Cheap vs. Professional Watercolor Paints — Is Expensive Paint Really Worth It?

Easy Art Strokes
27 followers
1 Video View·Jan 5, 2026
Hey friend, in this video we are going to be doing an art supply comparison of a couple different
pigment paint palettes. We have this like really cheap looking one, I mean I'm not judging until
we use it, we're gonna give reviews in real time. This set of watercolor, which pretty much
everybody knows this set, the eyeshadow watercolor set that you can find at pretty much any art supply
store. And then my handy dandy, been with me for 30 years, professional level watercolor paint. We
have a mix of my Mary Blue and Windsor Newton in here. So I'm gonna give my tips on what I'm
looking for in paint and what I'm noticing between the student level paints and then the more
professional level paints. I get asked all the time like what supplies should I use when I'm
or should I start with something a little bit on the cheaper side? Because
art supplies aren't cheap, like they can definitely break the bank... break the bane...
break the bank. But if you use high quality pigment from the tube and you paint, I don't know,
a handful of times a week, you're really not going to blow through that much that quickly. It seems
like it's not very much, but it really does go a long way. So I'm anticipating in this video
showing you why I toot the horn of professional level paint so much, is because especially
in wet and wet technique with watercolor, it makes a huge difference. So let's go ahead and open up
this. Let's litter. Yeah, what's the price? Three dollars. Five dollars. Okay, this set right here,
Basic, is one, two, three, four, five, six, twelve colors and it's five dollars. Where did you get it
or where is it? Where can you buy it? It was given. Okay, Walmart. Walmart has this. Like I said,
pretty standard issue colors. We have a white in there though, which yes, you can
buy white watercolor, but I just use the paper as my white or use white gouache because white
watercolor is pretty thin. Chinese white watercolor from my Mary Blue is a decent one. It's pretty
thick, but I just already am like, what a waste of space with a white color. We could have something
else in there, but that's okay. We're not going to judge until we start using. So first things first,
what I'm going to do is I'm going to do the same. I guess I'll use a round brush. No, this brush.
I'm going to do wet and wet technique. So this is going to tell me how well these colors will bleed
and blend and use wet and wet technique. So we're going to do a little pulling method. I'll start
with pink. I want to test out this color. I'm going to get it into like a milky consistency,
so not too thin, not too thick. And let's just kind of see. I mean, it's a nice color. I'm not
mad about that color. It's very like Barbie bubblegum pink. That's fine. Nothing wrong
with that. It's a fine color. It's not opera rose or anything like that, but it's a fine pink color.
And then let's do with water, the pulling technique, and we'll just see how it blends.
It's got a nice blend. It's not, it's not staining too bad. Like they're the color,
right. I overlapped with water right over that edge of the pink and it's not staining too bad,
but there is this harsh line. It's not a smooth blend. Like this pink is just kind of staying
there. Let's see when I grab more pink and I go on top of that edge, how well it blends.
It's doing a fine job. It's really honestly much better than I anticipated, but it's not
anything like Windsor Newton or my Mary blue, where it's like an explosion of color into
the wet section. So now let's do a couple different swatches. Maybe we do some orange
right up against that washy pink. See how the orange bleeds. Orange is one of my all-time
favorite colors, um, to use for wet and wet technique because it typically with this orange,
it just explodes and blends really aggressively. This one is very slow. It's not blending. It's
blending. Uh, it's bleeding a little bit, but it's not like bursting into this clear swatch
or this empty swatch of water that it's touching. So it's fine. We do see, we're starting to see a
little bit of that cauliflower forming around the dark pink edge. I'm assuming it'll do that
with the orange as well. So that is going to create a hard line and I didn't have too much
water on my brush. This is a really thin glaze. So I know that that would blend and, and dry a
lot smoother with the professional level. Now let's go over to this eye shadowy palette
with a similar color palette. So we'll do pink, our first swatch of pink in a milky consistency.
So I'm trying to get the same-ish amount of color on my brush. This pink is obviously
a bit more pepto-bismol, a bit more pale. Um, gotta like keep going back to your dish to get
more pigment. So this, the strength of this color, the vibrancy of this color is way more powerful
than this set. So that's good. Good job there. Like I'm gonna, to get it to this strength,
which I won't be able to, cause it's just a different pink, but I'm going to layer on top
of it a little bit more to make it slightly more opaque like that one is. And then we'll
rinse off the color and grab water and do some pulling. So that one, there's a bit more staining
effect. So you see how there's that edge that's not really lifting up. If I go over it a couple
times, it'll lift up. This one came up right away, but we do have some of that cauliflower happening.
So we've got our clear water only situation. Now I'm grabbing orange, trying to get it a little
bit more opaque in the milky value consistency, making sure to work quickly though, because I am
trying to show wet and wet. So this has to stay wet. Like I said, orange typically bleeds with
these colors really aggressively. This one is similar to this one. It just kind of stays put.
It's not really going anywhere, but I do think that this color is a lot stronger than that pink
and it has a nice intensity. It has a nice vibrancy. I like the color,
but again, it's not really like blending as smoothly as I would like it to.
So now we'll go to the professional watercolor. I didn't refill my pink in time for recording
these videos. My pink won't be as juicy. I won't be able to get up as much paint as I
would like to show, but this is quinacridone red, so it's a bit more of a reddish pink.
Opera rose would be the better color to compare it to for a more neon pink, but I don't have that
in my palette. So we're using this one and I'm going to grab a little bit more pigment.
So it's deeper. It's a fuller, richer color.
Obviously just a different shade of pink in general, but it's a nice juicy color. So now
we're going to go with that pulling method and grab that and pull it down. So as I'm stroking
it, you can see that really smooth gradient. That's what we're looking for. We kind of got
that gradient up here with the pink, but because this pigment is really grainy, you're seeing like
that dusting of pink on top of the water underneath, which I don't love that look.
That's kind of one of the cheaper looks of like cheaper watercolor paint is that like
spottiness where the dust of the pigment kind of collects. Now I'll grab cadmium orange or
permanent orange. Those two oranges are my favorite. They bleed very aggressively.
Obviously they're not going to do it right now. Usually they do, but it's going to have that nice
look over here. I did do another brush stroke right here. I'll do another clean one down here,
but see how smooth that bleed is. We don't have that like cobwebby
cauliflower texture. It's just kind of a smooth, dark to light. And that's what I'm looking for
with a nice, easy blend. And we're starting to get that on the orange as well. So if I show you
with, let's say, turquoise professional level watercolor, we'll do some more wet and wet down
here. We've got some circles. This is another good exercise. So look at how vibrant and rich
that color is. And I barely had to pick up any pigment on my brush. And then next I'll go with
just the water and it just easily pours right into that neighboring circle. And it's going to
have a nice smooth gradient where if I compare it to this blue, which again, this is a very
different blue. It's a beautiful blue though. Really nice kind of Royal blue. And let's see
how this dries. It's already got that chunky cauliflower gritty texture. This one, we've got
too much water going on. So this is user error, but it should like have a smooth blend of dark
to light into that circle. But this veining stuff, I really don't like that veining stuff happening
all over here and there. It's kind of nice, but you see the difference between the veining up here,
a little bit of veining on these colors, but not too bad. And then this smooth blend of color,
you don't have much veining. I went over the pink too much on the bottom here. So that's
why it cut off, but it's just a nice smooth gradient between dark to light and then dark to
light. No, um, cauliflowers are veining like that. And then we'll do this blue from the eyeshadow
set to see how it compares. Very similar blues. So the colors are nice if that's what you're
looking for. But if you notice a lot of this stuff happening in your work, like on the tips
of your leaves, you're seeing those veining situations happening, or it's just drying
funky and it's not blending as full and smooth for a gradient, then it could be because of your
supplies. I'm also working on cheaper watercolor paper, and that makes a huge difference too.
I absolutely, hands down, always recommend working with 100% cotton paper. I normally
work with St. Cuthbert's Mill, Saunders Waterford, cold press paper, 100% cotton paper.
But I just have this, what is it? 140 pound, which is good. Artist's Loft, so it's student level
watercolor paper. And that is absolutely making a difference in how some of this stuff is drying
for sure. But overall, you can tell there's a big difference between, especially this set
and the professional level, because we've got a lot of the veininess. And that's something that
over time, if you really want to enjoy your practice, you want to look at things that you
see on like a YouTube video or a tutorial somewhere, and you want to see something similar.
So if you're starting to notice a lot of the veins, a lot of cauliflowers and hard lines and
things like that, it could be because of your supplies. So if you've been working with the
cheap watercolor paint because it's more budget friendly, I highly recommend just incorporating
maybe three colors of professional level or five colors starting somewhere so you can start to see
results that you really love, because that's going to encourage you to continue to practice,
it's going to make you fall in love with the medium even more, and make you obviously not
critiquing your work over small things that you could change simply by upgrading your supplies.
So I would say if you only had to upgrade your supplies in small areas because of budget,
the first one would be paper. Paper is the most important to me. 100% cotton, cold press, 140
pound, that's what I look for. But then the next most important to me is paint. If you're,
you know, you can get away with some student level paints here and there, that's, you know,
every artist is different. Some people only use student level paint and have wonderful results,
but if you are like me and you like to see those smooth gradients and that
ease of wet and wet technique, then I highly recommend upgrading to professional level paint.
I have a list of all the supplies that I use, all the professional level quality paints that I use,
the paper, the brushes, all the things listed in the links below in the description of this video.
You can also go to generaney.com forward slash amazon and get all the links or at least the
product brands and buy them at your local store if you'd rather support local. But that's kind of
the reason why I'm always, always talking about the importance of supplies. The importance of
professional level supplies is just, to me, a no-brainer. It might not seem like that big of a
deal, but once you really get into working with watercolor, you're going to start to notice hard
lines and the veining texture a lot more and it's going to start to bug because it's distracting.
Like if this was on the tip of a leaf, I don't want to see that. I want to see something more
clean, more smooth with my gradients. And if, especially if you're painting with, if you're
painting landscapes and you want to see a smooth gradient, like here, if this is our sky, this is
distracting. You don't want those veins in your sky. You don't want the like cobwebby stuff in
your sky. You want a smooth blend from color to color or value to value. So there you have it,
a little comparison, side-by-side comparison of our basic student level paints. We also did,
of the eyeshadow palette and then the professional level, my Mary Blue and Windsor Newton colors.
Let me know in the comments below what you think of this little review.
If you'd like to see me compare more supplies in the future, in future videos, and also,
you know, just what you've been painting lately. Let's, let's do that. What have you been painting
lately that's been inspiring you lately? Drop it in the comments below. Encourage other artists
and make sure you check out the Complete Beginner's Guide to Watercolor on this channel.
It's a two-hour deep dive workshop for free on my YouTube channel where I go into all the
techniques, supplies, color theory, composition, everything you would want to know about watercolor
in this two-hour free workshop. I'll link to it in this video so you can check it out.
As always, thank you so much for watching these videos, for engaging with them,
and I'll see you in the next one.
