21 Video Views·Jan 12, 2026
Back in April, I attended my 1840s event in several years… and let’s just say I was not pleased with the current state of my 1840s wardrobe. After working through half a year of a deep dive specifically into 1840s clothing, I knew there were several things that needed to be worked on. This is the first in a series of dresses that will be “picked to pieces” and remade with better shape and construction techniques. This first dress is “wearable, but not up to living history standards” by my way of thinking. The dress was a bit too big in the waist, several inches too long at the sides and front waist, had pocket slits that were too far down, had modern selvages that were glaring when the skirts were pulled back for work, the skirt was not attached to the waist properly, the piping was too thick for normal historical use, the lining was cotton and not the more usual linen, and there was modern hook and eye tape down the back. While the whole gown was hand sewn, the stitches weren’t exactly small enough and there were some seams popping out. Needless to say, the entire bodice had to be taken completely apart, recut, then resewn. I was able to salvage much of the skirt sewing and since the dress needed to be made smaller and not larger, I did not need any extra fabric. But that doesn’t mean that it wasn’t a lot of work! I was basically making a new dress from scratch but with the added step of having to unpick the whole thing before recutting and sewing together.
We're going to fix one of my 1840s dresses
Hello everyone my name is Caitlin
I'm a living historian who trains other living historians in traditional sewing techniques and by replicating original garments
Several years ago I can't even remember how many I made this 1840s dress using a truly Victorian pattern that I no longer recommend as they're primarily designed for reenactors not living historians
The instructions are inadequate particularly in the skirt section and they also fail to incorporate historical techniques at their core
So I did the best I could sewing it entirely by hand using 1860s techniques I knew
Well I already did something about it but I think I need to take it up again
Anyway I used to wear a high collar but I live in Texas where that's not exactly something you'd want
So I cut it down to give it a lower neckline—a style possible in the 1840s especially for workwear
And this is going to be my main piece of work
However I think the last time I used it I have notes on my phone about what I need to do with it
It was only slightly open
So I just need to make a small fold which isn't a big deal
There will be a fold in the lining that should really be replaced as it's cotton whereas linen lining would be far more typical for this period and I have plenty of linen on hand
So that's not a problem
The sleeves are on the bias and I did a good job cutting them on the bias I think
Yes okay we did well
The cuffs can probably be replaced They're also very
dirty so at the very least they need to be washed
Most of the edging is coming loose here well
Well we're taking everything apart anyway so it's fine
Oh I'm sorry
I have a mischievous little kitten trying to chew on the beetle-wing dress while her sister is down below playing with flax—no problem
Well the border
I adjusted the neckline trim to be finer than the peach and sugar cream thread I used previously
However there is trim at the waist cuffs and shoulders everywhere
I don't think there's any more trim
Anyway all of that is too large and will have to be replaced
I'll remove it and put on a fresh trim
It's nothing special
I know the waistband is too wide on this garment or rather too long—typical of Victorian patterns
Those who sort them have longer waists so as they sort the waists grow longer and longer
I shortened this waist by at least four inches
And I want you to notice that this is where my natural waistline is—supposed to dip down slightly but this point here this thing shouldn’t actually drop down this far in the first place
It has to be right here
I already cut it It was right
here in the pattern So I'
ve already cut it halfway
I'm going to keep cutting it because it's too wide
It's far too broad
This shape isn't period-appropriate
So I'll have to redesign it and make it a bit shorter which isn't a big deal
I remember there was about an inch on each side that needed to be taken in because the dress was a bit too large
However the bust fit me perfectly
The length was good I don't think I need to do anything here It's
unusual to have a hem made from
the same fabric as the dress itself
The pocket openings need to be raised because they're
too low They should sit exactly where this bodice ends
Now it'll be about an inch taller further on
Well it'll stay right here since it's worth it and my pockets end up higher
So I had to reach up and then down to pull out the pockets which was extremely uncomfortable
There's tape on the brackets which I don't like
Let's replace it with real brackets
I think we might as well cover it all since we're cutting it anyway
Better that way right
And then oh the most important part
This has happened occasionally but it's very uncommon for the dress or skirt to cover the entire dress and then have this appear on top
I need to start blocking these things while I'm sewing because they keep trying to play with the dress since it's shiny
So I'm going to grab
Well we're taking it all apart anyway
I might very well pull the skirt forward and fold it more in front than in back which would be far more common
And anyway I don't like the way it rises
So overall I think that's going to be our best option
We're taking it all apart anyway so we might as well do
it now right If it's a more common option that'll better
At first I did it that way because there were no instructions on how to turn it over
I had never seen a dress from the 1840s and didn't know how it worked
And I remember the first time I saw a historical dress or a 1840s-style gown was when my friend House wore it to the Texas Living History Association
And that was the first time I ever saw a 1840s dress that was properly folded
I thought I should've seen it coming about four years ago when I made that dress
So it worked out fine
And now I have original dresses from the 1840s So now I
know how they're supposed to
look And I've seen several more
That's great
So I have extra fabric in case I need it
But I'm going to do my absolute best to not need it
Now something is cut incorrectly
If something should have been cut at the vis but wasn't then obviously I'll cut it again
Everything else
I want to show you how to remake dresses so they better reflect the era without using additional fabric
Because when you buy secondhand dresses that may have good fabric but aren't made with historical accuracy
You probably don’t have extra fabric to redo things
Sometimes finding these fabrics that have been discontinued for 10 15 or 20 years can be difficult or impossible
So I'm going to do my best not to need any extra fabric
But I bought it just in case I did
And if she didn't need it it would simply become children's clothing
So uh it would be used
however possible Alright
Yes let's go ahead and start taking the entire dress apart
All that handwork which to be fair I didn’t even know how to sew by hand back then
So I wasn’t using the best techniques anyway
Well we need to get it out
Let's get to it
It's going to be fun
Of course we'll start by taking the dress apart
This video will ultimately become a dress made entirely from scratch
Except first we have to take it all apart so we can cut and sew it again
Yes I’m aware there are scissors available
I prefer to use scissors
After fifteen years of using scissors instead of seam rippers
I think I've only ever accidentally cut dress fabric twice and I managed to use the fabric both times
So yes this is perfectly safe and fine
I usually use smaller embroidery scissors but I haven't been able to find any
So here we are
Let's remove everything
All edging side seams buttonhole tape and sizing
The only remaining seams will be those of the skirt panels and the anthem
Although we'll be redoing some of the skirt panels later on
Now if I weren't adjusting this bodice I would have left the side seams open
and I would have only removed the waist and neck trim
Just like the modern back hook-and-eye strap
because it could have cut the bustier with the side seam still attached
But it doesn't matter
She already knew she'd have to take the whole thing apart
or dismantle the dress as they used to say in the 1840s
Once I dismantled the bustier I went ahead and
cut it down
to a more reasonable length—freehand
But if you're in the same situation try
on the full top and mark where to cut
Since I had just put it on and taken my measurements I knew
exactly how much to remove and where
But if you don’t have that
Try on the bra with your underwear
mark it then take it apart
I accidentally cut the back one side a bit too high
Instead of adding extra fabric to lengthen it further
He cut the other side to make it match
So it ended up being a little higher
waist than he had originally planned
Yet it still falls within the acceptable range of the 1840 era
So I decided it was
acceptable even though it wasn't exactly what I had originally wanted
While sitting on the sofa
I went ahead and redid all
the trim the original trim was too large and long
So I cut it almost in half
Now if you come across a dress without hems
The best thing you can do is remove a seam from the skirt
And cut a strip of 2 or 3 inches from one of the skirt panels
That way you can cut the hem
Remember that the edge is cut across the grain
that is perpendicular to the fiber direction
Then all you need to do is sew a seam on the skirt
It's an easy way to add a hem without using much fabric
In my case I'm using size 8 crochet cotton for this edging
I found some original dresses from the 1840s
where the waistband is thicker with a medium-thickness thread
It's about the thickness of athletic wear or something similar
That's why I decided not to restitch the waistband and left it slightly larger
I only had to adjust
the hem for the arm size
wrist and neckline Now everything is ready
Keep going and cut all the corset pieces again in plain linen
This will be my new lining
I made sure to cut the neckline with that small fold
so the new corset pieces would fit snugly at the neck
I didn't have to worry about the dress fabric since it'
s gathered to look good and
then I went back to the sofa
I re-sewed all the side seams making sure the areas that
were supposed to be slightly smaller were properly adjusted
Just like the waist they were sewn well I
didn't cut the seam allowance in case I grow
I want that seam allowance to remain on that bustier
The backstitch is the most suitable stitch for sewing bra pieces
This bra style has no darts
but it has many more pieces than usual
But I reinserted the rod I had removed from the corset earlier placing it back at the V-shaped waist
And also a rod on each side I
use pieces of 6-inch metal rod
Next I stitched the neck and waist hems using the
backstitch The backstitch would also work well for this
But I've seen some originals that look more like a backstitch
So I've been testing it out and I'm impressed by how well
it holds up It's much faster than making a regular backstitch
I love learning little things like that Victorian people never
cease to amaze me with how intelligent and practical they were
They did just enough work to keep things
together but not so much as to waste time
Then I stitched the neck and waist edges with a neat whipstitch
And the lower corset piece is basically finished
Hemmed the sleeve edge with binding
And once the armholes were edging with a very loose running stitch
Keep going and repositioned the sleeves with a large backstitch
This time I chose not to line the sleeves since the originals show both lined and unlined sleeves
Based on my personal observation I'd say lined sleeves are going to become more common
However since this is going to be a work dress I wanted it to be as fresh
as possible Remember I live in Texas and I already have four dresses
And if I have four dresses two with lining in the sleeves and two without
that gives me a good variety for my wardrobe to suit different temperatures
At this point all I need to do is add brackets and grommets
to the back I position mine about three fingers' width apart
I've noticed that the originals vary significantly in how close the brackets and eyelets are to each other
However I do notice that the back closures tend to be farther apart than those on the front
With this the bodice is complete and we can move on to the skirt
Now we'll work on the skirt's balance or flare
I'll try it using a modified historical technique to work the stitch on the front of the bodice
Let's put on the bodice
I probably should wear my corset for this but the corset isn’t going to change the length of the bodice
I can wear it with or without a corset since my 1840s corset doesn't actually reduce my waist size
So I'm going to do this part without the corset
If it's your first time put on the corset and all the skirt supports
Since I'd already turned the back enough for my height with my bib coats
I could use it as a guide to make sure the front end also ended where the back reached the ground
So I didn’t have to bring all my parkas
either That made things much easier for me
Pin the back sides and front of the bodice to the skirt
Then to ensure the hem was even I folded up the top part of the skirt and pinned it in place where the hem looked just right
Once I was satisfied with how the skirt turned out—fitting me well and having the right length—
The top of the skirt was neatly folded I can
remove it entirely and place it on my ironing board
Wherever the skirt was folded there should be a
safety pin I'll make sure to iron it into place
I know the air conditioning goes in the back and I'm sorry but I'm currently working on hemming the skirt
The hem appears to be spinning as if you were only folding one section
Now the waist ended up slightly shorter at
the back I accidentally cut one side twice
So it ended up being just a little shorter
Not by much but enough
And then when I looked at the back I liked that it wasn't uniform
So I simply finish by adding
I suppose I could have made this decision because I did so
late at night Probably not the best choice but it was one I made
Instead of just taking a little extra fabric and adding it to the bodice
the piece I cut too large ends up requiring me to cut the other one to match
It still falls within the parameters of the late 1840s
It just wasn't what he had originally planned
And so what I'm doing to compensate is taking my turn and making it an inch higher than it used to be
So my skirt still ends at the same spot because I shouldn't be sewing near midnight
I make poor choices when I sew late at night
So I turned this side then let's move forward and make this work
Well there it is
Whatever it is that makes it uniform
That was my front
center Keep marking it
So that's just again due to the point on that bustier
That's why this is tilted more to one side than the other
Something that isn't exactly characteristic of the period
But what I had to do was hide my modern remains
There are a couple of ways to do it
Some people choose to cut off the excess entirely and simply sew the edges of the skirt without finishing them with whipstitch
Others choose to use the period method to incorporate the remains but
then one must contend with the fact that the modern remnants become visible
What I'm going to do is take the good portion of this
fabric fold it over the defective part and sew it closed
The only reason I do this is because every
time I lift my skirt to work people see the inside of my dress
And since this isn't a relic from the 1840s it needs to be hidden
This issue commonly arises with modern quilted cotton
So this is just one way to address it
Once again you can always trim the excess
but then you'd be left with an unfinished edge
It's better to fray the edges to prevent unraveling during use and washing
Another period-appropriate method to conceal the remains would be to fully line the skirt
Even though I haven’t yet found a cotton skirt that’s fully lined
And now my skirt is ready to be fitted
I'll make two rows of calibrated thread using a thick thread
I have a full video on how to calibrate skirts
So I'll leave the link below if you'd like to see it
Yes modern seamstresses this is what we would now call cartridge pleats
It's a modern term
The term piri means gauge
G-A-U-G-E-O-G-A-G-E
Now it's time to join the bodice to the skirt
This means that every single small fold joins the hemmed lower edge
Every single one of the small ones
And if I did my job well the skirt's hem will be even without having to cut anything off the skirt
This means the skirt can be easily taken apart and altered to fit a taller new owner
And the fabric is in larger pieces so I can cut them again and turn them into something else
And now my dress is finished
Here we are
So yes we're in the guest room right now because there are
girls in the sewing room and I didn't think they'd want that noise
Y R is sewing in the living room
So right now we're in another room of the house
But here's the dress
Next stop I can reach into my pockets
As if they were right here not down here
It's truly beautiful
It fits evenly
all around It looks good on me
I have a short neck and it's not
The last time I saw it the undercollar
was open but it isn't anymore That's helpful
It fits me well here This is nice
and snug I love the V-shaped waist—
it turned out really well
It looks much better than when it was just on the other side and could be lifted up
But it looks much better now
I insist the waist is a bit
This is roughly where my natural waistline is
Technically it could reach as far as here
Well what's that
About an inch but I insist this is still within the realm of possibilities
So I think it's a great work dress
I'm wearing two petticoats from 1860 so the dress is a bit long since they're not as full as they usually are
And I'm not wearing as many shirts as I usually do
Well sometimes I wear two vests but they're different in shape and a bit stiffer
Yes there are no other remnants so when I tie the skirt at the back there are a couple of ways to do it
I usually do this and hold it right here
It's quite normal to have to hold it
So that would be quite normal
And then of course there’d be room to walk in the front area
Sometimes it needs to be tucked inside the apron
Even though you know with accident scenes and stuff like that if you see skirts pinned up it's usually because of that
But I'm really happy with the V-shaped waist—it looks so much better
This entire silhouette is much better than where we started
That rounded shape
No you want the pointed V shape
So I think that's something good
Overall I think it looks really great
Maybe I would have extended the neckline a bit
Maybe it could have been a touch more boat-necked but it's fine
But this is definitely the first in a
series of dress renovations We have this one
I have well I guess one more thing and then we need to wrap it up
I think that's all
And of course I have that silk dress
I need to decide whether to go with the late 1830s early 1840s or a later date
I think I'd like to go with the
late 1830s style but we'll see We'll just have to
wait and see how it turns out It'll depend on what I need it for
And I have to work on a blue silk for this period
So yes the brown silk would likely better suited for the earlier era
See you Personally I absolutely love upcycling
clothes It's my favorite thing now I
used to hate it
I used to sell my dresses just to avoid having to do any kind of work on them
But as soon as I began to realize it's like a puzzle
And you have pieces that need to fit into something
else I don't know I love challenges and I love puzzles
So once I started viewing it as a puzzle and a challenge I absolutely loved it
I'd rather remake a dress than make a new one at any time
It's fascinating to see how my perspective has evolved since I began ten twelve or fifteen years ago up to now
Yes I'd love to spend more time restoring garments
I now have a pile of clothes in the sewing room that no longer fit me and need to be altered
We'll get it done
We'll have plenty of options
I think learning to take those garments and tailor them properly as was done in the 19th century
It's a very useful skill that many people don't consider
We're so used to taking basic measurements like bust and
waist and saying "Oh it fits well " when in reality it doesn't
because we have varying waist lengths you might have one breast
larger than the other or one side of the waist longer than the other
Those small adjustments and learning about your body and how your body adapts to clothing
and also how you can alter clothing to fit your body even
when they're secondhand and you're not starting from scratch
I think these will be truly valuable skills It's something I'm
working hard to improve and I hope to help others do the same
Finally I think that's all for today
If you enjoyed the video please give it a like and subscribe to the channel
Click the bell icon to get notified every time I upload a new video
And as always have a fantastic week and we'll see you again here in the next video