The Surprising Benefits of a Survivorship Policy

Finance Shield
6 followers
Jan 7, 2026
Today, we are going to discuss a case study
that involves a survivorship policy.
So when we look at survivorship policies,
these can be great life insurance policies
where both cash value and death benefit
are very important to you.
However, there are some items
that we definitely wanna be aware of
because it's much different than a single life policy
when we look at the MEC rules and other items
as far as how the policy functions
and different levers we can pull
after the policy is started.
So the first case study we're going to look at
in this video in particular
is based on a couple, both age 60,
both very healthy,
likely they're going to both receive the top health rating.
They recently received the top health rating
with single life policies,
but they have interest in a survivorship policy.
The funding they're considering
is $100,000 per year for seven years.
That's a total of $700,000.
However, they do want the option
to get a total of $1 million into the policy
and how they want to do that
is just continue to fund 100K per year through year 10.
So the policies are built in a manner
where if they want to continue to fund the policies,
they can, but they do not have to do that.
And the scenarios we'll look at
in this particular case study
will assume stopping the funding after seven years.
Now to hit on an item here
with respect to a survivorship policy, what is it?
It is one policy on two individuals.
The death benefit is not paid out until both insureds die.
So we've got a couple here
starting a policy at the age of 60.
They're both 60 years old.
Let's assume the husband dies at age 80.
Will the death benefit be paid out?
Only the husband died at age 80.
The death benefit will not be paid out.
We'll assume that the wife continues to live
up until the age of 90.
When she passes at age 90,
then the total death benefit will be paid out
to the policy beneficiary.
The death benefit, again, is not paid out
until both insureds die with a survivorship policy.
That can be viewed as a disadvantage to some,
or I should say a reason why some individuals
would not pursue a survivorship policy.
Because if you're a married couple
and something happens to one spouse
and the death benefit's paid to the other,
well, you've got that life insurance protection there.
With a survivorship policy, again, it's both individuals.
So that can be considered a drawback to some.
Here's an advantage.
Because the death benefit is not paid out
until both individuals die,
the insurance company knows that there's a high chance
of them being able to hold onto
the death benefit claim longer,
meaning there's going to be a longer period of time
before they have to pay out a death benefit claim.
As a result, when you look at the insurance expenses
on a survivorship policy,
they're lower, typically,
than what you'll see with a single life policy.
So in short, that results in more cash value often
when we compare survivorship policy
with some single life policies.
Not all the time, but it is very common to see that.
However, there are some very important things
to be aware of, which we're going to cover in this video
when we examine the different products.
What we're going to look at,
we're going to look at a survivor whole life 100 policy.
What that means is that premiums are payable
up until age 100.
It does not mean that the couple must pay premiums
until they're 100 years old,
but that's how long they can pay the premium
if they want to.
Then we've got a 12 pay policy.
This means we can pay into it for 12 years.
After 12 years, the premium is no longer due.
So we have a shorter funding period
than this particular case.
And then we have what is called
an estate guard whole life insurance policy.
This is a survivorship policy
where you see premiums due for a longer period of time.
We'll go through the illustration as well.
Policy design.
So in designing a policy,
we'll take the same approach we would
with a single life policy,
which is maximum cash value.
And why we do that,
even when a high death benefit is a priority,
is when you look at a whole life insurance policy,
single life or survivorship policy,
the policy with the most cash value long term
will have the greatest death benefit long term.
Now, on the flip side,
going with the highest cash value up front
will often result in the lowest death benefit up front.
So it is something we like to look at
to see examples of,
hey, do I go with a minimum death benefit up front
and know if I pump that cash value up over time,
my death benefit will pump up with it?
Or do I go with an option
that has more life insurance up front
and maybe I sacrifice some long-term performance
but then I know I have that protection?
Seeing the options help.
Maybe it's one product we look at
with two different designs
with a higher death benefit up front
versus a lower death benefit up front.
But in these examples,
because cash value is a goal,
we're going to look at a minimum base premium
which will reduce the death benefit,
reduce the insurance expenses
and then we will maximize the PUA.
Now, what I want to hit on here
is the MEC treatment.
If you were to look at a single life policy,
meaning just a whole life insurance policy
that's maximized for cash value,
how long do we have to keep the death benefit high
in order to prevent a MEC?
Give you a hint,
we see the number of years in this case study,
seven years.
With a single life policy,
what's another name for the MEC test?
The seven-pay test,
which represents the first seven years
on a life insurance policy.
So if this case study involved a single life policy,
meaning it was not a survivorship policy,
let's say it was just a 10-pay policy
or a whole life 100 on one individual,
say the husband,
what we would do is fund it at $100,000 per year
for seven years.
And then what do we do at year eight
regarding the death benefit?
If we have a term rider,
what do we do with that?
We cut it,
that reduces the death benefit.
We could also look at a reduced paid-up option,
which will eliminate the premium
and that will also do what to the death benefit?
It'll reduce the death benefit,
allowing me to reduce the insurance expenses
and that will often result
in stronger cash value growth.
That's an advantage to those options
where after the seventh year
I can reduce the death benefit,
lowering expenses
and maximize cash value.
With a survivorship policy,
you cannot quite do that.
We get this question sometimes from agents too,
which is,
why would you not use a survivorship policy?
Because that can drive the cash value
north much faster
and there's truth to that.
The reason why
is because when you look at the MEC treatment,
you do not have that same seven-year test.
Meaning if I design a policy
with a $100,000 MEC limit,
you're going to see that in some of the examples,
that's my MEC limit,
which is still based on the death benefit.
But then at year 8,
I drop the term rider
or I exercise a reduced paid up,
what'll happen is I'll trigger a MEC,
a modified endowment contract.
What you'll find is whatever death benefit
that was required to attain
a $100,000 MEC limit originally,
my death benefit cannot drop below that figure
at any point in time.
So it's not just the first seven years
I have to be aware of,
it's the entire life of the policy.
So when working with individuals,
if your survivorship policy,
or I should say,
if my goal is to maximize cash value
and I might want to reduce
that death benefit down the road
or if I'm funding with a lump sum,
the survivorship policy
might not be a good option.
It works well
if you're in a position
where you've got a large amount of assets
where you can continue to fund a policy,
even if life happens
and your income stops.
If I'm relying on my income
only to fund a policy
and then something happens
where I can't pay into it
like I thought I could,
I could be in trouble there
because I can't pull levers
such as reducing the term rider
or reduced paid up,
I'll trigger a MEC.
Whereas with a single life policy,
we would do that.
So my point is,
there's some other things
that we have to be aware of.
And of course,
we help with all of that
when we're working with someone.
So to look at this example,
let's take a look at the different products
and let's begin with this
survivorship whole life 100 policy.
So breakdown as to where the money is going,
that's always the first question
because where can your money go?
Base premium or PUA's?
Base premium term insurance or PUA's?
So here you've got an annual outlay
of $100,000 per year.
Here's your base premium,
just over $10,000
which is as low as we could drive it
for this couple,
both 60 years old.
Then we've got other riders
which we can explain
what all of this means.
We've got videos that explain it actually.
But what I want to hit on is this,
he funds it here,
the husband for 7 years
at $100,000 per year.
What happens in year 8?
We see this column,
this annual surrender
and what you'll notice
is that number the $10,426
matches the base premium $10,426.
So when we see this column
an annual surrender here,
what this is representing
is the fact that you are not
paying the premium,
the policy is covering
the premium internally.
What's happening
is this amount is being surrendered
from dividends
and also what's referred to
as rider value,
call it just build up in the policy
cash value build up over time.
The policy is paying for itself,
it's covering the premium internally
while the cash value is still growing.
Really you just want the bottom line,
here's what I'll look at.
My net out-of-pocket is 0
and is my cash value going up?
The answer is yes.
Okay good, that's what I want to know there.
The death benefit over here,
what happens here?
Increases while I'm funding,
what happens after year 7?
Begins to decrease but not by much,
it always stays above 1.9
and here's an important note here,
that initial death benefits $1.8 million.
$1.8 million,
MEC limit $100,000,
bottom right-hand corner.
So what that means
is that our policy
cannot have a death benefit
lower than that $1.8 million
because if we reduce it
to less than $1.8 million
through a reduced paid-up option,
what'll happen is we'll run into a MEC.
That's something we always have to look at.
Now it is very possible
that a reduced paid-up
could be available 10 years from now
or 10 years after the 7-year funding period
or later down the road.
That's very possible.
But in this particular example,
we could not execute a reduced paid-up.
So we just let the policy pay for itself indefinitely.
When we look at the guarantees,
that's not an attractive option.
Reduced paid-up is much more attractive there.
But this is an option
and we've got a survivorship whole life $100 here.
With the premium due indefinitely.
Let's look at that 12-pay example.
So same company here
with the 12-pay.
What I don't like
is that that premium's higher naturally.
It's almost $18,000.
And this is me pulling out all the works
when designing the policy
for maximum cash value.
So it's at $17,000 and change.
But with a 12-pay product,
it's a limited pay policy.
So what you typically see
is more of that premium comes back to cash value
as the years pass,
particularly year 2 in this example.
For the first year,
you're at about $77,000 and change.
Remember what it was in the last example?
We're going to look at that soon with a side-by-side.
What else do you notice here though?
Look at the death benefit.
You're at $1,500,000.
The last example was what?
$1,800,000.
Why the difference?
Well, the 12-pay product
has a guaranteed rate of 3%.
Whereas the whole life 100 product
has a guaranteed rate of 3.75%.
All it means is that
a different death benefit
gives me the same MEC limit.
And if you view that as confusing,
the main question I would ask
when you're looking at a policy
is what's the MEC limit?
This way you've got awareness
on what that MEC limit is
and then you know the minimum death benefit needed
in order to attain that MEC limit
to make sure we don't run into a taxable event.
So looking at this guy,
numbers look good,
break-even between years 5 and 6.
Funded it for 7 years
just like the last example.
But what else do we notice here?
There's your funding,
annual surrender,
higher surrender here
because the premium is higher.
But what else?
It lasts for a shorter period of time.
Only through year 12
instead of through age 100.
Here you've got the term rider.
This is the other big thing I'm looking at.
I do not want a term rider
attached to a policy too long
with a survivorship policy
or any policy for that matter.
But as I grow older,
I don't want that to be attached to the policy
and at a high dollar amount too long.
It will negatively impact the performance.
So we can't drop the death benefit
lower than $1,500,000.
So if after the funding,
I cut off the $1,500,000,
I'm just about there.
We could chop it off,
we're very, very close.
But what we did instead,
just gradually reduce it
and made sure the death benefit
stayed well above $1,500,000.
Building in a little bit of a buffer
in the event that dividends go down.
If dividends go down,
what could happen
is you could see the death benefit
increase at a little bit slower pace here
which could result in
less death benefit here
and a potential MEC.
Different company,
here we go.
Here's your funding,
$100,000 per year.
Net death benefit $1,700,000.
Through when?
Through the end of the funding period.
So how this particular design works
is we've got our whole life death benefit here,
our term rider over here
and as the whole life goes up,
mainly as you pump money into PUAs,
your term rider comes down.
Always keeping you level at the $1,700,000
until the term is gone altogether.
Like the 12 pay we just looked at,
the guaranteed rate is 3%.
So all I know when I'm designing this
is that I need a death benefit
of about $1,500,000
in order to prevent the MEC.
So what we could do in this particular case
is execute a reduced paid up in year 11
and when we executed it,
the death benefit did drop.
One went from 1.7 to about 1.55,
1.56, that's higher than 1.5.
So we did not trigger a MEC.
However, if we were to look at the guaranteed values,
we would trigger a MEC there.
That's the kind of stuff we want to look at
and really make sure that we've got awareness
before starting a policy.
Very, very important there.
But in this example,
we're good and my opinion is,
we would be likely fine
if we followed through with the strategy
and funding with a major mutual company.
We should be good there.
So let's look at a quick side-by-side here.
Beginning with the whole life 100 product option,
which by the way,
was the initial option he looked at
and what he was interested in.
But then it was one of those situations
where I said, hey this is a good option.
But by the way,
what I might consider
is perhaps options B or C,
which you've got the same funding,
but here we've got the same company,
just a different product.
And then also a different company
with a different product over here
with a bit more PUA flexibility
with how Guardian works.
But just different options
because in his position,
he has discussed the cash value a couple of times.
That's important to him
and maximizing that.
And discussing the guaranteed values
and non-guaranteed values,
he likes the major mutual companies,
he has some existing
whole life insurance policies.
He did not start them with us,
this was years ago,
but he does track the performance.
Meaning he looks at what was illustrated,
then he looks at what his cash value
actually appreciates to each year.
This way he can see,
is one company performing better than another
based on what I actually have
and what I actually pay in.
And he has noticed a trend
with different companies and such.
But anyway,
the trend is consistent
with what we often talk about.
But here we go,
the whole life 100 breaks even when?
Between 5 and 6,
how about the 12 pay?
Between 5 and 6,
there's not much difference there, is there?
In the first year there is,
how about by year 6?
No, you've got 611 with one
and 610 with the other.
There's about a $1,000 difference.
If you look at year 10,
is there much of a difference?
Not really.
When you'll see it start to pull away,
it's after year 12.
The reason why,
is because you still have that premium due,
years 8 through 12 in this example,
whereas over here,
you've got it due all the way through age 100.
So once that's gone here,
what happens?
Well, I like to explain it as,
there's less drag on the policy,
the cash value can pick up the pace
and the death benefit will naturally do the same.
So what you'll notice here as time passes,
this death benefit,
the whole life 100 is higher,
but as we get close to the end,
in our mid 80s and 90s,
you'll notice the 12 pay is stronger across the board.
Look at 85, very close.
You've got more cash value,
close to $100,000 more.
You've got about $70,000 less in death benefit
or about $60,000 less.
At 90, what's happened?
Stronger on both sides with the 12 pay.
Again, that's the same company there,
looking at the non-guarantees.
Then we've got the Guardian option,
which starts out with that level death benefit of 1.7.
So it starts out a bit higher than the 12 pay.
He also has flexibility.
What I mean is he can commit to the minimum premium only.
It's about $10,000 per year
when you look at the premium and the term.
And then he can add additional funds
to the product at his discretion.
So if this is you,
what it means you can do
is instead of being billed for $100,000 every year,
it can be billed for $10,000
and then add the rest at your discretion.
The other 90, you could just throw it into the policy.
Very flexible there.
And also, we executed that reduced paid-up
after year 11.
So what we can look at here,
some IRRs.
Check that out.
After year 12,
see that little jump in performance, right?
With that 12 pay.
You'll notice it over here,
year 8 after the funding,
then you'll see another slight jump
year 10 to 11 when we execute that reduced paid-up.
Point is,
really what we're looking to do here
is maximize the overall value.
The husband is an engineer,
very, very technical individual.
The wife's a physician,
had a lot of questions.
She's been doing a lot of research on her own.
But really, when we're examining the policy,
she had more high-level questions
from a planning perspective,
what she wanted to do,
the cash value and death benefit long-term,
wanted to set it up
with the proper trusts and such.
And then he really dove into the numbers
and said, okay,
in my analysis,
looking at these different products,
here's the option I really like
or here's what I'm gravitating toward.
What can we do to tweak this a little bit
or can anything be done to tweak this?
And when we do make it tweakable,
what we're looking to do
is typically set the policy up
identical from the get-go.
So you can make those tweaks and adjustments
after you start a policy.
This way, you don't have to feel
like you've got to get everything
right from the get-go
because there are many changes
you can make after starting.
So I hope you enjoyed this video.
In our next video,
we will look at case study number 2,
which is based on the same 60-year-old couple,
but a larger dollar amount
specifically for an estate planning case.
So if you did enjoy this,
please hit the like button,
subscribe for more.
And as always, I hope this helps.
Thanks so much.
Hey guys, Steve Parisi here.
If you enjoyed the content
you just saw,
please subscribe, like,
and hit the notification bell
for future videos.
If you'd like more information
or to see some custom policies for yourself,
feel free to call or email our offices
at the contact information below.
