BEST of 2025 EYE MAKEUP for Women Over 50! Eyeshadows, Mascaras & Eyeliners That Truly Deliver!

Cosmetics and Makeup tricks
241 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 13, 2026
So make sure to grab a beverage.
We're discussing eye products today, whether that's
mascara, eyeliner, eyeshadow.
What were my best picks for 2025?
Stick around and find out.
Hi everyone.
Welcome back to another video and my best of 2025 series.
So this video is dedicated to eyes.
So I'm going to share with you my favorite mascaras,
eyeshadows, eyeshadow sticks, et cetera, for the year.
And yes, I realize I am a little behind, but as I
explained in my previous video, December was just an absolutely
crazy month for me, but I always figure better late than never.
I do have a mix of some drugstore and some higher end products.
I know I have a lot of viewers out there that like both, so
we're just going to get started.
Now I'm going to first start with a product that I use for
my eyebrows because it is in the eye area.
The one that I really gravitated to this year, it was a new
discovery for me.
And that's another thing I want to say, not all of these products
were new launches for the year.
They were just new to my collection.
So the NYX micro brow pencil was a standout favorite for me this year.
I do have this in the shade brunette.
They do have quite a few shades, so I'm sure you can find the
one that suits your eyebrow hair.
The tip is one of those micro pencils.
So very precise and whether you have eyebrow hair or whether you
have some sparse areas going, this one does the trick.
It lays down the color really easily, very smooth, very soft.
The spoolie is on this end and that's another nice soft spoolie.
I would compare this one to the Anastasia Beverly Hills eyebrow pencil.
I think this is very comparable, but at a fraction of the cost, I think
it helps my brows look really natural.
And a little pro tip is starting in the middle of the brow and working out and
filling in the front part of your brow last, and that just helps the brow not
looking too sculpted or defined.
So I really enjoyed this one this year.
So we'll jump in now to eyeshadows, eyeshadow palettes.
Now I didn't really discover any drugstore eyeshadow palettes, but one
of the brands that I really enjoy using and they are pretty affordable when it
comes to eyeshadow palettes, because you are getting a lot in the pans, is Alter
Ego.
So two of their palettes that I really enjoyed this year were, one was called
Amber Glow and one is called Sunlit Dreams.
Very pretty.
This one is the Amber Glow.
Now, if you're not familiar with Alter Ego, they create their eyeshadow palettes
that I'm going to say replicate higher end eyeshadow palettes.
So say your Huda Beauty or your Natasha Denona ones, they do a fantastic job of
creating these palettes.
The colors are very rich.
They blend very easily and they're usually a combination of shimmer and mattes.
This is the Sunlit Dreams one.
They're just gorgeous.
Like this one is more warm neutrals, which is right up my alley.
I love how you can mix and match them.
And I have had so many of my viewers mentioned to me when I show Alter Ego
palettes, you leave me a comment and say that you've tried them and that you
really enjoy them.
They always come also with a nice mirror.
So you have that included as well.
And the other, like the packaging is always so pretty.
So these are wonderful palettes and they have so many different styles of palettes.
I'm sure that there is one that you can find on there.
So I'll include their website down below.
And sometimes they even have sales on, so it makes it even more affordable.
And then a little travel palette that I used a lot in the summertime.
It is a little bit of a higher price point.
It's by MAC and it's called Connect in Color.
And this one is embedded in burgundy.
So the packaging is really pretty.
And like I said, this was just my go-to palette for the summertime.
There's a little mix of some mattes and a few shimmers, but I loved the
convenience. It's only six shades, but you can do so many different looks with it.
Very buttery, very creamy, easy to blend in.
And there was some other styles of this for this collection, but I really enjoyed the
burgundy. So just a nice everyday little palette.
All right. So now we'll turn our attention to liquid eyeshadows.
So a fun one that I discovered this year from the drugstore is by NYX.
This is the NYX Glow Shots.
They come in a ton of shades.
This one I picked up was Mango Moment.
And surprisingly for an eyeshadow, these are made with vitamin C.
So the one applicator you can use a couple of different ways.
You can actually swipe the color right onto your lid if you want.
What I usually do is I'll put it onto the back of my hand and then just go in with
like an eyeshadow brush and swipe it on that way.
I like how it has a little bit of a shimmer, but it's not glittery.
I like that for my mature eyes because I don't want anything accentuating all of the
little bit of fine lines and wrinkles that I have going on, especially on my eyelids.
Not such a pretty shade.
I thought it was really unique.
So even though it is a liquid, it's very comfortable to wear.
You can wear it alone, which is what I usually do.
Or you can put it over powder eyeshadow or you can use it as a base for your
eyeshadow, depending on the shade.
You could even use this as a bit of a highlighter.
So this is such a pretty shade.
I could take that and apply it right onto my cheekbone.
But like I said, there's so many different shades you can just pick and choose.
So two liquid eyeshadows that I picked up from Sephora were the Makeup by Mario.
These are the Master Mattes cream eyeshadows.
I have two different shades.
One is Mauve and one is Sandstone.
Sandstone is my go to.
It's also a wand.
And sometimes I will use this one and then go in with the NYX.
So there's Sandstone and you can see it's a matte formula.
And this one is so pretty too.
This is Mauve.
So it's a little bit darker.
One of the things that I'll do as a quick and easy get out the door look is I will
swipe this on.
Again, you can put it directly onto your eye if you want.
Or what I do sometimes is I'll put it onto the back of my hand and use an
eyeshadow brush and apply it that way.
So this I will put all over the lid, the shade Sandstone, and then I will take
Mauve and just put that right on my mobile lid.
So there's Mauve.
These are so creamy, so easy to work with.
I would say these give more of a medium coverage.
But you, like I said, you can build them up and mix and match different shades.
He has quite a shade range for these, but I have not had any issues with these
creasing on me.
They are very long wearing, last all day.
And I just like the look that it gives my eye.
It's almost like a, a very soft and subtle diffused look.
Now moving on to a different type of cream eyeshadow.
There was a new one put out by Merit.
So I've always been a big fan of the Merit Solo Shadows, but they did create
some new shades this year, or I should say last year, 2025.
So I picked up the shade Glossier and oh my goodness, these are such a wonderful
eyeshadow, extremely pigmented.
This feels spongy.
It's such a lovely formula.
This one I'll use on days if I just want a real subtle look.
Hopefully if I turn my arm a little bit, you can kind of see the shade.
These are buildable.
They wear all day.
There is no creasing.
If you're not familiar with Merit, they are a minimalistic brand.
And the ingredients that they use in their products are just amazing.
So I was very happy to see that they came out with some new
shades of their solo eyeshadows.
So my love for eyeshadow sticks increased this year with the
addition of some drugstore ones.
So I have two shades by Covergirl and I have a shade by L'Oreal.
They, I also have another, like a darker shade from L'Oreal,
but this was my absolute favorite.
It's in the shade Alluring Rose.
And I use this one on repeat.
This is so gorgeous.
They are very creamy, very easy to work with.
One of the ways that I prefer to use a stick eyeshadow is taking a
brush and putting it onto the brush and applying it that way.
I mean, you can certainly go in and just apply it directly to the
lid and then just use your finger or a brush to do it that way.
I love how creamy this one is.
They also just blend in so evenly.
So for the shade, by far L'Oreal has my heart on that one.
And then the two that I have by Covergirl, one is in the shade
Bronze Glow and the other one is Ballerina Blush.
So similar to the L'Oreal, these are smudge proof, transfer proof.
So there's Ballerina Blush, bit of a rose shade and then the Bronze.
So that's Bronze.
The L'Oreal and the Covergirl are very lightweight.
Last all day.
They're smudge proof, transfer proof, super long lasting.
They don't fade, which I really appreciate.
I do have some long days, so I really need my eyeshadows to stay.
But I think eyeshadow sticks are such a great product for
getting out the door quickly.
Love that.
And then a brand that I've had on my channel quite a few times, I've
done some videos where I've included quite a few other products.
One of the reasons I love this brand is because it's specifically
for us mature ladies.
So it's a brand Prime Prometics.
And when I've shown products on my channel before, I've had so many
viewers reach out in the comments and let me know that they've tried
the products and they absolutely love them.
So I'm always so happy to hear from you guys when you agree with a brand
or a product that I've shown on my channel.
Now, two shades in particular that I used on repeat this year.
One is called Afterglow and one is called Violetta.
So I'll just quickly swatch those for you.
I love brands that really cater to us mature ladies, like for our
mature skin, because let's be honest, we have different needs
for our skin as we're maturing.
So there's Violetta.
So similar to how I use other eyeshadow sticks, I just take a
brush and apply it that way.
There is several different shades of these and then there is Afterglow.
So some of the features for these, they're water resistant, super
long lasting, a very creamy formula, but buildable.
They're hypoallergenic.
I like how it gives a natural wash of color to the eye.
They're not an overly like a shimmery shade, but the light reflecting
particles on the eye are very subtle.
So they're not going to accentuate.
If you have like crepey eyelids, it just smooths, smooths the eye area out.
So what I'll do is I will include their website down below in my description box.
You can go check out their website.
They have a whole bunch of different products for mature ladies.
Now I have to include some eyeliners because we're doing the eyes today.
So a drugstore eyeliner that I discovered this year.
Again, it's been around forever, but the particular
shade was one of my go-tos.
And it's the one by NYX.
It's the Epic Wear Long Stick Eyeliner.
It's in the shade Gun Metal Gaze.
That's actually what I'm wearing today on my upper lash line.
I did have to just quickly, I went and washed my hands because I was
running out of swatching space.
We'll start new.
So I love this shade because it is not a black, like a really harsh black.
It's a nice subtle gray, which I think brings a bit of softness to the eye.
It's a very creamy formula, but very pigmented.
And I used it right along my lash line today.
And the nice thing about these is it gives a little bit of time to work with it.
So what I usually do is just create the line.
It doesn't have to be like precise or perfect.
And then I go in with an angled brush and then I just blend the line out.
That also brings some softness to the eye.
I use this one to tightline.
So I did use that one today.
And what I like about it is even though I'm using it tightlining
on my upper waterline.
I don't have the transfer on my bottom waterline, which is really important.
I don't like to tightline and then it just transfers all onto my bottom waterline.
So this is great for that.
It is one that you do have to sharpen.
And then another eyeliner that I tried, and I just love the shade, is the Stila.
So this is a Stay All Day gel eyeliner, but it's in the shade Damsel Dark Brown.
So if you're looking for a very subtle brown, this one does the trick.
So that one right there.
So a few things about this one is it's very creamy.
It glides on to the eye.
I have used this one for tightlining as well, and it doesn't do
any transferring on my bottom.
But the shade is the one, it's what I fell in love with because
it's not that harsh black.
It's just like a chocolate brown, which again is bringing softness to the eye.
I don't usually use black anymore.
I stopped doing that years ago.
And then this eyeliner, it was a suggestion by one of my viewers and
it's the shade that she put, she said to try the shade and I
absolutely fell in love with it.
So it's by Leigh Swatchay and it's the shade Fall.
I believe I'm saying that correctly.
That one right there.
And I would say it's like a taupey gray.
So pretty.
It's what I'm wearing on my bottom lash line today.
The formula, I mean, it's Leigh Swatchay, so the formula is amazing.
If you're not familiar with Leigh Swatchay, it is a Canadian makeup brand.
And while I shouldn't say just makeup, they have all sorts of things,
skincare and all that sort of stuff.
But I really liked some of their makeup products.
This is so creamy.
I think this is wonderful for mature eyes because it does just glide on.
The packaging is pretty and they just have such great quality.
Prime Prometics also has eyeliners.
So if you are somebody that has mature eyes and you do struggle with
eyeliners, these are a great option.
These are super long lasting.
And what I really enjoy about them is they don't tug on the eye at all.
They just glide on, especially if you have more like crepey skin
or wrinkly skin on your eyelid.
These are wonderful for that.
Now, two of the shades that I have been using again on repeat
are Mulberry and Mocha.
These ones have a few more features.
They have little smudgers that are included on the pencil.
They are a twist up as well.
There's Mulberry and there is Mocha.
What really impresses me with these ones is they are so pigmented.
It is one of the few eyeliners that I can apply the pencil and I don't have to
like do any sort of pulling on my eye to make sure that the line looks smooth.
It just glides on.
So these are amazing.
I have done some videos where I've used these and I'll try and include those
videos down in the description box for you if you want to go check them out.
And then to finish off the eye products, we're going to talk about mascara.
I have three drugstore and then a higher end one, and two
of them are to be mascaras.
So first we're going to start off with a mascara that I found at the, at the
beginning of the year was a new launch.
And this one really, really impressed me.
So it's the L'Oreal Paradise, but it's the Big Deal version.
There is a regular, like a Paradise one, but this is called Big Deal.
Well, I instantly fell in love with this.
There were so many things about it, the formula, the wand.
So I love the wand because these are not like a spiky type of bristle.
They're quite soft.
And the thing that was really unique about this one is you can build it up and
build it up and keep adding more and more.
I think I got up to, in the video, I think I got up to like nine different
coats on the lashes and there was zero clumping, that just blew me away.
This one gives me fantastic length, volume, doesn't flake.
So super impressed with this one.
Then another one that I tried and it was recommendations
from quite a few of my viewers.
The Milani, it's the highly rated mascara.
So this one was fantastic as well.
The only thing I think with this one that some people may not enjoy is it's
a bit of a wetter mascara, but even being a little bit wetter, I found it
didn't really like weigh my lashes down.
I have quite short, stubby little lashes.
So I don't want a formula that's going to look heavy or weigh them down.
So this one was good for that way.
I didn't do that.
Now, the other thing is these bristles are more on the, I guess, spiky side.
So you just have to be really careful when you are applying it just
to not poke yourself in the eye.
But again, the formula was fantastic.
This is one of those mascaras that's been around forever.
This one I find gives me a little bit more volume than it does lengthening.
It doesn't do any flaking on me, lasts throughout the day.
Then a higher end version that I tried, but I only picked up the, the travel
size or the sample size is the one by Too Faced, this is called
the Ribbon Wrapped Mascara.
Now this is a tubing mascara.
What I enjoyed about this one is the wand.
These are very, very soft bristles on it.
This one does give me a lot of length and I love how it just removed so
easy at the end of the night.
It's like a super simple way to remove your mascara.
And it just coats every lash.
It even gets right into like these little corner ones that I have.
It just, these little bristles do such an amazing job of
getting right in the corner.
It lifts my lashes, gives it a bit of curl.
It separates them.
So this was one of my higher end favorites for the year.
Sorry, I did want to say one thing.
I forgot to say that the Milani also is a tubing mascara.
And if you're not familiar with tubing mascaras, what it is, is
it's, it's creating little tubes around each individual lash.
That's going to create some of the lengthening that you need.
But what I love about tubing mascaras is they are so easy and gentle at the
end of the night to remove all of the product, they literally
just come off as little tubes.
And I, I think those are great for mature eyes because there's less
tugging around the eye area.
That's why I usually won't use waterproof mascaras.
I find that they are just so hard to remove.
So I usually stay away from those, but tubing mascaras, I absolutely love.
And then last but not least, this is by far my favorite mascara for the year.
And it was a recommendation by several viewers.
And I think a lot of you will love this as well.
So out of all the mascaras I showed you today, this is the most affordable one.
And it's the Elf Lash Extender Mascara.
So this is a tubing mascara.
I love the formula.
There's no clumping, there's no smudging, no flaking, bristles are a little bit
harder, but I just make sure that I'm not poking myself in the eye.
This does have jojoba seed oil in it, which does help to condition your lashes
and be very nourishing for your lashes.
And when I had so many people recommend this mascara, I knew I just had to try it.
And I'm so glad I did.
So if you're looking for a great, affordable drugstore mascara,
highly suggest this one here.
So I hope you enjoyed my recap of eye products that I fell in love with for the
year 2025 and then stay tuned for the next video.
The last one is going to be all about lip products.
Now you may have to set aside a little bit of time for that one, because I already
know that one is going to be a little bit longer because there was so many lip
products I tried this year and so many good ones.
So I I'm really super excited for you guys to see that video.
Everything that I talked about today will be linked and listed down below in the
description box and where I can, I will try and include, because I do have quite
a few products here, I'll try and include as many links as I can down there.
And also some videos where I may have talked about some of these
products more in depth.
Don't forget to share, like, and subscribe if you're not already.
And as always, I hope everybody has a great week and a great life, and I'll
see you all very soon in my next video.
Bye.
