The Universe Itself Might Be Hiding the Gravity Particle From Us

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Thank you to Brilliant for supporting PBS. To progress to the next level in understanding
reality, we need to combine quantum mechanics with Einstein's general relativity. And to do that,
most physicists believe we need a theory of quantum gravity, which means we need
gravitons. But it also seems like the laws of physics make it impossible to ever detect this
quantum particle of gravity. Almost like the universe is set up to keep the final answer
forever out of our reach. So can we outsmart the universe, catch a graviton, and finally solve
physics? We've got a couple of quick announcements before we start. First, our eternal battle against
the algorithm continues. The best way to encourage YouTube to share our videos is to like and
comment. Doing both really makes a difference. And if you're new here, subscribe, hit the bell,
and introduce yourself in the comments. We're friendly. We're also offering 20% off the entire
merch store until January 19th, 2026. So if there's anything you had your eye on, there's a
link in the description. Now on to the episode. In 2012, the legendary physicist Freeman Dyson
gave a talk in which he speculated on the possibility of ever detecting gravitons.
He was not optimistic. In his Poincaré Prize lecture, he laid out how the universe seems to
conspire to make the detection of the quantum particle of gravity impossible. In some cases,
it seems to be impossible for all practical experiments. The experiments are just too
outlandish to ever happen. But in other cases, graviton detection seems to be in principle and
fundamentally impossible. We're thwarted by the appearance of black holes or by the quantum vacuum
from ever glimpsing a graviton. So does the universe really prohibit us from ever seeing
the building block of the fabric of spacetime? As a reminder, the graviton is the quantum particle
of gravity, just as the photon is the quanta of electromagnetism, gluons of the strong force, etc.
But the graviton is more than that. It's the building block of the fabric of the universe.
In the same way as an electromagnetic field can be thought of as being made of a sea of
virtual photons, spacetime is made of gravitons. At least that's true if spacetime has a quantum
nature, as most physicists seem to believe. All theories of quantum gravity require them,
from string theory to loop quantum gravity, so it's probably worth trying to spot one if we ever
want to verify these theories. Now in the past we've talked about indirect ways to test the
quantum nature of gravity, but what about detecting the graviton itself? Well there are two broad ways
we can think about graviton detection. On the one hand we can take what we know about detecting
classical gravitational fields and try to apply it to a quantized field of gravitons.
Basically to detect the gravitational effect of a single graviton. On the other hand we can treat
gravitons like every other particle and use the same techniques we once used to say squeeze photons
out from the electromagnetic field. By tackling both perspectives we can get a reasonably
comprehensive sense of how impossible graviton detection may really be. So let's start by trying
to detect the gravitational effect of a single graviton. We'll think about this in terms of the
most sensitive gravity detectors ever built, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory
LIGO. This pair of detectors tracks the subtle differences in phase of a pair of laser beams
traveling along four kilometer perpendicular arms. When those phases fail to line up it indicates a
a possible signature of a passing gravitational wave. We've used these observations to spot
gravitational waves from hundreds of merging black holes and neutron stars since the first
detection in 2015. So what would it take for a laser interferometer along these lines to detect
a single graviton? We'll follow Dyson's argument here. LIGO is able to detect gravitational waves
with a strain of 10 to the power of minus 22. That's the relative change in length that the
device is sensitive to. It corresponds to one one-thousandth of the width of a proton for the
300 back and forth reflections along LIGO's four kilometer arms. If gravity is indeed quantum then
gravitational waves are made of a coherent superposition of gravitons in the same way that
our lasers are made of photons. A wave at LIGO's strain limit would contain at least 10 to the
power of 36 gravitons. We're trying to see a single graviton so in principle we'd need a detector that's
10 to the power of 36 times more sensitive. The critical question we need to ask is how precisely
do we need to measure the variation in the length of detector arms to pick up that single graviton
event? It turns out that the answer is sort of independent of the type of gravitational wave.
For optimal sensitivity we need to be able to measure a length difference of the order a single
Planck length. This should already raise concerns because the Planck length is the distance where
our current understanding of space breaks down. But let's proceed. The limits of measurability of
literally everything is defined by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The principle sets an
absolute limit on how precisely we can know complementary pairs of properties simultaneously.
For example the position or momentum of something. Let's start simple by imagining one LIGO arm as a
pair of free-floating mirrors. A gravitational wave causes the distance between them to change
and we want to measure that changing distance. That's effectively measured by bouncing a photon
between them. However that photon also imparts momentum on the mirrors inducing an uncertainty
in the mirror position. The more precisely we want to measure those positions the higher the frequency
of light we need therefore the more momentum we have to impart. The position momentum uncertainty
relation can be used to relate the limit of the position measurement to the imparted mirror
momentum. We can then convert this relationship to one involving time. So in order to accurately
measure the separation of the mirrors that measurement has to happen fast. Faster than the
mirrors move out of position due to the act of measuring. Long story short we can maximize the
precision of our measurement of the mirror separation in two ways. By reducing the distance
between the mirrors that reduces the measurement time and by increasing the mass of the mirrors.
Heavy mirrors move more slowly when bumped by the measuring photon. If we want a one-plank
length position precision due to the passage of a graviton the mirrors need to be massive enough
and close enough together that they form a black hole. Well that sucks. By definition the formation
of an event horizon prevents our distance measurement. Dyson shows that we get the same
issue via a different argument even if we fix the mirrors in place. In general any distance
measurement on the scale of the plank length gives us black holes which means that the direct
measurement of the effect of a single graviton by a logo-like device is fundamentally impossible.
Okay let's try something else. The gravitational wave approach tries to measure the actual
gravitational effect of a single graviton but maybe treating gravitons gravitationally is using a
classical hammer to crack a quantum nut. Instead maybe we should look for gravitons by the same
method we look for other quantum particles. We can summarize that method in very general terms.
Crash particles together and see what happens. The physics of colliding particles is inherently
different to the interactions of classical waves so maybe that's the right approach for spotting
a particle that arises from a quantum field. The most obvious example of the particle collision
method is, surprise surprise, a particle collider. We discovered the Higgs boson by building a
collider so large that its collision energies could generate the mass of Higgs particle.
And that collider is the 27 kilometer diameter large hadron collider. So how large a collider
do we need to generate a graviton? Well gravitons are massless so the energy isn't needed to give
the mass like it is with the Higgs. Rather energy is needed to increase the chance of generating one.
Gravity is the weakest force by a long long way. It's 24 orders of magnitude weaker than the
weakest of the other fundamental forces. A fact which itself is a conundrum called the hierarchy
problem which obviously we've talked about before. In quantum terms that weakness can be expressed
as a very small coupling constant between the graviton and the other particles. The probability
of generating a graviton in a particle collision depends on that coupling constant and despite the
word constant the coupling factor actually increases with the energy of the interaction.
At around a billion joules the coupling for gravity reaches the ballpark strength of the other
forces so that's the energy that we need to reach in our collisions to have a fair chance of producing
gravitons. And how big an accelerator do we need to reach a billion joules? Well the LHC collisions
reach a whopping millionth of one joule. Now for a fixed magnetic field strength collision energy
scales directly with collider size. To get to the energy needed to generate a graviton a collider
with the same magnets as the 27 kilometer LHC would need to be around three light years in
diameter. Much bigger than our solar system. That sounds insanely difficult but it's in principle
possible and once we've built this graviton factory we then get to the real challenge.
It's not creating gravitons but actually detecting them. Now massless gravitons are stable so we can't
rely on looking for their decay products. We need to see one via its gravitational effect which we
just saw may be impossible or when it's absorbed by or scatters another particle. So the OG example
of discovering a particle this way is the photoelectric effect in which an electron is
ejected from a conducting plate by a single photon. Einstein used this effect to demonstrate the
So can we use a similar test to detect gravitons? An equivalent gravitoelectric effect? Well in
principle yes. A sufficiently high frequency graviton will carry enough energy to kick
an electron out of an atom or out of a conducting plate. We could also imagine a graviton equivalent
of the Compton effect in which electrons are ejected from atomic orbitals. Either way we
shift the problem from detecting gravitons to detecting electrons which is pretty easy. Now the
probability of an electron absorbing a graviton to produce one of these phenomena depends again on
the coupling strength of gravity. So just as with graviton creation this phenomenon is super unlikely
another way to think about this interaction strength is in terms of a cross-section. It's
called a cross-section because it tells us how big an electron looks say to a graviton. How close
the graviton needs to get to the electron center in order to hit it and get absorbed. And for the
graviton electron interaction the cross-section is proportional to the square of the Planck length.
So even if we can create a graviton in our interstellar sized collider let's call it the
SLC stupidly large collider we can probably never actually detect it. The other way we can increase
the likelihood of a gravitoelectric interaction is by increasing the number of gravitons in the
right frequency range. So maybe we amp up the power of our SLC or maybe we find a natural source of
gravitons. The theoretical physicist Steven Weinberg calculated that there are potentially a huge
quantity of high frequency gravitons being emitted by the sun. These are produced by electron graviton
interactions in the hot dense core of the sun. At the energy that we need the sun should produce
about 10 to the power of 24 gravitons per second. This amounts to about four per square meter per
second passing through the earth's surface. You probably didn't notice the several that passed
through you during just this sentence. The interaction cross-section for this is so small that
these solar gravitons only interact with a particle of matter roughly once every billion years or so
across the entire volume of the earth. Now we could build say a planet or even a star-sized detector
and maybe get a detection every thousand years rather than every billion but that still feels
like an unsatisfying yield. We probably need actually a stronger source of gravitons than a mere
entire star. The best option might be the collapsed core of a dead star. Robert Gould estimates that a
hot white dwarf or a neutron star would emit respectively a hundred and a hundred thousand
times more gravitons than the sun although over a shorter time scale. So placing a star-sized detector
near such a stellar remnant many light years away might get us a single graviton on a human time
scale. Of course the path to building such an experiment is far beyond human time scales if
it's possible at all and if we were to somehow pull this off we'd face an even more basic issue.
Neutrinos. These ghostly particles are notoriously hard to spot. Most of the sun's neutrinos pass
straight through the earth and we built detectors out of the antarctic ice cap to catch the occasional
rare interaction. But by comparison to the shy graviton the neutrino is a party animal.
For any of our graviton sources regardless of whether it's our sun, the white dwarf, the neutron
star, our detector will interact with 10 to the power of 34 neutrinos per single graviton.
And distinguishing that graviton from the neutrino noise seems practically impossible. Let's try one
more method that on the surface looks promising. In the 1960s Mikhail Gertzenstein showed that
electromagnetic and gravitational waves in a strong magnetic field can couple together.
This is more promising than looking for interactions between gravitons and say electrons.
EM and gravitational waves which both travel at the speed of light can experience wave resonance
that allows energy to transfer between them at a much lower coupling strength than is needed for
the absorption of a graviton by matter. This means a photon may be transformed into a graviton and
vice versa. So if we shoot a graviton through a magnetic field it will oscillate between graviton
states and photon states. This is called the Gertzenstein effect. Now to do this we need a long
hollow tube threaded by a strong magnetic field pointed towards a source of gravitons. The hope
is that some of those gravitons will turn into photons that we can detect. And as you may have
guessed the universe again conspires against us. The magnetic field needs to be quite strong for
the Gertzenstein effect to work. How strong? Well strong enough that we have spontaneous creation
of matter-antimatter pairs inside the tube. The vacuum polarization resulting from this limits
the coherence of EM waves in the tube preventing resonance with gravitational waves and shutting
down the Gertzenstein effect. So we are at strike three for detecting gravitons. It seemed that the
doesn't want us to see its deeper structure. But is it really impossible or just nearly impossible?
In a couple of the cases we looked at the answer is that it's impossible. The barrier to graviton
detection seems fundamental. The formation of black holes, the breakdown of the vacuum, tells us that
the laws of physics forbid graviton detection by these methods. But in other cases it's just
astonishingly difficult. We need star-sized graviton sources and detectors and some yet
unknown way to filter neutrinos. But next to impossible is still possible. I'm saying there's
a chance. And maybe the problem is actually just that we haven't come up with a smart enough
experiment yet. Or maybe we have. Since Dyson's 2012 lecture we've detected gravitational waves
directly and we've made major advancements in quantum technology. This has inspired a new
generation of physicists to come up with a new generation of proposals. For example we may be
able to combine the two broad approaches that I mentioned using a LIGO-like interferometer
combined with absorption of gravitons this time by a detector with novel quantum properties.
How does that work? Well that's for an episode coming soon when we'll find out how we really
may be able to detect the particle at the heart of spacetime. Thank you to Brilliant for supporting
PBS. Brilliant is where you learn by doing. With thousands of interactive lessons in physics, math,
programming and AI Brilliant helps build your critical thinking skills through problem solving
not memorizing. Each lesson starts by helping you master the foundations then levels you up
to increasingly challenging problems. And if you're into computation Brilliant offers a course
in algorithmic thinking designed to help you understand the computational sides of algorithms.
In the course you'll tackle real programming challenges that teach you how to think through
algorithmic design strategy and optimization. To try everything Brilliant has to offer go to
or click the link in the description. Brilliant also gives our viewers 20%
off an annual premium subscription which gives you unlimited daily access to everything on Brilliant.
