Ratan Tata Interview | With Suhel Seth | Rewind Awaaz | CNBC Awaaz

Ratan Tata
1 follower
Please subscribe and don't forget to press the bell icon to get notified whenever we upload a new video
There are very few people in the world and also in India
who inspire
with decency
with a strong set of values
Who believe in what they say who are torchbearers of not just a legacy?
But who are deeply passionate about India
Even fewer are from the world of business
but today I have a guest who is not just a colossus, but actually an
inspiration to people across ages
Age doesn't define him his work does and he continues this tirelessly as someone
Who always believes in what he does and does what he believes in?
Welcome mr. Tata. Thank you, sir. It's nice to be here sir Ratan Tata Trust
Will be completing almost a hundred and twenty five years of its existence the first of the trust
When you look back at the work that the Tata Trusts have done. What do you feel in?
What ignites this feeling of compassion and giving back? Well, I have a great sense of pride that
over these
125 years
Sir Ratan Tata left his legacy to
the philanthropic
causes followed by his
Brother when Sir Dharam Tata when he passed away
did exactly the same and
Over the years
Tata's have
been structured
By the holding company or the proprietors ownership
being held
by
Two charitable trusts and over the years an increase in the number of charity
Trusts that were created
to work on
the
Disparities that one found in the country
in that time a colonial country
And to work for the common good of the common man
this was a
Different thing it it set up cancer hospitals
schools and
institutions of that nature
It had also
Dealt heavily in terms of individual hardships
so through the years that
The trusts have dealt with
Individual hardships it has given they have given scholarships to students
We've had past presidents of India who have been
scholars of
those Tata scholarships
We have created institutions which stand today like the Indian Institute of Sciences the trust did not
Actually set up Jamsaji Tata set that up. There's an interesting anecdote there right between Swami Vivekananda and the conversation
That Jamsaji Tata had with Swami Vivekananda aboard a ship. I don't
specifically know
about that conversation, but
They met each other and were inspired by each other. I I know that
So over the years
The trusts have
have
focused on
either
creating institutions that
that serve the common good like
cancer hospitals, etc and
Institutions of learning some international and some domestic and
causes which
Were were said to be for the common good
What is refreshing is
that the holding company for the old Tata group which
Jamsaji Tata set up
that
66% or
in that time or 85% of its
income and dividend outflow
became income to the trust for the common good of
The Indian
Citizen and
Foreign causes but when you I mean as you rightly said at that time there was no need there was no mandate today
We have CSR much abused as it is a phrase
But what do you think went through the minds of the founders when they set this up and especially transferring?
Their value in Tata sons to the trusts. Well, I think it was a different view of
Ownership
Mr. JRD Tata often used to
Refer to Tata's as being the trustees of the of the people
The Tata family could have become tremendously wealthy
by by having
distribution
distributorships
Partnerships, etc in the businesses, but most of the businesses
Whether it was steel with it was power
Or or
Institutions were set up as
institutions for the country
So Jamsaji Tata could just as well have dedicated Tata steel to the nation or dedicated
Tata power to the nation
They belong to their shareholders and to the people
personal ownership and personal wealth
Happened when it happened but was never the criteria for these companies to to be established
so it was natural that he he did leave his ownership to his two sons and
Then his two sons who had no children
Left them in charitable trust
as beneficiaries of the
companies that they
they held
So it's a refreshing change that gave gave way to
Ownership in in an industry not being for the beneficial interest of A or B or C
but for the better good of
humanity, so if you look at the trusts today they span a
wide range of sectors and there's a certain stress that you've laid on
Technology being a great intervention in some of the applications
Where do you believe the transformation of the trusts actually began and why?
well, you know if you
If you look at India through the years
The needs of India have changed
We had famines food famines in the British times. Yeah, we don't have famines any longer
We had a majority of the people living in the
Rural areas today. There's a mass migration to the urban areas
giving
finally an important
issue of
creating an important issue of urban poverty and
hardships that didn't exist before
They're the creation of jobs in industrial organizations today automation and and
Differences in terms of value chains, etc make
Human jobs less important than machine machine jobs in many companies
So the needs of the nation have changed
Food shortages continue to exist in pockets
Water shortage is something that never existed in the past, but it's an issue today a
much larger population and creating jobs and knowledge
These are all issues that are issues of the changing times
For the trust to continue to do what they did at the turn of the century
Would be to be sitting in the twilight
Thinking that the issues of the country are the same and
To me that would have been a disappointment
So I think the trusts have gone through and are going through a transformation
That
to
to use
short-term
Is making the trust relevant today if we had not done that they would have become irrelevant
And
creator of
edifices that
that stood out as
as evidence of what the trust did but did not make a contribution to
To the country. Well, I completely agree about the relevance of the trust
The one thing that a lot of people talk about is the Tata culture
the Tata way of life
If you work for the Tata's on the one hand, it's almost as we are working for a family on the other
It's almost as if you're part of a legacy
how have
successive
leaders you before you JRD
How have you managed to retain that Tata culture in times which are sadly?
materialistic competitive
How you maintain that culture first of all that culture
Becomes embodied in the DNA of an organization
It's set off by the early leaders the founder in our case
who
Never was in need of wealth because he had it all
But it wasn't what drove him
Success of giving India its own independence in steel or power or
or the hospitality
area
Well what gave him the pride that he had made India as self-sufficient?
He didn't at that time look at
The companies as being his but being belonging to the country
somehow
That
Prevailed through the years through through his sons and then through JRD Tata for 50 years or so
where
JRD would stand in a line rather than beat the queue. Yeah
Where he would give way to a customer first and not him
and that humility I
think
Became embodied in in what all the leaders of Tata companies had done and we should
Protect that
Ferociously the day we lose that. I think we've lost an important
facet or
input in in the companies that we have
and the day we decide
to cheat the day we decide to
Do something that
Hold something for us and not for the customer. I think we will have lost a very very important asset
Has it been tough to stick by these values?
Especially during times when values were being trampled upon because of politics competition blah blah blah
Were there times that you often felt that thank God we are not the shortcut Tata's
Was you would have taken that shortcut? Yes, I'd be lying if I said there weren't moments when
When those issues came up and those decisions had to be made
happily at every time
Boards stood together and leadership stood together and saying that's not what we do
We over the years on occasion have suffered as a result of that
but on the whole I think we have I
Believe that it's very important to come back at at night and say I have not succumb. I
Love that because it's very easy to succumb. Yeah, I mean you must have faced political pressure economic pressures and
Yet you stood the course
Sometimes you didn't know if you were doing the right thing
All things are not black and white
You have a choice one choice
is
Leads you down a certain path long term
Another leads you down another part short term and then you have to weigh
one issue against another
Hopefully you make the right decision. Sometimes we don't but we do it with
innocence or naivety rather than
Manipulation and
negativity, so I
think that
That's a sort of dilemma that faces
many leaders in in the corporate world or politics
So it does in the business community, too
He invited me to come to just move the factory to Gujarat
and I said
We'd come if we had a home and he said I'll get you the land you want in three days
Amazing and then he delivered that on the third morning. He he said
Ratanji here's the
The land that I promised and that just doesn't happen in India
so mr. Modi as
as prime minister now is
Offering India
The Indian people a new India
in
1991 when you took over you were stepping into giant shoes
JRD's shoes and then you brought the entire group together
I still remember the work that you did around brand Tata and royalty blah blah
When you took over and sat in that corner office in
1991 what is the one thought that raced through your mind?
Because you were now the torchbearer and the legacy holder of
Almost 120 130 years of existence on the one hand. It was a big move for me
but on the other hand, I
joined the group in
62
So I've been in various positions on the shop floor in
in Australia and
In textiles and steel in
Tata Motors
through the years and
it was
in relative terms easy for me to relate to the
The bigger issue
The one thing I had which maybe is not so evident
Is I had a terrific mentor in JRD Tata. I
remember walking back from the
Meeting and where I was appointed chairman
When he walked back I walked with him to his office and he told his secretary
Halu we'll have to move out of here now
Superb and I said no J. You don't move out. This is your office as long as you want it. So he said really
So I said yes it is
He said where would you sit? I said where I'm sitting today. I
have an office down the down the hall and
That's fine
then I was
deadly afraid that
the JRD would forget that he stepped down and
And time and time again because he never stepped off the companies he remained
On the board of Tata Steel or
Telco at that time
And I I thought suppose he
Runs the group from behind and forces his view and he never did. In fact, he was
my greatest mentor and
The years that he was alive. I I used to go into his office and say J. I
Wish this had happened ten years ago. We have got such a great relationship
And he said yes, you know, I would I wish so too
so I
Was very lucky in in having him there
He lent his weight when he had to
Example the retirement age without his support. I could never have done that
He would explode if he thought
Something was being done that was wrong
But on the whole he was the terrific mentor
He was like a father like a brother
Gave advice. He always had time for you a terrific relationship and
very very important not enough is being said about that, but you too have been pretty reticent and and
shy if I may add about
Talking about the experiences that you went through
Your relationship with Jamie and some of the things that we're hearing now. We've never heard before
in your interactions with jrd
What is the one thing that you took away from that interaction?
What was the core of his of his brand values or his colonel as it were?
I would think if I were to have to pick one
Humility would be on the top of the list. He was
just a person who
longed to be
Anonymous and to some extent that's rubbed off on me. Yeah, you love being anonymous. Yeah, I do and
And as you as you go through life, you find that that becomes less so
And less possible and then you look at
seeking anonymity by
By hiding, but were you always shy were you always?
Away from you didn't want to meet not meet people. You didn't want the arc lights on you. I
Think so because
when I was in school, etc, you you wanted to be part of the school and not
Not the rich man's son or the chairman's son or
Or have a big car take you home while you're your classmates went by bus or smaller cars
you just wanted to be a
normal person and
from time to I think I owe a lot to my father to
ensure that we at no stage grew up my brother and I as as
pompous young young people, but
as
As people who would like to be every day and I think that has stayed with me
I want to come back to the city. You were born in Bombay
What was it like growing up and I know the personal trauma you went through on 26 11
What went through your mind on that evening? I remember you rushed to the Taj to see what was
Happening what went through your mind and and it must have broken your heart to a great extent. Well to me
It started by
one of my colleagues
Noshi, Sonala
telephoning me and he's saying that
There's some shooting at the Taj
So I called the Taj and nobody replied from the switchboard
as things turned out
I
Was not allowed into the lobby
the police came and they pushed everybody out and
Krishna Kumar was
Standing on this footpath outside. I was partly there partly home watching on television and
It became very clear
in a couple of hours that it
was not a gang fight or an underworld thing it was
Some form of
attack by terrorists or
or by enemies of the state
The next morning the government rang me to say it was all over. I in fact issued
TV statement that morning saying it was all over and it was not it went on for three days. Yeah
By that time everyone knew what it was it was an attack by the enemy of the state and
My my take on that was that whatever happened we were under siege in this hotel
That we would whatever they did. We would rebuild the hotel the city would stand
Stand up and not fall down
And there was a tremendous
Galvanizing of this of the citizens of Bombay something that made
Who made in everybody very proud of the way? Everybody stepped up to play a role. Nobody
walked away from the situation as it stood and
And you felt a great sense of pride that you were a part of this
Great city with citizens who were
Not running away from what we did and I remember you were
Particularly grieved at the at the loss of so many
People including people who were working at the at the Taj at that. Oh, yes
I'm gonna come back to a
larger national picture
You've seen prime ministers. You've seen governments at work
At the state level at the international level
India is at an exciting
time at an exciting place
What are your views about?
Narendra Modi
First of all, let me just say I
Known mr. Modi when he was
chief minister of Gujarat I
turned to him when
We had to change factories from single from single in West Bengal to
Gujarat
So I've seen him and and will never forget the way he
Found solutions for a company that was looking for a home. How was that meeting when you met?
Mr. Modi in those days and told him about this move what I've said publicly is
He invited me to come to just move the factory to Gujarat
and I said
We'd come if we had a home and he said I'll get you the land you want in three days
Amazing and then he delivered that on the third morning. He said
Ratanji, here's the
The land that I promised and that just doesn't happen in India
so mr. Modi is as prime minister now is
offering India
the Indian people a new India, I
think we need to
Give him that opportunity to offer that new India
he's able and capable of and
Innovative enough to look at India fresh
and I for one am optimistic that
with his leadership
India will
Be that new India that he has promised
It's interesting. You mentioned the new India of late. We've seen you invest in a lot of startups
You're backing a lot of entrepreneurs young people who are taking great risks
What is your philosophy and and why do you choose the kind of investments you make? Well, first of all
the
embodiment of
vision
That makes a
startup happen is
important you
I'm not going to invest in a business that I have no interest in
so
The business of the vision of that startup is important first, but the most important issue
Is to meet the founders. I have changed my view sometimes from negative to positive sometimes positive to negative
With with the founders I've
For example a founder that intends to just scale up his company to sell off
It's not a company. I
obviously want to be with a
founder who has a passion to to stay with something and build it into a
sustainable
Company that is taking its place is somebody I tend to support
so
it varies
when I was chairman
I couldn't take this kind of view because somewhere or the other would be conflicting with something that
Daughters were doing now as a
free person
It's it's invigorating to do this and I'm meeting a lot of young
Young people who
Who one day will be
Leaders of their industry and it's nice to interact with them, but I don't think you'll ever be free in a sense
I'm sure Chandra would come to you comes to you seeks your advice seeks your views
He too needs a mentor. So which brings me to a very interesting point. You've done so much
from flying planes to running conglomerates to sitting on international boards
What's the one thing that continues to drive you to this day? It's a difficult question to answer
Because
You get driven by some fire within yourself. You don't necessarily know what it is
It could be the people who lead an organization. It could be
the passion with which
Somebody is pursuing what he wants to do
It may be
Taking the side of the downtrodden
Because he's being picked at
it varies from time to time, but
there's
There's an issue of wanting to make a difference
And if you can help make that happen
That consumes you and and provides you with the motivation to go to go forward
I feel that the group is in
Very able hands with Chandra if you were to send out a message
To these young people who are watching the program today. What would that be?
As you said at the beginning of this conversation
That there are still some
Sociological there are societal issues that afflict our country. Let's imagine the prime minister will say
Mr. Tata
Please lead one specific
nation altering mission
What would you pick if asked?
first of all, I hope I would never be asked anything like that because I would I
Would not be the kind of person to to leave that. I
Don't think I could answer that
off the cuff
and it's too important an issue to
Give a
Flip an answer
But I think the way such a thing ought to be done is to be freed of
Political baggage that often such a thing would would carry and the freedom
To to the person who's asked to do whatever is necessary to make that happen
far too often you have a good idea that's squished because of political or
Sociological thing it just cannot be done. So it's too difficult to be done
Or it's too risky to be done as such with public funds
and that might
those might be the very things that are necessary to pull a
Country out of a particular morass that it may be in in a in an area
so
I'd like to
Duck that question
from your vantage point
seen what you've seen of the trust of the of the relationship that
The trusts have with the people and with the opera with the holding company
do you believe corporate India has really pulled its weight in the area of philanthropy and
Involved itself in nation-building like in many other countries where
Individuals get involved with nation-building as well. I think the only fair answer to that is there been certain
Certain companies that I think would make everybody proud with what they have done
be it in the pharmaceutical area or be it in chemicals or be it
in areas
relating to
Rural development, which they're done more than they
need to
to do to have a public face and
There are companies who have not
But I think if you go to any country you would have the same mix same mix
Companies that are
Conscious and
Compassionate about the have-nots in their country and those who don't care
now that you're at arm's length from the
operations of the Tata group
What excites you the most?
About the group and what worries you the most if anything worries you at all
What excites me is the area we're working in now and trying to transform the trust
because we're actually
In a manner of speaking having the same
excitement as as one did in setting up an industrial enterprise
dealing now with
We're trying to reach people trying to provide health care the national cancer grid the cancer grid nutrition
And while the trust cannot take care of the country
we're
setting some
foot footfalls in
in the sand
Which I must say the state governments and the central government
They're all supporting us fully and and I think what we're trying to do is taken
As being genuine and honest and it's very rewarding to see
State governments and the center working with us
Things that some people would say could never happen. So that's the trust
What excites you about the Tata the house of Tata the
Industrial a bit and what worries you the most if anything, I think
It's too hot a question to answer
Given what we've been going through in the last several months
All I'd like to say is that I feel that the group is in
very able hands with Chandra
And
Businesses a cyclic they will have their ups and downs
We have been a group that has worked with companies when they're in peril and brought them up
and I hope we can continue to do that in the years gone by we will
Probably the group will look different over the next 10 years. There'll be companies that
Were not there earlier and there'll be
Companies that were there not there
10 years from now because they will not be relevant or they may have been sold or
transferred to another company
so the face of
Tata's may change
But so long as there's still the same
drive to make this an
enterprise or a conglomeration of enterprises
that operate with ethical
Standards and value systems. I
Think I would feel very proud. I know you're not the preachy kind and you don't like pontificating, but that'd be
There gonna be tons of young people watching this conversation
They're gonna be watching on television. They're gonna see snippets online
Many and you know this yourself many admire the house of Tata
They admire the Tata way of life and they admire Ratan Tata
If you were to send out a message to these young people who are watching the program today, what would that be?
It could be anything be business nation, whatever what I would tend to want to convey
Is that people should do what they believe is the right thing to do?
however, usually that's also the most difficult thing to
And it's the riskiest thing to do but if they believe in something they should pursue it
And they should like I said earlier
Try to make a difference
not a difference that's
disruptive or or
Negative but a constructive difference
One other thing I I would like to add
which
Which sounds politic, but it's it's not
we as a country or the citizens of a country need to
Get back the pride that we should have
That we are Indians now that we're Punjabis or Parsis or?
or Tamils or
That we're Indians first
Then we have a country that we belong to and that we should be proud of
We need to we seem to be losing that somewhere. Why I
think there are many reasons for that, but I
Think that can be won back
Into a sense of pride. We we shouldn't have that sense of pride every time we go to war or have a conflict
or get
attacked by terrorists
should be there all the time and
To my mind Modi's working on that and he has been working. Yeah, he has absolutely
and he's built a vision of a unified India and
people may disagree with that, but I
Think that that's what the country needs at this point in time. It needs everybody to rally around
The direction that the leaders are giving us
So one hopes that the young of tomorrow it'll will be driven by that to some extent
So then I would ask you which was your most despaired moment as it were. That's an easier one to
answer because I've always felt the
Greatest despair I had was when Tata's decided to put
Central India mills, which is what Johnson you started into liquidation
For if I recall at that time is 50 lakhs of rupees. Yes. I thought this was a very
untouched I like
At your
sprightly age you still have
multifarious hobbies from tinkering and driving cars to flying planes to reading to
Architecture
Do you think in many ways this?
Cross-functionality shaped you and so someone else to say but what do you feel? I?
Think you you can't
Just have one interest you you need to be able to
jump
so I think I've been fortunate in in
having those interests I
Failed in in some ways when I retired I said I would
Relearn the piano. I haven't done that but you you you used to play the piano at one time long long ago
and I actually
started
Relearning the piano I got a very
able piano teacher to
to come and teach him but other things overtook my ability to
be consistent and
On the piano I had one
Real problem. I I found I couldn't get relate my
Left hand to do something different from my right hand
Frustrating issue and I I think that sort of wane my
Urge to to do what would give me many hours of joy when you look back at this life
Biggest achievement you might
What will you define as your biggest achievement? I?
really wouldn't be able to
to define that it had been many moments which make one feel a sense of great satisfaction and
They've been a few times when?
It's almost despair
So then I would ask you which it was your most
despaired moment as it were
that's an easier one to
Answer because I've always felt the the greatest despair I had was when
Tata's decided to put Central India Mills, which is what jumps as you started into liquidation
for
If I recall at that time is 50 lakhs of rupees
I thought this was a very
untied I like move
but it was done and
Many people went out of work. I saw the misery that it caused
blue blue-collar workers got taken care of by
by the government
but the officers of the company really suffered and
That's remained in my in my heart is as something that was a moment of
Mr. Tata you were
Sat on international boards you continue to you've been feted by governments nations
admired a lot
Who do you admire?
two people that apart from charity whom I mentioned who I admire greatly and
Sort of oscillates between being a family member and a mentor and and
the business when I admire
two people
Not connected with me have been inspirational to to me and have had the profound
Impression on on what I've done and how I've done it have been
Dr. Armand Bose who
Both speakers the Bose corporation
he and I
Enjoyed a
Friendship that was very close and was very personal because
He opened his company to me. We we spend hours and hours together and
Discuss
Various things in fact, I knew more about the Bose corporation than most people might have done
and the other person
Is a person called Henry Schott
who
Was the chairman of Cummins engine company where we had a joint venture with?
Yeah, the Tata Cummins here
then became
The chairman of Lucent
Which was the telecom company that merged with Alcatel
those two people were
Were people that and Henry's continues to be today
Dr. Bose died a couple of years ago
People that have
Had a great influence on my on my career
the one thing that you've managed to hide very successfully from people is
a deep
sense of wit that you possess
We saw
Glimpses of it when you related that street urchin story
Isn't that a very Parsi trait to have I wouldn't say wicked but to have
Titillating wit and why have you hidden it from people? I haven't hidden it from people. I some people bring it out
the other day had
Had that not been mentioned
It would never have occurred to me
to allude to
something that that I
Do it
all the time to speak
Again, it's so what happened with that street urchin you were driving. Yeah, and then you know, it's not something
I always used to stop and talk to them because
Many of them are bright young kids who just don't have a chance
They're not interested in going to school they're interested in a job they
and
and they make more money than they would make if they were working and
They're just a part of India. That's
Fascinating. It's the young India of tomorrow
Do you think when you when you look back the appetite for risk amongst the youth in India has increased?
Early we would follow traditional patterns of jobs now more and more people are self-starters
depends on the area
People like the street urchins what chance do they have?
They look for a job
there
they live by day to day and
they
they sometimes skate on thin ice in terms of
the law
It's a difficult thing and to relate them to a
middle-class family that works hard
Goes to school or college aspires to be in a company
then the
Wants are different. The aspirations are different
But all of them put together would make a tremendously
Entrepreneurial India, so last two questions
Next and I know you don't like anniversaries with next year
The house of Tata will turn 150
That's a significant milestone for any industrial group
Especially, you know in young vibrant democracies like ours. What are your thoughts about that?
well, I'm very happy to see that we've held together for that period of time and
Many companies disintegrate but in that kind of period of
Are just a tombstone and I think we should do everything we can to preserve it and to
continue that
as I said earlier the
The group may change it may look different in the next
30 years 50 years
But it should embody the same values and the same ethical standards that it has had
should never forget that
most of its earnings
Go to philanthropy
not in in the pockets of founders and and leaders and
That it's doing something for the common good of mankind. I think that's
Very satisfying if that if that were to happen finally
How would Ratan Tata like to be remembered?
very quickly
What I said earlier, I'd like to be remembered as a person who made a difference
not
anything more not anything less that's as
brief as
Pithy and as deep as it can be. Thank you. Mr. Tata for this lovely conversation
It's very rare to
Get you to speak
But I'm glad you agreed
there are people who want to
Hear you
And I'm glad we touched upon some of the issues that we did from business to nation to the world. Thank you so much
Thank you. So it's always a pleasure to deal with you and to interact with you and
The pleasure has been mine
