Why The Buddha Was The World's First True Scientist?

People & Faith
22 followers
1 Video View·Jan 6, 2026
Why the Buddha was the world's first true scientist.
When you meditate, whether you realize it or not,
you're actually making some assumptions.
That the mind can be trained,
that your actions can actually make a difference,
and that it's worthwhile to train the mind
because the mind is what determines
what actions you're going to take.
You're also assuming that there's a pattern
to the way action plays itself out.
Certain actions are going to be skillful.
In other words, they lead to good results.
Other actions are not.
They're going to lead to suffering, to harm.
If there were no pattern,
the things you learn today wouldn't be applicable tomorrow.
You'd never know.
Meditation, trying to learn any skill,
would be a waste of time
because the rules could change at a moment's notice.
And if your actions didn't make a difference,
why are you sitting here?
The simple fact that you're here meditating,
trying to train the mind,
means that, at least on one level,
you accept these ideas as assumptions.
It's like scientists.
Sometimes people believe science doesn't make assumptions
that it doesn't accept anything that hasn't been proven.
But that's not really the case.
Scientists work with lots of assumptions.
One, if you're going to run an experiment,
you have to assume that some things cause other things,
and that by changing A, you may change B.
In other words, you assume
that there are actual causal connections in the world.
In fact, that's what you're looking for,
to see precisely what those connections are.
You also assume that the way you design
and run the experiment will make the difference
between whether it's a good experiment or a bad one.
You're assuming that people, you and other scientists,
are responsible for their actions,
and they can make choices
as they design and run their experiments.
Some forms of scientific knowledge like to claim
that everything in the universe
is predetermined by past causes,
but the activity of science itself assumes free will.
If people couldn't make choices,
there'd be no sense in criticizing someone
whose experiment was poorly designed,
or accepting the results of someone
whose experiment was well-designed.
It would all be very arbitrary,
and both sides could simply say,
well, I was predetermined to do it that way.
That would let them off the hook.
You're also assuming that some patterns are universal.
The science of meditation.
I was reading recently about experiments
indicating that some of the constants they use
in order to calculate the size
and the history of the universe
seem to be different in one direction
from what they are in another.
That's kind of scary.
Scientists like to think that the laws of physics
are the same everywhere.
That's one of their basic assumptions.
But this experiment calls that into question.
So there are a lot of assumptions you make
simply by the fact that you act.
Try to be aware of these assumptions,
because we're going to be exploring them in the meditation.
Meditation actually puts them to the test
for a particular purpose,
which is to put an end to suffering.
You need to train the mind.
You need to experiment.
Now, experimenting doesn't mean
simply following some rules.
It means having a control and changing other things,
manipulating them,
and seeing if your manipulation makes a difference
as measured against the control.
You could sit and watch a process
for years and years and years,
but if you didn't do anything to the process,
you wouldn't really know what the causal patterns are.
You might think you see some patterns,
but you can't really check them
unless you've manipulated the causes
and seen if the manipulation
makes any difference in the effects.
There's an old Thai joke about the farmer
who went into a town for the first time in his life.
He saw a flashing neon sign.
It so happened that he saw the sign when the light was on.
He walked up to it and tried to blow it out.
He blew on it, and sure enough,
the light happened to go out,
so he assumed that he had blown it out.
Of course, the way you check for that
is to see if the sign comes back on again
and then see if it goes out on its own
without your blowing on it,
or if it goes out every time you blow on it.
You've gotta check things again and again and again,
trying different approaches.
This is particularly important
as you try to get the mind to settle down.
What's going to work?
What's not going to work?
Sometimes it's a fluke.
You're sitting here and all of a sudden,
everything just comes together,
but you've got to figure out why.
Otherwise, it's not going to come together again
and you won't know what to do.
It's not just a matter of accepting that,
well, sometimes the mind comes together
and sometimes it doesn't.
The coming together, as the Buddha said,
is something you want to develop.
You work on it.
You bring it into being.
That's what bhavana, the Pali word for meditation, means.
You bring things into being.
You develop them.
You work on your concentration.
You see what you can do to make those moments
of concentration more frequent and longer lasting.
You've got to experiment.
Otherwise, you won't learn anything
about the processes of the mind.
You can see things arise and pass away,
arise and pass away, and that's it.
But the important thing about arising and passing away
is trying to notice what you did
to make these things arise,
particularly unskillful mental states.
What did you do?
And what did you do when they passed away?
When there's suffering, stress,
what did you do to increase the stress?
What did you do when the stress stopped?
Then, once you think you've noticed a connection,
you've got to test it again and again.
Ajahn Phuong wasn't interested in hearing
about things happening in your meditation
until they had happened at least two times.
In other words, he wanted you to gain
a certain amount of mastery over your meditation
so that you could bring these states of mind
into being at will.
If they were just flukes, he wasn't interested.
So it's important to be clear on our assumptions
as we meditate here.
The idea that we're simply going to watch things
and that objective truth is going to appear
when we're very non-interfering.
You've got to call that idea into question
because the truth may be appearing,
but how are you going to know what's connected with what?
After all, causation is the basic issue of right view.
Right view is not about inconstancy,
stress, not self.
Those are the three characteristics
or the three perceptions for developing dispassion.
Right view has a larger framework.
It's all about the four noble truths.
You're looking for the stress,
trying to comprehend it until you can understand the cause.
When you see the cause, you abandon it.
The causal connection is what's important there.
Similarly with the path.
The path doesn't cause the end of suffering,
but it takes you there.
The image of the path is like a road going to a mountain.
The road doesn't cause the mountain
and the fact that you follow the road
doesn't cause the mountain,
but by following the road, you get there.
There's a connection between the action
and the point where it leads.
We're assuming that there's a pattern here.
Otherwise, what the Buddha taught 2,600 years ago
wouldn't be relevant anymore.
Things could change at any time,
but if there's going to be a path to the end of suffering
that people can teach to one another,
we have to assume that there's a pattern.
Then, based on that assumption, we experiment.
This is what's scientific about meditation.
We have some of the same assumptions
that a scientist brings to an experiment,
that you have free will,
the ability to choose
how you're going to design your experiment,
and that you have to change things
in order to learn about patterns.
Otherwise, you can go through life
thinking that neon signs are going to stay lit
until you blow on them,
just because one neon sign happened to go out
the one time you blew on it.
You have to try again and again and again
to see what works and what doesn't,
what's connected to what.
That's where insight arises.
And the skill in the meditation
comes from learning how to anticipate
when something is happening that will be skillful or not.
If it's not, what are you going to do to deflect it?
If it is skillful, what are you going to do
to make sure it really does give its results
and that it keeps on giving its results?
The only way you can anticipate these kinds of things
is by going over them again and again and again.
So we try to limit the number of variables here.
You're sitting here with your eyes closed,
focused on the breath.
Well, the mind's going to do a lot of different things
even while you're focused just on the breath.
You have the choice to decide what to do.
You can change the way you breathe.
You can change the way you focus.
Which aspect of the process are you going to focus on?
The Buddha talks about four frames of reference
in establishing mindfulness.
Body, feelings, mind, mental qualities,
all taken in and of themselves.
It's not that they involve doing four different kinds
of meditation exercises.
You stay with the breath, which is an aspect of the body.
Then if you're having trouble staying with the breath,
you look at what other issues might be involved.
Is there something wrong with the feeling
that you're creating with the breath?
Can you change that feeling?
The Buddha recommends breathing in a way
that gives rise to rapture or pleasure.
Do you know how to do that?
That's one aspect of staying with the breath,
but it's connected with feelings too.
Or you may look at the mind state
that you're bringing to the meditation.
Sometimes the mind is sluggish.
Sometimes it's down, depressed,
and you need to do something to give it more energy,
to gladden it, as the Buddha says.
Other times, the mind is bouncing all around
like a ping pong ball.
When that's the case,
what can you do to get it to settle down?
If it's burdened by a particular assumption,
if it's burdened by a particular thought,
what can you do to get it out from under the burden?
That's using the mind as your frame of reference.
You're still there with the breath,
but you're looking at the problem from a different angle,
the angle of how the breath is related to the mind.
Finally, there are dhammas, mental qualities.
This frame of reference gives guidance
for when you see that something keeps pulling you away.
How can you deal with it effectively
so that you don't keep on being distracted by it?
What qualities do you need to let go?
What qualities do you need to develop?
All of these four different frames of reference
deal with different aspects of the problem
of how you stay with the breath.
The skill here is a matter of learning to read the situation
to notice which aspect you have to focus on.
This comes with practice,
and it comes with experimenting, tweaking things.
I think it was Kurt Vonnegut
who compared scientists to little kids,
people who still like to play even as they grow up.
And most of the famous scientists were like that.
They would play with ideas.
They would play with possibilities.
That's how they discovered things
that other people hadn't discovered before
or hadn't even thought of before.
Science is not a body of knowledge.
It's an approach with assumptions.
And meditation is the same.
You could read all the teachings in the canon.
You could read all the teachings of the Ajahns
and be able to repeat them,
but that wouldn't get you awakened.
That's the wrong approach.
What does lead to awakening is taking the Buddha's approach,
which was an experimental approach
based on the assumption
that you can learn from changing your actions.
That's actually two assumptions.
One, you can change your actions.
Two, there are patterns that can be learned in that way.
This is what makes meditation a science.
The clearer you are about the fact that the approach,
this experimental approach,
is going to give you the knowledge,
that's when the knowledge
really will make a huge difference in your mind,
in your life,
in your entire relationship to space and time.
It's that radical.
So be willing to call
some of your other assumptions into question,
especially those that get in the way
of the quest for the end of suffering,
and give this experiment a try.
How and why we meditate.
We start with thoughts of goodwill
to remind ourselves of why we want to meditate.
We want to find a happiness that's reliable,
that doesn't harm us or anybody else.
That's why we spread goodwill
both to ourselves and to all beings,
to remind ourselves that we're looking
for a special kind of happiness.
Then, when we're clear about why we're doing it,
we settle down to business.
Here, the business is watching your breath.
Take a couple of good, long, deep, in and out breaths,
and notice where you feel the breathing in the body.
You feel the passage of air through the nose,
but you also feel the rise and fall of the chest,
sometimes the rise and fall of the abdomen or the shoulders.
Notice where the feeling of breathing is most pronounced.
Allow your attention to settle there and keep it there
all the way through the in breath,
all the way through the out,
and even in the moments between the breaths.
As you breathe in,
notice if there's any unnecessary tension
in that part of the body.
It may be that the breath is too long,
so that as you get toward the end of the breath,
it's beginning to feel uncomfortable.
Well, allow the breath to grow shorter,
or if it's too short and you feel like
you're not really getting the full energy of the breath,
allow it to stretch out a bit.
In other words, experiment with the breathing
to see what feels best.
If you find something that feels good, stick with it.
It may feel good for a long time,
or it may feel good for just a little while,
and then not so good anymore.
In that case, try changing it again.
Try to keep on top of what the body needs.
The purpose here is twofold.
One, to get the mind to settle down in the present moment,
and two, to be observant.
The breath is one of the few bodily functions
that you can actually change consciously,
so try to take advantage of that fact,
both for the settling down and for the being observant.
If the breath feels good and you find it interesting
to notice how the way you breathe
has an impact on how the body feels,
that helps you to stay in the present moment.
You start learning about what the breath is doing,
and as you learn about the breath,
you're going to be able to learn about the mind as well,
because ultimately, the breath is not the problem.
The real problem lies in the mind.
We all want happiness, and yet we choose to do things
that can lead to pain, for ourselves or for other people.
So there's a disconnect.
The question is, where exactly is the disconnect and why?
Sometimes it's because we don't have a very clear knowledge
of what our intentions are,
or it may be because we don't really see the connection
between our actions and their results.
So, starting with the breath, notice what your intention is.
You're here for the sake of happiness.
You're here to learn how to train the mind
so that it doesn't create a lot of problems.
And of course, not every part of your mind
is going to be cooperative.
Some parts are going to wander away with other agendas.
So for the time being, you just let them go.
In other words, you don't have to get entangled with them.
Just notice that there are other thoughts in the mind,
not connected with the breath,
but you don't have to follow them.
That right there is an important insight.
You don't have to run after everything
that comes up in the mind.
Then, stick with the breath as long as you can
and see what impact it has on the mind and on the body.
This is the part of the practice
that requires some conviction.
It's like making scrambled eggs.
The right way to make scrambled eggs
is to keep the heat really low.
You stand there, stirring the eggs in the pan,
and nothing seems to be happening.
You feel a very strong temptation
to turn up the heat to speed things up,
but you have to resist that temptation.
Just keep on stirring and stirring and stirring,
and after a while, the eggs really do begin
to coagulate on the bottom of the pan.
It's in the period when you don't see
any immediate results coming
that you need to have the conviction
that the cookbook was right.
It's the same with the meditation.
There are times when you sit in meditation
and nothing much seems to be happening,
and so you need the conviction to stick with it,
to give it time to do its work.
This is why we have the chants on the Buddha,
the Dhamma, and the Sangha prior to the meditation,
to remind ourselves that this path we're following here
is not a brand new path.
It's not something we just recently cooked up.
In fact, the Buddha himself said he didn't invent the path.
He discovered an old path.
There had been Buddhas before him,
awakened people before him,
and this is the same path they all discovered.
We have all of the Buddha's awakened disciples guarantee
that yes, this path does work, so you just stick with it.
Part of the mind will complain
because of course the mind still has its greed,
aversion, and delusion.
It's not the case that you sit down,
close your eyes, and they all go away.
They hide out for a while,
but they're going to come up again,
and they're going to complain.
They'd rather do this, think that, go here, go there.
Just remind yourself that you've been following greed,
aversion, and delusion for who knows how long.
They do provide some pleasure,
but there's usually a lot of pain
that goes along with that pleasure,
and they leave you holding the bag,
and you've been falling for their tricks
again and again and again.
How about trying something new,
new for you at least, something different?
So you just stick with the breath,
stick with it, stick with it.
As the Buddha said, patient endurance
is what burns away a lot of the issues in the mind.
It doesn't solve all the problems.
The ultimate problems are going to require
very refined discernment.
You develop that discernment
from your right effort as you practice.
So to develop right effort as a beginning step,
you use whatever cruder skills you have at your disposal.
Conviction, patience, your stick-to-itiveness.
Now, that can get very old very quickly
if you don't have something of interest.
That's why we emphasize working with the breath.
When the breath gets comfortable,
the next step is to think of that sense
of comfortable breath spreading through
different parts of the body.
When we talk of breath here, it's not air coming in and out.
It's the movement of energy in the body,
which is what gets the air to come in and out to begin with.
Without that energy, nothing would come in and out at all.
So notice, when you breathe in,
where do you feel the energy flow in the body?
If you're really sensitive,
you find that it goes throughout every nerve in your body,
from the top of the head, down to the feet,
down the shoulders, down the arms,
all through the torso, deep into the head, all around.
There's even an energy that surrounds the body.
So try to make yourself as sensitive as possible
to the energy that's happening right here.
If you can't feel it everywhere,
focus on the areas where you can feel it,
where it's most blatant.
Eventually, as your sensitivity develops,
you'll notice it in areas where you never sensed it before.
You'll start to realize that many of the sensations
you are familiar with are actually breath sensations.
As with any delicate task, this takes time.
But if you have something with which to entertain yourself,
you find it easier to stick with the task.
Here, the entertainment is actually part of the work.
We've talked about working with the breath.
We can also talk about playing with it.
It can actually be fun.
Start noticing that there are spots, say in your spine,
where there's a lot of tension.
But if you consciously relax the tension,
a sense of flow will go through.
It feels a lot more refreshing.
You may find that releasing one spot of tension in the body
has a chain reaction effect,
so that other areas of tension in the body
begin to relax as well.
This is something that's fun to explore.
You may notice that the way you hold your body will change.
When the flow of the breath energy in the body is improved,
this is going to be good for your posture,
good for your health.
This is medicine that doesn't cost you anything at all.
And as for the work, try to spread your awareness
to fill the whole body,
so that eventually you'll be aware of the whole body
all the time through the in-breath,
all the time through the out.
That broadens the range of your awareness,
and you begin to see things happening in the mind
that you didn't see before.
They were hidden in a blind spot
because the range of your awareness was very narrow.
But as you allow the awareness to broaden out,
you begin to see little bits
and snatches of thoughts here and there.
You can catch sight of the mind's decisions.
Usually, in an ordinary mind,
there are several conversations going on at once.
You may be paying attention to one or two,
but there are others going on as well.
Every now and then, you slip in,
add a little something, and then slip right out.
Then you can deny what you just did,
telling yourself that you didn't do
any of that slipping around at all.
This is one of the reasons why we don't see the connection
between our actions and the suffering we cause.
There's a fair amount of denial going on in the mind.
But when your range of awareness is all around like this,
it's harder to maintain that denial.
And it's better for you that you don't.
You can begin to see what's going on,
and you're in a position to do something about it.
Some unskillful thoughts in the mind can hang on
simply because you're not paying attention to them.
When you see them clearly, it's very easy to let them go.
There are others, though,
that are going to require more work.
What the Buddha calls exerting a fabrication,
or fabricating an exertion.
He uses both phrases.
What they both mean is that you have
to do some conscious work in order to understand
why you're stuck on this particular kind of action
or kind of thinking.
Then you make the effort to provide the mind
with an alternative, a more skillful alternative
to the way you've been thinking.
And it turns out that the way you breathe
is very intimately connected with all of this.
It's called bodily fabrication.
As I said, it's one of the few functions in the body
that you can intentionally change.
So you work with that and put it to use.
Suppose that anger comes up in the mind.
One of the first things you can do about it
is to notice where in the body is the tension
that goes along with the anger.
Then try to breathe through it.
Think of the breath energy
as just dissolving that tension away,
allowing it to dissipate out into the air
so you don't have to keep carrying it around.
Or you don't feel burdened with the need
to get it out in your words or your deeds.
As you're working with the breath,
you also become sensitive to two other kinds
of fabrication the Buddha talked about.
One is called verbal fabrication,
which is the way the mind talks to itself.
It directs its thoughts to a particular topic
and then it starts evaluating the topic
and deciding what it likes and what it doesn't like,
what it wants to do and doesn't want to do
with regard to that topic.
When you're working with the breath,
you're engaging in just that kind of verbal fabrication.
You become more conscious of it.
You realize that you can change the way
you talk to yourself about things,
especially when you start getting new perspectives
about what's going on in the present moment
as to what's going on in the mind
and what's going on in the body.
Then there's what the Buddha calls mental fabrication,
which are the perceptions, the labels we apply to things
along with feelings, feeling tones of pleasure, pain,
and neither pleasure nor pain.
And again, as you're working with the breath,
you get hands-on experience
in how you can shape these things
and use them to shape the state of your mind.
When you stick with the breath,
you're also holding a particular perception
of the breath in mind.
If you think of the breath simply as the air coming in
and out of the nose,
that influences how you're going to breathe
and the way you experience the breath.
But if you think about the energy in the body
as being breath,
then it can go anywhere in the nervous system.
It can go through anything at all.
That gives you another perception.
It's going to change the way
you actually experience the breath.
You can start to think
of all those little tiny nerve endings
going all the way out to the pores of your skin.
They've got breath energy too.
If you hold that perception in mind,
how does that change the way you breathe?
How does it change the way you feel in the present moment?
Does it feel more pleasant?
If not, what other perception of breathing
can you think of that would?
So as you focus on working and playing with the breath,
you're getting some conscious experience
in learning how to manipulate what the Buddha calls
bodily fabrication, verbal fabrication,
and mental fabrication
to create a sense of ease within the body and mind.
Then you can use those same fabrications
to deal with whatever else comes up in the mind.
For the time being,
you don't want to get too involved
in analyzing any distracting thoughts.
Work on using these three types of fabrication
to make your concentration as solid as you can.
After a while though,
as you get skilled at these types of fabrication
and you feel solid in the present moment,
you can turn and look
at whatever in the thought seems so attractive.
You can start analyzing the thought
in terms of the three types of fabrication.
How are you breathing in relation to the thought?
What things are you saying to yourself that give rise,
say to greed or aversion or delusion?
What are the perceptions
or mental labels lying behind these thoughts?
And what kind of feelings surround them?
Can you change those things?
Fabricate something different
so that when an incident comes up in your life
that you would normally react to with anger,
can you refabricate your reaction?
Something that would give rise to lust,
can you refabricate that
so that the aversion, the anger,
the lust don't hold any appeal?
Two things help to cut through that appeal.
First, simply having access
to a greater sense of wellbeing
as you work with the breath and play with the breath
gives the mind sense of hunger,
just wanting some action,
wanting some entertainment, less of an edge.
Second, you see that the way you normally react is optional.
It's causing stress that doesn't need to be there.
You see that you're creating an awful lot of the situation
just by the way you're looking at it.
And if it's causing stress,
well, why not look at it in a different way?
Why not breathe around it in a different way?
Perceive it in a different way.
Evaluate it in a different way.
These are some of the lessons you can learn
by working and playing with the breath like this,
allowing the mind to become more firmly settled
in the present and to see things a lot more clearly.
You come to understand this process
of how you fabricate your experience,
and you can use that understanding
to eliminate all the stress
that the fabrication creates for the mind.
This is one of the Buddha's major insights.
There's an analysis of suffering and stress
called dependent co-arising,
which describes all the different factors
that, based on ignorance,
give rise to stress and suffering.
Half of them, including the three types of fabrication,
come prior to sensory contact,
even before you see something or hear something.
The mind is already primed to create suffering out of it
if it's operating under the power of ignorance.
What we're doing here is learning how to bring knowledge
to those processes so that we're no longer priming ourselves
for suffering and stress.
We're priming ourselves to put an end to it,
which is in line with our original intention.
We want to be able to see why the actions we do
for the sake of happiness end up leading to stress
and how we can change those ways
so that we can actually act in a way
that leads to true happiness.
We break things down into very simple components
so that we can manage them.
We realize that this is a problem we can manage.
That's the good news of the Buddha's teachings,
that even though we may be causing ourselves stress
and suffering, we can put an end to it.
If our suffering really were caused by things outside
that were beyond our power, then there'd be no hope.
Or if it were caused by things we were doing
that we couldn't change, there'd be no hope either.
But here we're making choices.
We're probably not making them all that wisely,
but we do have some wisdom.
We do have some discernment.
It's just a matter of applying it,
giving it a foundation here in the present moment,
and then really using it to look carefully to see
where are we creating unnecessary stress
and suffering for ourselves?
What can we do to change?
It's by using our wisdom and discernment
with these basic, immediate things,
exercising them with these questions
that they develop and grow.
When the mind is well-settled and well-centered like this,
it fosters a sense of well-being.
That sense of well-being is important.
If, when you're feeling down on yourself
and you're already feeling uncomfortable inside,
you'll do nothing but criticize yourself,
and that can be a dead end.
But when the mind feels at ease
with a sense of fullness and well-being
here in the present moment,
then you can bring up the fact
that you've got some habits here
that are not all that skillful,
and you're in the mood to tell yourself,
let's do something about them.
The mind is then a lot more willing to listen
and to work on the problem.
So these are our basic skills.
These are our basic components
into which we break things down
so that we can understand
Then the things that we tend to cling to,
the habits we tend to fall into over and over again
that are leading to suffering and stress,
we can take them apart.
We can then put everything back together again
in a better way that turns into a path
that, unlike our normal life,
doesn't just keep going around and around
and around and around in feedback loops.
This is a path that actually goes someplace,
someplace that's really worth going to.
And here again, this is where conviction is important.
The state the Buddha described as health, nibbana,
is something he can't pull out of his heart to show to us.
So we're not in a position
where we can wait to accept things
only when we know them for sure.
We have to bring some conviction to what he says.
On the one hand, we have to take his word for it
when he talks about the kind of commitment it requires.
On the other hand, he doesn't have the role of being a God
who can tell us what we have to do,
but he does say he's an expert in putting an end to suffering.
That requires some conviction on our part,
but it's not a conviction devoid of reason.
What he says is very reasonable,
but to follow him requires a lot of commitment.
It's a path that requires an awful lot of attention
and a lot of persistence, patience,
you really do have to commit yourself to this.
We're working on a big problem,
and it takes time and effort to break the big problem down
to manageable bits so we can understand.
Oh, this is why I've been doing this all along,
and here's an alternative.
So the path does ask a lot, but it offers a lot as well.
And if you think of the alternative,
just continuing to suffer again and again in your old ways,
it makes sense to give this path a sincere and serious try.
A meditator is a good friend to have
when they talk about things
being unconscious or subconscious.
It's not that there's a basement in the mind
where whatever happens has to be unconscious
and in the dark.
It's simply that we're not paying attention.
Thoughts go flitting through the mind
and then leave an imprint on the body,
or events in the body can have an impact on the mind.
All too often, if we're not aware of this,
the tension builds up
and results in a sense of being burdened, being weighed down.
The Buddha's essential insight
is that much of that being burdened or weighed down
is totally unnecessary.
In fact, none of it is necessary.
There may be stress in the body,
but it doesn't need to have an impact on the mind.
As the Buddha says,
when people are in physical pain,
it's as if they were shot by an arrow
and then they shoot themselves again with another arrow,
the sense of being burdened or victimized by the pain.
That image has always struck me as a little too weak.
We don't shoot ourselves with just one extra arrow.
We shoot ourselves with many more arrows,
a whole quiver of arrows.
And of course, the act of shooting ourselves
with those arrows makes the original pain even worse,
to say nothing of all the pain of the extra arrows.
So no wonder we feel burdened all the time.
No wonder we feel victimized,
or at the very least, that something is wrong.
So what we do when we meditate
is that instead of looking for the answer outside,
we look for the answer inside.
What are we doing here
that's adding all that unnecessary pain?
This is not a selfish question.
If you can stop adding that extra pain to your own mind,
you're less burdened and you're less of a burden on others.
You can actually start paying attention
to how other people are getting along.
This part of the practice tends to be underappreciated,
but meditators are really good friends to have
precisely because they've learned
how not to weigh themselves down all the time.
When they're not weighed down,
they can actually be of more help to others.
When pain comes along, whether it's physical or mental,
they realize that they don't have to take it personally.
There's a passage in the canon where the monks are talking,
and one of them, Ven, Sariputta says,
you know, I was thinking today,
is there anything in the world
whose change would cause me grief?
I couldn't think of anything at all.
And Veni, Ananda, another one of the monks, says,
but what if something happened to the Buddha?
Wouldn't that cause you grief?
And Sariputta replies, no, I'd reflect on the fact
that he was a great human being
and had been very helpful to many,
and it's a sad thing he couldn't live on,
but I wouldn't feel any personal grief around that.
And Ananda says, that's a sign that your conceit has gone,
conceit here meaning not necessarily pride or arrogance,
but more a sense of who you are
and how you take things personally.
If you can be in a difficult situation
and not take the loss or change personally,
you're actually more helpful to others
than you would be otherwise.
I've seen many cases where people are crying
over someone who is about to die,
and a lot of the crying has to do
with how much they're going to miss that person,
how much grief they feel.
That's not all that helpful to the person who's dying.
The best gift you can give to someone else
who is in trouble is that you've taken care
of your habit of personalizing the grief,
of focusing on how much you're going to feel the loss,
how much you're going to feel deprived.
Once you've gotten past those issues,
you can look more carefully.
What does this person need?
How can I be of help?
We were talking today about helping someone who's dying.
The first thing the Buddha said is to try to make sure
that the person isn't worried.
There are two cases in the canon.
One is of a woman whose husband seems to be on his deathbed,
so she goes and tells him,
don't worry about me.
I'll be able to take care of myself when you're gone.
Don't worry about my financial situation.
Don't worry about my turning away from the Dhamma.
In fact, I'll be going to the monastery
even more now, so put your mind at rest.
And it turns out that the husband doesn't die,
at least not then.
He recovers and he goes to tell the Buddha
what his wife told him.
The Buddha replies, do you realize how fortunate you are
that you have such a wise wife
who has your best interest in mind?
There's a similar case where one of the Buddha's cousins,
Mahanama, learns that the Buddha's going to go away
at the end of the rains retreat.
So he asks the Buddha what to do,
what to say if anybody is dying while he's gone.
What should I tell him?
And the Buddha says, the first thing to tell him
is to not worry about his family.
Regardless of the situation,
the fact that you're worried now
isn't going to help anybody.
So drop those thoughts from your mind.
But the Buddha doesn't just leave the person there.
He then tells Mahanama to ask,
are you worried also about the sensual pleasures
you're going to be leaving?
If the person says yes, then Mahanama should say,
try to set your mind on higher levels of being
where the sensual pleasures are more refined.
Yi Wei, in this way, he should keep advising the person
to take his thoughts all the way through
even higher and higher levels
until he gets to the Brahma world
where the pleasure is the same pleasure we gain
from a really concentrated mind.
If the person can keep that up,
then the Buddha says to tell him to let go
even of that type of pleasure.
That too is impermanent.
The sense of identity you would build around that
is impermanent too.
Let go of it.
If the person can follow you all that way,
then he or she can gain total release
from all kinds of suffering.
That's a huge gift you can give to someone who's dying.
It's not always the case that the person dying
can follow you that far.
It generally would require someone
who's got a good meditative background,
but you never know.
Still, your first duty always is to try
to pull that person away from any worries
and then advise them to set their minds on something good.
It could be the good things they've done in the past,
which doesn't mean the good times they've had
because that gets people sentimental
and that can get them really upset.
Instead, have them think about the times they were generous,
the times they were virtuous.
If they have any meditative background,
try to remind them of that.
Give them something good to hold on to.
This means that you're not putting your own sense of loss
in the way of really helping them.
This is why a meditator can be a really good friend,
someone who really is concerned with your welfare,
who is not only thinking of his or her own sense of loss
or sense of pain and who is not being burdened
by those extra arrows.
In my own case, many of the people in my family
wondered what good it was to have a monk in the family.
But then one year, my father went through
a severe depression.
I was in Thailand and only after several months
was I able to make my way back home.
Within a couple of weeks, after talking to my father
and letting him talk, he was out of the depression.
This was after my brothers had been trying
for months to help him.
That's when one of my brothers said,
you know, it really is good to have a Buddhist monk
in the family.
Of course, you don't have to be a monk.
Anyone who has trained his or her own mind
is a good person to have in the family,
a good person to have as a friend.
So as you're meditating here, remind yourselves,
it's not just for us that we're doing this.
We're doing this so we can also be a help to others.
The less we burden ourselves with our own sufferings,
the stronger we'll be.
If we're not carrying huge loads around,
then when we find somebody else carrying a heavy load,
we have free hands to help them put their burden down.
In that way, your training in good friendship can continue.
As the Buddha says, you try to look for good friends,
people you can rely on,
not only so that you can gain their help,
but also so that you can learn from them
what it means to be a good friend.
In that way, you can pass on the gift,
responsible for your goodness.
Each time you sit down to meditate,
remind yourself that this is the most important thing
you can be doing right now.
It's the most important skill you can develop in your life,
the ability to drop all your other concerns
and focus on what really is your responsibility,
which is the shape of your mind.
It's so easy for us to talk about
how we're responsible for things outside,
and that is part of our goodness.
But where does that goodness come from?
If you're responsible for things outside,
and yet are doing a horrible job
creating suffering for yourself
or suffering for other people,
it's nothing to be proud of.
You have to give precedence to the state of your mind
so that you can take care of your responsibilities well.
But the state of your mind isn't something
that's going to be good on its own.
It needs training, it needs nourishment,
the proper kind of nourishment.
All too often, we nourish ourselves
with thoughts of our own importance
or thoughts of sensuality, thoughts of who knows what.
And that kind of food is not necessarily good for the mind
because often those thoughts can poison
whatever goodness we may have.
The Buddha gives an example
of someone who's practicing concentration
and starts thinking about how his concentration
is better than other people's concentration,
and that right there spoils it.
This tendency doesn't apply only to concentration.
It can apply to anything else you do in life.
You do it well,
but then you build up a lot of pride around it.
It's like taking good nourishing food
and then sprinkling arsenic
or bits of rotten fish over the top.
For the goodness of the mind really to be good,
it has to come from within,
from a sense of its own inner sufficiency,
its own inner strength,
its ability to nourish itself properly.
And then whatever goodness it does outside
will just naturally come.
It's a natural expression of the mind.
It's more likely to be right for the occasion
and not harmful to anyone.
So to really be responsible,
you have to take responsibility for this,
the state of your mind right now
and your ability to protect it, look after it.
That means you have to give it a lot of attention.
It also means you have to be willing to put aside
a lot of other connections in your life.
When Luang Pu Uthai was here these last couple of days,
that was one of the things he repeated over and over again.
Our need to be quiet, the need for restraint,
the need to focus on what really is our responsibility,
which is the shape of our mind.
No one else can do this work for us.
You see this when you're dealing with other people.
People you love are suffering
and there's something in them that you can't reach.
As when someone is really, really sick
or really miserable and really depressed
and yet you just can't reach them or someone is dying.
You realize that if that person had taken care
of his or her own mind, he or she wouldn't be suffering
and we would be suffering a lot less.
We wouldn't be worried for them,
which means that one thing we can do now
for the people who will be around us when we die
is to develop skill in nourishing the state of our mind.
So this is your number one responsibility,
the shape of your mind right now
and the goodness of the mind is something
that doesn't need to be decorated.
It doesn't have to have a lot of pride
or conceit or anything.
You may need to develop a certain amount of pride
or conceit as you're working on these skills.
But as the skills get better and better,
you find that pride and conceit are really unnecessary
and they get in the way.
You can put them aside because the goodness of the mind
in and of itself is its reward.
So we focus on the breath to try to bring the mind first
to what the Buddha calls a state of seclusion.
Put aside any unskillful thoughts that come up.
Try not to get entangled with any concern
that they're arising as a blemish on your ego.
What the hell, they're here,
but you don't have to get involved with them.
They're gonna come, but then they're going to go.
You just don't have to get involved
and you learn how to pull away from them.
It's not that you're in denial about them,
it's just that you don't have to participate
in whatever stories they wanna get you involved in.
You see them come and then you just watch them go.
You've got a place to stand here with the breath
apart from them.
So try to make the breath as comfortable as possible.
This is your nourishment along the way
to getting the mind in really good shape.
This is the energy field in the body
that allows the breath to come in, allows it to go out.
It nourishes the nerves, nourishes the blood vessels
and allows the body to move.
It's our most direct experience of the body
and yet we tend to look past it.
We tend to see the solidity of the body as prior
and then wonder how we can get breath
to go through the solidity.
Actually, the breath is already there.
As far as our awareness is concerned,
the breath is primary, it comes first.
The reason why healthy breath energy
is nourishing to the mind
is because it's so near to the mind.
It fills your awareness of the body
with a sense of comfortable energy.
That energy becomes the medium
through which you experience
every other aspect of the body.
When that sense of well-being nourishes the mind,
you're in a much better position
to look at your own drawbacks
and not get ensnared in all the stories
and back and forth recriminations
that usually build up when you notice
you've been doing something unskillful.
That's because you now realize
you don't have to identify with those things.
They're just there.
Causes have created them
and when the causes are removed, they'll go away.
Of course, one of the big causes
that keeps these things going
is that you're paying attention to them.
You want to get involved in them.
So you learn how not to pay attention to them.
You starve them.
Then all these distractions and other things
that pull you away from centering in on the mind
don't have a foundation.
They slip away, slip away.
Part of the mind will say
that you're missing out on something important.
But although it's true
that there's a lot in the world that you're missing,
you're not really missing anything important
if you haven't taken care of the mind first.
This is your top responsibility.
You can't put it off to when you're old.
You can't put it off to weekends or to next year's retreat.
You've got to deal with it every day
because the mind can create trouble every day.
So you've got to keep riding herd on it.
But riding herd doesn't mean that you're harassing it
or causing it to suffer.
You're actually giving it a sense of wellbeing
and learning how to protect it,
how to foster a sense of its value.
This is where all our goodness comes from.
This is where the potential
for the end of suffering comes from.
The suffering that we're creating
with our minds right now is the problem.
So you've got to solve the problem where the cause is.
And it turns out that in the midst of this cause,
there's something that's deathless.
Only it doesn't lie in the midst of things.
It's a different dimension.
It's out of space and time, but it's contacted right here.
The Buddha doesn't talk much about it.
He says, it's something you realize by doing the practice.
We were talking today about trying to get our heads
around the idea of what this deathlessness might be like,
but it's not something you get your head around.
You try to get your head around suffering
so you can comprehend it to the point
where you can develop dispassion
for the things that make you cling to it.
As for the cause of suffering,
you try to get your head around it enough to abandon it.
But the end of suffering, the cessation of suffering
is not something to comprehend.
You discover it, it's there.
And regardless of how wonderful your theories are about it
or how accurate your ideas may be about it,
there's no way they can touch the actual reality
of this potential, this dimension.
But we can talk about developing the path,
using the strength we gain from concentration
to look into the ways in which we're causing suffering
and learning how to abandon them.
We do this by looking into
the most paradoxical habit of the mind,
which is that it likes to create suffering.
We don't understand why this is happening.
We want happiness, we want pleasure.
And yet the things we do end up creating so much suffering.
We're attached to things that are causing suffering
because we don't see the connection.
Or if we see the connection,
we don't think there's any alternative.
So when the Buddha talks about the path,
it's to remind us that there are alternatives, good ones.
And when he does talk about the cessation of suffering,
he tells us enough to let us know that it's really there
and it's really good and it's really worth going for.
It's much better than all the other ideas we have
about who we are or how great or important we are
or how horrible we are.
All these stories where whether we think we're good or bad,
we're making ourselves the hero,
we're making ourselves the heroine,
none of which are helpful.
You need to look into the state of your mind right now.
How is it dealing with itself?
How is it dealing with its thoughts, its cravings?
How is it dealing with the good parts of the mind?
What is it doing to maintain them, to give them importance?
Those are the questions you really want to ask
and those are the ones you want to focus on answering
because by focusing on them,
you can find something really good in the mind.
When you've got that real goodness,
then you don't have to create
all the artificial forms of goodness
that we build around ourselves, our self-image,
our idea of how important we are in this way or that.
This then gets reflected in the way we're generous.
The Buddha talks about how the different levels
of generosity that come along as we're practicing
get higher and higher
until finally we get to the state of awakening.
Then generosity is just a natural ornament of the mind.
In other words, the goodness we do for other people
at that point isn't done
because we want something out of them
or because we want something out of being good.
When the mind has taken care of all of its needs,
when it's taken care of all of its inner responsibilities,
then everything that's left is a pure gift.
This is why this, your state of mind, should take priority.
As for anything that gets in the way,
anything that distracts you from this,
you've gotta put it aside for the time being.
It's like learning a musical instrument.
You have to be willing to go off and practice
for hours and hours and hours by yourself.
You're not playing for anybody else.
It may sound like you're being selfish,
but no, you're learning how to get really good
at what you're doing
so that when the time comes
and you actually do go out on the stage,
you've got something good to offer.
You've got something good for people to listen to.
Like the Buddha, he left his family,
and many people get upset about that,
thinking he was a deadbeat dad.
But you have to remember that one of the ways
that a husband or father could provide for his family
in those days was to go out on an expedition,
go out exploring, and to come back with a treasure.
Sometimes it would take years.
In this case, the Buddha came back
with a really great treasure,
the treasure of the deathless.
So even though he had to isolate himself from his family
and it did cause them some grief,
he himself found it hard to leave them.
Still, he knew that he had to.
And when he came back,
he had something that more than compensated
for those six or seven years.
So remember this.
When you find that the demands of the practice
pull you away from your family or your friends,
it may look like you're being irresponsible,
but you're actually taking care
of your number one responsibility.
And when you do that, everybody benefits.
Whether anybody else appreciates that fact doesn't matter.
You know that this is what you've got to do.
