Taylor Swift joins TIFF CEO Cameron Bailey in an engaging conversation about filmmaking and the visual aspects of her music.
Swift is a creative powerhouse. Singer, songwriter, producer, actor, director — this multi-hyphenate artist is the only woman in history to win the Grammy Award for Album of the Year three times, tying for the most wins by any artist (alongside Frank Sinatra, Stevie Wonder, and Paul Simon), as well as earning prizes in eight other categories. In addition to music, Swift has long been a visual storyteller. From influencing the edits of her music videos, to writing the treatments herself and then making the jump to director, she has defined a distinct style that extends out of her songwriting. In 2021, she released re-recordings of Fearless (Taylor’s Version) and Red (Taylor’s Version), her acclaimed second and fourth albums, as an act of reclamation and creative empowerment. The latter release was followed by All Too Well: The Short Film, which she directed, wrote, produced, and appeared in.
What can you tell us about The Red Scarf, because there must have been a lot of decisions
that went into exactly what you did.
What can I tell you, is the question.
I've always been very fascinated, and one of the reasons I wanted to make a short film
and not a music video for this song is because I've been fascinated with the dynamic of the
age of the character that Sadie's playing, and what a precarious age that is when you
are.
You could fit back at your family home, sort of, but you sort of don't.
You could fit in an adult's cultivated apartment where they have like a French press and they
have all the things that adults have, but you kind of don't.
So you kind of fit everywhere, but you kind of fit nowhere.
And I think that plays into a little bit of where she's coming from, and I have to credit
Dylan too with the fact that I know that he's gaslighting her, and I know that he's like,
I know it's problematic, but I'm watching that and I'm like, he is so charismatic.
He is charismatic problematic, and I am still sort of rooting for them to work through this
because he makes some charming points, and he does it in a really, really like, I don't
know, just the way that they both played it, I was just blown away.
It's beautiful.
I'm sure so many people relate to it as well, because charismatic, problematic, definition
of a boyfriend, maybe.
An ex-boyfriend.
Okay, an ex-boyfriend.
I don't know how far we want to go with that, but zero, that's it.
Nowhere.
There's another element in the film that there are a lot of theories about, which is that
red scarf.
Yeah.
What can you tell us about the red scarf, because there must have been a lot of decisions
that went into exactly what-
What can I tell you, is the question.
Basically, you stop it, stop it.
Basically, the scarf is a metaphor, and we turned it red because red is a very important
color in this album, which is called Red.
And I think when I say it's a metaphor, I'm just going to stop.
Leave it.
And I'm going to say thanks for the incredible question to whoever asked it.
You've really taken us for a ride with that one.
Thank you.
The scarf question was mine, actually.
Thanks, at Cameron Bailey.
That's right.
Yes.
Thank you.
You mentioned music videos.
I do want to go back, because before you directed this film, you began to have increasing visual
input into the making of your music videos, and I want to ask about that process, how
you were drawn to getting into the creativity of the music videos as opposed to just being
on camera.
Yeah, it was a baby steps process.
It wasn't like I woke up one day and I was like, you know what I want to do, direct.
That was never something that I was programmed to say to myself, because I didn't go to film
school.
I've been on the set of 60 plus music videos, and I've learned a lot from that process,
because I've always got my eyes and ears open, and I'm always looking at shots and thinking,
I like that one.
I don't like that.
Why and why not?
I like that lighting.
I don't like that lighting.
Why and why not?
You kind of are learning based on your experience, but I had a really, really close creative
relationship with Joseph Kahn, who's just like a legend in music videos.
He did Toxic by Britney Spears, just to give you an example of what we're dealing with.
We made several music videos, and we got to the point where I'd call him up and I'd be
like, okay, wrote this song called Look What You Made Me Do.
I want to come out of the ground as a zombie, right?
We're seeing my hand out of the ground, and then I'm dead, and then I'm in a bathtub of
diamonds, and then there's a mountain of me's trying to kill the current me, and he'd be
on the phone and be like, yeah, I know exactly what we're doing.
Okay, amazing, amazing.
And so having that relationship where essentially it got to the point where I was sort of starting
to write the treatments to the videos.
And I then decided it might be really cool to co-direct and to step into that role.
And so I got to co-direct a few videos with incredible collaborators, and I learned what
it was like to start writing in-depth treatments and shot listing and really leaning into it.
But when I did it on my own, that was when I really, really learned everything.
All of the evolution we've been talking about, from beginning to contribute to and collaborate
on music videos, to making your own short films, and this one, particularly recently,
it's coincided with you taking back control of your music, which we've all been following
and celebrating.
It's amazing.
I really appreciate you saying that, but if you're new to this saga, what Cameron's referencing
is that basically I started out on an indie record label I signed when I was a teenager
and I had always had the hope, desire, and dream of buying back my master recordings
for my first six albums when it came time to, when my record deal was fulfilled.
When my deal was done, that didn't happen.
My music was all sold to an outside party.
And I...
So it's...
We don't...
It's...
Yeah.
But basically, what happened was a period of extreme despair for me, and then I came
out of that and said to myself, if I made that music the first time, I can make it a
And it was so exciting, honestly, to get to do something that I haven't really seen done
in the music industry in this particular way.
It's cake genius.
Seriously.
That is so nice.
It's just brilliant.
James Varsity!
And so basically, we treat them like they're big releases.
We do a whole album.
We redo the entire photo shoot.
We make music videos, and sometimes we make a short film.
And so it's really been, honestly, insanely beautiful, because you have...
My friend's daughter is 12, and her friends were saying, like, oh, we just...
We love this new Taylor Swift song that just came out called You Belong With Me.
And I was like, who's going to tell her?
No, don't tell her.
That's a really old song that came out in, what, 2008 or something.
So it's really been an amazing opportunity to revisit my old music, make exact copies
of the old music.
And what I also do now is I...
There were a lot of songs that I wrote that didn't end up on the album, so we call those
songs from-the-vault tracks.
So I record them, I put them out, so it's been really wonderful, and it's only been
possible because the fans actually want this to happen.
I can't believe that, too.
That's amazing that you guys have been so wonderful about it.
But basically, this song, All Too Well, the 10-minute version, has a very long story.
It is a story about as long as the song, but I'll try to make it shorter.
This was a song that originally was released on an album called Red in 2012.
Thank you so much.
You guys are great.
And it was a song that I loved so much, but it was never chosen by an A&R team in a conference
room as being a single.
Nobody saw the potential in it, except for the fans who loved it so much that they made
it sort of their favorite song on that album.
For me, the song was so tough because it was about something that, at that point, was very
current for me.
I would have a really hard time performing it at the time.
I had to really force myself to focus on other things to try to get through it during tour.
So there would be no world in which I could have made a visual element to that song at
that point in time.
I needed 10 years of sort of retrospect in order to know what I would even make to tell
a version of that story visually.
And I'm so grateful that I was able to do that with some crazy stroke of all these different
twists of fate.
Can't believe it.
Do you make a connection between coming to the point where you can create your own images
and owning your own music?
What's the connection?
I think it's very connected, and not in a way that was conscious, but I think in a way
where hopefully the more years you live, the more things you learn, and you hope that you
get braver as time goes on.
And I've been very lucky to, when I've taken these baby steps creatively, I've been very
lucky to have people go like, no, no, no, go further, it's great, keep going.
And I think I would have really tried to keep expanding creatively even if I had been squashed
the first time I tried to make something.
But it was really beautiful that we're in a place where hearing the idea of a female
filmmaker doesn't make you roll your eyes or think as skeptically as it once was.
And we have so many incredible female filmmakers to thank for that.
A lot of them here during the festival.
Absolutely, absolutely.
And I just feel really grateful.
You think about people like Nora Ephron, there's people who paved the path, and then there's
Nora Ephron in the forest with a machete just hacking to where the path will be paved.
And I think about writer-directors like that who inspired the writer-directors who inspired
me.
It's like a whole...
I think about people like that all the time.
I also just do want to say that I'm aware of the fact that I'm in an incredibly privileged
place to have gotten to finance this short film independently.
Because when we talk about female filmmakers, I am one of them, but I also realize that
there are people who are working so hard to get financing and to get any type of budget
together to make the productions and the projects that they want to make.
So I honestly bow down and tip my hat to those female filmmakers.