How Did This Family Business use Whole Life Insurance?

Finance Shield
6 followers
Jan 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Today, we are going to take a look at a case study
of a family business.
We've got a family in the farming industry.
They're also involved in real estate
and they're interested in a whole life insurance policy
set up for maximum cash value and flexibility
so then they can use it for their business.
So we're going to look at exactly
how the policy should be set up
and then how they can use it for the business.
Let's get on into it and have some fun.
So to kick things off,
age 36, that is the age of the son,
which we are looking at the policy on.
I have had conversations initially with the father
who was interested in the product,
had a lot of questions about how the product works and such,
but he's interested in taking the policy out
primarily on his son, possibly his son's wife as well,
but just due to the father's age and the overall planning,
it does make sense to go on the son.
So the son is 36 years old, who I have also spoke with
and he understands the product and finance in general
at a very, very high level.
He does a lot of due diligence
before committing to a strategy.
So he is a business owner, both he and his father are.
They are in the farming industry.
They also have a lot of real estate investments
and this part is going to be critical
to the initial funding of the policy
with respect to what they want to do.
Here's what they're interested in,
cash value for their business.
Specifically, they want to build that cash value up
and use it as a line of credit for their business
instead of a bank if possible.
So as they have made large purchases for their business,
as financing needs have come and gone,
they've used a bank as most business owners do,
especially if you need to carry a lot of inventory
at certain points in time.
That's where having a line of credit with a bank,
for example, can be very, very valuable.
So what they'd like to do
is establish their own line of credit
and reduce their reliance or their need to go to banks
so they've got control.
So the thought here is with the cash value,
if they can build that up,
they'll have their own source of financing here,
their own personal line of credit
or business line of credit
with how they plan on using it
and this will be pretty cool to see.
So we're going to look at a model
that demonstrates this in a little bit.
Why they're interested in that
is one, the policy does continue to compound
when you borrow against it,
when you look at how loans work,
but also when you look at loan rates right now,
they range between 5% and 6%
and that can also be a fixed rate.
So where we are,
where we're at in the interest rate environment right now
where rates with banks are a bit higher,
being able to lock in a low fixed loan interest rate
is attractive to them.
If interest rates go back down
and a more attractive rate becomes available
with a bank or third-party lender,
then they have a cash value collateral loan available,
which is when you assign your cash value
as collateral to a bank
and they give you a line of credit
against the cash value.
It's a nice option,
we've got other videos that talk on it.
But my point is they like the idea
of locking in a lower fixed loan interest rate.
The death benefit here is important.
I spoke with both the father and son,
father had more interest in this.
The death benefit from a legacy planning standpoint
is important and the main reason why
is because he had mentioned,
it was the previous generation,
there was about $21 million passed
and most of it's gone.
It was squandered for lack of a better word.
So he does have a trust established.
He did mention that it's been revised
three times already,
specifically to prevent this from happening again.
Where money is passed to the next generation
and it's spent unwisely,
not in the way that he wants it spent.
He wants it to remain in the family
and actively used to continue
to increase the family's net worth,
both their personal and business value.
So that's a little overview there.
The plan.
So we mentioned the real estate before,
that they've got some real estate investments
and they are selling some of them.
So they've got some real estate out in California
that they are in the process of liquidating
and they're planning to sell a lot more of it.
And as of now,
they are expecting to net after-tax
somewhere between $2 and $2.1 million.
So what they want to do is take that,
let's call it $2 million
and move it into a policy.
So the funding scenario we're going to look at
is $500,000 per year for 4 years.
That'll be on the sun.
He does have the option to continue
to feed the policy thereafter
but where we wanted to start
was just moving that lump sum into the policy.
Now we still are discussing this.
In our most recent call,
he did ask about a strategy
of moving $700,000 per year
into the policy over 3 years.
He is interested in getting it
into the policy quickly,
which at his age,
that'll look a little bit stronger
but it won't make a huge difference
when we look at the performance.
And really,
when you get to this level
and trying to figure out
how long you want to spread a lump sum out
when moving it into a policy,
in this case,
really has to do with this,
how long is it going to sell
some of the properties
compared to others?
Because with real estate,
sometimes we can sell it quickly,
other times we can't
because things come up
that perhaps we didn't expect at all.
But my point is,
if we build in some more time there,
that may be attractive,
might not be either.
It depends really on him
and his situation
or the family situation.
What we're going to look at here,
we are going to review the company
and also product selection.
One of the most important things
when it comes to maximizing the cash value,
company selection.
One of the 4 major mutual companies
that have a track record
of delivering strong cash values
and death benefits,
actual performance,
not just illustrations.
4 major mutuals are
MassMutual,
Guardian,
The New York Life
and Northwestern Mutual.
Step 2,
policy design.
If the policy is designed
with a minimum base premium,
that will result in
maximum cash value upfront,
maximum cash value
based on the guarantees.
We're maximizing the overall value
so if I want to be able
to use it through loans,
I've got as much possible working capital.
That's where cash value maximization
really comes into play.
So the different options
we started with
was a MassMutual 10-Pay
and then a Guardian L95 policy
with a 5% PUA fee
and a 10% PUA fee
as those are 2 different options.
Same product,
that L95 product
but whatever PUA fee
I select from the get-go,
I'm locked in indefinitely.
So very quickly,
the 5% PUA fee
will give you stronger guaranteed values
and it will also give you
more money upfront.
So when I focus on the guarantees,
I'll see more from start to finish
when I look at the 5% PUA fee.
When I look at the non-guaranteed values,
I will have more upfront
for about 12 years,
it's typically 10 to 12 years.
But then if I'm looking
at the non-guaranteed values,
the 10% PUA fee
will have significantly more value
looking at it from a long-term perspective.
But looking at the different carriers here,
so MassMutual and Guardian,
we use both heavily,
cream of the crop
when it comes to carriers.
Flexibility is the big thing.
So when it comes to policy flexibility,
Guardian,
if I'm paying in $500,000 per year,
will allow a design
where he can commit
to approximately $50,000 per year,
10% of the total amount
and then just add the rest at his discretion.
So if he feels that that real estate
may sell slower
than what he's anticipating
perhaps based on past experience,
that's where that flexibility may be nice.
Or for example,
if he says,
hey, I can cash flow the $50,000
no problem for my business,
which he can.
And then I can just add
the additional funds
when the real estate sells
and I don't have to worry about
paying the full amount
on my premium due date,
that's where Guardian
is very advantageous
based on his particular situation.
Because he can commit
just to the minimum premium,
when the premium is due,
he only has to pay the $50,000
and then the additional $450,000
can be added at his leisure
and he doesn't even have to add it.
Some years he might skip it,
then resume the following year,
very, very flexible there.
MassMutual on the other hand,
is not quite as flexible
where I can commit
to the same $50,000 minimum
then add more money at discretion.
What you can do with Mass
is send the full $500,000
and you still have the $50,000 minimum,
but then let's say I send
the full $500,000 in the first year,
second year the real estate sale is delayed
so I only pay in $70,000.
If I want to add more money
back up to $500,000
I have to wait until the premium due date
in order to avoid medical underwriting
if the policy is set up properly.
There's a variety of ways
to set up MassMutual policies
but if one is comfortable
and disciplined
to make 1 time per year payment adjustments
MassMutual works very, very nicely.
But the big, big difference there is here,
Guardian, I can commit to the minimum
and add more discretion.
MassMutual, if I'm comfortable
with a 1 time per year payment
$500,000, $500,000, $500,000,
$500,000, it'll work perfectly fine.
So what we're going to look at
is as follows.
First, we are going to review
different illustrations
just side-by-side of these 3
and then we'll look at a loan demonstration
which will hit on
one of their main objectives here
which is to utilize the policy
as a line of credit.
Let's have some fun, shall we?
What we've got here
is a side-by-side of the different options
$500,000 per year for 4 years.
He has the option to fund longer
than just 4 years.
Afterwards, he can continue
to pay in $500,000,
maybe it's $100,000, maybe it's $50,000.
He's not forced to stop after 4 years,
that question does come up sometimes.
With a 10-pay policy,
the premium is due
for a maximum of 10 years.
The L95, he can pay into it
up until the age of 95
so he can keep on feeding it
if he wanted to.
But we're focusing just on the lump sum
as that is the primary goal right now.
So over here with MassMutual,
$500,000 in the 1st year,
you've got just over $450,000
in 1st year cash value
which is about 90% of your payment,
a little bit more than that.
So rich 1st year cash value
when we look at a whole life insurance policy
what's highlighted in yellow
represents the break-even point.
And remember these payments here
are coming from real estate sales.
Guardian L95 product,
1st year, $500,000 in,
very close to that MassMutual option,
you're at $442,000 in the 1st year.
2nd year, look at this,
you're paying $500,000,
you get that back
and a little bit more.
That's the only option
where we see that occur
in the 2nd year.
If you look at this,
back to the Mass option,
year 1 to 2,
you paid in $500,000
and you got less than that back.
You were at $451,000
at the end of the 1st year.
If you got your full $500,000
back in year 2,
what would you be at?
$951,000
or a little bit less than that.
So that L95 with that 5% PUA fee
is the only option
where we see a positive growth rate
or positive cash value growth
by policy year 2
and a break-even point
between years 3 and 4.
Great option for strong upfront cash value,
also a great option
if you like the stronger guarantees
because this does have
the strongest guaranteed cash value
short-term and long-term
when comparing these 3.
And then you've got
the L95 10% PUA fee
which does offer
greater long-term potential.
The break-even is still attractive there
between years 4 and 5.
So in a case like this
and really any case
but especially larger numbers,
what people often like to see
or like to show
even if they don't ask
to provide more clarity
is the net growth rate
and also the total gain.
So when I say net growth rate
what I'm referring to
is the annual internal rate of return.
Just because when someone first discovers
whole life insurance
we see the dividend rates
associated with a life insurance company.
Here MAS the dividend rate is 6%
and Guardian the dividend rate is 5.75%.
You'll never see the internal rate of return
hit that dividend rate
and the reason why
is because the dividend rate is a gross rate
that's applied to the policy
after the insurance expenses and such.
So as we look at this guy
1st year you paid in $500
you've got just over $450
which means you lost about $50,000.
That's why
we see that negative
internal rate of return
of a little bit less than 10%.
Year 2 you paid in $500
you got a little bit less back than your $500
which is why we see that
negative internal rate of return.
In year 3 you paid in $500
you got that back
and a little bit more
if we got the full $500 back
we would be at what?
$1,438
but we're a little bit higher than that
we're at $1,464
which is why we see that
positive internal rate of return.
Then the total gain on cash value
you'll notice the 1st 3 years
your total funding is what?
$1,500,000
your cash value is $1,464
that's a loss of $35,000.
By the 4th year
total payments are now $2,000,000
cash value is $2,018,000 and change.
Everything above the $2,000,000 of total funding
is the gain
money you're receiving
from the insurance company
or you have received
from the insurance company I should say.
You'll see that gain increase over time
and this IRR does assume
the company's current dividend rate
their current illustration
what everything shows today
things will change over the years
and this is where we definitely want to
track the actual performance of course.
But we've got the annualized IRR
and also the total gain on cash value
and then we'll do the same thing
with the other options.
And to take it a step further
we may look at the guaranteed values and such
or we would look at that
to show a worst-case scenario
this way you can really refine
your decision-making process
because the 1st thing
that I am going to stress to him
and I did stress to him
is really making sure
that the product is selected
A, that maximizes the cash value
but then B, from a flexibility standpoint
you are comfortable with.
We talked about MassMutuals
and Guardian's flexibility before
if he says hey I'm going to have the money there
or hey I can cash flow the $500,000
no problem with proceeds for my business
and then I can refill the kitty
when a piece of property sells
then MassMutual can work fine
because I'm comfortable
with the one-time per year payments.
Guardian on the other hand
if he says boy I love the idea
of being able to commit
just a $50,000 per year
and then pay up to 10x that
whenever I want
okay I'm interested in that
now we just need to decide
between these 2 options.
But this is where
it's always beneficial to start
and you can do this
by looking at 2 products
sometimes 3
you look at a couple different companies
so we don't have buyer's remorse
the top options
which is what most people gravitate toward
and what products have produced
the strongest actual results
as we've examined them over time.
Let's wrap this up
so we're going to look at the
10% PUA fee option
and here's what we got.
So this model does not display
direct loans from the
life insurance illustration
that is something we will prepare
we do prepare for everyone
we work with
when they want to see loan illustrations
this is a quick loan workbook
that we do send to those we work with
so they can really get a quick idea
of what the numbers look like.
Meaning if this is me
and I'm thinking about
borrowing $1,500,000
what's the cash value growing by
and how much am I going to pay in interest?
That's what I'm interested in
and I want to make sure
that I'm not in the red
meaning I don't want to see interest costs
higher than what the policy is growing by.
So what we've got here
again on the left
the growth illustration.
So what you'll notice
is the annual outlay
total payments
cash value and death benefit
but then the annual internal rate of return
this is isolating what the policy
is growing by year over year
we just looked at this on the last workbook
but then we've got the yearly cash value growth.
For example year 4 to 5
he pays in nothing
the cash value was $1,959,000
the following year
it was $2,044,000
how much did it grow by?
Isolating the cash value growth that year
$85,000 and change
year 4 to year 5
that's what I got from the company
that was applied to my cash value.
Same thing the following year
a little bit stronger
$89,000 and change.
Then you've got the total gain on cash value
if I look at year 10
paid in $2,000,000
got $2,571,000
so that $571,000 is the gain.
That's how much more I have in cash value
than what I've paid in total since day 1.
So where these are valuable
or why these are valuable
when looking at loan scenarios
is because when we start taking loans
and seeing how much we're paying in interest
what we can do is compare
how much we paid in loan interest each year
with how much our policy is growing by each year
and then also our total interest payments
so over the life of a loan
what's the total amount I paid in loan interest
and compare that with my total gain.
The column highlighted in yellow
LTV at 95% of cash value
that displays how much you have access to.
So let's assume year 4
he wants to take out a loan
we mentioned earlier $1,500,000
he loans $1,500,000
loan interest rate 4.76%
where that came from
this Guardian
has a fixed loan interest rate 5%
however if you pay the loan interest annually
when it's billed on your premium due date
the policy anniversary date
they apply a discounted rate 4.76%
that's where that came from
if we're looking at a different product
we would change the rate accordingly
or if we didn't want to pay the loan interest
on the anniversary date
we could increase it to 5%.
Here's what I want to look at
borrowed $1,500,000
my available equity
dropped as a result.
Now remember you're still compounding
on your full cash value.
Guardian is direct recognition
so the values would be different
than what we've got here
full disclosure
but again this is meant to give us a quick ballpark.
So 4.76% of $1,500,000
$71,400.
Here's your cash value growth
it's $1.86
on the $1.96
$35,000.
Rather than looking back and forth
in blue
you've got your comparison.
So if you take that loan
and never pay it
never pay the principal
just pay interest forever
what happens?
Well you can see each year
what the cash value is growing by
compared to what you're paying in loan interest.
So in year 4
if I take that $1.5 million loan
I'm going to be paying more in loan interest
than what I'm receiving from the company.
The next year however
cash value growth is $85,000
and I paid $71,400.
I'm positive now.
The reason why
because if you look at year 5
the IRR is 4.35%
the loan rate's 4.76%.
How am I positive?
That 4.35%
is on the total cash value
whereas the 4.76%
is only on the $1.5 million.
So I'm getting the compounding
on the entire balance
whereas I'm paying loan interest
only on the outstanding loan balance there.
So let's pay this off.
You know what?
Let's first take another loan
because I want to make sure
we're upside down for a little bit
just to make the scenario worse.
Let's say year 6
I borrow another $500,000
and that's a good starting point
because I paid in $2,000,000
and now I've taken $2,000,000 in loans
and paying the loan interest.
But let's begin to repay it at
let's do $250,000 a year.
We can do it however we want
it can be a lump sum
some years it can be nothing
but I'm just going to do it consistent here.
So as you begin to chip away
at that loan
principal goes down
but here's really what people like to look at
including myself.
What's the cash value growth
compared to the loan interest paid each year?
And in this particular model
it looks good.
There are 2 years where I'm upside down.
If I don't like that
then I would just reduce the amount
that I loaned those years.
I'm okay with it because it's 1 year
that's fine
awareness is the key in my opinion.
Then the total gain on cash value
compared to total interest payments over time.
So as we look at these interest payments
this is what it is each year
but we do need to look at the total amount.
So what do you have here?
By year 9 they're about the same
meaning your total gain is $451,000
total interest paid is $452,000.
Next year $571,000
and a gain compared to about a $500,000
to about $500,000 in interest payments
when I look at it.
But again this is meant to provide awareness
so I can see everything up front.
Again if I'm using my policy for business
this is typically what people like to see firsthand.
What does it look like?
How much is the policy growing by?
How much am I paying in loan interest?
Am I attracted to this
or do I need to look at a different strategy?
When it comes to using the policy
this is something a lot of people
including myself like to see.
So I hope you enjoyed this video.
If you did please let us know
let us know if you have any questions at all
and as always I hope this helps.
Thanks so much.
Hey guys Steve Parisi here.
If you enjoyed the content you just saw
please subscribe,
like,
and hit the notification bell for future videos.
If you'd like more information
or to see some custom policies for yourself
feel free to call or email our offices
at the contact information below.
