Use of Force

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jan 4, 2026
Hello everyone, today we will be talking about user force. This presentation will basically be
a basic introduction of user force in international laws and how states can use their force in order
to intervene in the actions of other states and whether they can do that or not. So let's start
with the brief history first. First of all, before 16th century what used to happen was wars
were a mean of preparation of illegal acts. So whenever there was some illegal act states used
to wage war on the other states and then states also used to wage war due to religious reasons
to spread their religion or to suppress other religions. But during 16th to 18th century
there was actually no limit on going to war. So if a state wants to go on war with another state
they can freely do so. There wasn't any restriction, the sovereignty of state was not
established and so on. However, after 19th century when World War I happened this tradition was
changed and there was actually concept of state sovereignty that was introduced and then there
was also a concept of territorial integrity and political independence. So the concept basically
was that every state has their territorial integrity and they are politically independent
and no other state has right to intervene in these rights of the other state and a state cannot just
go on and wage war on the other state. And because of this it was stated that the state cannot
actually freely go and wage war on each other without any superior authority or without any
motive. The main authority that regulates the use of force is the article of UN Charter.
The main article that we will be discussing here is article 2.4 of the UN Charter which actually
restricts the use of force and it reads as all members shall refrain in their international
relations from the threat to use the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity
or political independence of any state. So this article is basically establishing the territorial
integrity and political independence of the states and restricting the other states from using threat
or use of force in order to intervene in other states matters. Now what does threat mean? There
are several debates on the interpretation of the word threat. It can be any statement,
it can be any provision, it can be creating an economic situation or a political situation that
can actually threaten the other states and their integrity or sovereignty. And that shows that
force will be used to compromise the sovereignty of the country. So if it's a statement that shows
that the other state's sovereignty will be compromised or if an economic situation is
created that shows that other state's integrity or the sovereignty will be threatened then that
can be considered as a threat. And let's look at an illustration of it when Saddam Hussein
attacked on Kuwait. It was considered against article 2.4 of the United Charter because it
prohibits the attacking, occupying and harming of other states. Now there are some exceptions in
which states can actually use force. Let's look at those exceptions. The first one and the
most important one is self-defense. So when the state has to use defense then they can use force.
And the second one is action with security council, the third one being humanitarian
intervention and then the last one being consent when the state itself allows it.
We will be looking at each of these exceptions in detail in the following slide.
First one being self-defense. Article 51 of the UN Charter regulates self-defense
and what it basically entails is that it is an inherent right of individual or collective
defense. So it can be exerted by one individual state or it can be exerted by a group of states
until the security council has taken necessary measures to maintain the international peace
and if force has been used under this particular article then it has to be immediately reported to
the security council. Now there are several interpretations of the word armed attack that
has been used under this article. There are two basic approaches. The first one is literal
approach. What it means is that armed attack will be considered when an army is physically
attacking the state. There are several criticisms of this approach that when there is a physical
army at your border then how can you prepare yourself for the self-defense. So that branches
out the other approach which is the loose approach. It includes the anticipatory defense.
What it means is that the armed attack is anticipated and it does not have to be physically
or immediately implemented. However, when we are talking about using self-defense as
for the sake of use of force, it has to be immediate. For example, the threat has to be
immediate otherwise there would have been an option to going to the security council.
So if the option of going to the security council is open then the use of self-defense cannot be
imposed and there must be a response in some attack. So the state which is using self-defense
has to be a victim. Self-defense in itself is subject to these restraints which is necessary
and proportionate which means that self-defense has to be necessary and it should be proportionate
to the attack that was put on the state. Now when force is used as self-defense then it needs to be
immediately reported to the security council and the measures that were taken under this defense
also needs to be reported. Exception of this particular provision is article 52 where
if the states have a regional agreement between them then that incident will be reported to the
regional authorities rather than directly to the security council. Right to self-defense is life
until security council takes an action and makes a peaceful agreement. So when a security council
intervenes and tries to make a peaceful agreement only then after that the states cannot
make a defense of using force in response to self-defense. Then that right actually stops.
Now coming towards anticipatory self-defense. When a state suspects or anticipates an attack
then it can be taken as self-defense. This is what we call anticipatory self-defense.
However, anticipatory self-defense itself poses certain questions. One of the most important one
is on what grounds do we understand that the anticipatory self-defense that we used
was on the right parameters or not. For that we need to look at Caroline test.
In Caroline case what happened was that there was a US team board named Caroline which was carrying
arms for the aid of Canadians against Britain. So Canadians and Britains were having war and
US was aiding Canadians in that conflict. Britain had attacked that ship and causing it to blow up
and eventually it fell into the Niagara falls. Now the argument that was posed by Britain was
that they attacked the ship because in response of as a self-defense. So this case then established
the main principle in determining what it means to take self-defense in case of use of force.
So this case then established Caroline test but which is stated as when an attack is immediate
leaving no moment of deliberation and no choice. So the two distinct principles that this Caroline
test then establishes are that the use of force must be necessary because the threat is imminent
and thus the peaceful alternative is not an option. So the threat has to be imminent and
the use of force has to be necessary. So this established the principle of necessity that there
was no other choice other than using force. The second principle then is the response must be
proportionate to the threat. So it also established the principle of proportionality that the kind of
force that was used by the attacker should be proportionate to the force that the victim is
using as a self-defense. Now we see application of Caroline test in oil platform case 2003.
In this case, there were certain Iranian missiles that hit US vessels. In return,
US attacked certain oil platforms in Iran and destroyed them. This matter then went to the
International Court of Justice where the court heard that the attack by the US was neither
necessary nor proportionate. The first step that the US should have taken was to inform
a security council about this attack but US failed to do so. Moreover, the US did not resort
to peaceful means under Article 33 of the United Charter. That should have been the first step of
the US. After establishing these principles, the ICJ goes on to hold Iran accountable for the
attack on the US. Now the second exception of using the force is when security council takes
an action. Chapter 7 of the United Charter determines the authority of the security council
in using force. The main articles that regulates this authority of security council is Article 39,
41 and 42. In Article 39, it actually establishes the power of security council to determine if
there is an existence of threat, act of aggression or breach of peace and then make provisions
accordingly. Article 41 of the UN Charter deals with the actions that security council can take
and there does not necessarily have to be an armed force, a use of armed force. So security council
is not actually required to go and wage war on the other state. Security council can adopt other
measures as well. For example, interrupting economic relationship, means of communication
and so on. Under Article 42, the instances where the Supreme Court can actually use the actual
force, which means the armed force, is in maintaining the international peace and security.
Now there are some examples and we can see where a security council used force in order to
restrict the other states from attacking the sovereignty or integrity of the
certain states. The first example that we have is of Kuwait, when Iraq intervened in Kuwait and
started waging war and trying to take over Kuwait. That is when security council intervened and
tried to stop Iraqi forces. The next example that we have is of Haiti, where security council
restored democratically elected head of the state and then tried to make peace in that state.
The last example here we have is of Rwanda, in which security council intervened in order to
terminate the genocide. The next exception that we have in using force is humanitarian intervention.
When there is a big or a major human rights threat, then security council can intervene
and use force in order to stop that threat. The examples that we see in which security council
intervened based on human rights grounds are Somalia and Bosnia, where they delivered
humanitarian assistance. The last exception that we have is consent by state, that is when a state
itself consents with the use of force in order to eliminate or make peace during an internal conflict,
only then the other state can intervene and then use force. So these are the four exceptions to
use of force. Generally, these are the cases. The most important one is self-defense and these are
the cases where it is primarily preferred that the security council is involved and
actually makes peace during the armed conflict. Thank you.
