CARTA_ The Genetic History of Europe with Johannes Krause.mp4

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
32 Video Views·Jan 12, 2026
So we start where we started this morning already with
Janet partially talking about some of the earliest modern humans that we have outside Africa. Until recently
we had a very small number of them. It was only about a handful that we had from all over Eurasia,
like people that lived, modern humans, homo sapiens, between 40 and 45 thousand years ago.
And that fortunately recently changed and that largely changed because of the corona pandemic
because you see here Helen Rouillet, she was actually doing a sabbatical with us in Germany
and she was a bit stuck. She couldn't go back to the US. She's actually based here in California
State University and she could also not go to Czech Republic where she was supposed to study
some human remains. She's a paleoanthropologist. She's really good in identifying human bones from
tiny fragments of fauna. So I had to call around some of my neighboring museums and curators and
they came up with a whole lot of boxes full of bones that looked like that, that were excavated
some hundred years ago and then left in storage from a site called Rhanis, which is in Thuringia
in central Germany. And Helen actually looked at those boxes and she could identify from those
boxes about a hundred bones where she was pretty certain that they were human bones. And indeed
when we sequenced them, they turned out to be modern humans. They're not really looking impressive,
right? So like tiny little fragments, I couldn't even say if it's a bone or a stone, but she
could tell it's human and some of them were really well preserved, having a lot of human DNA
and some of them were even older than 40,000 years, even older than 45,000 years based on
radiocarbon dating. So that more than tripled our record that we had from Europe for that time
period, which was really exciting. So now we have a number of about 10 additional individuals now
from this time period between 40,000 and 45,000 years ago from Europe. We then published a paper
at the end of last year, together here with Aref and Kai, where we looked at those earliest modern
human genomes that we now have. One of the things that we found was that those individuals were
actually pretty closely related. Some of them were second degree relatives of mother and daughter,
some of them were third, fourth degree relatives, and some of them were even relatives fifth degree
to one of the other human genomes that we had from before from a site that is 250 kilometers away.
So what's the chance that we have a handful of genomes from a time period of 5,000 years that
happened to be one big family, right? But it's not a complete coincidence because we could also show
that the population size of that population was tiny. The population size was only about 300
individuals, stretching all the way from Great Britain to Poland, right? So it was really sparsely
populated Europe at that time. We also did a phenotypic reconstruction, no big surprise. This
was a population that just came out of Africa, so it has an African phenotype, dark hair, dark skin,
dark eyes. What was a big surprise was when Vanessa here did the population genetic analysis,
she could actually show this was a branch of humans that branched off from the non-Africans,
from the people outside Africa, before they branched off from each other. So it is actually
not closely related to Europeans, not closely related to East Asians. It's actually kind of an
offshoot that comes early off from this non-African branch, but it's also an extinct branch. It has
not genetically contributed to any population later, right? Those people went extinct. They came
to Europe about 45,000 years ago and eventually they disappeared. They have not contributed to
later people. But they did live after the admixture with Neanderthals. And this was very important
because they lived very close to the admixture with the Neanderthals. So Janet has already shown
it early on. They had, in fact, long stretches of Neanderthal DNA in their genome. And those long
stretches are there because they lived so close to the admixture. And because they are radiocarbon
dated, so we know exactly how old they are, we could then date when the actual Neanderthal
admixture happened because the fragments get shorter and shorter. We could then use those
Neanderthal fragments to actually tell us when this admixture happened. We calculated it was
60 to 70 generations before they lived. So if you take a generation time of about 30 years, you get
a time of about 49 to about 45,000 years ago. This is when the admixture with Neanderthals
happens. Now we have a really precise estimate before we thought it was like 65,000 years ago
to maybe 45,000 years ago. And now we actually know it happened less than 50,000 years ago.
And why is this important? Because it tells us that human remains, modern humans outside Africa
that are older than 50,000 years cannot be part of the genetic diversity of humans that we have
today because all people outside Africa have the Neanderthal admixture today. And also all the ones
that we have so far analyzed from the past have that same part of Neanderthal admixture. So if
there are humans that are outside Africa that are older than 50,000 years, they represent a genetic
lineage that is extinct, that we don't have in the record so far. So basically all this kind of
early out-of-Africa movements where there's quite a few remains from Australia that are 65,000 years
ago, from China 70,000 years, 120,000 years, from the Near East, those all have to be lineages that
are extinct. They cannot be lineages that are still present in the record today. And that's a
possibility that they're extinct. All the other possibility is just the dates are wrong, right?
And actually for some of them it has been shown that some of them that were supposed to be 100,000
years old are only about 40,000 years old, right? It could be that all of them are in fact younger
than 50,000 years. It's kind of hard to date this material because radiocarbon dating doesn't work.
We have then also been looking quite extensively at the next 30,000 years after we have the first
people in Europe. So from about 40,000 years ago, you have then people that are genetically
connected to even modern-day Europeans. And we looked at the hunter-gatherers, about 350
individuals in a paper that we published two years ago with Cosimo Post. And just to give you a bit
of a summary about these populations, we can say that just before the maximum of the last ice age,
about 30,000 years ago, what we have in Europe are two main populations, two genetic clusters
that have the same culture. It's called the Corvettian culture. Those mammoth hunters,
they're actually quite famous. But there's a western group and an eastern group. And what
happens after 30,000 years ago is that it gets really cold in Europe. This is the last
glacial maximum. The glaciers actually go down further south, and almost all human
populations in Europe go extinct. We can say that there's no survival of humans in central
Europe, in eastern Europe, and, and that was a big finding of the study, also not in southern
Europe. Italy also gets depopulated. No one survives the ice age in Italy, but a group
of people survives in Iberia and in southern France. So this is the survival of this western
population. But then after the last glacial maximum, around 20,000 years ago, when it
gets warmer again, this population expands from Iberia into central Europe. And there's
another population that expands from southeastern Europe, in Anatolia or the Aegean, we're actually
not quite sure exactly where they came from, into Italy, into southern Europe. And then
something really strange happens, which we still haven't really understood why it happens
After 14,000 years, when the ice age is really over, then it gets as warm as it is
today. So there's a kind of period that we call the Bölling-Allerröd, where it suddenly
gets like pretty warm. Then this blue population expands throughout Europe and
replaces the orange population. So this population then becomes what we call the
western hunter-gatherers, the Mesolithic, the last basically hunter-gatherers that are
living in Europe before farming comes in. And this is the population that expands the
most into western Eurasia, but there's another population that expands from the
east into eastern Europe. And then those are the two populations of hunter-gatherers
that we have there about 5,000 years ago. What's interesting about them is it's quite
stable, so there's actually not much gene flow between them. So over 6,000, 7,000
years, those two populations live in those different parts of Europe. And what's also
interesting is their phenotype is different. The western population has blue eyes, all
of them, and dark skin. Actually, the skin color we cannot distinguish for people in
sub-Saharan Africa. So until 8,000 years ago, all western Europeans had actually
dark skin. And in the east, you have a population that has lighter skin, not as
light as the people today, but they have dark eyes. So there's two phenotypes,
pretty stable over several thousand years. And then eventually, those populations
actually get forced to meet because there's another population moving in from
Anatolia, bringing farming to Europe. So this is the big change, the Neolithic
transition. We have farming coming in with people from Anatolia, largely pushing away
the hunter-gatherer population, slightly also mixing with them, giving them rise to
the genetic makeup that we have in later European populations. And it's changed,
and the phenotype is also nicely illustrated by this guy. I don't know if you
know him. He's called the Iceman Ötzi. This is a reconstruction from the museum
in Bolzano in Italy. This was done 15 years ago before there was a high-quality
genome. We recently did a high-quality genome on him, and he looks quite
different, in fact. What we can say on the one hand is that he didn't have hair on
his head because he had actually genes for early male pattern baldness, which some
people in the room also share. Sorry, no offense. And what we could also say is
that he had a different skin color. He had actually dark skin. He didn't have that
light skin. He had darker skin than anyone else in Europe today. So the
phenotype was a bit more like that, like a dark Jean-Luc Picard, not so much like
Heidi's grandfather you see on the left. And it's actually quite interesting
because that phenotype is much closer to the mummy, right? The mummy actually looks
quite dark. In the 1990s, when they did the first histological research on the mummy,
they could actually show there's a lot of melanin. There's a lot of dark pigment
there. But of course, a European cannot be dark, right? He has to look like Heidi's
grandfather, right? He cannot look like this guy in the middle. So it kind of
tells us a lot about our preconception about those things. Most of those genomes
that we have been analyzing in the field early on were in prehistory because we
thought we can contribute a lot to prehistory because there's no historical
records so we can tell all kinds of stories, right? But that has actually
changed recently because we could actually show that there is actually a lot
of interesting stuff that you can also do for recent time periods. So when you
actually look at that in the last six, seven years, there was actually quite an
increase of genomes from historical times, from the last 2,000 years. This was
largely because of this group of people here that I was lucky to be part of, the
Histogenes Consortium, where we sequenced the genome of about 7,000 people from
Central Eastern Europe from the migration period onwards. So after the collapse of
the Roman Empire, then into the historical, kind of medieval populations.
We also looked at the pathogen genomes from that population as well as isotopes
really propagating as a force. We found a lot of exciting things. So some of that
also links to the kind of research that was just shown by Xu Wen. We could, for
example, show that one of those populations that was present during this
migration period in Pannonia, what's modern-day Hungary, actually came all the
way from Mongolia. Over 8,000 kilometers, this population moved and then settled in
the 6th century, creating this so-called Avar Empire, which lasted for about 250
years. After the collapse of the Romans, basically this population came in,
established a kingdom, which was actually quite stable. It was one of the most
stable kingdoms in Europe of that time period. What we have also been doing in
this project is we do a whole cemetery approach. That means we look at everyone
at the cemetery. It actually gives us a lot of insights into how this population
is structured, what's the social structure of those groups. What we often
see is large pedigrees. They're all somehow related to each other, but they're
all related through the male line. If you look at that, the squares is the men
and the circles are women. All the women come from outside. There's no female
offspring. This is all some guy who has two sons, who has six sons, who has so
and so many other grandsons, and so forth. It's all the sons of the sons of the
sons of the sons. It's a very strong party locality. We also see polygamy, so
some males have offspring with multiple females, and we have also females that
have offspring with multiple males. In all the cases where a female has children
with multiple men, actually the men that they have children with are closely
related. They're either brothers or their father's son. It's probably when the old
man dies, that female actually moves into the family of the stepson or of the
brother of the other male individual. It's called levirate unions, and that's
pretty common during that time. We also know that actually from historical times
in step population, so that was a pretty common practice. This is interesting
insight. We can also see that people also wanted to stay close together in the
afterlife. Actually, in the burial ground, you see people are closely related and
clustered together, like what's also common in a lot of places today. What is
also quite surprising is that despite them all being related in this big
pedigree, we find no evidence for consanguinity. In no case are the parents
closely related, which means they must have kept complete track over nine, ten
generations, who's related to whom. So they had probably an oral history where
they knew, I'm the son of the son of the son of the son, whatever. Probably always
through the male line, but they kept complete track of that so that they kind
of avoided inbreeding, which is also a practice that is in step populations,
again recorded in the 19th and 20th century. Then lastly, I want to talk about
the last big migration that shaped the genetic landscape of Europe, and that is
the expansion of the Slavs, the biggest language family we have. There's a lot of
countries that are Slavic-speaking today, and there have been different hypotheses
about where those people came from and how did they expand. Some people said they
were kind of modern-day Poland, some people said Belarus, some people say the
Lower Danube region. To address this question, we have assembled genomes from
the time before the Slavs are archaeologically present in those places
and after, to see what changes. We often do that, the time triangle, we look before
and after, and then maybe see where those people were coming from, which was a
study we did together with Joshua and Susanna. And again, we do what you've
already seen, show one presenting here, this type of principal component analysis.
This is modern-day Europeans, so this is this map that reflects basically the
geography. You have Great Britain here, you have Italian peninsula, Sardinia here,
you have Scandinavians, Central Europeans, Eastern Europeans, and so forth.
Now we are projecting the people from the past on top of the modern-day people.
And if we do that for the Balkan, modern-day Croatia, people before Slavic
people in this region actually cluster on top of Italians, which is not a big
surprise because they were part of the Roman Empire. So they were just part of
that basic sphere of Southern Europeans. The Germans of that time, of the 5th, 6th
century, they fall all over the place. It's the migration period. You have people
that look like Sicilians, you have people that look like Norwegians, you have people
that look like Western Europeans, and people that look like Eastern Europeans.
So there's a big, big genetic diversity here. We call the population also the
Allemands, all kind of people. And in Poland, modern-day Poland, you can
actually see people who look like Scandinavians because they are goths that
have just expanded into this region. So they also look different to the people
before. And now, as we move then into the time of the Slavs, how did that look like?
And in the Balkans, after the Slavs, people look like this. In Germany,
after the Slavs, the Slavs basically look like this. And the same happens in Poland
and Ukraine. People suddenly look like that. They all look the same.
They're all with the Slavic expansion. They all look the same.
They're all closely related. We see a lot of IBD links between them.
We have a population that expands into the region and replaces the previous
population. There's a big genetic shift, almost 100% of the Slavic population
moving in. And that's also reflected in modern-day population. In black here,
you can actually see this large contribution of Slavic ancestry in a lot
of places. In Eastern Germans, for example, about 50% of the ancestry of an
Eastern German is Slavic. In some minorities, we have some minorities that
are still Slavic-speaking. For example, like the Zorbs in Germany is 95% Slavic
ancestry. So they have, over 1,000 years, they have stayed in documents.
They have not mixed with the German speakers around them, it seems,
which is quite remarkable. And you can see that the strongest,
actually, in Ukraine, too. We also looked at where it's coming
from, and this population seems to have originated in what's today Belarus or
southern Lithuania. So this is where this population then expanded.
Why it expanded? We think probably because the Germans had moved away, right?
Because it's the migration period. They moved to England. They moved to Italy.
They moved to whatever other places, Siberia, North Africa. And this is why
there was a lot of space so they could move there. So this model seems to be
mostly supported. So what are then the seven major insights from Archaeogenetics
of Europe that I tried to show you in my little tour here? So first of all,
we can now say that modern humans outside Africa diverged less than 50,000 years.
Right? So all people that are older than 50,000 years have to be something else.
They're not the people that we know. The first modern humans in Europe,
they disappeared. It's actually quite interesting. There was a lot of story
of success. People came to Europe and then go poof, like Neanderthals.
They disappeared as well around that time. I think probably there was a volcano.
There was a big volcanic explosion 40,000 years ago that wipes out probably a
large part of the animal population, probably also the human population.
Cultural innovation often accompanies migration. So this is also some lesson we
learned from Archaeogenetics. When we see big changes in the culture,
it's usually because someone moved in and then replaced the previous population.
The European phenotype, light skin, light eyes, light hair, is actually very young.
Right? Light eyes are a bit older, probably 10,000 years, but light skin is
really just 5,000 years that people got light, probably because of agriculture.
So when agriculture spread, the diet changed. And in the diet was not a lot of
vitamin D. Right? That was a problem when you kind of don't do hunting and gathering
and eat fish and meat. You actually eat plants that don't have vitamin D.
And one way to get vitamin D is not just by eating it, but also in your skin,
you can produce it. But if you have light skin, you produce much more than if you
have dark skin. So that was probably the adaptation to live up in the north and do
agriculture, which is why Europeans got white. In the European languages,
I haven't talked too much about, but they seem to have spread from the steppe.
So about 5,000 years ago, there was a massive movement of people from Eastern
Europe into Central Europe, and that seems to bring the Indo-European
languages there. There's a lot of mobile groups during the migration period,
where for many of them, when I talked to my mother, it's like the migration period,
people were moving. It's like, oh, that's interesting research you do.
And it's kind of like surprising. But it's actually a lot of kind of researchers
have said that this was not happening. There was no people moving during the
migration period. It was just elites and trade, but actually we joined all this
massive number of people moving. And what we can basically say is migration and
mobility is the rule and not the exception in this. People have been moving all the
time. At least in Western Eurasia, there was a high amount of mobility that
actually brought all these populations in contact over thousands of years.
With that, I would like to thank, of course, the whole department,
lots of collaboration partners, lots of funding agencies, and thank you for
your attention. I'm happy to take questions later.
