Tiramisu...But Make It Cookies

Health Food
429 followers
Tiramisu cookies! This one was highly requested, and honestly I resisted making these cookies for
a long time, and that's because a tiramisu cookie is going to need to be made with mascarpone frosting,
it's going to need to be refrigerated, and refrigerated cookies can kind of be a pain
because they need to still be good even when they're cold, but we finally nailed it. It took
a lot of attempts. This recipe is going to make about 15 cookies. They're larger, more gourmet
style cookies, so I felt like that was a good number, but I don't see any reason why this
recipe wouldn't double well if you wanted to make more. All right, let's start with a large mixing
bowl. To this we're going to add a half cup or 113 grams of softened unsalted butter. We'll also
add a half cup or 100 grams of granulated sugar, and then just a fourth cup or 50 grams of firmly
packed light brown sugar. The light brown sugar really adds like a nice subtle depth without
making the cookie too rich on its own. If you've made my classic tiramisu, you know that the cookie
layer itself is not super flavorful. It's flavored a lot with coffee, so I didn't want to go overboard
with sweetening the cookie. I didn't want like a sugar cookie base. All right, let's go ahead and
use an electric mixer. You can use a stand mixer with a paddle attachment if you prefer. I'm just
using a hand mixer. We'll beat this until it's light and creamy. All right, once this is light
and creamy, let's take a look. Make sure you can get a good look at that. We are going to add our
next ingredient. I'm just going to slide this out of the way because the next ingredient is an egg.
One large egg. Room temperature is nice. Helps things combine nicely. And then, kind of a twist
from what we do with a lot of our cookies, we're also going to add one large egg white. So we're
not going to use the yolk. I'm going to save it for something else or discard it. Now this extra egg
white was intentional. I wanted these cookies to be a little bit lighter and cakier for a couple
reasons. I wanted them to kind of be distantly related to ladyfingers, which use a lot of egg
white. And having a lighter texture keeps it softer in the refrigerator. So this was very
intentional. Don't just throw in the egg yolk because you don't want to get rid of it. Let's
go ahead and mix these in. And when I'm doing this, I gradually increase my speed to high and
I'll mix on high for a bit because I want things really well incorporated. I want the batter to be
nice and uniform. Oh, and I almost forgot the vanilla extract. We'll add this as well. Not
too much vanilla. Again, I didn't want the cookie itself to be too rich. A fourth teaspoon. I
usually add it with eggs, but it's okay to stir it in after. Just enough vanilla. The main flavor
of the cookies will be espresso. We'll get to that in a bit. Okay, these are really nicely combined.
Slide it out of the way. Grab a separate bowl for your dry ingredients. We're going to add
one and three-fourths cup or 220 grams of all-purpose flour. We're also going to add three
tablespoons of cornstarch. Cornstarch really, again, helps lend itself to that slightly cakey
but still tender texture of the cookie. A teaspoon of baking powder and one-fourth
teaspoon of baking soda and one-half teaspoon of table salt. Go ahead and whisk everything
together. Get this nicely combined. Just a reminder, the full recipe with weight is always
listed in the description of the recipe, and I always include a link to the printable recipe
on my website. If you are watching this from the membership, you get early access, so you're
usually seeing this before that printable link is working because you are seeing the recipe before
even the followers on my website are. Soon that'll be available for you too. Bring back our wet
ingredients, and we're going to gradually add the dry to the wet. Stir on low speed until combined.
Don't need to go crazy anymore. Usually just add it in two or three parts. It's really not that
much flour. A bit more. Always scrape your bowl. Make sure everything's well incorporated. Okay,
next up, we talked a little bit about espresso powder. Let's talk about that a bit more. Espresso
is a key flavor in tiramisu, so of course we needed to incorporate it in our cookies. To get
a really nice, strong flavor, a very present flavor, we are going to bloom the espresso powder
first rather than just mix it in with our dry ingredients. So I have a tablespoon of very hot
water here and a tablespoon of espresso powder. Drizzle that in. I'm living on the edge of this
tiny dish, but we'll make it work, and then just whisk it together. The hotter your water, the
better because it's going to do a better job of blooming the espresso and getting a really deep
flavor. Let's bring this back, and we will use our mixer again to stir in the espresso. I kind of
like to start stirring on low speed and drizzle it in. A little messy. That's okay. I say low
speed, and then I like turn it up to high. Patience. Put the last bit in, and this bit of liquid being
added also helps add a little bit of lightness to the cookie. Again, that's not something I aim for
in a lot of my cookies. I'm looking for dense and chewy usually, but this cookie called for lighter
and cakey-er, and I will say it works really well. So this dough is going to need to chill,
especially since we just put that hot water in it. It's going to be a little bit too sticky to
manage. I like to chill it for at least 30 minutes, but an hour's even better. Of course, you can even
chill it longer than that. I'm going to cover it with plastic wrap. We'll place it in the fridge.
Now, a bit before you're ready to begin baking and your dough's done chilling, you'll want to get
your oven preheating to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. All right, this dough has actually chilled a
little bit longer than an hour, so it's probably going to be a little less sticky than yours will
be at 30 minutes. We're going to go ahead and scoop about two tablespoon-sized portions. It's like 35
grams. Now I have to measure it to make sure it's actually 35 grams because I have a problem with
not always making my cookies uniform. We're going to want to roll the dough into a smooth ball.
It's a lot easier to do if the dough is a little bit colder. Place it on your baking sheet. Make
sure you space your cookies at least two inches apart. Too many cookies on a baking sheet will
make a mess. We're going to lightly flatten the cookies. If there's the dough sticking to your
hands too much, just lightly dampen your fingers with a little bit of water and the dough won't
stick. All right, let's do a couple of these. I usually do six cookies to a sheet, and I always
line the baking sheet with parchment paper. The dough will be a little bit stickier if you pull
yours out after 30 minutes, but it should still be manageable. It's not just chill it a tad longer.
All right, let's go ahead and flatten these guys. Your oven should be preheated to 350 degrees
Fahrenheit by this point. We're going to take these over to the center rack of our preheated
oven. We're going to bake for 9 to 10 minutes. So if you're familiar with classic tiramisu,
you will have these lady fingers, and you dip them in an espresso liquid mixture before you
the tiramisu. I wanted to replicate that and also infuse even more flavor and moisture into the
cookies. We're going to make a very simple—it's not a syrup—we're going to make a very simple
espresso mixture to brush over the cookies. So I usually prepare this while they're baking.
So you'll need just a half tablespoon of espresso powder—it's one and a half teaspoons—and
two tablespoons of hot water. I'm going to go ahead and mix that in, get it nice and smooth.
And then you'll also need a teaspoon of either Kahlua, which is what I'm using today and what
I prefer, or you can use a spiced rum. I think a Marsala wine would also work well here. You just
use a teaspoon of this. And if you want to go without the alcohol, you can, but you will lose
some of that classic tiramisu flavor and some of that depth. It'll just be a little bit less
flavorful. I might recommend using a splash of vanilla instead. All right, now when they're
finished baking, the edges should be set. They might be beginning to turn a very light golden,
but you do not want to overdo it with these cookies. Error on them being slightly underdone
rather than overdone. If they're overdone, they end up dry and it's just—it's tragic, guys. Now if your
cookies kind of domed on the top, maybe you didn't flatten them enough, you can use the clean—yep,
okay, it's clean—clean bottom of a measuring cup to just very gently flatten the top. That way you
have a smooth surface for putting our frosting on top, but that wasn't really necessary with these,
but I wanted to demonstrate. Now I let these cool for about five minutes. I want them to be still
warm when I brush them, but I don't like them to be too hot because sometimes they're a little
fragile when they're hot. So after a few minutes, I'll take a pastry brush. We'll go ahead and dip it,
and then I kind of tap off the excess. I don't want to make the cookie soggy, so it's a light
brushing. I'm gonna press it against the side to drip off any extra, and we'll lightly paint the
top of each cookie one way, and then we'll go the other way and paint it again. You will not use all
of this mixture. Tap off the extra, brush it, brush again. Again, do not go overboard on this or the
cookies will be soggy. All right, now the cookies will need to cool completely before you can put
the frosting on. If you try to add that while they're hot, the frosting will melt. It'll be messy. You'll be sad.
So we're going to set these aside, and while they're cooling, we can prepare that frosting.
What I love about this icing or frosting is that it actually is very easy. Mascarpone can be a
little bit fussy to deal with. Not in today's recipe, and this is way easier than making like a
zabaglione for tiramisu. So we need a half cup or 120 milliliters of cold heavy cream. Go ahead and
pour that into a mixing bowl. Add four ounces of mascarpone cheese straight from the fridge, nice
and cold as well. Everything where the cream and the mascarpone are cold, just go right in together.
Three-fourths cup or 95 grams of powdered sugar. One half teaspoon of vanilla extract. This is my
teaspoon. I'll just go halfway. Two teaspoons of Kahlua or rum. Whichever one you choose to use,
spiced rum is what you would use. You will need an electric mixer for this step. Grab it. We are
going to start mixing on low speed. Once the mascarpone seems like it's mostly incorporated,
mostly broken up, increase your speed to high. And we're just going to continue to mix on high
speed until we have stiff peaks. This is looking pretty good. I'd call that stiff peaks, wouldn't
you? So this is going to go into my piping bag. You can just spread the topping on top. You can
pipe it on top. Do whatever you want, but I like to use a half inch. I think this is a half inch tip.
Maybe I'm wrong on that. It's a 1A tip. Our frosting right in here. I have my glass for my
trick. Remember, we are only piping the frosting on completely cooled cookies.
Bench scraper is great for just moving that down. All right, let's check on our cookies. Make sure
they're cooled completely. Keep this cold if they're not. Once they're nice and completely
cool, we can go ahead and add our frosting. Go ahead and do a nice decorative little swirl.
This is kind of how I do my loft house cookies. Don't go too crazy on your frosting because this
makes like exactly the right amount to cover 15 cookies. Then, of course, we need a dusting of
cocoa powder. I recommend natural cocoa powder. I think that's best and most classic. Scoop up a
bit of it here. Go ahead and dust that over the cookies. And, of course, you can enjoy these
cookies right away, but if you don't eat them right away, you will need to keep them—oh,
that was heavy—in the fridge in an airtight container. I am really excited for you to try
this and let me know what you think. I really do always love hearing from you. If you enjoy this
one, maybe you will also enjoy my classic tiramisu or my tiramisu cake recipe that I shared a bit
ago. I'm going to cut into one so you guys can see this texture. You can see they're nice and soft,
a little different from the cookies I often go for. I really like these and I think you will too.
This needs to go. We need new everything. Was he like,
wouldn't the butter or something? I am appalled.
