What kind of music can make a person forget the taste of meat for three months?
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount.
Unveiling the Forgotten, the Forbidden, and the Divine — a journey through China’s lost wisdom and a return to timeless tradition.
Follow me, and rediscover the China that time tried to forget. And consider supporting my research through a donation to help keep these forgotten voices alive. (Donation link: https://paypal.me/KSJBG)
Hello everyone, I'm Sarah. Welcome to Idioms and Their Origins, where every saying has a story.
Most of us think of music as harmless, something we put on in the background,
something that helps us relax, focus, or escape. Rarely do we stop to ask what music is doing to
us, not emotionally, but morally. Two thousand years ago, Confucius believed this question
mattered so much that he saw music as capable of determining the health of an entire society.
In the Analects, there is a short line that later became a famous phrase,
when Xiao Wang Wei. It says that when Confucius heard the ancient Xiao music,
he forgot the taste of meat for three months. At first, this sounds strange, almost exaggerated.
Why would music make someone forget food? To understand this, we need to step into a very
different way of thinking about sound. The music Confucius heard was near popular music,
nor performance music. It was ritual music, traditionally traced back to Emperor Shun,
a ruler remembered not for conquest, but for moral authority. According to early Chinese records,
Shun created Xiao music to reflect harmony between heaven, earth, and human society.
Music was not meant to entertain the individual, but to shape the collective heart.
In ancient China, music and governance were inseparable. A ruler who allowed chaotic or
indulgent music was believed to invite moral decay. Xiao music was slow, measured, and restrained.
Its purpose was not stimulation, but alignment. When Confucius heard it, he was not overwhelmed
by pleasure. He was overwhelmed by order. That is why he said he forgot the taste of meat.
Not because food lost its flavor, but because something deeper had taken precedence.
Confucius made a careful distinction between sound and music. Sound is mere vibration.
Music is sound shaped by virtue. He once described Xiao music as being both perfectly beautiful and
perfectly good. Beauty refers to form, balance, and harmony. Goodness refers to moral orientation.
Music that has beauty without goodness can be exciting, but it does not study the soul.
This way of thinking may sound foreign, but it is not uniquely Chinese.
In ancient Greece, Plato made a remarkably similar argument. In the Republic, he warned
that changes in musical styles would inevitably lead to changes in laws and morals. Music,
Plato argued, enters the soul without asking permission. It forms emotional habits before
reason has time to object. For both Plato and Confucius, music was never neutral. It always
pulled the listener in some direction. Confucius expressed this idea through contrast. Opposed to
Xiao music were what he called indulgent sounds, music that excites desire, amplifies emotion,
and weakens restraint. He warned that when such sounds dominate a culture,
those who flatter desire rather than cultivate virtue rise to power. This was not a complaint
about art or creativity. It was a warning about what constant stimulation does to character.
In Confucian thought, there is an even stronger term for this kind of sound,
the music of a fallen state. History offers many quiet parallels.
In the later years of the Roman Republic, philosophers noted a cultural shift.
Public life became louder, more theatrical, more obsessed with spectacle. Entertainment replaced
civic ritual. Sensation replaced restraint. No single song caused Rome to fall. But the
collective appetite for constant stimulation revealed a society that had lost its inner
discipline long before it lost its borders. Not because music collapses a nation overnight,
but because when a society becomes saturated with restless, indulgent sound,
it signals that something essential has already eroded from within.
Confucian texts describe the music of decline as anxious, successive, and emotionally distorted,
sound that no longer brings balance but feeds agitation. Chinese history records a striking
example of this idea. During the Sui dynasty, there was a court musician named Wang Bochang,
a master of musical theory and pitch. When imperial officials presented a new court music
system to the emperor, Wang Bochang listened and immediately objected. He said plainly,
this is the sound of a fallen state. It is not something your majesty should hear.
He described the music as sorrowful, indulgent, and unrestrained, technically impressive,
but morally disordered. The emperor took his warnings seriously. Wang Bochang was asked to
redesign the instruments, lowering the pitch and restoring what he called upright and proper sound.
Years later, while the Sui dynasty was still at its height, Wang Bochang heard new court
music being performed. He wept and said, these sounds are excessive and sorrowful.
The world will descend into mutual destruction. At the time, no one believed him. The empire
seemed strong. But within a generation, the Sui dynasty collapsed into chaos,
exactly as he had predicted. This is why Confucius did not treat music as a matter of
personal taste. To him, and to those who truly understood sound, music revealed the inner
condition of a society long before collapse became visible. Wen Shao Wang Wei is not about forgetting
food. It is about recognizing when sound carries order, and when it carries decay. In this sense,
music becomes diagnostic. It tells us what kind of inner life a culture is cultivating
long before political failure appears. Today, we live in a world saturated with sound.
Music, videos, short clips, notifications, each competing for attention. Much of it is designed
not to calm the mind, but to provoke reaction. We call it entertainment. Confucius would have
called it influence. Wen Shao Wang Wei is often translated as being so absorbed that one forgets
taste. But this misses the point. Confucius was not losing himself. He was finding alignment.
When the heart encounters something truly ordered and good, the senses do not disappear. They simply
stop demanding center stage. This is why forgetting taste is not an act of denial,
but a sign that inner hierarchy has been restored. The question Confucius leaves us with is not
whether music is enjoyable, but whether it makes us clearer or more scattered, calmer or more
restless, whole or fragmented. We rarely ask this because modern culture treats all sound as
personal choice. But the truth is what we repeatedly listen to becomes familiar. What
becomes familiar becomes normal. And what feels normal eventually shapes who we are.
The music we live with does not merely reflect us. Over time, it forms us.
Wen Shao Wang Wei is not about ancient music. It is about discernment. It asks us to listen
more carefully not only to sound but to ourselves. Because in the end, the sounds that
surround us quietly shape our inner life. And when inner life loses order, the outer world
eventually follows. That inner life slowly and silently shapes the world we build.
That's it for today. Please share your thoughts in the comments.
Like and share if this resonated with you. See you next time.