Ventilator-associated Event (VAE) with Case Studies

CDC
258 followers
1 Video View·Jan 7, 2026
During the CDC 2025 NHSN Annual Training, Emily Witt presents Ventilator-associated Event Case Studies
This video can also be viewed at
https://www.cdc.gov/wcms/video/low-res/nhsn/2026/210421042025NHSNATVAECaseStudies.mp4
My name is Emily Wit. I am a member of
the protocol and training team with
NHSN. And in the second part of the VAE
session today, uh we are going to test
your knowledge on all of the excellent
information um that Sam provided in her
presentation uh by going through some
case study examples. Um and these
examples were created to be um very
similar to the ones that uh the VAE team
receives via the NHS and help desk. So
hopefully um they will be helpful to you
and valuable and we will go ahead and
jump right into it.
All right. So this is the case example
that we are going to be working through
during today's uh case uh case study
session. And here is the information. So
we have a 16-year-old patient. They
present to the emergency department at
9:00 p.m. on March the 1st with an
admitting diagnosis of influenza with a
suspicion of complication related to
bacterial pneumonia. This patient
experiences respiratory distress and is
intubated and placed on a ventilator in
the emergency department. They then
remain in the emergency department for
several hours um before they are
admitted to an inpatient unit. The
patient is admitted to an adult
inpatient location. it's the ICU at
11:30 p.m. on March the 1st, so the same
day they originally presented to the ED.
And um just to cover all of our bases,
uh I will provide the information uh
that for the purposes of today's case
study, uh VAE surveillance is selected
in the monthly reporting plan for the
adult ICU at this facility.
Whoops. I think I might have
accidentally given you the answer.
Pretend you didn't see that everyone. Um
so this will be a gimme I guess the
first question of the day. Uh have a
have a little hint there. Um so first
question uh is this patient eligible for
VAE surveillance? And your options are A
no this is a pediatric patient or B yes
the patient is located in an adult
inpatient unit that is conducting inplan
VAE surveillance. Um, and while you're
putting your answers in the chat there,
I will note that um, on the slides, I'm
going to have the the gray box that you
see is a case summary. So, this is the
exact same information that was provided
on the previous slide. Just wanted to
have it available for you all as you are
making um, your selections.
And for my colleagues um, in the chat,
what are what are we seeing? Oops.
>> Lots of bees coming through. Lots of
bees. uh B's or Y's, which is B's for
yes.
That's all I see. Oh, I saw I saw a
couple of A's, but mostly B's.
All right, awesome job. Those of you who
selected B, um that is correct. Uh you
will remember that VAE surveillance from
Sam's presentation is locationbased and
so all patients in an adult p and and
adult inpatient location are included in
VAE surveillance regardless of the
patient's age. So even though this was a
16-year-old patient, they were in an
adult inatient location where VAE
surveillance um was being conducted and
therefore they are eligible for VAE
surveillance.
All right. So, let's take a look here at
the patients ventilator settings um
while they were located in both the
emergency department and after transfer
to the ICU. So, taking a look at the
PEEP and FiO2 ventilator settings um for
March the 1st. So, specifically, we're
looking at March the 1st here. Uh what
are the daily minimum values for this
patient on March the 1st? And you have
your options um A through D here. in
FiO2 of 40 and PEEP of five, FiO2 of 40
and PEEP of 8, FiO2 of 40 and PEEP of
10, or FiO2 of 60 and PEEP of 10.
I'll give you a minute to put your
selections in the chat.
>> We are seeing alphabet soup, Emily.
Okay.
>> A B and D
or A.
>> Perfect. that means that this is going
to be um an excellent teaching
opportunity. So um we will go ahead and
move to the next slide and see the
correct answer and that is going to be
uh D. Those who selected D, great job.
And we will um we are going to talk
about why. So let's go to the next slide
to review why that is. So, um, as you'll
recall, uh, from Sam's presentation,
ventilator data that's obtained from
patients in the emergency department or
other locations prior to admission to an
inpatient location are not included in
VAE surveillance. So, only those
ventilator settings that are documented
while this patient is admitted um, or
located um, to an adult inpatient
location are used to make a VAE
determination. Um, so in this case,
you'll see that there are settings
recorded in the emergency department,
but those will not be used. Um, the
patient was only in the inpatient
location, only in the ICU for a very
short period of time on March the 1st.
You'll remember they were admitted to
the ICU at 11:30 p.m. And so values from
those ventilator settings were only
documented one time in the ICU for March
the 1st. Um and so therefore in
situations like this when no FiO2 or
PEET value is documented to have been
maintained for greater than one hour um
or it was only documented once um the
daily minimum values are going to
default to the lowest setting documented
during that calendar day um regardless
of how long it was maintained. Um and
again in this case you'll see the PEEP
and FIO2 were recorded only one time for
March the 1st. That's going to be your
your FIO2 of 60 and your PEEP of 10. Um,
and therefore those are going to be the
settings that are automatically going to
be your daily minimum values for March
the 1st.
All right. So, continuing to look at the
same patient from our example here. Um,
we know they have moved to the adult
ICU. They are eligible for VAE
surveillance and they have been
ventilated for over a week. Um and
during that time we have information on
their daily minimum values for PEEP and
FIO2.
So taking a look at the the daily
minimum value information presented
here.
Our next question is is a VA is a VAE
identified for this patient and your
options are yes in the PE parameter, yes
in the FiO2 parameter or there is no VAE
for this patient.
Okay, we're seeing a lot of C's. Emily
as in cat. C's have been
>> a lot of C's. Okay, C as in cat. Thanks,
Tony.
Awesome job everyone who selected C. Uh
that is correct. Great job. Um so taking
a look at the um at your daily minimum
values recorded here you'll see um first
of all in the FiO2 parameter we see that
there is um you know just kind of stable
uh 6050 there's no worsening um nothing
really to take a look at there but
taking a look at the PE parameter you do
see that there are two calendar days of
improving daily minimum PEEP um on
mechanical ventilation days three and
four there is a baseline period of
improvement there um however while There
is worsening in the PEEP parameter on
mechanical ventilation day five um with
an increase of with an increase to a
PEEP of eight. Um you'll recall again
from the presentation that that increase
in the daily minimum PEEP values must
meet the worsening oxygenation criteria
of greater than or equal to 3 cm of
water over the daily minimum PEEP of the
first day in the baseline period. And so
that first day in the period of
improvement on mechanical ventilation
day three is a PEEP of eight. And since
the worsening of eight on mechanical
ventilation day five is not greater than
3 cm of water um over that first day in
the period of improvement that is not
met and therefore no VAE is identified
um for this case. Awesome job everyone.
Sorry about that. It looks like we're on
a little bit of a delay here. So again,
just highlighting um some of the
information I just said here um related
to the um related to uh that period of
of improvement and then the um the
worsening not meeting the the 3 cm of
water threshold.
All right, just going back to our case
example here. We're about halfway
through the case studies. Um, so I
wanted to give a quick refresher. Um,
just remind you all of the case that
we're still working through before we
move on to the next the next couple of
questions. So again, we have our
16-year-old patient presenting to the
emergency department um with an
admitting diagnosis of influenza and
suspicion of complication related to
bacterial pneumonia. Um, they are
intubated and placed on mechanical
ventilation in the emergency department.
They are then um admitted into an adult
inpatient location. in the ICU um where
VAE surveillance is selected in the
monthly reporting plan.
So here we are going to look at a
variation on this same patient. So we do
have some additional information
available in the worksheet. Now um on
the screen as you can see we see that
the patient has been ventilated for over
a week. Um during that time we have
information on their daily minimum
values for PEEP and FIO2. And I will
note here um just to draw your attention
that these are different daily minimum
values than we used in the last example.
So um just uh keep an eye on that when
you're making your assessments um for
this case. And then we also have um some
of the additional information that you
may need to make a determination on if
this patient meets back, IVAC or PAVAP.
um for example the temperature, the
white blood cells um that they were
administered antibiotics and that they
also had a positive diagnostic test um
from respiratory secretions on their
second day of mechanical ventilation.
So next question is a VAE identified for
this patient and your answer choices are
yes or no. The patient had pneumonia on
admission and therefore is excluded from
VAE surveillance.
and I think I'm seeing some A's coming
through in the chat here. Um, I'm trying
not to click off the screen since the
slides are getting a little hung up, but
from what I can see, I'm I'm seeing some
A's coming through.
>> That's correct.
>> Awesome.
Great job. Yes, those who selected A,
you are correct. uh that is met in the
PEEP parameter um for uh for this case
and we're going to talk about um why or
how we're going to look at our um look
at our worksheet example and go through
um how how that is met and that a VAE is
identified in this patient. Um but I did
want to talk a little bit about um the
patient having pneumonia on admission
and why that does not exclude them for
VAE surveillance. Um so as um I'm sure
you all have heard maybe throughout the
various trainings over the last couple
weeks um like all NHSN definitions uh
VAE is a surveillance definition and the
intention is to allow for standardized
use across all reporting facilities. Um
and the the definitions can then be
applied in essentially the same way to
all patient populations.
um and underlying conditions or
diagnosis um for example a diagnosis of
pneumonia on admission uh don't exclude
a patient from having a VAE and the
reason why that is the reason why um we
want to ensure surveillance is done for
all eligible patients um regardless of
the reason for which the patient was
admitted or the reason for initiation of
mechanical ventilation um is because
exclusion of those patients could
potentially result in a missed
opportunity for preventing complications
um which is what you know these
surveillance definitions are all about.
Uh for example, a patient may be
admitted with pneumonia and they require
intubation mechanical ventilation. Um
this patient then may stabilize or
improve on the ventilator and then
worsen again. And it's really possible
in instances like this that that is an
indication of a new hospitalacquired
process um such as you know as Sam
mentioned ventilator associated
pneumonia, pulmonary edema um ARDS etc.
um as opposed to to a worsening of the
process that they that the patient
presented with on admission. Um so the
goal of surveillance is really to
capture uh this valuable information um
when looking at improving patient
outcomes and preventing complications uh
related to mechanical ventilation. So
that's just kind of a little bit of
background on why um you know these
these diagnoses or conditions on
admission um don't exclude a patient
from surveillance.
So with that being said, um we are going
to uh look a little bit at how this
patient uh met Zach um and review the
review the details here. So as you can
see we have um we do have our two
calendar days of st excuse me two
calendar days of stable daily minimum
peak values. We have a peep of five on
mechanical ventilation day mechanical
ventilation days three and four. So this
is going to establish your baseline
period of stability.
Then on mechanical ventilation day five
um the daily minimum PEEP does meet the
threshold for worsening oxygenation uh
with an increase of at least 3 cm of
water over the daily minimum PEEP on the
first day in the baseline period. So we
see that go from 5 to 8 which meets that
3 cm of water threshold. Um the increase
um the PEEP of eight is maintained for
at least two calendar days as you can
see mechanical ventilations day five and
six and therefore um criteria for back
is met in the PEEP parameter and your
date of event is going to be mechanical
ventilation day five and this is the
date of onset of worsening oxygenation.
All right, let's continue looking at our
same example um for case two here. So we
know that VAC is met in the PE parameter
and that does set a VAE window period uh
which is demonstrated by the gray boxes
in the worksheet table here. We have our
date of events on or excuse me our date
of event on mechanical ventilation day
five and then the two days before and
two days after um set that VAE window
period.
So with that information available to
you and again this table on the slide
here is the exact same one that we just
presented on the previous slide. Um what
level of VA of the VAE algorithm did
this patient meet? Um VAT, IVAC or PAP?
>> There are a lot of B's coming in. B as
in brown. A lot of B's coming in. Couple
of C's sprinkled in too.
>> Okay.
Awesome. That is great to hear.
All right, we're gonna not tell you what
the correct answer is immediately. We're
going to talk talk through some things
first. Um, so we do know that from the
previous slide already have established
that is met in the PE parameter here.
Um, and remember the algorithm is
progressive. So knowing that we've met
back, we can move on to then look at the
IVback criteria.
And within the VA, excuse me, within the
VAE window period, um, we did have both
the temperature and the white blood cell
count criteria met in this case. Um, and
as you'll recall, you only have to meet
one or excuse me, you only have to meet
the temperature or the white blood cell
count criteria. It doesn't have to be
both. Um, in this example, there just
happens to be both. Um, but you do only
have to meet one of those criteria. um
within the VA that or excuse me within
the IVAC criteria. Um we also have four
consecutive um qualifying antimicrobial
days within the window period. Um and
I'm talking through it on this slide.
We're going to look at an example in the
table on the next slide. So I know this
is this is hard to not have the visual
the visual aid, but we will have one on
the next slide. So just wanted to to
assure everyone of that. Um that there
were four um four consecutive qualifying
antimicrobial days within the window
period. And therefore, IVback is met.
And with IVAC being met, we now move on
to assess for additional evidence of
infection or if a PAVAC is identified.
And in this case, um, as you all saw on
the previous slide, um, we did have a
positive respiratory secretion result
for Corona virus, um, which is eligible
for use in meeting PT criterion 3.
However, the collection date for that
specimen was outside of the VAE window
period and therefore PEVAP is not met.
Um, so the highest level of the VAE
algorithm um where all the criteria is
met in this case is IVAP. And it sounds
like that was um the answer that almost
everyone put in based on the feedback
from Tony. So awesome job everyone. That
was that was really fantastic.
And here like I said um I wanted to
review that that same information again
just with the visual aid of the
worksheet. Um so like we previously
established VAC is met in the PET
parameter
for the IVAC criteria. Um again we have
both the temperature and the white blood
cell count criteria. Um one of the two
of those must be met in this case. Both
happen to be met in this particular
case. And then looking at our
antimicrobials, um we have sept trioxone
and isothermiain um meet the criteria
for new antimicrobial agents started
within the VAE window period. Um so
remember four qualifying ant the four
qualifying antimicrobial day requirement
can be met with different antimicrobial
agents as long as each of these
antimicrobial agents is new and there is
not a day between the different
antimicrobials. Um so although there
were not four consecutive days of Seth
trioxone given or four consecutive days
of eiththermyiain given both are
considered new agents within the VAE
window period and there wasn't a day in
between the administration of these
different antimicrobials and therefore
together they do meet the four
qualifying antimicrobial day
requirement.
And then finally um we see here that
that um corona virus positive
respiratory secretion was collected
outside the VAE window period. Um it was
collected on mechanical ventilation day
two and um therefore it is not an
eligible specimen for use in needing
PAVAP.
All right. Our final question um again
is a variation on this case. Um so we
have the same uh PEEP and FIO2 daily
minimum values here. Uh so hint hint we
already know that that is met right. Um
but we do have different antimicrobial
and pathogen information uh presented.
So based on the information available,
the slight variation for example case
three um available in the worksheet
table here, your final question is what
level of the VAE algorithm did this
patient meet? And again the choices are
VAC, IVAC or PVAP.
Emily, it looks like there's a mix of
C's and A's.
>> A mix of C's and A's. Okay.
All right, awesome.
>> Good balance.
>> Okay, perfect. And yes, this was this
was a little tricky. Um, but that's
good. We're definitely we're going to
talk about it. We're going to talk about
um why the answer uh to this question is
what it is.
So again here um we're going to talk
about uh the answer to this question I
will go ahead and say is a it's back. um
and we're going to talk about why um we
already again had established um that
AVAC was met in the PE parameter
and then also looking at the um excuse
me looking at the temperature and the
white blood cell criteria for IBACK
these were also met um in the VAE window
period uh in this case however um the
antimicrobial the sept trioxone was
started on mechanical ventilation day
two it was started outside of the VAE
window period um which means that it
does not meet the new definition. Um, so
remember both the temperature and white
blood cell count and that qualifying
antimicrobial day criteria both must be
met um met within the VA window period
in order for IVback to be met and IVAC
was not met in this case. Um, and I did
hear that a couple of um a couple we
were seeing some C answers and um this
was a little bit tricky and I do
understand um why that that answer was
provided. So we're going to talk about
this in a little more detail. Um so if
we look at the pathogen we do see that
that semi-quantitative result of 3 plus
P arugenosa it does meet PBA criterion
one right it was collected within the
VAE window period however remember that
the VAE surveillance algorithm is
progressive so that has to be met before
you assess for IVAC and then IVAC has to
be met before you assess for PEAP and so
in this case because IVAC is not met we
would not assess for PAVAP so even
though we have that eligible specime
within the VAE window period. Um, we
would not even assess for PEAP knowing
that IVAC wasn't met. And then this
would be reported, this VAE would be
reported um, at the VAC level.
And again, just wanted to lay that
information all out in the worksheet.
Um, I personally am a visual learner. I
like to see it this way. Um, so maybe
you all prefer to see it this way, too.
Again, um we have the information here
about the temperature and white blood
cell criteria met in the VA window
period. Um but as you can see, uh that
antimicrobial
is started outside of the window period
and therefore is not considered new um a
new antimicrobial for qualifying
antimicrobial days. Um doesn't meet that
new definition. And because IVAC is not
met, you're going to stop there at the
algorithm and report this VAE um at the
VAC level.
All right, everyone.
