The real estate market downturn is expanding every single month, and the data is now flashing warnings that most of the media and industry won’t talk about.
In this video, I break down why home prices are already worse than 2008 in one critical metric, how affordability has completely broken, and why more markets are starting to roll over, not just Florida and Texas.
We’re now seeing:
House payments at nearly 40% of median income
Prices needing to fall 30–40% to restore affordability
Inventory quietly stacking especially in Sunbelt markets Builders slashing prices and buyers still backing away
A growing stalemate between locked-in sellers and priced-out buyers
This is not a cooling market. This is a down cycle, driven by speculation, affordability pressure, and changing migration trends.
If you’re a buyer, seller, or investor, this is information you need to see before making a move.
Read my Substack for what I can’t say here: jonbrooks.substack.com
The real estate market downturn is expanding
every single month across the country
as more counties go down in price.
Let's dig into what is going on
and what is causing this across the board
so you can make the best decision for you and your family
and your real estate investments.
Now, this is the key chart that we really wanna dig into.
This comes from ReVenture Consulting.
This is house payments as a percentage of median income.
Now, there's something called the rule of 28%,
which is basically saying this is the standard.
We don't wanna spend more than 28% of your median income
on your household payments.
Well, right now, we are all the way at this next peak
in 2024 of 39.4% over here.
The first bubble that we had in 2008 was a 38.1%.
So when we're looking at house payments
as a relative indicator to median income,
we're already past these levels
of the great financial crisis
in the bubble that we had in that time period.
For us to get back to this 28% rule,
we need to see prices come down 30 to 40%.
Now, my personal investment models show
that we need to see prices come down between 31 and 42%
for financial investments in real estate
at the values that they are today
to make sense to buy and hold a real estate asset.
This is important because there is a backstop
to real estate where prices come down.
If rents stay at a certain point,
it makes sense for us to continue purchasing real estate
at that price.
Of course, that also depends
on where mortgage interest rates are,
which is the major factor
that's caused both of these housing bubbles.
Housing bubble number one was just obviously Ninja Loans,
just giving loans to everybody humanly possible.
Housing bubble, and that started with Greenspan,
expanding homeownership, et cetera, et cetera.
We all know the story there.
This housing bubble was just completely caused
by 2020 time period and the zero interest rate policy
that the Fed adopted,
which just caused people to rush into the market,
not only institutional investors,
but mom and pops to go out there
and gobble up three, four, or five properties,
including Airbnbs and all these speculative investments
that they thought the market would continue forever.
Well, now we're starting to see
that this market has stalled out
and that prices are actually starting to come down
across the country in specific areas.
So this is a great chart as well
to just show more cyclically
what is happening with US home prices.
These are inflation adjusted home prices.
You can see the 2006 bubble,
and now we're in the 2005 bubble,
which on an inflation adjusted basis,
we are way beyond, again,
the peak of the 2006, 2007 time period.
This is what is causing the affordability crisis
and locking out the next generation
from their ability to be able to purchase a home.
But not every market is reacting exactly the same.
Why?
Because real estate is regional and it is also micro.
The areas that saw the largest levels of speculation
are the ones that we are starting to see
the market continue to move down.
We're also seeing migration patterns
abruptly change directions,
which caught a lot of homebuilders off guard,
and now we're basically seeing the homebuilders suffer
and just slashing their prices on their properties
to get them sold and get out of their positions
because they thought that migration
would continue to move forward.
So let's see.
We see Austin, Texas, Tampa, Miami, Orlando.
So a lot of Texas, here's Jacksonville, Florida.
That's where I am.
A lot of areas where there was a wild amount
of speculation, institutional investors, mom and pops,
were gobbling up as many starter homes as humanly possible,
jacking up rents for people,
making it really unaffordable.
These are the areas that are now losing prices.
Look at this.
And of course, this is just the average
for that specific city,
but there's specific markets in each city
that are doing much worse than the average.
And I think this is important to mention
because there's areas of Jacksonville
that are only down 5%,
but there's other areas that are down 20%.
So it depends on where you are,
how close you are to new construction
and the amount of multifamily new construction
that's coming onto the market.
Meanwhile, you can see in Connecticut, Ohio,
New York, Illinois, these areas are still appreciating.
They're appreciating about the normalized rate.
We like to say about three to 4%, right?
That's what's traditionally set out there
that real estate appreciates.
However, those are starting to slow as well.
This data comes from Resi Club, Lance Lambert,
from December, 2025.
However, we are still seeing,
I'm talking to top real estate agents across the country.
Yes, they still show on paper that the prices have gone up,
but they're starting to slow
in their acceleration of that appreciation.
So this is another chart that just shows
that real estate is very regional.
You can see here year over year declines in two regions,
which is the South Atlantic
and the West South Central areas.
The Sunbelt areas are the ones that are slowing the most,
but you can also see in the Northeast
and the Pacific areas,
you're starting to see a little bit of an increase
in the Middle Atlantic.
But you see in the United States across the board,
when we just look at everything together,
it shows 1.7% increase from last year.
And the price change from 2023 to 2024 was 4.7.
So we are seeing a deceleration
in home prices across the board.
I actually expect prices to be flat
or negative across the board next year,
slightly negative as the market starts
to continue to move down due to this affordability crisis.
Here's a report comes from the FHFA.
Here's a little segment that they set in here.
So even though we were up year over year,
16 of 20 markets declined month over month in October,
signaling a broad stagnation as high mortgage rates
weigh on affordability and suppress price momentum.
Well, we're at 6.18% in our rates today.
And so that's not a very high interest rate.
If the government doesn't step in,
we could actually see higher rates next year.
However, I fully believe the government will step in,
the Fed will step in and start buying
mortgage-backed securities and treasuries
to do anything that they can
to bring down mortgage interest rates
and continue to push the housing market
because it has such a multiplier effect in the economy.
So here's the chart that shows
where we're starting to see the pain already.
Most of them, six of the top 10
are actually already in Florida.
Home values are falling in 10 major metros.
This is according to realtor.com.
After years of record-breaking appreciation,
the market is starting to come back down to earth
in some areas where houses are beginning to lose value.
Of course, right, markets are cyclical.
They go up, they go down.
I think a lot of people are stuck in their heads
that real estate always goes up 3% to 4% every single year.
That's just not the case.
You saw the chart earlier.
You can see that it's very dynamic
and there are specific markets
that are more boom-bust in nature
because of the speculation in those markets.
That includes right now Florida and Texas,
and Florida's always been a speculative market.
So you can see Northport, Cape Coral, Lakeland.
Let's see, Tampa, Daytona.
These areas are actually starting to see
the year-over-year declines already,
and this data is lagging.
It will take time for the real data to start playing out.
We're likely gonna see more distress
start to show up in Q2, Q3 of next year.
That's where I believe there's going to be
a wave of foreclosures that are a backlog,
hitting the market, especially here in Florida,
that haven't been processed through since 2020.
And obviously, this is a great chart
that also is from Resi Club.
It says, change in metro-level home prices
since each metro's respective peak in 2022, right?
So it was about August to October timeframe
that we had the peak here in Florida for prices,
and then the Fed's raising of the interest rates
obviously moved the market downward
and there was a stop being a relocation
from the Northeast and from the West of Florida,
and now we're actually, according to a new BOA,
B of A article that came out,
their report basically said that we're near net migration
to Florida at this point in time in the marketplace,
and that migration is going to drive buyers.
So if we don't have migration to the area,
then it's gonna be locals who are already priced out
due to affordability.
The inventory continues to stack every single month,
which is causing prices to come down.
So you can see Punta Gorda is basically ground zero.
Cape Coral's down 18%.
Naples is down in Daytona Beach,
and by the way, I still talk to people
and they say, Daytona's a great place.
It's like, it's one of the worst, okay?
So it's very, talking about their investments
and things like that in specific areas,
and perhaps they're doing well
if they bought at the right time,
but if they bought between 2022, 2024,
they're down on their investment in underwater,
and if you include the closing costs
to buy and sell that round-trip cost,
they're down a lot more than they might think.
So this isn't a cooling effect.
This is a down cycle that I believe we're going to see
for the next five to six years here in Florida specifically,
and in the Sunbelt areas,
where there was just a large amount of speculation.
The Northeast, again, is a completely different market.
You look here at Rochester and Milwaukee,
their markets are up since the peak in 2022,
and they just continue to drive forward.
There's people relocating back to those areas.
There's businesses there.
They did not overbuild,
and there was not wild speculation in those areas.
So that is why they're not seeing
what we're seeing here in the Sunbelt.
And of course, this is a chart that came out from Compass.
This shows Florida inventory is headed lower.
Well, of course, during the end of the year,
inventory heads lower,
and there's two factors that are coming in.
One is seasonality.
This is typically what happens towards the end of the year.
You can actually see it right here.
In the prior year, it kind of dips a little bit, right?
That is totally normal.
However, the phenomenon, while you might see this as,
oh, this is a good thing for Florida,
we're seeing all this inventory come down.
That must mean things are starting to get better.
It's not.
It's actually the opposite.
The reason why is because there's pent-up supply.
Sellers are listing their house.
They're not getting the price that they want,
and then they're getting upset,
and they're rage-quitting the listing,
taking it off the market,
and they're hoping that they can get
a higher price next year.
This is unlikely to happen
as more and more inventory comes on.
The houses are sitting longer.
The demand is waning,
and affordability is only getting slightly better
just because people are starting to slash their prices.
So I don't think this is a good indicator.
On the ground, we're seeing a very high level
of expired listings,
a very high level of withdrawn listings,
and we expect this inventory
to come back on the market in the spring.
Probably February, March, and April of next year,
we're gonna see a rapid amount of supply
come on the market here in Florida.
And inventory, from the same company, Compass,
they're putting out this forecast.
They're already expecting inventory to move up.
It was 12% increase over the last year
and another 10% increase in 2026,
and this is how real estate inventory stacks up
and we start to see prices come down.
It's not an overnight thing.
You can see the cycle.
Real estate's very cyclical.
And now that we've got this extremely low inventory
that we had in January 2022,
then we had the Fed hike its rates,
and we saw it starting to move up,
and now we're at this period
of we're just gonna continue to see inventory move up
until the government steps in
and tries to lower rates again,
and we might see the inventory
start to level off a little bit.
But they're expecting another 10% increase
over next year.
But ultimately, what's happening right now
is that the U.S. turnover ratio
for the number of homes sold,
there's 27.7 homes sold per 1,000 homes
in the first nine months of this year.
This is one of the lowest levels that we've had in decades,
and this is a big red flag.
Why is this happening?
It's because 70% of homeowners
are locked into these low mortgage rates
that they refinanced or purchased
in the 2020, 2021 time period,
and fewer selling
because they don't wanna lose that interest rates,
and the next buyers can't buy
because they can't do it at these prices
and at these rates that we have today.
So it's just a stalemate that's happening
between the buyers and the sellers,
and we expect the stalemate to continue.
That being said, one side will give up,
and it's gonna have to be the sellers at this point
because of the amount of inventory that's coming on
and the demand from the buyers.
So prices will start to come down across the board,
not just in the Sunbelt areas,
but in the Northeast and these other areas.
The prices will start to decelerate,
and then eventually they'll go negative
over the next couple of years.
That's my projection.
The magnitude and timing and direction of these
are very hard to calculate.
I'm not gonna guess.
I'm just telling you directionally
what I believe is going to happen in the future.
When the fear sets in in the marketplace
and people no longer think it's a good time to buy,
then it gets across the country and feels that way.
That's when things will really start to accelerate.
And people are already starting
to go underwater in their houses.
You can see this is from Google search.
People just searching help with mortgage.
It's above the 2008 level already,
which is crazy because there's a record amount
of equity in people's houses.
But the problem is the people who bought
put 3.5%, 0% down, FHA, VA,
low percentage down for conventional
during these boom years, 2022, 2021,
and we're basically going back to 2019 levels of pricing.
And so people are starting to go underwater already,
which is a big red flag.
But the reality is Housing Wire is pitching
that there's still a shortage of supply of housing to,
obviously they're incentivized to pitch this narrative
to us because there are so many builders
and title companies and everybody who sponsor their business
and that's how they make money from these sponsors.
So just be aware that you're gonna continue
to hear this narrative that there's a housing supply
shortage and they're going to continue
to push this across the board.
Just be careful who it's written by
and why it's being written for you
because they're, again, trying to get this narrative
that there's just not enough inventory
so you'll continue to buy.
But the reality is that new construction inventory
is stacking, we're already at 2009 levels,
the highest level of completed unsold homes
since July 2009, and this is a huge red flag
as this inventory continues to stack very quickly
in a short period of time.
Look at how fast it's moving up,
just the same way it did last time.
And so for people to say, hey, the market's still healthy,
everything's great, and then you still look at this chart,
obviously that is a massive red flag
just staring us in the face.
And imagine being that buyer who bought a Lenar home
for half a million dollars in 2022.
I mean, this is an insane number.
The average selling price has dropped from 511
all the way to 375, more than a 22% decline.
And the new orders have moved up, obviously,
because once they reduce the price,
people are saying, okay, you're gonna reduce the price,
you're gonna buy down my interest rate,
and they're preferring this to existing homes.
But I mean, honestly, the quality that we see locally
of the Lenar homes is just not something
we would ever want to be involved with.
It's not looking good in that regard.
And there's tons of lawsuits that might be filed
in the future for these builds that they slapped up
in a record period of time.
So we're starting to see this drastic drop in price,
and that's impacting all of the properties
around these new construction communities.
And the people who bought in the first phase,
and there's multiple phases,
the first phase people are immediately underwater
when they purchase those homes.
So yes, you do get the low rate,
but then generally you're immediately underwater
if you don't put a large percentage down.
And the labor market is starting to crack.
You can see a deceleration in the labor market
for the amount of hiring.
This is a change in ADP, private employment.
We see this across the board.
We're already at great financial levels
of layoffs announced, and so we're likely
to see some distress coming into next year
if the labor market continues to crack.
That will be the number one thing
that will crack the housing market.
So I'd love to hear what you're seeing.
Will, do you think that the downturns
will spread to other markets?
Do you think now is a good time to buy?
I'd love to hear what you think and what you're seeing.
Drop a comment of where you're located
and what you're seeing on the ground.
I'm always learning from the people across the country,
top agents across the country,
and if you need a top agent for your market, let me know.
I'm in touch with many of them,
and we talk every single day.
People are reporting, hey, this is what we're seeing.
This is an example of what we're seeing.
We're seeing more short sales.
We're seeing more foreclosures spike,
and they're describing what's happening,
and then in the Northeast, we're hearing some people say,
hey, it's been good for the last year,
but we're really starting to slow.
I think the affordability is finally catching on
with the buyers here locally,
and relocations are slowing and things like that.
So love to hear what you're seeing on the ground.
You know, again, I don't trust the media across the board.
Sometimes the data is lagged,
so you're not getting a full picture of what's going on,
and things can change pretty rapidly
in the real estate market, as we've already seen
just in the past three years
with the amount of supply that's come onto the market.
As always, if you wanna follow me on Substack,
look for my link below.
You can subscribe and get an update
two to three times per week of what's going on.
I also post all these charts on X.
You can follow me, at John Brooks.
Would love to connect with you,
and people are already 7 million views there
in just the last 30 days,
so thank you guys for following there.
As always, thank you for watching,
and I will be in touch next week.
See you later.