There Are Too Many Kinds of Trash Cans

Daily lifeDaily life
1 follower
The other day I needed a new trash can, an easy enough purchase, I thought.
I went to Walmart's website looking to see what trash cans were in stock at my local
store.
I figured I could avoid buying a big huge box and packaging if I purchased locally and
just picked it up.
I noticed there were a handful to choose from.
Some had automatic openers, I didn't want that, too tricky with kids.
Some were a little too plastic looking to be in my kitchen.
Some seemed unreasonably expensive.
But then some of the other ones looked good, had bad reviews.
And then, 45 minutes later, I was cross-comparing trash cans and had read countless reviews
of various ones.
How did this happen?
It's a trash can.
How have we complicated something as simple as buying a trash can?
I wanted to know more.
Somewhere along the line, buying things stopped being about getting what worked and started
being about what's optimal, what's the best one.
It's no longer enough for something to just do the job.
We want the best value, the best design, the highest review, the most sustainable.
We want people to walk into our kitchens and go, oh my god, that is a nice trash can.
Did you see that trash can?
The fact that it is stainless steel, she obviously cares a lot about design.
That is not a trash can that you just buy on accident.
She clearly researched this.
She thought it through.
I bet she's the kind of person that has every aspect of her life organized.
I bet she's one of those people with those perfect pantries.
A perfectly organized pantry to match her perfect trash can.
I bet she never shoves down trash to make it fit.
She probably takes it out every night.
Of course she does.
Oh, look at that trash can.
I am suddenly very aware of my own trash can and how inferior it compares to that trash
can.
You know.
You know that sounds a little silly, but it's also a little bit true.
We buy things because we want the best and a little because we want people to be impressed
by the best that we bought.
The point is that even trash cans can say something about us.
And so when we shop, we're not just looking for the best value and the most functional.
No, no.
We are considering the best design, the one with good reviews, the longest lasting option,
how that product makes us look, the brand that made it, the story of the people who
started the company.
And if you still think I'm crazy, just consider the water bottle industry.
I mean, guys, it's a water bottle.
It's a vessel that holds water, and yet there is an entire culture around them.
They are accessories and status symbols depending on which one you have.
They have new color releases, holiday editions.
Your water bottle says something about you.
And once you realize there is a best when it comes to buying anything, choosing anything
else starts to feel like a mistake.
So instead of asking, will this one work?
We ask, what if there's a better one?
Good Enough stops feeling responsible and starts to feel a little bit lazy.
The problem is, there are endless amounts of anything online, from water bottles to
trash cans.
You could spend hours shopping and comparing, and there would still be more trash cans and
water bottles to choose from.
It never really ends.
And every time you find one, there's these little caveats built in to make you second
guess your choice.
You find a product that seems good, but it's not like being at the store where you can
be like, okay, looks good, and put it in your cart.
Next to the product, there are these little stars, reviews.
Curiosity killed the cat, but gosh darn it, you need to know what other people said about
this trash can.
Now, reviews are meant to help us, to give us an idea of what other people thought so
that we can know that we're spending our money well.
We're not wasting it on inferior trash cans.
One person says it's great, another says it'll do the job.
One person says it cracked in the first month, and the other doesn't like the lid design.
This person's mad because the FedEx delivery guy wasn't friendly.
Someone else says it is the best trash can he's ever had, and then someone else thinks
this is where she's supposed to leave the review for the air fryer that she just bought.
This was supposed to help me make the right choice, but now I'm just confused about a
bunch of other people's opinions, and now I'm double-guessing all of my choices about
the vessel that I'm going to throw trash into.
Now, I have four kids, and we had names picked out for all my kids before they were born,
but we didn't tell anyone else the names until the child was born, and that's because naming
kids is hard.
And we knew if we settled on a name between the two of us, then to let in other people's
opinions would leave us double-guessing ourselves, rethinking the name that we thought that we
liked, questioning our choices.
Reviews are like that.
But nearly all consumers are reading reviews before they buy something.
Most studies show that about 95% of people will read online reviews before they make
purchases, even on everyday items.
Some people read multiple review sites and countless individual reviews before buying
something, which allots to consuming a lot of extra cognitive load just to be sure that
their choice is the right choice.
Now, listen, I get it.
It makes sense to read through some reviews and insights if you're buying something big
or, like, expensive, like a new camera or a stereo system or a projector or you're,
like, booking a hotel.
But we're reading the reviews of everything, from laundry detergent to barbecue sauce to
trash cans, all for the fear of choosing wrong, and that's because the internet has taught
us that there is a right answer.
You just have to find it.
Before you used to pick from what was available.
You bought the thing and the decision ended there.
Now, every purchase comes with rankings, best-of lists, side-by-side comparison.
I mean, a simple Google search shows me endless side-by-side reviews of the best trash can.
I mean, pages of this.
There are whole videos comparing the best trash cans on the market, like more than one,
which I feel like is the maximum amount of videos that I need on trash can comparisons.
And everyone is weighing in, from the New York Times to the Spruce to Bon Appetit.
Good Housekeeping even says their reviews are from experts.
Experts at what, exactly?
I'm not sure.
Throwing away trash?
And they say that the best overall is the Simple Human Rectangular Trash Cans.
Listen, I don't doubt that this trash can is nice.
I mean, for $110, it better be.
It better throw away the trash for me, honestly.
A simple search of this trash can sees that it has a 4.7-star rating.
I mean, what about a trash can means that it should be 4.7 stars?
I need to know more.
This person says, great.
I wish it was heavier.
I can move when you press the bottom.
Beautiful but delicate.
I don't know how I feel about a delicate trash can.
Spacious.
It holds more with no can liner.
I'm not sure about that, Marie, if I would be...
I feel like the can liner is kind of integral for a trash can to work, but that's fine.
Nice design.
Very functional.
Would recommend.
Love our new white trash garbage.
We are not folks to spend this money on a trash can.
We do for a simple human.
Totally worth it.
Silent and perfect.
I mean, that's a review that makes me want to buy this.
Within three days of getting this trash can out of the box,
it started squeaking every time we stepped on the barred throwaway trash.
I don't want that.
I love my new wastebasket.
Never thought I'd buy a $100 trash can, but it was worth every penny.
This one says, sleek and sexy.
I don't know.
Did the trash can write this review?
And now you can see how easy this game is.
I'm no longer looking for a trash can.
Now I will double guess any trash can purchase against this one.
The alleged best trash can.
The point is, when there's always a best choice,
buying something as simple as a garlic press or a pillowcase gets these weirdly high stakes.
And that's why buying things online isn't really fun anymore.
So I was telling my husband about this video the other day.
We were getting ready for bed and I was like, I'm working on this really great video.
It's about how there's too many trash cans.
And he was like, how are you going to make an entire video about that?
And you, dear viewer, may be asking yourself the same question.
I mean, how far are we into this video?
Maybe five, eight minutes.
And I still have a lot to say.
Online shopping has changed what our brains get rewarded for.
The satisfaction doesn't really come from owning the thing.
It comes from the search.
Comparing options, reading reviews, narrowing it down.
Feeling like you're getting closer to the right choice.
Studies on how dopamine neurons fire reveal that they're actually becoming active before
a reward and they guide decisions based on whether something might turn out better than
expected.
In other words, dopamine isn't just about pleasure.
It's about craving, anticipation, and the possibility of something better.
And that's exactly what happens when we scroll online.
Comparing options and hunting for the right one.
The brain treats the search itself like a reward task.
Releasing dopamine as we get closer to what we think might be the right choice.
But an interesting thing about this chase, about finding the best one, is that once the
decision is made, once you hit checkout, that good feeling drops off real fast.
The package arrives and it's fine.
It's a trash can.
And it's because the real excitement and rush and dopamine spike was never about the trash
can.
It was about the chase of it.
Which, honestly, we can agree seems silly when we step back and really think about it.
Like, why do we care so much about the best one?
It's because the internet offers infinite options, so the chase never really ends.
Psychologists have long studied what's called the paradox of choice.
The paradox of choice comes from psychologist Barry Schwartz, and the core idea is pretty
simple.
More options don't make us happier.
They often make us more anxious, less satisfied, and more regretful.
Our brains are really good at choosing between a few options.
They are bad at choosing between dozens or hundreds.
Classic research in cognitive psychology, which is often associated with George Miller,
shows us that working memory can handle roughly four to seven pieces of information at a time.
And more recent research suggests that it's probably closer to four when things are complex.
So if there are three trash cans, you know what?
Actually, I need a break from trash cans.
So, um, I don't know, let's say, like, Bluetooth speakers, okay?
If there are three Bluetooth speakers, your brain can compare them directly.
But if you have eight or ten or thirty Bluetooth speakers, your brain can't hold them all.
So it starts cycling, forgetting, rechecking, and re-evaluating.
Your brain stays in this evaluation mode longer than it's really designed to.
When you have endless supply of Bluetooth speakers available on the internet, which
I am certain it is an endless amount now, I mean, a quick search of Bluetooth speakers
will have your head spinning.
Side note, remember when you used to Google things and it would tell you, like, how many
links that search returned?
It would say, like, there's 1.3 million results on this search.
They don't even do that anymore.
It's just because there's just too much content out there now.
So when you search for a Bluetooth speaker online, your brain knows that there's no way
it saw everything.
What if there was a better choice?
I wish I had gotten a different one.
Research consistently shows that people with more choices report less satisfaction and
more regret afterward, even when the outcomes are objectively pretty good.
Now, for most of human history, choice looked very different than it does today.
From an evolutionary standpoint, for most of existence, options were pretty limited,
right?
You, like, ate what was available.
You used what you had.
In some cases, you had a couple of things to choose from, but it was, like, a small
number, very clear, visible alternatives.
Even just 20 years ago, we mostly shopped in stores.
And you would go into a store and you would have a natural stopping point of what's
available on the shelf.
Tools didn't change every year.
Products didn't have endless versions and new color drops in holiday releases.
Once a decision was made, it tended to stay made.
Decisions had a clear stopping point.
You choose, you act it, and your brain moved on.
And once the action was taken, your brain would need to disengage from it.
So its attention could return to, well, like, survival.
Cognitive scientists describe this as a closed decision loop.
Your brain essentially doesn't like loose ends or getting hung up in one decision for
a long time.
And that's not because your brain is dramatic.
I mean, sometimes it's a little dramatic.
But it's because constantly thinking about something uses a ton of energy.
So your brain is wired to close the loop and move on.
That's what our brain was evolved for.
Short decision loops with a clear done signal.
But the internet breaks all of this.
Online, choice is infinite.
There is always another option, another review, another comparison, another best of list.
There are no boundaries, no shelf limits, no closing time.
So your brain really never checks something off as done and moves on.
It just registers it as this could be better still, tasks still open.
And so basically, the mental system that once helped us stay alive now keeps us stuck comparing
trash cans and Bluetooth speakers at 11 p.m.
Over the last 20 years, retail hasn't just grown.
It has fundamentally changed buying.
In the early 2000s, shopping was limited, right, to the physical space.
But online retail has removed those limits completely.
Digital shelves go on forever.
And instead of choosing between a handful of options, we are faced with hundreds of
nearly identical products that differ only slightly in price and branding or features
or whatever.
Then add in global manufacturing, white label production, and fast copy cycles.
Think fast fashion.
It means that as soon as a product succeeds, dozens, if not hundreds of lookalikes appear
almost immediately.
And because the shopping algorithms tend to reward speed and low price rather than actual
quality or originality, the imitations surface really quickly and really aggressively.
Original ideas plummet.
Again, the internet is not designed for you to find the best.
It's designed to keep you double-guessing and staying on the platforms.
And while this has driven prices down, it's also made shopping feel riskier, right?
We now have to question the safety, the quality, the authenticity of the products we're getting
in ways that just weren't common 20 years ago.
And thus, again, we are left constantly double-guessing every single choice and purchase.
The online shopping environment doesn't just let people buy things.
It encourages you to analyze, to evaluate, to compare.
And I think understanding this helps explain why buying online feels so exhausting.
Oh, good.
You're still here.
I ran out and got a coffee.
I hope you don't mind.
I'm not quite finished because I still have a lot of thoughts about this.
Because as I learned all that I've learned so far in making this video,
I was left with a question, kind of opened this can of worms.
And I was like, if online shopping is so exhausting, why do we even do it?
Online shopping is dominant for most people,
with the majority of consumers saying they prefer it for convenience.
But after learning all I've learned, I can't help but wonder, is it really more convenient?
Online shopping is convenient if you're thinking about access, right?
Logistically, you can see more options, compare better prices,
and shop from your bed, which is nice.
Online shopping does feel faster and easier because there's no driving,
no dealing with other people, or wandering aisles looking.
But when you actually count up the time,
online shopping kind of takes up this invisible time that a lot of us overlook
because we're doing it from home, from the comfort of our couch.
We might spend 45 minutes researching reviews,
and let's be honest, often longer than that,
then 10 to 15 minutes comparing, finally deciding,
applying promo codes, and checking out.
Then when the product arrives, it can take 10 to 15 minutes of unpacking the product,
breaking down the boxes, recycling,
figuring out what to do with all of those packing peanuts.
It's easily over an hour of time.
In-store, the same purchase might look like
10 minutes of added driving when you're out doing other errands,
15 minutes in the store,
fewer options means you can make your decision quicker,
and then you can just bring it home without worrying about packaging.
You're done when you leave the store.
And yet, most of us still use online shopping.
Although, I will say, I don't think I'm alone in my skepticism.
A lot of people are starting to not enjoy shopping online as much as we used to.
A very recent study just done in 2025,
more than three quarters of consumers now say that
online shopping feels functional but not fun anymore.
And 29% of people call online shopping a chore.
What I think I have realized is it's because
the internet isn't really designed to help you find what you want
and feel satisfied about it.
Nothing about the internet is designed in a way for you to open your screen,
quickly find the product you need, close it, and move on.
Literally every app and website and device
is designed to keep your attention with clickbait titles,
sidebar ads, pop-ups, quick eye-catching short videos.
The longer you search, the more you scroll.
More helpful content gets served to you,
best-of lists, top 10s, side-by-side charts,
experts weighing in on things that no one really needs an expert for.
I mean, really, a trash can expert?
Online shopping works better the longer you stay undecided,
and that's because your indecision is profitable.
We are surrounded by content designed to keep us almost confident,
but never quite done, just informed enough to keep going,
just uncertain enough to click one more link.
There is always a smarter, better choice waiting,
and if you do make a choice, just wait three months
because they'll release a new version that's even better.
Oh, oh my god.
I didn't think anyone would still be here.
Yeah, so anyways, at this point in the video,
I kind of just start spiraling.
I'm like, why do we even care?
What's our obsession with having the best?
What is it that keeps us scrolling forever,
trying to find the best of something?
You know, why can't we just move on?
At a basic level, our brains are built to compare and optimize.
Our brains are wired to seek improvement.
If we want to go back to the evolutionary standpoint,
I bet you didn't know that shopping for trash cans
had so much to do with your caveman ancestors, did you?
Typically, choosing the better option, a sharper tool,
a safer shelter, a more reliable resource matters.
In some points in our history, these choices were life or death.
Imagine if buying a trash can was life or death.
Our brain evolved to pursue advantage when it was available.
The problem is that for most of human history,
better was pretty obvious.
Today, the internet presents better everywhere, all the time,
and there's always more of it, endless betters,
to create the illusion that there is a single correct answer.
And of course, the status singling.
When you have the best, or allegedly the best,
it communicates our taste or our success.
As humans, we love to use possessions to reinforce the story
that we tell ourselves about who we are.
I am someone who buys nice trash cans.
It seems ridiculous, I know, when you put it that way,
but you know you've done this with something.
And I think one of the most interesting bits,
and then I promise that I'm going to wrap this up,
is that how online shopping has kind of removed
the specialness of things.
So not too long ago, I was doing my holiday shopping,
as I'm sure many of you were,
and I was in a store looking at some options,
and I realized that none of them felt special or good enough.
And then it hit me that this was kind of a newer feeling
when shopping.
When I used to do Christmas shopping 15 years ago,
I would head to the mall,
maybe hit up HomeGoods and Target,
buy my presents and be done.
But the internet made it so that we can find
the perfect gift every time,
so now that's the baseline.
In the past, we might gift someone a new hat,
or a nice casserole dish,
or an ornament that we saw,
and we thought of them, and so we bought it.
But now it has to be the best casserole dish
that's new and trending,
and came from some high-end brand.
You have to spend two hours finding
that just right ornament.
And I realized it made Christmas shopping less fun,
less special.
When I used to wander the aisles looking for something
that would make me think of my dad or my friend,
now I can spend countless hours cross-referencing,
watching comparison videos,
scrolling infinite gift guides,
looking for the best, best, best of everything.
Somewhere along the way,
we have optimized our life to the point
that we've lost the simple enjoyments.
We can be more productive, more efficient,
more effective, get better results,
higher quality product,
and that optimization feels logical, right?
Neurologically, our brain likes forward motion.
Progress and improvement triggers dopamine,
and optimization creates endless progress signals
to our brain.
There's always a faster method,
better tool, or smarter product choice.
Algorithms, platforms, and systems benefit
when we keep refining, searching, and comparing.
So optimization keeps us engaged longer,
and it feels responsible,
but it's also extremely profitable.
Over time, this trains us to believe
that stopping early is careless,
and that the best choice is always just
one more click away.
But the problem is that always trying to get the best
has no natural stopping point.
You'll always chase it,
and that's why the real counterculture move today
isn't about finding the best,
or the most novel, or the most aesthetic,
or the one that says you're smart,
and savvy, and trendy.
It's deciding when good enough is enough.
And that's why intentional living, at least for me,
isn't about finding better systems or smarter strategies.
It's about deciding where I'm willing to stop.
Not everything needs to be optimized or the best.
Not every purchase needs to be researched to death.
Some decisions are allowed to be boring and done.
And that's what intentional living looks like
in an environment that constantly asks us to care more.
It's choosing, on purpose, where our attention stops.
Peace isn't going to come from the perfect choice.
It's going to come from deciding which choices
simply don't matter enough to keep thinking about them.
Because we're not spending our money only.
We're also spending our attention, our energy, and our time.
And I'd honestly rather save those
than find the perfect trash can.
Holy cow, I honestly thought I was never gonna stop talking,
but we have made it to the end of the video.
And in case you were wondering after all of this
what trash can I got,
I will give you a little treat for making it to the very end.
This is the trash can that we ended up with.
I ended up going for the cheaper one with not as good reviews.
And honestly, it works fine.
As always, I hope that you're having a fantastic day.
Remember to be kind to yourself and others.
And I will see you all in my next video.
