel
when they disappeared in 722 BC is still a mystery.
But it's one I hope to solve someday.