How Hillary Clinton Became A Hawk | Hardball | MSNBC

Hillary Clinton
2 followers
Jan 11, 2026
Mark Landler, author of “Alter Ego” and White House Correspondent for The New York Times, examines Hillary Clinton’s unique approach to foreign policy.
Welcome back to Harvard.
Could we see a more hawkish administration and US foreign policy if Hillary Clinton wins
the White House in 2016?
As New York Times reporter Mark Landler recently wrote, quote, Clinton's affinity for the armed
forces is rooted in a lifelong belief that the calculated use of military power is vital
to the defending of our national interest.
That's quite the contrasting view from that of her former boss, President Obama.
Back in March during a town hall, I asked Hillary Clinton what she thought about enforcing
regime change.
What do you think, quickly, of the whole history of the United States in your lifetime of knocking
off leaders, whether it was Mosaddegh in Iran, or it was Arbenz in Guatemala, or knocking
off Allende in Chile, or knocking off Patrice Lumumba in the Congo, or knocking off Trujillo,
or who else have I missed?
I mean, we've been doing this for a long time.
That's why I'm skeptical.
But what is your view of all those assassinations, all those attempts to change the history of
other countries?
Should we be doing that kind of thing?
Well, I don't think in the vast...
In the vast majority of cases, the answer is no.
But, you know, there's always these historical games you can play.
If somebody could have assassinated Hitler before he took over Germany, would that have
been a good thing or not?
Well, Mark Landler is here with me.
He's just written a new book, Alter Egos, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, and the twilight
struggle over American power.
Now, everybody's going to find this fascinating.
But what did you make of her response to my question?
I thought she'd say something like, oh, that was a bad part of our Cold War history.
We should have knocked off all those guys.
No, she said, hey, could have gotten Hitler.
Yeah, no, I zeroed in on that very last piece of it because she was almost pushing back
on what you were saying and saying there is a rationale for this kind of thing.
And I think that's what you saw during the first term of the Obama administration, where
she sort of functioned as a house hawk.
But more than even just being a hawk, she also was the person who is the most willing
to see interventions ending with a good outcome.
And that's what made her very different than President Obama, who I think generally viewed
interventions as ending with a bad outcome.
How do you figure that with the fact she grew up sort of as a young woman with the Vietnam
War all around?
They're watching all these guys getting drafted and the killing of, you know, the horrible
killing that went on in Vietnam.
Most people said that was overreach.
We tried to take over a country.
We tried to run it.
We should have limited our intervention.
Yet you say she believes in positive intervention.
I think she does.
And I think if you go back and look at that Vietnam experience, which I tried to again
in this book, is, you know, she actually had a sort of an interesting history with Vietnam.
She wasn't really fervently opposed and passionately opposed the way some anti-Vietnam protesters
were.
And to some extent, her opposition was rooted in fears of things like, was the president
abusing his executive authority when he did the secret bombing in Cambodia?
That was something that really interested her back when she was an intern in Washington.
I think, though, the difference is she still defaults to a belief that American intervention
is fundamentally can be a good thing.
It doesn't necessarily have to be a bad thing.
And the contrast I draw, and I draw it through the entire book, is that Obama, having spent
a childhood in a very different place, some of it in Indonesia, simply had a different
view of America's role and generally thought that these interventions didn't end well.
And then, of course, the Iraq war, for him, a formative foreign policy experience, probably
the most important one he had and the one he brought into office with him, whereas she
had seen some things work out well, the Balkan interventions.
Well, her key decision politically, which hurt her in the 2008 race, was supporting
the authorization for going to war in Iraq.
How did she turn on that over the months and years since then and before that?
How did she get to that decision?
How has she reviewed it since?
Well, look, first of all, she's acknowledged it was a mistake.
It took her a very-
What's that mean, though?
What's mistake mean?
Okay.
And she acknowledged it was a mistake because she said that she wasn't given access to-
That's not a mistake.
The full intelligence dossier, right?
Right.
And the point is she didn't read the full NIE that actually talked about whether Saddam
had weapons of mass destruction or not.
Well, did he have nuclear weapons?
I've got no evidence that ever suggests that we knew or thought he did, but they sold it.
That's right.
So the bottom line is she sort of hung it around being deceived by the administration
when the argument is she probably didn't do adequate due diligence to figure out the truth
for herself.
Why don't you want to vote yes?
I think that it was a combination of what I said earlier, which is her own instincts.
Plus, you have to also acknowledge New York Senator, post 9-11, worried about her own-
Concerned about Israel, too.
Precisely.
And worried about her own possible political future.
But how about being a woman?
Does she feel, it's hard to do the psycho babble here, but does she feel as a woman
she has to prove herself extra tough, like more of a hawk than the regular male candidate?
I think that was probably true in the Senate, certainly.
But I almost feel at this point that it's now more a matter of what she, of her reflexes
and her instincts.
And it's less of a pose.
Maybe it was more of a pose early on.
I think now it's much more in breadth.
I'm with you, Mark.
I think you got it.
I think she's tough.
I think she's going to be a strong president if she gets in there.
Look out, bad guys.
Anyway, Alter Egos, let's read the whole name, Alter Egos, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama,
and the twilight struggle over American power.
When we return, let me finish with the man who clearly didn't spend his life preparing
to run for president.
You know who I'm talking about.
You're watching Hardball, the place for politics.
