InFocus featuring Dr. Rachel Volberg on problem gambling

Western Massachusetts News, Weather & Sports
497 followers
Jan 9, 2026
InFocus with Patrick featuring Dr. Rachel Volberg on problem gambling.
from the 22 News Plus studio.
This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry. Hello everyone and welcome to
this edition of In Focus. I'm your host
Patrick Barry. Today we're talking about
the state of gambling here in
Massachusetts and the way it leaks over
to the rest of the United States and
possibly the world. Uh sitting across
the desk from me from the University of
Massachusetts is Dr. Rachel Volberg. She
is the uh and I will gush at you a
little bit now the preeminent brain on
gambling uh not only here in
Massachusetts but probably in in the in
the country. So we are I I'm very
excited to have uh Dr. Bullberg sitting
across the desk from me. When we talk
gambling,
gambling has been around forever. As
long as humans have been around, there's
been some sort of wagering and betting,
but explain to me formalized, legalized
gambling here in the state of
Massachusetts. When did it first occur?
So, gambling, as you said, has been
around for a long time, eons. Um, most
human societies have some form of
gambling that they engage in or multiple
forms. Uh in Massachusetts,
uh the first form of legalized gambling
was actually horse racing.
>> Okay.
>> Uh back in colonial times, they
permitted betting on horse racing,
although wasn't it wasn't very um
wasn't very encouraged, but it was
legal. Um, and then in 1971
is when the Massachusetts lottery was
first legalized,
>> and that is what we count as the
beginning of legalized gambling in
Massachusetts.
>> So, and and was Massachusetts the first
state in the country to legalize
lotteryies or No,
>> it was not the first, but it was close
to the first. I want to say the so there
was a there was something called the
teapot dome scandal back in the 89 1890s
and every state in the country shut down
whatever lotteryies they had.
>> Wow.
>> Everything became illegal and in I want
to say 1969
is when quite a few states were looking
at major holes in their uh revenue
compared to their budgets. And so they
were looking around for what can we
legalize or what can we tax um you know
that is not a tax on individual people.
And so lotteryies became uh one of
>> just a way to raise revenue
>> a way to raise revenue and they spread
very rapidly. So between I want to say
1972
so just after Massachusetts and call it
1982
um almost every state country legalized
interesting and so it's it's sort of
correct me if I'm wrong a fun tax. So
it's a tax on the people who want to
have fun because they want to play
lottery. Did I simplify it because it's
not everybody like I don't play the
lottery all the time. The initial
lottery that was legalized was the large
jackpot lottery.
>> Okay. Yeah.
>> Buy a ticket, you know, on Saturday and
then you have to wait until Friday
night,
>> right?
>> Very late Friday night for the numbers
to be announced and then you look at
your ticket and you find out if you won
or lost. So that was the first game was
large jackpot. Um but lotteryies
and lottery people who run lotteryies
figured out pretty quickly that um there
was more uh revenue to be made with are
called instant tickets or scratchers.
>> Okay. And Massachusetts was the first
state to ever issue a scratch ticket.
Correct.
>> Yeah. And actually, I I was listening to
a podcast quite a while ago that was
about an inventor in Massachusetts who
invented the paper that instant tickets
could be printed on so you can scratch
the surface off.
>> And that was actually one of the reasons
why Massachusetts went in
ticket sales as early as it did was
because they
>> knew that there was a piece a type of
paper that they could print those
tickets on. So in your studies and
research,
has the revenue from lotteryies helped
the state of Massachusetts in any way?
>> Oh yes, I would say definitely. All
right. Um, so the state of Massachusetts
when they legalized lottery and and to
this day um all of the uh lottery tax
revenues or all of the revenue basically
beyond what they pay for administration
and advertising um goes to uh
unrestricted local aid.
>> Okay. There's 351 towns and cities in
Massachusetts and there's a formula that
the legislature has developed that um
basically, you know, dictates how much
money each um municipality will receive
and that's money that's that's not
required to go to any specific purpose.
So the towns are
>> very very um eager to get that money
because it's money that they have to
spend on you know things that the state
tells them they have to
>> it's interesting you you explain it like
that because I think a lot of people you
you see I think annually the mass state
lottery puts out information of how much
re how much revenue was gained
>> and everybody goes well where's that
money going you know we don't see you
know my road's not paved the potholes
and you are not being fixed. But so the
money is definitely being distributed to
the communities.
>> Oh yeah. And the communities can you
know they can add it to their
transportation budget or they can add it
to their education budget or they can
you know they if they have a capital
project that they can't get funded
through you know through um existing
mechanisms they can use the money for
that. So you know there's it's
unrestricted local aid. So that's that's
>> so it's good money
>> pot of money for the municipality.
>> Well, we've covered the Massachusetts
state lottery. Still to come, we've got
casinos, sports betting, online gaming,
and what what would you call it? Eye
gaming.
>> That's online gambling.
>> It's okay. We've got plenty more to talk
about. Stay with us. We're back in a
moment.
>> This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry.
This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry.
Welcome back to this edition of In
Focus. I'm your host, Patrick Barry.
Sitting across the desk from me today in
the 22 News Plus studios is Dr. Rachel
Bullberg from UMass. She is the
preeminent brain on gambling. In the in
the first part of our conversation, we
talked about the the um the start and
growth of lottery here in Massachusetts
and across the United States. When it
comes to lottery spending here in
Massachusetts, because we were one of
the first, we started scratch tickets.
Where does Massachusetts stand
as far as the amount of money people
spend individually on gambling and
lottery? Massachusetts head and
shoulders above any other jurisdiction
internationally.
>> Internationally.
>> Mhm.
>> In terms of per capita spending on
lottery.
>> Really?
That's Do we know why?
>> We have some theories.
>> And what are those theories? Well, one
of the theories um is that
Massachusetts, the state lottery in
Massachusetts actually has the um
highest percentage of payback uh in
terms of winning tickets.
>> Oh, okay. So instead of
>> highest chance of winning,
>> yeah, instead of 50%
uh money spent on the lottery that goes
to the operator, uh in Massachusetts,
somewhere between 72 and 75% goes back
to players.
>> Wow.
>> And so you have a much in Massachusetts,
you have a much better chance of
winning, you know, even if it's a small
prize, um you have a much better chance
of winning than in most other juries.
Not to say
you will be on the plus side of gaming,
it's just you have a greater chance of
winning. So if I might buy a $5 scratch
ticket and win $2. So that's
>> And what are you going to do with those
$2?
>> Buy a $5 scratch ticket.
>> Buy buy a $2 scratch ticket.
>> Exactly. Ex. So it just kind of keeps
feeding itself.
>> Yeah. Called the churn.
>> The churn. Okay. So that was that's
lottery. About a decade 15 years ago,
all of a sudden casinos came to our
state here in Massachusetts. I mean, we
used to think of Atlantic City and Las
Vegas as the two gaming capitals of the
United States. And then
what h how did American Indians become
sort of the the preeminent location for
gambling because Foxwoods then
Moheaggan's son
>> for for casino gambling?
>> For casino game. Right. Right.
>> So that was in 1988. uh Ronald Reagan uh
as he left office signed the um Indian
Gaming Regulatory Act uh also known as
IIGGRA.
>> Okay. So what that what the legislature
uh thought that they were passing was
um a law that would allow uh tribal uh
entities uh to conduct uh uh bingo
games.
>> Okay.
>> But they divided it into class one,
class two, and class gaming. So class
one gaming was traditional indigenous
games. Class two gaming was bingo and
pull tabs. Class three was casino games.
And every state that had legalized
charitable casino night then was in the
position of having to negotiate because
the law required it. Negotiate with any
federally recognized tribe in their
geographic area um that uh to to conduct
class three gaming. That's casino games.
But the casino games that the tribes
would conduct would not be regulated or
and would also not benefit the state.
The all of the proceeds would go to the
tribal government.
>> Okay. So, I remember when Foxwood opened
>> 1992.
>> I was going to say somewhere right
around there. Exactly. And it was a
bingo hall.
>> Yes, it was.
>> Yeah.
>> A large scale bingo hall.
>> And I think there were some slot
machines in there. Well, they in 1988
they began negotiating with Lel Wer Lil
Wer Governor Wer um and he signed a very
unusual compact with the um
>> Nash Antuckets is that
>> Mashantucket Peekquats
uh which said which guaranteed the state
25% of the revenues that the tribe was
going to collect on slot machines. Okay,
>> that was very very unusual to get a um
income division like that and um it had
to be approved by the Bureau of Indian
Affairs which took quite some time but
uh I believe it was in 1994 when slot
machines became operational at Foxwoods
>> and then in 1997 when the Moheagans um
also received federal recognition and
negotiated the same compact. So
Connecticut is in the very unusual
position of actually receiving uh
significant revenues from the tribes,
right,
>> from their gaming activities.
>> And then from there, how did
Massachusetts get into the casino game?
>> Well, Massachusetts got into the casino
game. Um, I was sitting in my office in
Northampton in 2007 and saw the headline
or the news item um that the Mashpwampog
had received federal recognition from
Indian Affairs and I thought
>> here we go.
>> Okay, here we go. There's going to be
casinos in Massachusetts. I've been
living here for quite a long time.
>> How quickly will it happen? I don't
know, but it will in inevitably.
>> And what year was that?
>> That was 2007.
>> 2007. And sure enough in
>> less than 20 years ago
>> yeah in 2008 Deval Patrick our governor
at that time proposed commercial casino.
>> Okay.
>> Um because everyone knew as soon as the
mash as soon as the mash no mashp1 pino
sorry um as soon as the tribe received
fair recognition they were going to
start trying to get class 3 gaming. They
had made it very clear.
>> Okay. Um, so then it was like, well,
Massachusetts is not going to benefit
from, you know, a very large-scale
casino that's going to be placed
somewhere in the state,
>> right?
>> What are the alternatives? And the
alternative was to legalize commercial
casinos in Massachusetts. Now, it took
quite a few years for that legislation
to actually um be passed, right?
>> There was a lot of negotiation and a lot
of decision making. Um but the um
expanded gaming act passed in 2011
>> 111. Okay.
>> And and the um yeah it was it was a it
was a really um from my perspective as a
gambling researcher and someone who
studies gambling, it was one of the best
pieces of casino legalization
legislation that I've ever seen.
>> In what way? Well, just to start at the
top, um the Expanded Gaming Act in
Massachusetts um established an
independent regulatory agency,
Massachusetts Gaming Commission, um with
the with with two
equally important responsibilities. The
first was to establish and regulate a
viable new industry in the Commonwealth.
The second equally important
uh responsibility was to minimize and
mitigate gambling problems and gambling
harm. Okay.
>> And so unlike most gambling regulators
anywhere in the world, um the regulator
in Massachusetts is equally responsible
protecting as well as um you know
ensuring a legit. So historically where
we would think of Las Vegas or Atlantic
City as the gaming capitals, they didn't
have those regulations to protect people
from harmful gaming.
>> Correct.
>> Whereas Mass So Massachusetts was on the
leading edge of this.
>> Yeah. and Massachusetts um it was on the
leading edge because um New Zealand was
ahead of the curve and had similar
legislation and
having done quite a bit of work in New
Zealand, I handed over their um casino
legalization language and said you might
want
>> Interesting.
Very good. We are up on our second
commercial break. Still plenty more to
talk about when it comes to gambling
here in the state of Massachusetts. Stay
with us. We're back in just a few
minutes.
>> This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry.
This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry.
Welcome back everyone to today's In
Focus. I'm across the desk today with
Dr. Rachel Volberg. She is a research
professor at UMass Ammerst and the
pre-minent brain on gambling, not only
here in the Bay State, but uh really
across the country. So, Dr. Wberg, thank
you so very much for joining me. I
appreciate it. We've covered a lot of
ground in our first two segments with
the Massachusetts the evolution of the
Massachusetts state lottery, evolution
of casinos, and when within the last
couple of years, sports gambling has has
really come on uh uh come on to the
forefront. Is that a good thing or a bad
thing to have sports betting available
in general? You know, you talked about
the Massachusetts lottery being a good
thing for Massachusetts because it's
it's money that goes back to the cities
and towns. Casinos have brought in
revenue to the states. Is sports betting
the same thing?
>> Well,
I'm not sure that sports betting is
quite the
phenomenal good deal for the state as
casinos or the lottery. Um the the tax
rate on uh sports betting in
Massachusetts is about the same as it is
in most other states in the US which is
about I think it's 15% for the
brickandmortar sports books and 20% for
the online operators. But that means
that 80% to 85% of the money that is
being that's being uh generated by
sports betting in Massachusetts is
actually leaving state.
>> So when it comes to sports betting here
in the state, you said brick and mortar
versus online. So So brick and mortar,
can we go to Encore or MGM and do sports
betting in those brick and mortar
locations?
>> Oh, yes you can.
>> Okay. And I didn't realize that. I
thought it was all online in
Massachusetts.
>> No. Okay. because I know I have a number
of friends who spend their weekends on
their phones, you know, trying to become
a millionaire. Um, and never works, by
the way. So there, so there's are
casinos here in the state. And there's
one
>> Yeah, there's actually three classes of
casino of of sports betting licensed in
Massachusetts. Uh, category one is the
brick and mortar. Category two is the
racetracks um that are supposed to be
allowed to have sports books.
>> Do we still have racetracks in Mass?
Yes, we do. But they don't have Well,
only Plainbridgeidge Park because you
know, Plain Ridge Park has live racing.
It's harness track.
>> Um but the other two uh racetracks that
are still operating um do not have live
racing. They they have um simal cast,
>> okay,
>> and advanced deposit.
>> Um so that's category two. There are no
category 2 licenses that have been
issued yet in C in Massachusetts.
And the category three are the online
operators. Each of the category one
operators, the three brick and mortars,
um is allowed to have a number of online
brands. So, you know, you you can you
know, you can bet on sports at MGM at
their sports bar or you can bet on
sports um at Bet MGM. Okay.
>> Which is one of their brands. Gotcha.
>> Then there's a couple of others. When
was sports betting legalized here in
Massachusetts or when did it come to the
state?
>> Well, so it's important to look back.
Um, in 2018,
uh, the Supreme Court overturned a
federal law that made it illegal for
sports to uh, or sports betting to be
operated by the states. And uh, so that
was 2018. in October or late in the year
it was overturned.
2019 10 states legalized sports betting.
2020 uh only a few I think three states
legalized and then been you know off to
the races as they say. Um we now have 39
states have operational sports betting.
>> Wow.
>> Massachusetts came a little bit late to
the game as it often does. Um but sports
betting uh the law passed in August 2022
and became operational in January and
March of 2020.
>> Okay. So now you have I can drive down
the street street to downtown
Springfield, go to MGM and bet or I have
there's apps on my phone. Exactly.
What's next for gambling in
Massachusetts? You know, we we've gone
from scratch tickets, walking to your
convenience store to Okay, now there's a
casino nearby. Now I can do it on my
phone. What's What's the evolution next?
Are you looking at, you know, down the
road to what the residents will have
available next?
>> I'm I'm a longtime gambling researcher,
so I'm always trying to look over the
horizon. Um, in this case, I don't have
to look over the horizon. There are
actually uh bills under consideration in
the legislature as we speak to legalize
what's called eye gaming or online
gambling. And that is essentially casino
gaming or casino games that are
available on your on your device on your
smartphone. So that's slot machine games
and table games.
>> So you'll be able to play poker,
blackjack or slot machines right on your
phone.
>> Craps, whatever.
>> Wow.
>> Roulette.
>> Interesting.
>> But the big money is in the slot
machines.
>> Right. Right. because the chance of
winning is lower,
>> right?
>> Well, and it's a speedier game.
>> Oh, that's true.
>> So, there's more churn. So, you know,
the house takes a percentage of the
churn and
>> that's where they make their
>> We've only got a couple of minutes left,
but I I I I do want to ask the question
with the proliferation of sports
betting. Is it a should it be a shock to
anyone that we see professional athletes
getting caught up in this, being
suspended for gambling? I mean, you look
back to the Black Sox scandal with with
Shoulless Joe Jackson, Pete Rose, you
know, and then, you know, we've got B
current modern-day basketball players,
baseball players being suspended for
betting and and is should that be a
shock to anyone?
>> Can I just say that I am not shocked at
all? I'm not quite frankly because it's
it's
>> I mean lots and lots of people have said
to me, "Oh, you know, I bet I know the
fix is in." So, you know, like I know
I'm going to lose because the fix is in
like I watched that I watched that play
and that was such a fixed play,
>> right?
>> You know, people are not
um people are not necessarily gambling
on sports because they, you know,
because of love of the game. Um,
increasingly it becomes about wanting to
win money, right?
>> And you know, people have lots of
reasons that they want to win money. Um,
>> or you know, they maybe they have other
reasons for gambling, which we know
people do, but money is a lot of what
it's about,
>> of course. Um
but really that that nexus of sports and
money
really comes with
>> influences a lot of people
>> and and it it comes with some very
perverse incentives for the athletes and
for the people who know the athletes and
for all of the people around you know
the sports um who may have insider
information or may know something and
you know like carefully drop it into a
conversation.
>> Yeah. Wow. Uh Dr. Rachel Wberg, our time
is up, but I cannot thank you enough for
joining me today to give us sort of an
overview of the state of gambling here
in Massachusetts and and across our
country. Wonderful meeting you. Thank
you so much.
>> Thank you for having me.
>> This is 22 News in Focus with Patrick
Barry.
