The 5 Most Under-Appreciated Rolex Models (One Will Definitely Surprise You)

Classic Watches & Style
2 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 17, 2026
So it's a bit of an oxymoron,
talk about underappreciated and Rolex.
They dominate the industry in so many regards,
but if you really get down to it
and you compare it all relatively speaking,
there are some Rolex models that are not as talked about,
not as collected, not as sought after as others.
And in this video,
what we're gonna be looking at
is the five most underappreciated Rolex models
as we enter 2026.
What I'm looking at here is current production models only.
So we're not looking at models from the past,
vintage pieces,
but really try to inform this around data.
A lot of this will come down to trading values,
retail prices, things in comparison to that.
That is all subject to change in the future.
So if you are watching this in the future
and things do change, don't get mad at me.
This is all a reflection of what is going on
at the time of recording this video in December of 2025
as we get into a new year
and looking at the landscape of Rolex.
And some of these might surprise you more than others.
And where I'm really thinking about this
is all relatively speaking.
It's not all about just the most approachable Rolex models
and the ones that are trading the lowest below retail.
I wanna try to derive some level of reason
behind why I think these might be solid buys
or just maybe not thought about
in the same way as they should.
And maybe just being watches
that more people should actually consider.
Now, if you're simply looking for Rolex watches,
where is the point of entry for the brand?
I'd recommend checking out the article down below.
I'll put it in the description.
We put this together,
going through a variety of different references,
the low and highs of different models that you can go into.
That includes both vintage and modern.
We break down different price ranges
of some of those top references,
discuss Rolex models adjusted for inflation.
I had head-to-head pricing
for comparisons of specific models,
price changes over time, and a lot more.
And so if that is more your speed,
that will also be in the description down below.
Let's stick around here until the end.
So to kick things off,
I wanna look at the one
that probably will surprise the most people
when I lead off a video with this.
And some might just be like, I'm clicking off.
This guy doesn't know what he's talking about.
But hear me out.
So I have talked a lot about the Explorer II.
And this is not where I'm going with the Explorer II
because I think recent data that I've seen
shows the opposite.
I've always championed the Explorer II.
I'm wearing one on my wrist.
I've talked about it all the time.
You look at previous videos
where I've talked about this as being underappreciated.
When you start to look at what's happened
with the Rolex Explorer II,
especially the white polar 226570,
it trades over retail.
And then even the black dial trades over retail.
And I think now as you factor all of the fanfare
that's been directed towards the Explorer II,
I don't know if it's necessarily underrated.
It is properly rated.
And if you looked at people that watch this channel,
it's even more out of bounds.
When we did our Rolex tournament,
that had a starting number of Rolex watches
that eventually got narrowed down
to a 64 watch tournament.
But the starting number in the original form
was well over 200.
The Explorer II was a one-seas.
That means that it was in the top four
of the most popular Rolex models
when people were trying to classify them best.
So that watch has no reason to be on this list.
But why did I bring that up at the beginning?
Because I think the first watch here I wanna talk about
is just the Rolex Explorer.
Now, some of you might be freaking out
in the fact that I just said
that Rolex Explorer is underappreciated.
It's a watch that people talk about all the time
in the collecting community.
But you contrast that
to the amount of time it's talked about
versus what the real landscape looks like
and how it's actually not purchased
as much as many people like to think.
And you look at the trading values,
it starts to make more sense.
So for one, it now is behind the Explorer II
on the preview page for Rolex.
When I referenced the Explorer II
as being underappreciated,
I don't read into this a crazy amount,
but the way that Rolex positions their website
is probably a representation
of how they might think about the brand,
but also it's probably meticulously crafted.
Maybe I'm giving them too much credit,
but I just feel like everything that Rolex does
is so thoughtful.
So to lead with the Explorer II
rather than the Explorer,
to represent the Explorer collection,
I found that pretty telling.
In addition, the current production Explorer 36 millimeter,
that's the 124270, trades below retail.
And then the 40 millimeter is just going to edge it out
in its trading value over retail,
but it's not a huge appreciation by any means.
So it indicates that not a difficult watch
to get at retail pricing.
And then the two-tone trading considerably under retail.
But here's a point that really surprised me.
You talk all this acclaim around the Rolex Explorer.
It's like the one watch,
a Swiss army knife of luxury watches.
You can wear it anywhere.
Then you look at the Rolex Oyster Perpetual,
which is the black dial.
One of the dial variations at 36 millimeters
is the 126000 series.
It edges out the Explorer at 36 millimeters
in trading value.
So yes, a 36 millimeter,
one of many dials Oyster Perpetual is more sought after
than a Rolex Explorer by the numbers.
If I had to make a guess why the Rolex Explorer
doesn't perform as well as some people might think,
it's probably because it doesn't appeal
to a casual watch buyer that is looking to acquire a Rolex.
I mean, someone that's going for a Rolex,
if they're more casual in their interest of the brand,
they might buy it just more for the show.
And a Rolex Explorer is pretty understated.
I mean, if you think about the Rolex Explorer,
it doesn't have a fluted bezel.
It doesn't have anything that's over the top
in its presentation.
There's nothing that I would ever say is ostentatious.
It is versatile to maybe a fault,
and that might be holding it back.
And then you look at pretty much
every other Explorer reference going back,
it even underperforms compared to
other Rolex steel sports models.
Even the Explorer II,
if you go from like almost every generation
all the way back,
every coinciding reference from the Explorer II
seems to outperform that of the Explorer family.
So there is a retail consideration there,
but it goes to show that the Rolex Explorer,
despite all the acclaim that it has
in the watch collecting community,
maybe isn't getting the flowers that it deserves
and ending up on as many people's wrists as we think.
So now we move to watch number two.
And for this, I wanna look at the Yacht-Master.
Now, I'm not speaking about the Rolex Titanium.
That watch is correctly rated,
if not overrated potentially,
because it is trading way over retail.
That watch is amazing,
but I wanna focus mostly on the Rolesium models
with the blue hands
and the mix of precious metal with stainless steel.
So the Yacht-Master first released in 1992,
and it has had its ups and downs in its existence.
I wouldn't say it's ever found its proper footing
until the Rolex Titanium came out.
That seemed to be the first time when that was released
because of the titanium aspect
being brought with the design
where something really did take off in popularity.
For the most part,
it's gonna fall deeply in the shadow of the Submariner,
and it's not a perfect one-to-one of a comparison,
but I think there are a lot of people
that will cross shop between a Submariner and a Yacht-Master.
Now, my case for the Yacht-Master being underappreciated
rests on several points.
Number one is that the collection has been thinned
as there's no longer a Yacht-Master II,
so we're seeing Rolex themselves recognize
that maybe this collection doesn't get as much attention.
Now, the Yacht-Master II,
completely different proposition as an idea
versus the traditional Yacht-Master,
but that's one point there.
Then secondly, given the abandonment of 40 millimeters
as a size for the Submariner,
the Yacht-Master to me has become increasingly compelling
for those that are looking for multiple sizes
of something that follows the design format of a dive watch.
Now, it does have a different water resistance rating
than the Submariner,
but there still are a lot of the same day-to-day principles
that are brought forth by the Yacht-Master.
I'm looking specifically at the 40 and 37.
37 is an exotic case size,
and I think it is going to overlap with a lot of wrists,
and if you wanted a mid-sized dive watch from Rolex,
I mean, Tudor, you have plenty to choose from,
but in the broader crown ecosystem,
this is an amazing choice
for getting more of that mid-sized dive watch
where Rolex doesn't really play much in that game anymore.
Then we talk about Rolesium Platinum
being utilized at this price range.
This is something that typically as a metal,
platinum is usually held in very high regard,
but then you get down to where the trading value is
for a watch that has stainless steel
and platinum's part of the metal composition.
You're gonna find that that watch
is gonna trade for less or roughly the same
as many of the stainless steel offerings
from Rolex in the Submariner form.
What I found was pretty interesting
is a standard Sub Date trades for roughly the same
as a mixed precious metal offering from Rolex,
while the Starbucks trades for $800 more,
so even adding to this idea.
The 40 millimeter Rolesium does trade over retail,
yet on a percentage basis,
significantly less than other sports peers from Rolex.
Other than the Explorer Two-Tone,
this is the most attainable precious metal
mixed sports watch on the secondary market,
even at retail pricing.
And then as one final consideration
I'll just throw out there
is that the Yacht-Master look is more influential
than many people give it credit for.
I don't know about you,
but I see this raised graduation scale bezel style
copied all the time from micro brands on up,
and it's something that we probably don't talk about a lot,
but I just look at it and then recognize,
yeah, that's a Rolex Yacht-Master bezel.
In a very short period of time,
this has become one of the most influential design styles
for a watch of the entire genre,
and I don't think this whole collection
gets the appreciation that it deserves.
Now, for some of you,
you might be scratching your head
because of the inclusion of this next model,
but here we have the Rolex 1908.
Now, when the 1908 first came out in 2023,
it didn't cause the same immediate buzz
as we saw this past year with the Landweller,
though it certainly was well-received
compared to the outgoing Cellini at that time.
The 1908 serves as the high-end dress genre for the brand,
which competes on a different level
compared to the robust sport upside of pieces
like the Datejust even,
and the Landweller and Day-Date.
There's 100 meters of water resistance
in comparison here, 50 meters of water resistance.
So this leads to the watch competing
with the likes of high horology brands,
which is a pretty fierce level of competition
that Rolex is going up against.
That said, the 1908, to me,
still seems pretty underappreciated for a few reasons,
and a lot of this is more recent developments.
This is a very nascent model for Rolex,
but they're starting to figure out
how they wanna position this.
Now, one is that it's been overlooked
by the recent buzz around different models.
2023, it did get some love,
but compared to the Landweller, for example,
it's not something that people talk about
over and over again,
but they've done a nice job with positioning this
as a way better answer to what the Cellini
was hopefully trying to figure out years ago.
But it also, in comparison to what else is out there,
it sits at the bottom of the Rolex page,
and I talked about all of the elements of Rolex's site.
I tried to derive meaning from that.
Now, some people might disagree,
but the fact that it's at the very bottom
tells me that it's not something
that many people are necessarily considering.
In addition, it's a rare circumstance
when a Rolex watch is factory-offered on a leather strap,
and further, despite only being precious metal,
it is arguably the most value-packed
fully precious metal watch from the brand.
Now, some people will rightfully say,
well, that is on a strap.
So let's look at it on the SETIMO bracelet,
which retails for $35,900.
Good chunk of change, no question about it,
but a watch that I absolutely love
and one of my favorite releases of 2025,
maybe my favorite release from 2025 from Rolex
when I just put it on my wrist for the first time.
Now, that completely transformed the design,
and I think when adding a bracelet to this style,
it differentiates this watch
from nearly every other watch of this category
and allows Rolex to be Rolex,
because to me, Rolex and what they do with their bracelets,
how it's presented, how it feels,
this is in more of an alignment
with what I think somebody might want
if they are gonna look in the direction of a 1908.
But then get back to the subject at hand,
how this is actually one of the most attainable
all-gold watches for Rolex,
but also stacks up pretty well to the competition.
Compared to a Submariner date gold on bracelet,
that's retailing for $44,600.
To the Day-Date 40 millimeter in yellow gold,
so same metal type, $44,200.
Then a Sky-Dweller, now you are dealing
with a larger case, elevated complication,
but that's gonna sell in yellow gold for $56,200.
The closest comparison that you're going to have,
and the only thing that's going to undercut it,
is a Ladies Datejust in yellow gold,
which is gonna be around that $32,000 range.
So on a bracelet, the 1908 is the most value-packed package
in all-gold, all-gold bracelet in a watch for men
from Rolex in the contemporary catalog,
which I've never heard someone necessarily say that.
When we think of the 1908,
we think high-end.
This is the upper end of the Rolex catalog,
but have you ever thought about it that way?
When I did the analysis, I'm like,
wait, that's pretty interesting when you think about it.
You want an all-gold watch from Rolex,
and I think on the Satemo bracelet,
it actually is one of the coolest combos.
Some might argue when you're looking at the actual amount
of gold that is used, this is one of the reasons why.
1908 is probably not going to be as expensive.
But all of this aside,
like when you're looking at someone's wrist
and they're wearing a Rolex watch and it's in gold,
are you thinking like,
what is the volume of gold in the case?
Like, that's not something that crosses my mind,
and I don't think it crosses the mind of anybody
that would ever look at a watch on someone's wrist,
especially a Rolex.
Now, further, the 7140 caliber is a step up
from other calibers from Rolex.
It's slim, has a sloxy hairspring,
corner G escapement,
and also a visible see-through case back.
And in all, I think the 1908 is still in its infancy,
so part of the reason why I'm putting it here
is because there's a lot of room to grow
and where this collection can go,
and I see it getting more popular,
especially with the recent developments
in the last 12 months.
Now, for years, the Air King and the Milgauss
would duke it out back and forth
on what was the outsider of the Rolex steel sports genre,
and the Milgauss always had its fans.
Now, the Air King, I'm sure it had its fans,
but we don't hear about them as much,
and that's why the Air King is the fourth watch on this list.
So the Air King has the history to go along with it.
We can go back to 1945,
and it predates pretty much every other sports model
from the brand, you name it.
Explorer, Submariner, GMT-Master, Daytona,
and it only gets a fraction of the admiration and fanfare,
and it has a pretty cool story to go along with it
with all the Air Series models,
with the Air King being the lone survivor
of that Air Series long-term.
It is only definitively bested by age
with the Oyster Perpetual
in the contemporary lineup of Rolex.
The Datejust right there with it,
but the Oyster Perpetual really set the standard
for all models to follow.
Now, I talked about the 1908 being at the very bottom
of all watches from Rolex,
but if you go to the sports side of the catalog,
the Professional Series,
the Air King will be at the very bottom.
Further, it's only bested by the Explorer 36 millimeters
when it comes to attainability at retail
for a steel sports model from Rolex.
The Air King at 40 millimeters is $7,750 at retail
at the time of recording this video,
whereas the Explorer 36 millimeters is $7,500.
And when you factor in the secondary market,
the Air King is one of a few exceptions
for a stainless steel sports watch from Rolex
that trades below retail,
and I think a lot of that has come down also
to the recent availability of the Explorer
now going back to 40 millimeters.
The Air King is also quirky.
It's one of these models now
that with the departure of the Milgauss in the lineup,
it fills a void for those that are looking for something
that doesn't just scream Rolex
and is not taking itself too seriously,
but is still very much a professional watch.
It's the only Rolex model in the lineup now
with two different colors on the Rolex logo
at 12 on the dial,
and it's one of a smaller group of pieces
that has a colored secondhand,
and finally has that distinct dial numeral set
with those enlarged minutes.
And when we talk about pilot aviation watches from Rolex,
we talk about the GMT-Master family.
That's what dominates.
But the Air King has a lot of history in that regard.
It predates the GMT-Master,
and also, functionally speaking,
is very much in alignment with some of the principles
of a pilot watch.
Orientation triangle,
larger minute track on the outside with those numerals.
There's a lot of times where people probably don't even think
of the Air King as a pilot watch.
They just think of it like,
yeah, that's that different, weird-looking Explorer,
and I think that's selling this watch very short.
So now we get to the final watch on this list.
Now, Rolex has several model families
that could be suitable for those
with the connection to the diving innovation
that the brand has in the mid-20th century.
You, of course, have the Submariner,
the model that needs no introduction
and is enjoyed by the masses,
with many owners likely not being aware
or even caring about the contributions
to the dive watch history that was brought forth by it.
And then you have the Deepsea,
a make-no-mistake piece made for the extreme
with dimensions and water resistance to match the approach.
And then finally, splitting the difference
of these two ideas is the 43-millimeter Sea-Dweller.
So the Sea-Dweller red in stainless steel,
this is the reference 126600,
is my final mention for a watch on this list
for a few reasons.
Now, one is the point that involves
what we discussed earlier.
It sits in a sweet spot of wearable luxury appeal
without fully abandoning this tool watch premise.
The Sea-Dweller at 43 millimeters certainly is a size up.
However, it is also still relatively wearable
for a decent segment of the watch buying public.
And we talk all the time about smaller wrist,
smaller wrist, smaller wrist,
but there's a whole segment of people out there
that want a larger watch that is wearable.
It's not gonna be a complete brick on the wrist,
like the Deepsea Challenge.
This is where the Sea-Dweller, I think,
can shine for certain people out there.
Then you're looking at the price and positioning.
The 126600 retails for $13,750 at the time of recording.
But then when looking at the secondary market,
it trades for $11,447.
So this is a drop of 16.7% of value,
and it makes it one of the single best chances
to obtain a Rolex Steel Sports watch at retail.
Further, the Sub and the Sub-Date and Steel
all trade above the Sea-Dweller,
despite this discrepancy in retail pricing.
And then another reason why I wanted to mention this watch
is because it sits in a nice pocket for case size
for a certain segment of buyers.
It's one of the few examples where you'll see
a case size being specifically offered by one model family.
Now, there are some rather rare exceptions,
like 39 millimeters with the 1908,
44 millimeters with the Deepsea,
but the 43 millimeter case size, it's a nice sweet spot.
You can decide to wear this more as an everyday piece.
And for those that maybe have a larger wrist
and want something with more presence,
they like the diving heritage that is brought forth
and just want something that's different,
that is where the Sea-Dweller shines.
And at 43 millimeters and its position in the market
from pricing and consideration,
I would say it's one of the most underrated Rolex watches
in the contemporary lineup.
But all right, guys, that's my video and my take
on some of the most underappreciated Rolex watches
in the catalog in 2026.
Do you guys agree with my takes?
Do you disagree?
Is there another watch that you think
should have been included instead of one of the watches
that I had on this list?
I'll leave some comments down below.
I know some of these choices might get some people saying,
no, I think this is better, this is better.
No, you can argue it out in the comments.
Just wanted to give my take here.
If you did enjoy the video, please give it a thumbs up,
subscribe, hit the bell icon.
Really do appreciate that.
Also check out teddybaldister.com.
teddybaldister.com is an authorized dealer
for over 35 brands.
Every purchase from our website
comes with quick and fast fulfillment,
dedicated customer support,
a full factory warranty for all the products that we offer.
I know there's a lot of different places
you can buy a watch nowadays,
but we'd absolutely love to have your business.
It allows us to keep doing what we're doing here.
We love what we do.
But guys, thank you again so much for watching.
Be well, and I'll see you all very soon.
