George Washington and the Peaceful Transition of Power: A Conversation with Dr. Lindsay Chervinsky

Traditional Style
16 followers
51 Video Views·Jan 13, 2026
Dr. Lindsay Chervinsky is a presidential historian and author, and the Executive Director of the George Washington Presidential Library. In this June 2024 interview, Dr. Chervinsky discusses the precedents that George Washington set as president, including the peaceful transition of power from one president to the next.
So George Washington was going to be the first president and everyone knew it for a couple of
reasons. First, he was really like the most famous man in the world at that point. The only other
person that maybe rivaled that fame was Benjamin Franklin, but he was very old and in poor health
and everyone knew he was really not up to the demands of the job. Second, Washington was really
seen as a national figure. He wasn't seen as much of a Virginian and that was because he had served
as the commander-in-chief of the Continental Army and had been all over the country over the last
eight years, which is something that relatively few people did. Lastly, he had demonstrated that
he could be trusted with that type of power. He had wielded enormous authority during the war
and given it back and at a time when people were very worried about monarchies and dictatorships
and authoritarian regimes, having that proof that someone was willing to give it back was an
extraordinary thing and very unusual and so really gave people confidence that he would be a good
president. When Washington came into office, the presidency was really just an idea. It was written
down in very few words in Article II of the Constitution, but things like how the president
would act, how the president would dress, how the president would interact with other branches of
government, whether or not the president would travel to go see American citizens, how much power
the president actually had day to day over domestic and foreign policy issues was really all up in the
air. And so Washington's presidency was essential in crafting the expectations for daily comportment,
for daily activities, but also for establishing precedent that when there was domestic crisis,
we expect the president to act. We don't expect Congress necessarily to take the lead. When there
is a foreign policy question, when there is a threat of war, we expect the president to act.
And Washington was the one that took action and set those expectations such that he was
establishing precedent for those that followed. Other countries have actually really always watched
the American experiment. You know, in some ways we like to talk about American exceptionalism
and some of those claims are not well founded, but other nations really have always watched the
American project because when we started, we were doing something so new and so unique and
the revolutionary rhetoric was inspiring to other revolutions. The European powers were sometimes
very happy for us to fail because it would be an opportunity to seize authority or trade or money
or resources. So they weren't necessarily always rooting for success. When Washington decided he
was going to retire, it was a shocking moment. It was totally revolutionary and King George III
reportedly said that that would make him the greatest man in the world. Now whether or not,
that evidence is a little bit fuzzy, but I think that it is emblematic of the response of,
wow, we cannot believe this is actually happening. It was essential to Washington and the nation
to establish a peaceful transfer of power really at the center of the democratic process
because that is what characterizes a democracy. We go to the ballots, we select someone, that person
wins. If it is taken by force, it is no longer a democracy or a republic or a democratic republic,
whatever language you want to use to describe it. And they understood that that characteristic
was central to the type of government they were trying to create. They had seen firsthand
examples of the other types of transition and so in order to preserve the democratic project
or experiment as they called it, it had to be a peaceful transfer or it no longer would survive.
