The Sad Downfall of Lewis Hamilton.

Formula 1 News
151 followers
54 Video Views·Jan 13, 2026
Comments are disabled for this video.
The beginning of 2025, looking back, felt like a fever dream. The start of any year is the time
for endless optimism, and seeing the photos and videos of the most successful driver go to the
most successful team in F1 history, it was difficult not to get swept up in the thoughts
of Lewis Hamilton winning races for Ferrari. Unfortunately, whilst Ferrari's PR department
was moving like 2023 Red Bull, the season was, well, 2025 Ferrari. An absolute disaster from
start to finish that included multiple disqualifications, no podiums for Lewis Hamilton
for the first time in his career, a car that both drivers felt at times was undriveable,
and even ended up with Ferrari chairman John Elkin bizarrely praising Ferrari's technical
department and criticising its drivers. The number one word that comes to mind when I think
about Lewis' 2025 season would be sad, especially when looking back at the only high point of the
which was the sprint in China. Those sessions were just vintage Hamilton in terms of nailing a great
lap when three different teams were in contention for sprint pole, and then in the sprint itself,
it was like Lewis' championship winning years with him nailing the start and then completely
controlling and dominating the whole race without any drama. In the context of 2025, when I have
spent so much time talking about how many mistakes both Lando and Oscar have made as they have gone
for their first title, the sprint in China was a Verstappen level of execution from Hamilton,
which is exactly what we know Lewis is capable of.
And now really quickly before we move on, I want to say that right now,
if you have got the motorsport itch and are looking for something to watch
during the F1 off-season, then I thoroughly recommend to check out Formula E Driver
Season 2 which covers the 2025 season. In a world where we are seeing more and more
character and personality driven motorsport series, this is one that really surprised me.
It made me root for a driver that I actively disliked before watching the series,
it showed an intense and toxic teammate rivalry which we all love to see, and in general,
even for those of you who are perhaps Formula E sceptics, it might just entertain and surprise
you when you see it. On top of that, I also did a quick review of it on my channel which I'll link
down in the description, but once again, if you have got that motorsport shaped hole in your life
that you want to fill ahead of the 2026 season, then check out Formula E Driver Season 2 streaming
right now on Amazon Prime Video, but for now, let's get back to the video.
I think the disappointment of 2025 has exposed so many shortcomings at Ferrari that
it's important to separate Hamilton's decline and underperformance with the fundamental issues
that still exist at Ferrari and that won't be changing regardless of what driver they put into
that team. As far as Lewis, it's important to say right from the outset that he has not been better
than Sainz was relative to Leclerc, and the reality is that in terms of performance, unless
things drastically change with the new generation of cars in 2026, Ferrari made a mistake in dropping
Sainz in favour of Hamilton. The Hamilton-Sainz comparison to me is a very important one because
in Leclerc you have a proven benchmark who in my mind is the second best driver on the grid right
now and essentially gives you the maximum of what that car can achieve over a season. When it comes
to qualifying, Leclerc has beat Sainz and Hamilton in every single season that they were teammates,
with Hamilton's deficit in 2025 of being on average 0.178 seconds slower ranked as the
second largest gap during this timeframe, only behind Sainz in 2023. The reason why this deficit
and Lewis' poor qualifying in general has had such an effect on his season is because in 2025
we have had the closest ever grid in Formula 1 history from the fastest to the slowest car on
the grid. The consequence of this is that the penalty for qualifying a couple of tenths behind
your teammate was more severe in 2025 than it was in previous seasons, and when you combine this
with the fact that at times the Ferrari was a borderline midfield car, it meant that Hamilton's
margin of error went from small to essentially non-existent. Or whilst before qualifying a
tenth and a half behind Leclerc would put you in the lower half of the top 10, in the 2025 Ferrari
Lewis qualifying a tenth and a half behind Charles more often than not left him knocked out in Q2.
Or when it comes to the races, if we take a look at the percentage of points scored relative to
Leclerc, Sainz during his first season in 2021 actually outscored Leclerc scoring 101.5% of
Leclerc's points before then tailing off and scoring 79.9%, 97.1% and 81.5% in his last season
in 2024. Hamilton on the other hand scored just 64.5% of Leclerc's points in 2025,
but an important distinction to make is that if you look at his percentage at the midway point
of the season, he was actually up at a pretty respectable 86.6%, which just emphasises even
more how bad of a collapse Lewis had at the end of the year. And now it's worth noting that this
coincided with Ferrari's own performance collapse during the latter half of the season, which even
affected Leclerc's results dramatically. This wasn't an issue that was just isolated to Lewis.
To me Lewis was going through the exact same emotions as Schaal in knowing that
the car was getting worse, they weren't capable of fighting for any meaningful results
and they just wanted to get to the end of the season as quickly as possible.
Or where I think it differed for Lewis is that his confidence and motivation was already at
breaking point and so all of those negative emotions were just dialed up even more to the
point where in interviews, whilst Leclerc looked and talked about being disappointed a million
times, Hamilton looked and sounded like a man who was absolutely broken by the end of the year.
The bottom line is that qualifying pace has been Lewis' biggest issue not just in
2025 but in the ground effect era and it's no coincidence that his most painful
and emotionally charged interviews in 2025 have come after qualifying. To his credit,
whilst there has been a lot of culpability on the team side, he has never shied away from taking
accountability for his own poor performances, sometimes even, in my opinion, being too
self-critical like calling himself useless and even saying that the team probably needs to change
drivers. And now those are words from a frustrated driver right after a bad performance so like with
any driver you have to take them with a pinch of salt but it's clear that they come from a place of
confusion, frustration and self-doubt as to how Lewis' biggest strength throughout the
entirety of his racing career has suddenly disappeared. If we go back to 2011, that was
the year that was dominated by Vettel in the Red Bull and it was also one of Lewis' weaker seasons.
It was the only year in which Jenson Button beat him in the championship but yet despite that,
he still had the 2nd highest average qualifying position on the grid only behind Seb and he was
able to get 3 Grand Prix wins. The point is that even during a weak season, the things that made
him special were still there namely his qualifying pace and it was actually in the races where he
struggled more. If we compare struggle to struggle, what we have seen after 2021 in the ground effect
era is Lewis' quali pace be eroded away and in fact now I'd say his biggest strength is probably
his race craft. Even in 2025 he was nominated for multiple overtake of the month awards and
in the wet at Silverstone and Spa he was still exceptional. The problem is that in the ground
effect era there just hasn't been a lot of variance. In the last 2 years of the previous
regulation cycle in 2020 and 2021 we saw Ocon, Gasly, Perez and Ricciardo win races and then
also saw the likes of Seb and Alonso score surprise podiums in midfield cars as well.
Compare that to the last 4 years and there just hasn't been as many shock results due to better
reliability and worse race ability, all of which has put a bigger emphasis than ever before on
qualifying. Or when Lewis' quali pace which was his biggest strength diminished with the start of
the ground effect era, his chances of being competitive up against tough, young and fast
teammates in Russell and Leclerc disappeared with it. Maybe if his teammates were mediocre
midfield drivers it would mask his qualifying deficiencies but that has not been the reality
in the ground effect era. He has been up against 2 drivers in their absolute prime,
both of whom by the way I think have been massively unfortunate to not have had the
opportunity to fight for a title yet and they have both been able to expose and capitalise
on Lewis' weakness. I think it's very easy to have the optimistic view that maybe all of this
was just an isolated problem because of the ground effect cars and that things will be
different in 2026. But I am not so sure, because contrary to popular belief, Lewis throughout his
career actually has been an adaptable driver. He was able to win races and championships with
Bridgestone and Pirelli tyres, with grooved and then slick tyres, with the small refuelling era
V8 cars, with the simpler, bigger V8 cars, with the narrow V6 hybrids and then also with the
wider V6 hybrids as well. There was nothing to suggest that Lewis shouldn't have also been able
to adapt to the ground effect era cars as well and that is why I don't see too much optimism in the
2026 changes helping Lewis, because to me his struggles have been more fundamental than just
a regulation change. I have also no doubt that age has something to do with it as well, because
even if we look at Fernando Alonso who is the closest comparison, I wouldn't say that qualifying
has been his strongest quality, especially if you compare him to his prime at Ferrari.
What's difficult with Fernando is that he is teammates with Lance Stroll who to me is a driver
who I'm not even sure would even be on the grid had it not been for his dad owning the team.
The last decent teammate that Fernando had was Ocon back in 2022 and although Fernando was the
better driver, he wasn't doing anything in 2022 up against Ocon that for example Oli Berman hasn't
been doing as a rookie in 2025. Both of them narrowly outqualified Ocon with Oli also managing
to beat Ocon in the championship which Alonso wasn't able to do in 2022 albeit Fernando did
have a lot of reliability issues. The point is that every single driver whether it's Hamilton,
Alonso or even Schumacher, they all lost qualifying speed into their late 30s and early 40s
but because Alonso and Schumacher were racing in the midfield and going up against lesser teammates,
it didn't stand out as much as it does with Lewis because he is still racing amongst
championship calibre drivers who are fighting every single race for wins and podiums.
To me Hamilton's late Mercedes and Ferrari period is actually very comparable to what we saw
with Schumacher when he returned to Mercedes in 2010.
Contrary to a lot of revisionist history, Schumacher's time at Mercedes was not a success.
Yes there were glimpses of the old Michael magic like the pole position lap around Monaco in 2012,
the podium in Valencia and then the almost podium in the 2011 Canadian Grand Prix as well
which was a very underrated drive by Michael. It just was a disappointment.
When Michael announced his comeback with Mercedes, the team that the previous year as Braun
had just won both titles, and also going up against a promising but young driver in Nico
Rosberg, everyone including Michael expected for him to be the same championship calibre driver
and absolutely no one in the media that I could find could even comprehend that the
7 time world champion would be outperformed by Nico Rosberg. And yet, it was Nico who delivered
Mercedes their first podium, pole position and Grand Prix win, whilst beating Michael
in every single season that they were together. The Mercedes years up against Rosberg are a
blemish on Michael's legacy in the exact same way that the ground effect era, albeit up against
better teammates in Russell and Leclerc, will be a blemish on Hamilton's. But similar to Schumacher,
when we talk about him as one of the all time greats, we talk about his achievements at Benetton
and Ferrari because how great you were in your prime and the competition that you faced from
your teammates and from the other teams, is more important than how you tailed off
in the twilight of your career. Maybe it's because we are living through the weakest
season of Lewis Hamilton right now, but there definitely seems to be a double standard in that
no one was retroactively reassessing Michael's career after his disappointing time at Mercedes.
And now, whilst Lewis has been at the heart of his own collapse and underperformance,
it's at this point where I think we should also talk about Ferrari. What's really difficult and
where I actually have a lot of sympathy for Lewis is that one of the reasons that he moved to
Ferrari was because he wanted to find a new motivation and go to a new environment that
would re-energise him. But what I think he didn't expect was for that to coincide with one of the
worst Ferrari seasons in recent memory. In 2025, Ferrari were an embarrassment on almost every
level, car performance, car development, operationally and even on the management
side. Even Leclerc had long lost his motivation by the end of the season, but for Lewis it was
a worst case scenario of joining a team just as they started their decline, during a time when
he was actively looking for positivity to reinvigorate him. In the end, every single
one of Ferrari's internal struggles just compounded and broke Lewis' confidence,
which was already fragile going into the season. The most glaring example of this was the Lewis
Hamilton and Riccardo Adami partnership, which was an absolute disaster. This is something that
Vettel and Science fans will be very familiar with and although it was easy to say at the
beginning of the season that over time their communication would improve and Lewis even came
out early on and defended Adami, the reality is that it didn't. Even in Abu Dhabi, Adami
failed to tell Lewis that he had been given a track limit warning until he did it a second time,
putting him at risk of getting a penalty. And it's these basic errors in communication,
during a time when Lewis needed more support than ever before given his struggles,
that I think in my mind makes this driver-engineer combination completely incompatible.
Out of the many awkward exchanges, the Monaco weekend is also one that stands out as
probably the worst. During the most important qualifying session of the year around a track
that is impossible to overtake on, Adami gave Lewis incorrect information about Max being on
a slow lap, causing Lewis to block Max handing him a three-place grid penalty, which dropped him
from 4th down to 7th, essentially ruining his race before it even started. Lewis did manage to
recover in the race climbing from 7th to 5th, which is about as well as you could do around
Monaco, but not before yet another miscommunication with Adami, failing to answer Lewis' simple
question about the gap in front of him, instead choosing to talk about Charles Leclerc's tyres.
The problem with these mistakes is that it adds an extra, unnecessary amount of pressure on the
drivers that they don't need to be dealing with on top of the pressure they are already under at
Ferrari. Or when you consider that Ferrari had Vettel, Sainz, Leclerc and now Hamilton drive for
them, these are all drivers with immense authority and respect, who I'm sure worked very hard behind
the scenes to make positive changes internally at Ferrari, and yet when you see John Elkin come out
publicly telling the drivers to essentially keep their mouths shut because they are unhappy with
how uncompetitive the car is, you understand that this is still an organisation that is extremely
resistant to self-scrutiny and lacks a lot of self-awareness in terms of where they need to
improve to become successful. Going back to what I said at the start of the video, the overriding
feeling that I had watching Lewis at Ferrari, especially towards the end of 2025, was that I
was watching a broken man, who to me did not look like he wanted to be there anymore. And to be
honest, given how shambolic his season and Ferrari were, why should he? I think regardless of how
2026 goes, it is the right time for Lewis to bow out of the sport, not because he's got something
to prove after the disappointment of the Grand Effect era, but because he doesn't. Unless he's
enjoying racing in F1 now more than ever, which I seriously doubt, the timing feels right,
because whilst on his day he can still deliver those championship calibre performances,
with his diminishing qualifying pace he just isn't able to access that level of performance
consistently anymore. Well, there you have it. If you did enjoy this video and want to
support the channel, then don't forget to subscribe, that would be massively appreciated,
and I'll see you in the next one.
